The Amazing Spider-Man 2: 10 Ways The Reboot Is Superior

Sam Raimi may have brought us one of the best sequels in superhero history, but Marc Webb's take on the character is far better.

By Baz Greenland /

Marc Webb's Spider-Man universe is on track to be a very different beast from its predecessor; Raimi's movies delivered one of the most loved sequels of all time and had a combined worldwide gross income of $2,484 million. But with one successful reboot completed and the potential rise of the Sinister Six in the upcoming sequel, audiences are witnessing a confident, epic, very different saga from Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy. Recently at Whatculture we discussed 10 reasons why The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is going to fail. There might be a sense of fatigue as the film approaches (it does appear we've seen a good chunk of it in the last 584,674 trailers), but there are plenty of fans (myself included) that can't wait to see what the sequel to the best Spider-Man film to date brings us. With a stronger lead, phenomenal casting and a whole heap of mystery, Webb's Spideyverse is doing the unthinkable; bringing Spider-Man to audiences that is better than anything that has come before. With The Amazing Spider-Man as our primary point of reference and a number of predictions based on the trailers and comments from Webb himself, I look at 10 reasons why Webb's movies are already doing things better than Raimi's. Sacrilege you ask? Allow me to change your mind but if you don't agree, please feel free to comment below!

10. Amazing Casting Throughout

Sam Raimi had great casting choices; Alfred Molina's Doc Ock became the template for what great super villains should be and Tobey Maguire brought a loveable charm to his performance (outdone by Andrew Garfield though). But more often than not, some performances felt a little off. Willem Dafoe bordered between evil and hammy on more than one occasion. Thomas Hayden Church's Sandman was a big improvement but overall felt a little bland. Jame Franco's Harry Osborn became a bit of a non-entity. Kirsten Dunst started off okay as Mary Jane Watson but became more irritating as the trilogy went on and Topher Grace was frankly a bit of a disaster as Eddie Brock. On the other hand, The Amazing Spider-Man was filled with one phenomenal performance after another. Andrew Garfield's mix of geek and charm blew Tobey Maguire out of the water and Emma Stone brought all the sass and sex appeal that was sorely missing in Kirsten Dunst's performance. As serviceable as Cliff Robertson and Rosemary Harris were as Uncle Ben and Aunt May, they can't hold a candle to the perfect casting of Martin Sheen and Sally Field. But it didn't end there. Denis Leary was a great foil for Garfield as Captain Stacy and Rhys Ifans elevated what was admittedly a weaker villain in the Lizard. As for what's to come? With a trio of villains played by Jamie Fox, Dane DeHaan and Paul Giamatti there is the potential for three Alfred Molina's in the sequel. DeHaan's Harry Osborn is sure to put all thoughts of Franco's version to bed and be the most exciting element of The Amazing Spider-Man 2. Of course we need to see the film to be proven right but with every character dripping with talent - and if a trawl through the IMDB cast list is anything to go by - we're certain to see no dud performances in Webb's movies.

9. A Less Cartoony Tone To Spidey's Universe

As good as it was, if you watch the first Spider-Man now in relation to Marc Webb's reboot, it comes across as a little hokey. Scenes mesh together like they're ripped straight out of a comic and while that might have been fun at the time, audiences are looking for more sense of realism appropriate to the story that is being told. One of the biggest faults that can be labelled against Raimi's trilogy is that some of the characters are just plain silly. From the clichéd Russian landlord in the second film to the high school bullies of the first; while some characters are given depth to breathe, others are just archetypical stereotypes. Worse than that though is the design of the Green Goblin himself; they might have struggled to portray his physical transformation from the comics, but the green Power Ranger costume? The biggest shame is that William Dafoe had all the facial mannerisms to portray a wonderfully manic, deranged villain and it's hidden under a mask. Perhaps The Lizard wasn't the best choice as a villain (I will admit the 'turn everyone into Lizards' plot is a touch hokey) but what made The Amazing Spider-Man so great was the fact this his descent into a monster was just the end game of his story. He was a man who worked with Peter's father and is genuinely trying to gain that scientific breakthrough to help himself and aid the mysterious Norman Osborn in his illness. Like Doc Ock, Connors is a tragic hero and judging by the approach to Max Dillon in the sequel trailers, we might be seeing a similar approach here. With a much stronger narrative and element of mystery, Marc Webb's Spideyverse is clearly moving away from the simplicity of Raimi's trilogy.

