Bohemian Rhapsody Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs

Rami Malek elevates a generic biopic.

By Jack Pooley /

20th Century Fox

Queen biopic Bohemian Rhapsody is finally out now in UK cinemas, and the production certainly hasn't been without its controversy. This is with regard to both its content being carefully controlled by the band themselves, and the fact that the majority of it was directed by Hollywood outcast Bryan Singer.

Advertisement

Reviews were held until the day before release, which is rarely a good sign, and predictably, the film has opened to mixed reviews from critics.

On one hand, Bohemian Rhapsody is an enjoyable, easily digestible tribute to Queen and especially frontman Freddie Mercury, but on the other, it's an astoundingly broad film that just doesn't probe deep enough into Mercury or his bandmates.

Advertisement

Needless to say, most of its major awards prospects are already up in smoke, though Rami Malek will probably end up sneaking a Golden Globe nomination for Best Actor as a consolation prize.

It's certainly not a bad film, but many viewers, hardcore Queen fans or not, might be left frustrated that it's not an edgier, more daring piece of biographical drama...

Advertisement

Downs...

5. It's A Totally Safe, By-The-Numbers Biopic

Fox

Probably the biggest fear going into the film was that it would turn out to be a simple, garden variety musical biopic with little to distinguish it, and sadly that's totally the case.

Advertisement

This basically feels like a Wikipedia entry on Queen in movie form, a staggeringly inoffensive film designed to appeal to as wide a cross-section of audiences as possible.

It hits beat after beat with a metronomic level of predictability as the band comes together, gets famous and encounters personal woes, and finally concludes with their epic Live Aid performance.

Advertisement

It's not so much that Bohemian Rhapsody needed to be surprising, but there's a disappointingly workmanlike feel to the movie considering the flamboyant personality of the band and its frontman in particular.

4. Bryan Singer's Clumsy Direction

Fox

The movie of course had a rickety production with Bryan Singer being dismissed from the back-end of principal photography due to his failure to turn up on set.

Advertisement

Dexter Fletcher took over shooting and editing the movie, and though it's impossible to tell exactly who filmed what, the end product feels cut from the same clunky cloth throughout.

Singer's going to shoulder most of the blame here as he probably should, because there are so many fundamentally heavy-handed and groan-worthy creative choices.

Advertisement

From a terrible press conference sequence in which Singer probes Mercury's sexuality with sledgehammer-subtlety to obnoxious use of "Under Pressure" as the singer approaches a personal crossroads, it's all laid on with a comical thickness that again just reeks of pure biopic formula.

Nobody's saying the movie needed to be flat and "gritty", but ultimately the abundance of glossy CGI scene transitions and text flying around the screen feels embarrassingly conventional if not flat-out lazy.

Advertisement

3. It Sanitises Mercury's Sexuality & Death

20th Century Fox

There was a ton of pre-release controversy about the movie downplaying Mercury's homosexuality and eventual death from AIDS, and while the film certainly doesn't ignore these aspects of Mercury's life, they do feel rather glossed over.

Advertisement

The main problem is that both Mercury's gayness and death are basically whispered in hushed, polite tones, presumably in order to avoid "offending" less-progressive audiences and scaring away their box office bucks.

The movie doesn't re-write Mercury's lifestyle or his death, and there are surely few who wanted the movie to focus heavily on the singer's final days, but even so, it skirts past these pivotal moments a little too eagerly.

Advertisement

2. The Occasionally Rough Production Values

Fox

It's clear that Bohemian Rhapsody wasn't exacly thrown together with a shoestring budget, so it's a bit disappointing that the production values are all over the place.

Advertisement

The key issue is clearly the visual effects: a number of CGI scene transitions look goofy and awkward, and it's painfully clear during the (otherwise brilliant) climactic Live Aid sequence that most of the crowd are digital.

There are a few especially dodgy crane shots through the crowd where it's incredibly obvious they've been copy-and-pasted into the scene.

Advertisement

The lip sync could also be better in places, though perhaps a little of the blame here lies at Malek's feet, despite the generally impressive quality of his performance.

It's rather obvious numerous times throughout the film that he's miming over a track - ignoring the impossible-to-imitate nature of Mercury's voice, of course - and perhaps some more judicious editing could've better concealed it.

