Avengers: Endgame - 10 Secrets We Just Learned From The Writers At Comic-Con

Captain America almost lost his head. Literally.

By Danny Meegan /

Though it was originally known for its focus on comic-books, San Diego's annual convention has long since been taken over by Hollywood's biggest movies.

Advertisement

The Marvel Studios panel is one of the most hyped film events of the year full-stop, and other genre franchises like Terminator and It also have a presence at this year's show, ensuring that SDCC will remain a primary go-to destination for blockbuster movie fans craving more information on their favourite properties.

But it isn't just upcoming movies that attend. Comic-Con is a celebration of nerd culture as a whole, and a lot of the folks who make our favourite movies, games, TV shows and comic-books host panels every single year, and in 2019, two of the Marvel Cinematic Universe's veteran writers did just that.

Infinity War and Endgame scribes Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely recently visited Hall H to discuss each film's creative process, reflecting on their time spent working in the MCU. The two men held an extensive discussion, revealing new details and behind-the-scenes secrets, giving us an insight into how the Infinity Saga's epic finale was constructed, and the various story points that almost made the cut.

10. Smart Hulk Scenes Were Actually Shot For Infinity War

Even though the trailers teased his appearance in the Battle of Wakanda, the last time we saw the "regular" version of the Hulk was in the opening scene of Infinity War, where he got his ass kicked by an armoured Thanos.

Advertisement

But originally, things were planned differently. Smart Hulk was, at one point, going to appear in the final moments of Infinity War, bursting out of the Hulkbuster to take part in the fight against Thanos and his goons. Markus and McFeely discussed this back when Endgame first came out, but now, they've gone one step further and confirmed that some of these scenes were actually shot.

"Smart Hulk was in the third act of Infinity War. We wrote it, we shot it, and went on to shoot most of Endgame, and he achieved union with the Hulk while inside the Hulkbuster. He kicked Cull Obsidian’s ass. But it didn’t work. It was the wrong tone for the movie. But we had already shot Endgame, where he was already Smart Hulk."

The problem with cutting those Infinity War scenes? Banner was already Smart Hulk in Endgame, which had already been shot. So, to explain the character's new look in a quick, to-the-point manner, the diner scene was created, wherein Smart Hulk gives a general overview of his origin to a bemused Scott Lang.

9. The Reverse Snap Was Almost VERY Different

That moment in Endgame where the Avengers assemble on the battlefield to face Thanos and his armies is one of the best moments in the MCU, a dramatic, thrilling, one-of-a-kind scene that we probably won't get to see for quite some time.

Advertisement

But it was almost nothing like that. In fact, one iteration - according to McFeely - was played for a quick laugh.

"We had one where they all come back to the compound. Boom, there they are, you hear, 'Mr Stark' and there's Peter coming around the corner. And then we cut five minutes and they're all eating pizza. It was terrible."

This idea probably didn't make it into any polished drafts of the script, because even by reading that sentence, it's obvious that this would've been a joke too far. Maybe it would've been funny on opening night in a packed theatre, but long-term, the more "serious" option that they went with will have a bigger impact.

Would it have even made sense for the Avengers to sit around eating pizza while Thanos and his armies lurk nearby? Presumably, this version of the story still had some sort of third-act threat for them to deal with.

8. That Back To The Future Jab Was A Direct Quote

We already knew that the team behind Endgame consulted with physicists to help them map out the movie's depiction of time travel, but we now have a little bit more of an insight into the firm stance they took on the matter.

Advertisement

Where a lot of popular time travel tales abide by the "Back to the Future" rules - i.e. if you shoot your past self, your present self will disappear - Endgame instead opted to go with alternate timelines and the multiverse, so when present Nebula kills her past self inside the wrecked Avengers HQ, she stays put.

And because it wanted to point out that this version of time travel was not like the one seen in the beloved sci-fi classic, Endgame even featured a line that straight-up told audiences as much: when Scott Lang asks if Back to the Future is "bull****".

As revealed at Markus and McFeely's panel, that remark was a direct quote from one of the experts the filmmakers spoke with, who clearly isn't the biggest fan of Back to the Future's scientific accuracy.

7. Figuring Out Thanos' Endgame Story Proved Tricky

In Infinity War, Thanos has a clear purpose, and one fixed goal. Collecting the Infinity Stones is all he cares about, and so, the film was built around this mission, almost making him the protagonist.

Advertisement

But once he's achieved that goal... what do you do with him? That was the question facing Markus and McFeely during the development of Endgame, and it proved quite tricky to answer.

You can't just write him out of the film entirely, because if the story is about the Avengers trying to undo his universe-obliterating snap, then he will absolutely want to stop them doing that, right? But if you literally just showed him beating the Avengers in the last movie, how do you tone down his power levels (or make the rematch more even), without it seeming like a cheap nerf?

The Thanos conundrum caused the writers headaches for weeks, but the problem was solved by Endgame executive producer Trinh Tran in one succinct sentence: "what if we just killed him?"

Once the team had that idea nailed down, Markus said that it helped solidify Thanos' entire story arc, because it signified that his one sole purpose had been truly, irreversibly, fulfilled: his death sealed his victory.

