Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice could change blockbuster cinema forever. Not because it'll make so much money that any previous superhero movie looks depowered or will shake up the status quo moreso than Marvel ever has (neither of those seem likely), but because it could very easily mark a total shift in how these sort of films are marketed. Just a few days ago the majority of people were highly hopeful for the DC smackdown, gleefully speculating and getting to a Star Wars-level of excitement. I've consistently not been on board with the film, but while nothing on screen has won me over, I wouldn't deny there was some hype from other quarters. And then this happened. The third trailer was released on Jimmy Kimmel Live just a week after the record-breaking first look at Captain America: Civil War and, in the space of three minutes (already too long for a trailer), Dawn Of Justice went from being one of the most anticipated movies of 2016 to one of the most derided. The trailer is just that bad. It's such a sharp turn of opinion, quashing all hype with a simple laser blast. The only real upside (because, let's be honest, even I don't want this movie to be bad) is this palpable distaste will lingers long enough to force studios to finally realise less is more when it comes to advertising and see others adopting a similar method to the teasing Lucasfilm's did with The Force Awakens. Here's hoping. But what exactly did the Batman V Superman trailer do so wrong? Here are the eight ways it kills any residual hope for the movie.
Honourable Mention - Hyperactive Lex
Rivalling Batfleck, the backlash against Jesse Eisenberg's casting as Lex Luthor has been unrelenting, and no amount of moody bald images, Paul Revere quotes or Fortune profiles have swayed people. And this trailer is not going to help. Eisenberg is channeling his inner Eisenberg as Lex Luthor, Jr., playing that same awkward nerd he's done for the better part of decade, only with the confidence money gives. It's an idea, for sure, but is hardly the Luthor fans were expecting. However, I'm not going to pass judgement of Jesse Eisenberg's villain just yet. Mainly because I think he's a good actor (check out Louder Than Bombs) and would quite like everyone to be wrong, but mainly because we don't know yet what sort of angle in general the DCEU is taking with the character - this hyperactive evil may be all there is to Lex, but I'm willing to bet there's something more insidious and, yes, classical hiding under the surface. We do at least know he's going to lose that hair, after all.
8. It's Quite Simply An Awful Trailer
Right, let's just get this out of the way first - this is a bad trailer. Forget opinions about the film, it's a clumsily edited, overlong piece that doesn't really know what point it's trying to make. Compared to the Comic-Con tease, which was an effective piece of marketing (I didn't like it, but that was more down to the nature of the film), this is a major step down, to the point where unconditionally sold Bat-fans are getting worried. There's almost a minute and a half dedicated to one long set-piece, then an onslaught of vaguely connected fight shots before it suddenly drops a major (as in, probably end-of-second-act) reveal, then... title card. That alone is a mess, seeing three different ideas rammed together with nary a care for spoilers or enjoyment, but beyond structure some of the editing choices in this are just bizarre. Watching the trailer a second (and, urgh, third) time, you realise that pretty much every concurrent shot has no actual relation to the previous one; they're simply edited together quickly to create the illusion of narrative. This is a common trick, but the prevalence here makes the whole thing disorenting - we've got clips from a least three different fights mushed together lazily in that middle stretch. There's also this odd recurring juttery cutting of shots to the soundtrack's drums, taking moment we've already seen and making them look like poorly buffered clips or an irritating fan edit. Is this meant to make reused footage more exciting? Because it really doesn't work.
7. The Dialogue All Sounds REALLY Self-Aware
"You must be new - that's Bruce Wayne." "We have a bad history with freaks dressed like clowns" "Bruce Wayne meets Clark Kent. I love it." "You should not pick a fight with this person." "The greatest gladiator match in the history of the world."