Advertisement

1. The Sloppy Pacing & Editing

Fox

The pacing in this movie is all over the place. The opening sequence in which Queen's original frontman quits and Mercury quickly joins the fold, for instance, is almost comically breathless, written and edited for maximum storytelling efficiency despite seeming rather contrived as a result.

Advertisement

Most of the first act feels rushed, honestly, yet other scenes - such as the creation of "Bohemian Rhapsody" - are sensibly lingered on, creating an uneven rhythm which probably could've been remedied with stronger editing.

At 134 minutes, it's certainly not a short film, and yet it really feels like there should've been a more concise and consistent way to tell this story. At times rushed and others sluggish, it's basically all over the place.

Advertisement

Again, though, this is hardly a bad movie, just an underwhelming one. With that in mind, here's everything it gets right...

Ups...

5. Rami Malek's Chameleonic Performance

Fox

Though we'll never know what wonders Sacha Baron Cohen could've done if his planned Queen biopic ever went ahead, Rami Malek is an extremely solid replacement.

Advertisement

His inherent physical resemblance to Mercury is far from uncanny, but thanks to impressive make-up work and Malek's perfection of the singer's physical mannerisms, he ends up thoroughly convincing for the most part (those lip sync issues aside).

It's a broad portrait for sure, but one suspects that with a stronger script and direction, Malek could've ended up a major Oscar contender here. He's the movie's easy stand-out all the same and carries it effortlessly through its rougher moments.

Advertisement

4. It's An Enjoyable Celebration Of Queen's Music

Fox

Above all else, you will likely come out of this movie with a smile on your face and tapping your feet to Queen's music.

Advertisement

Presumably at the behest of the band themselves, the bulk of the focus here is on the influential nature of their music, how they've captured the hearts and minds of generations and how they pretty much define the word "iconic."

If you're a Queen fan, which you probably are if you're planning on seeing this movie, it succeeds as a doting tribute to their artistry even if it sometimes feels a little too close to an estate-approved hagiography (because that's basically exactly what it is).

Advertisement

3. The Superb "Making Of Bohemian Rhapsody" Montage

Fox

By far the best sequence in the entire movie is a lengthy scene devoted to the creation of Bohemian Rhapsody itself.

Advertisement

Through an hysterical, ludicrously entertaining montage, we see the band coming up with all the consitituent elements which comprise the song, while Mercury insists on yet more and more layering to the operatic vocals.

Considering that most of the movie covers their music in only a very broad sense, it was great to see this delineated sequence bog itself down in the more technical minutiae of the band's genius.

Advertisement

For another band it might seem a tad self-indulgent, but considering the near-universal, show-stopping appeal of the song, it's nothing short of fantastic.

2. Mike Myers' Hilarious Cameo

Fox

In case you weren't aware, Mike Myers has a cameo in the movie as EMI executive Ray Foster, and his brief appearance is one of the best scenes in the entire film.

Advertisement

The scene in question sees the band attempting to convince Foster, who has worked with the likes of Pink Floyd and Jimi Hendrix previously, to push Bohemian Rhapsody as a single, despite the song's six-minute length proving offputting to radio stations.

Myers, who performs the entire scene under a pair of sunglasses - despite being indoors, hilariously - and a silly wig, once again proves his wonderful penchant for blending into a scene, given that most viewers probably won't even realise it's him.

Advertisement

His performance is a real giggle, coming complete with a totally unsubtle reference to his iconic scene from Wayne's World, which of course famously features the song itself.

Please be in more movies, Mike Myers. We miss you.

Advertisement

1. The Spectacular Live Aid Finale

20th Century Fox

The film concludes with Queen's unforgettable Live Aid performance, and it's certainly a suitably bombastic emotional high on which to close things out.

Advertisement

Yes, it is ultimately in the service of downplaying Mercury's death and there are some aforementioned technical issues, but from moment to moment, it is an electrifying recreation of the famous gig.

This gives Malek by far his grandest stage to embody Mercury, which complete with an uncanny stage setup and even a cameo from a dead-on Bob Geldof lookalike (Dermot Murphy), ensures the sequence gives audiences one hell of a barnstorming finale.

Advertisement

What did you think of Bohemian Rhapsody? Shout it out in the comments!