8. Villains That Have A Real Connection To The Hero

Sam Raimi really tried with his villains but every connection to Peter Parker/Spider-Man felt a little forced. Despite knowing Harry for years, Peter didn't meet his friend's father and future Green Goblin Norman Osborn until the events of the first film. Despite their shared love of science, our hero never met Doctor Octavius until the sequel and they shared just a single scene with the good scientist mentoring Peter, before he transformed until the villainous Doc Ock. The third film was worse. Flint Marko was retcon'ed into Peter's life as his uncle's killer, undoing the events of the first film. Eddie Brock had no purpose and no build up through the series other than to be Peter's rival and future Venom. Harry Osborn was far better, having two films of plot to build on, but the whole amnesia story line messed that one up. The villains of Marc Webb's films on the other hand have one clever connection; the link back to Osborn Industries. It began with Doc Connor/The Lizard in The Amazing Spider-Man and looks set to continue with Harry Osborn and Max Dillon/Electro in the sequel. Mixing the obvious endgame of Norman Osborn and the mystery of Peter's parent's disappearance, the shadow of Osborn Industries hangs over Peter's story, giving him as much a motivation to discover what happened as the villains (past, present and future). That's why The Sinister Six movie should be a success; because these villains will have as much a connection to the Spider-Man and the shadowy Osborn Industries organisation as each other.

7. A Protagonist With Depth And Backstory

We certainly loved Tobey Maguire's performance as Peter Parker, but there's no denying that the depth of his story boiled down to what you saw on screen was what you got. A schoolboy with an unrequited crush on a girl in his class/neighbour. Check. Uncle dies and he gets upset? Check. Wins said girl over with reveal of secret identity. Check. Goes a bit emo when he bonds with an alien symbiote. Check. The big moments in his life are laid out on front of us and you never felt there was more to his story, or his family, off screen. Andrew Garfield's Peter Parker is a whole other story. Sure we get the same big turning points; getting bit by the spider, his uncle dying, struggling with his love for a girl, but this is just a part of his history. The most interesting aspect of his character and indeed the saga as a whole is the mystery of why his parents left him with Ben and May as a child and their eventual fate. It served as a foundation for Peter's story in The Amazing Spiderman, leading him to Oscorp, Doc Connors and his ultimate destiny as Spider-Man. Judging by the trailers and the presence of his father once more, this story looks set to continue apace in the sequel. It also goes without saying that as good as Maguire was, Garfield is better. His Spider-Man has all the trademark quips (his encounter with the carjacker and cops in the first film). His Peter is funny and endearing (the 'we don't have a chimney' and his 'whhhaat?' response in the latest trailer for Spidey 2). The kookiness and spark of his relationship with Gwen Stacey too, Garfield's performance is electric and immediately makes his own distinctive mark on the web-slinging hero.

6. Martin Sheen And Sally Field As Uncle Ben And Aunt May

Such perfect casting as this requires more than a single line of reference; it requires a whole discussion point of its own. I mentioned before that Cliff Robertson and Rosemary Harris were good in their respective roles but their sole function was to spout wisdom and nuggets of self-awareness at critical moments throughout the trilogy. They seemed too removed from Peter's life, even before he was bitten by the spider in Spider-Man. They were very fond of each other but the generation gap suggested they don't really get each other. But in comes President Bartlett - sorry - Martin Sheen, and suddenly we have a connection between Uncle Ben and Peter Parker that is warm, supportive, filled with moments of wisdom that show they truly get each other. Uncle Ben understands Peter's attraction to Gwen Stacey, his desire to learn more about his father and his general sense of trying to find a purpose in life; this is what makes his death so tragic. In Raimi's version you feel like Peter has lost a parental figure. In Webb's version you feel like Peter has lost a core part of who he is. Sally Field is also a revelation. You might have felt sad when Raimi's version of Aunt May lost her husband. In Webb's version you feel that pain. Even after Ben's death she doesn't struggle to grasp who Peter is becoming; she connects with him, sharing her frustrations as well as her love for her nephew and you truly get a sense that together they are trying to rebuild their life together. Had Aunt May disappeared from Peter's life after the first Spider-Man you would have considered her just one chapter in his story. But in Webb's version, May still has a big role to play in Peter's development and this is going to be a great thing to behold.

5. Performances That Don't Feel Forced Because Of Bad Scripting

We certainly don't want another round of emo Peter Parker in Webb's version of the saga. As discussed, Tobey Maguire made his Peter a three dimensional character but there were times when his reactions felt unnatural because of what was in the script. In the third Spider-Man, you wondered why, even under the influence of the symbiote, he would act like a douche. But it was other characters where Raimi's trilogy failed in this respect. The board at Oscorp in Spider-Man were one step away from twitching their moustaches as they voted Norman out. The same goes for the 'I'm a military badass' General Slocum or the wide-eyed voice of reason Dr. Stromm, whose sole purpose was to warn Norman of the perils of taking the formula that transforms him into The Green Goblin and become his first victim. Worse still is Eddie Brock in Spider-Man 3, playing angry just because it needs to be loosely believable that the symbiote will feed on that anger in order to transform him into Venom, or Harry Osborn's 'I'm good now just because I've lost my memory'; it all felt staged. At the other end of the scale we have some brilliant and truly believable performances in The Amazing Spider-Man; Captain Stacey's antagonism to Aunt May's frustration and fear for Peter - the realism of their reactions made us really engage with the characters and the story.