Good Bat of Gotham, can you have a single line of dialogue that isn't overtly winking to the audience about, well, everything? Yes, Clark Kent is an alien who arrived on Earth and became a superhero and, yes, Bruce Wayne is a masked vigilante who dresses like a bat and, yes, they're going to fight, but the script doesn't need to be alluding to it at every turn. I'm OK with things being a little extravagant - this is aiming to be a comic book transplanted to the big screen - but as with adapting a regular novel or beloved play some consolations need to be made if you're going for anything approaching realism, which for all the Synder-style this definitely is. I'm not going to judge how out of the place the lines feel because odds are we're not even getting them delivered in the correct context. Now some of these lines could work within the context - Lex is clearly one for high minded self-aggrandising, so his "greatest gladiator" summation does (for all its mirroring of Warner's hopes for the film) fit, as does delightfully announcing the two heroes meeting (if he knows their secret identity) - but overall it's groan-worthy stuff. Urgh.
6. Jokes On You - There's Humour
Over a year ago the ironically laughable story broke that forging forward DC's movie universe was going to be ruled over by one ironclad commandment: "no jokes". The logic behind it made some sense - the report came less than a month after Marvel had cleared up with the incredibly jokey Guardians Of The Galaxy, a film only made possible thanks to the quipping of The Avengers, which in turn owed a lot to the wit of Robert Downey, Jr.'s Tony Stark. It's a total overreaction of course, treating cinema as a two-tracked form, but you can see why Warners would try to resolutely differentiate themselves from their rival by going for an unmistakably different tone. But it turns out the joke was on us; there is going to be humour in this. And not just a bit of levity to break up the self-sincerity; we're talking Marvel-style barbs. "Is she with you?" Supes asks Batman, to which the Caped Crusader responds, "I thought she was with you." Urgh. That could, quite literally, be Iron Man and Star-Lord discussing the arrival of Captain Marvel in Avengers: Infinity War and it wouldn't feel out of place. But here? Given how this world has been set up it feels odd, and only furthers the thinking that, while Dawn Of Justice wants to resoundingly set up the DCEU, Warner Bros. still haven't quite decided on what tone they're going with.
5. Dumbsday
So, it turns out Michael Shannon wasn't trolling after all when he said he was involved in Batman V Superman with flippers for hands - as has been popularly rumoured for a while, the film with climax with the DC Trinity going to go up against Doomsday, in this continuity a unholy mutation of General Zod engineered by Lex Luthor. I'm going to say it again - urgh. Seriously, this is a f*cking stupid idea on just about every level. From a design standpoint it's not just a strange bastardisation of the character (yes, he looks like the Cave Troll from Fellowship), but he literally looks dumb, like he's a grunt henchman with none of the intelligence. And even he'd turn his stubby nose up at not only shoehorning a whole other key sub-plot and villain into an already overstuffed movie, but then removing pretty much any element of surprise by revealing it here (something that admittedly likely only happened to stop all our feverous speculating). I'm not too upset about the alteration to Doomsday's origin - he was a character created simply to kill Superman, everything else came after. If anything, having him be a creature produced for that same explicit purpose in-universe adds a nice bit of metatextuality to the film. But did everything have to be so poorly handled. Doomsday? More like Dumbsday.
4. Recreating Man Of Steel
If they hadn't already seen their two previous attempts at a cinematic universe shot down (Christopher Nolan resolutely capped off his Batman trilogy and Green Lantern was an embarrassment for all involved), you have to imagine Warner Bros. would have just let Man Of Steel lie. Its box office was fine enough, but hardly enough to make it a success, while the tepid critical reaction was only accentuated by polarising fan opinion. And, with little in the way of wider-universe references (bar a couple of cheeky Batman and LexCorp nods), it would have been easy to just pretend it was a one-off. But as waiting another few years to start their own MCU equivalent would mean DC was too behind, here we are with Man Of Steel 2. And boy are they doing their best to account for that misfire. The Comic-Con trailer already showed that we were going to be seeing the Battle of Metropolis again (dozens were killed, apparently), this time from Bruce Wayne's perspective, but the new trailer reveals it's not just a quick motivational flashback - on top of saving a little girl, we're going to see much of Supes' fight with Zod recreated from street level (albeit with much less murky visuals). Look, I kinda appreciate that they're addressing Man Of Steel's fundamental narrative issues, but to lean so much on it is just going to kick things off on a very sour note. Especially when the finale looks to be repeating that same "urgh, really" destruction porn action.