6. How The Living Tribunal Would've Been Introduced

Back when Endgame first came out, Markus and McFeely revealed that they tried to include The Living Tribunal in Infinity War's Titan battle scene. The character - one of the most powerful cosmic beings in Marvel Comics - has never been adapted into a live-action setting, and he obviously didn't make the cut here either.

Advertisement

Now, the writing duo have expanded on how exactly they would've introduced the character, stating that Thanos would've been sent to him and judged guilty.

"It was partly inspired by Kevin Feige... he came into the conference room in Atlanta, where we were trapped for years, and he had brought a bunch of comics panels with him... and he wanted to make sure we didn't lose the psychedelic nature of the [Jim] Starlin universe... and so we stuck the Living Tribunal in the movie. So, as Thanos and Doctor Strange came to blows, Doctor Strange blew Thanos' mind and sent him through the mindscape."
"In the end, he would have been dumped in front of the Living Tribunal, who judged him guilty."

A neat idea, but this scene would've been an unwelcome distraction during what is supposed to be a tense, propulsive and focused fight sequence. Imagine The Living Tribunal just showing up randomly. Instead of being invested in the rest of the movie, general audiences would be thinking "hold up. What was that? Explain!"

On the plus side, the character is still free to be introduced in a movie further down the road.

5. Thor Almost Fought A Serpent

As good as it turned out to be, there was always a chance that Thor's Infinity War subplot simply wouldn't have worked. Out of every story thread in the film, it's the one that feels the most detached from the primary plot about the Infinity Stones, so there was a risk that audiences might have found it uninteresting by comparison.

Advertisement

This in mind, it's not surprising that Thor's mission went through many iterations and tweaks before the filmmakers settled on the final version.

One of the most curious of these versions was detailed by Markus and McFeely at their panel. The duo revealed that, at one stage, Thor was going to fight a giant serpent in his quest to grab Stormbreaker, but this idea was scrapped because it felt too "adventure-related" and "insufficiently character-based."

The writers also stated that this early version of the Thor subplot "sucked rocks", and that nobody liked it. This led to them having to fly back to Burbank and frantically re-jig the whole thing.

4. Nick Fury Was Never In The Final Battle (And Neither Were Pepper's Powers)

Aside from addressing some major creative turning points, Markus and McFeely also touched on a few smaller issues too. For example, at one point during their panel, they were asked about Pepper's Extremis powers, which they stated were never once considered for Endgame's final battle.

Advertisement

Now, if you read that and thought "why would they be considered in the first place. Didn't she get rid of them?" then you win a cookie, because yes, as of the end of Iron Man 3, Pepper is no longer infused with the Extremis virus. Sounds like the person who asked the question might have missed that detail.

The writers also added that Nick Fury was never a part of the final battle either. It certainly would've been cool to see him in there, but it's hard to imagine him having much of an impact. Not only does he not have superpowers, he doesn't even have Black Widow's melee skills, or Hawkeye's marksmanship.

What's he going to do, intimidate Thanos to death?

3. The Tony & Howard Scene Was Inspired By Markus' Personal Life

One of Endgame's emotional highlights is the touching conversation between Tony and Howard Stark. Writers often draw from their own personal experiences when building scenes and characters, even for fantasy and sci-fi stories, and with Endgame, this was one such moment.

Advertisement

In Civil War, we learn that Tony never got to (properly) say goodbye to his father before he was killed by The Winter Soldier, which led to Tony creating BARF, so he could relive their final moments together over and over again. But in Endgame, Tony finally gets some real closure with his old man.

In recent years, Markus' father passed away, and he also had a child. So, while writing Endgame, the whole parenting conversation between Howard and Tony came straight from Markus' desire to share that nervousness and self doubt people can feel before welcoming a baby into the world.

2. Jane Foster Almost Had A Bigger Role

Scientist Jane Foster makes the briefest of brief appearances in Endgame, visible onscreen when Rocket and Thor (well, mainly Rocket) are trying to retrieve the Reality Stone that's trapped inside her body. But she almost had a much bigger part.

Advertisement

Early on, it was going to be Jane who helped raise Thor out of the well of sadness he'd lost himself in, and not his mother, Frigga. However, it was decided that Jane simply wasn't the right candidate for the job, and Frigga was drafted in instead.

A conversation scene between Rocket and Jane was also scripted, which would've involved Rocket explaining that he intended to extract the Reality Stone from her. Jane, intelligent as she is, would've understood completely.

Unfortunately, there wasn't enough room to cram this extra scene in, and it was shelved.

1. Thanos Almost Chopped Off Cap's Head

Endgame isn't sunshine and rainbows from start to end, but it's also not unbearably dark, either. However, if one of Markus and McFeely's early ideas had made the final cut, the scales would've tipped much more heavily towards the sinister end of the tonal spectrum.

Advertisement

As crazy as it sounds, the writers once considered including a scene where 2014 Thanos entered the final battle by throwing down the severed head of 2012 Captain America, showing the Avengers that he had utterly devastated that other reality and was capable of doing the same to theirs.

For obvious reasons, this idea was nipped in the bud early on, and the final version of Endgame only features a single decapitated head.

Advertisement