4. More Spectacular Action Sequences

A bit of a cheat perhaps given that special effects are always improving and therefore any subsequent film should always look more impressive than the last. But to be fair, in defence of Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy the effects still stand up today and Spider-Man looks amazing swinging though New York. The sequence where Flint Marko is resurrected as Sandman is pure perfection. The speeding train roof fight with Doc Ock is the most exciting sequence in all three films and Venom doesn't look bad at all...that's the best you'll get with that one. The trouble is, with the exception of the final showdown in Spider-Man 3, it'll all one-on-one action sequences that in terms of today's Avengers...and dare I say it the Alcatraz battle in X-Men: The Last Stand...feel quite small. The joy of Spider-Man has been the multiple rogues gallery (hence the Sinister Six) and we haven't really had that. Until now. If there's one thing that the Amazing Spider-Man 2 promises more than anything else, its spectacular action sequences. The showdown between Spider-Man and Electro glimpsed in the trailers looks stunning. Spider-Man facing off against Rhino looks magnificent, and we haven't seen what the battle with Green Goblin looks like yet (are we going to see that Gwen Stacey moment?). The scope and splendour of the sequel promises to deliver something not seen since the Chitauri attached New York in The Avengers.

3. Amazing Chemistry In The Romantic Leads

Try as they might, Maguire's Peter and Dunst's Mary Jane had nothing on the romantic duo that was Garfield's Peter and Stone's Gwen. The tension, the passion, the goofy humour; it's there on screen in spades and isn't surprising that they became a couple off screen as well as on. In Spider-Man, Mary Jane was Peter Parker's one true love because we were told (literally in the opening) but it never felt really believable. Sure we felt her frustration over his secrets in the sequel and she certainly had some sass and passion in the first film but we didn't really care, not like we were supposed to. Had she died, would it have had the impact it deserved? Now Peter and Gwen; we believe every lingering look, every kiss, every moment of them together. Already in the trailers we can see that spark hasn't gone anywhere. There's a reason they couldn't stay apart at the end of The Amazing Spider-Man, despite Peter's promise to her father and if the Green Goblin seals her fate (a fate that readers and non-readers alike will be painfully aware of), it is going to be unbearable to watch. As for Mary Jane, ultimate love interest or not, she's going to have some massive shoes to feel when she eventually turns up in this Peter Parker's life.

2. An Epic Build Up Throughout The Saga

With the tagline 'His Greatest Battle Begins' and the look of those trailers, we know that The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is going to be epic. Through a lot of clever marketing and soundbites, we also know that it doesn't end there. We have a confirmed Amazing Spider-Man 3 still to come as well as at least two sequels in the pipeline. The story of Peter Parker is only just beginning. That epic scope is something we didn't really see with Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy. While there were ongoing arcs (Harry Osborn's descent into madness, Peter and Mary Jane's burgeoning romance) each film also acted, for the most part, in isolation; there were always new villains with new storylines but it was never clear if there would be a sequel to each film or what the plot might be. It all just fitted together as the saga went along. With Webb's Spider-Man (and beyond his final turn behind the camera in The Amazing Spider-Man 3), you get the sense that the overall themes have been plotted out already and there is an end goal in place, be it the rise of the Sinister Six, his arch nemesis Norman Osborn or something else entirely. It will be exciting to watch and even more fun to ponder on as we move into the long wait between The Amazing Spider-Man 2 and The Amazing Spider-Man 3 in 2016.

1. A Bigger Universe

Marvel apparently have movies planned out to 2028. Fox is going to expand, with both The X-Men and The Fantastic Four coming head to head in the same universe. Superman versus Batman (or quasi Justice League) is coming in 2016. Even TV is getting in on the act with a Flash spin off from Arrow and the four Marvel Netflix series in development, starting with a fresh take on Daredevil. No longer are superheroes living in isolation. Spider-Man is getting in on the act too; the limitations of the Spideyverse aren't holding Sony back and we already have Venom and Sinister Six spin-offs in development. The former we assume will come to the fore in the third Amazing Spider-Man film, and then maybe as the anti-hero Agent Venom of the comics, while the latter will be the first super-villain-centric film released. It's ambitious. It could fail spectacularly. But it could also be the jewel in the crown for Sony in the same way that The Avengers was for Marvel. While the risks are greater, it shows that the current incarnation of Spider-Man is far bolder and innovative than Raimi's trilogy. That isn't a fault of those films. They helped to redefine modern superhero tales and Spider-Man 2 was the blueprint for modern superhero sequels. But in today's superhero cinematic universe Webb's Spider-Man is making that epic leap and that is an exciting thing.