3. The Religious Parallels Are Back
Guys, you know what the superhero genre needs more of? God metaphors. You see, these guys are modern myths, so we should blah blah blah. Yes, it's this again... urgh. Man Of Steel was full of christ imagery, to the point where it became clear Zack Snyder simply doesn't understand what the word "subtext" means, but he's only ramping it up for his dreary smackdown; "If man won't kill God, the devil will do it," screams Lex Luthor as he creates Zodsday. Great. Just great. There's nothing wrong with drawing upon classical iconography when constructing a new story - Batman has done that countless times as a franchise itself - but this same old Superman/Jesus schtick is getting a bit tired and is really holding back the character, ensuring that no matter how gritty the image or brooding the narrative, Clark Kent is stuck being the generic wholesome hero. Aside from how worn it is though, the whole idea doesn't even really fit with the neck-snapping, taunting version of Kal-El we've got here; in fact, Snyder seems petrified of realising the traditional boy scout persona, so why his movie is going so deep into this parallel territory is beyond me. Maybe he's more Old Testament now (or perhaps a Greek style God, tying into the alleged mythic nature of the DCEU), but, whatever the case, can it not be done with some finesse?
2. Sigh, It Is Just Super Friends
I've been saying this ever since the film was announced, but the very nature of building the DC Extended (née Cinematic) Universe on top of a Batman versus Superman movie means that you inevitably know the punch-up will end with the two putting aside their differences and becoming pals. No, not parting on shaky terms destined for lots of scowling in the coming years, but actually becoming a movie approximation of World's Finest. It's only looked more like that as production rumbled on, with the introduction of the Dawn Of Justice subtitle, the official synopsis teasing a greater threat and the plethora of (now-confirmed) rumours about Dumbsday's involvement, but now it's fully confirmed for the whole world that this is indeed the movie's real purpose; after spending much of its run time on the titular conflict, the final thirty seconds of the trailer jumps to Lex Luthor creating Doomsday, bringing Wonder Woman into the fray and causing the Son of Krypton and Bat of Gotham (urgh) to fight side by side. It feels like a lost opportunity as an idea, making the once-in-a-lifetime cinematic event a footnote to a Justice League prequel. The fight will happen, sure, placating those who want super-on-super action, but it's just part of a bigger movie, rather than the entire point. That's disappointing, but what makes it worse is that it's been confirmed now; the movie is still three-and-a-half months away from release, yet we already know what its end state is going to be from the official marketing. Who markets a film called Batman V Superman on the fact that the fight ends with them best buds? And that thinking may just be the biggest mar against the film...
1. The Marketing Is Changing Tact Already
Black and blue, God versus man, day versus night; there is possibly no simpler sell in the history of cinema than Batman V Superman (ignoring, of course, that the "V" of the title makes no sense). It's the two most iconic superheroes on the planet (sorry Spidey) sharing the screen for the first time ever in the ultimate battle royale. But, just like Warner Bros. quickly grew far too accustomed to the idea of Batman being in the movie and desperately threw in half of the Justice League in an attempt to already sweeten the sugary pot, they're now altering the marketing so it becomes this epic DC Trinity piece instead. I've already established why that's a problem for the film, but what's really damning is the reason why. Compare Batman V Superman's promotion to Star Wars: The Force Awakens, which was still very much angling its trailers at fans up until a few weeks ago, and what do you see? There's a clear difference in approach here, and the key to it is who the trailers are aimed at; instead of comic and superhero movies fans who've been aware of the movie since SDCC 2013, this latest ad, with its plot overview and obvious lines, was for those who didn't even realise the movies were coming out. Nothing wrong with that of course, but what does it mean? Well, perhaps being the first big release of 2016 (Deadpool comes first, but being R-rated necessitates a whole different approach) has motivated Warner to try and start the wave of hype early so it'll peak the moment everyone's recovered from Star Wars. However, I'd wager instead that they've realised that the film they've made is going to play much better with the broad mainstream audience rather than the die-hard fans, so are chasing that audience as soon as possible. And while that's good for business, that doesn't say much of the finished product, does it? What did you think of the latest Batman V Superman trailer? Do you still hold out hope the movie will be good? As always, share your thoughts down in the comments.