Doctor Sleep Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs
The Shining sequel does King and Kubrick proud.
Just in time for Halloween, the adaptation of the sequel to Stephen King's The Shining, Doctor Sleep, has begun its international rollout, and fans will be relieved to know that writer-director Mike Flanagan has delivered both a worthy adaptation of King's novel and a fitting successor to Stanley Kubrick's 1980 movie.
Critics have broadly praised the film so far, and while it doesn't even begin to meet the richly atmospheric highs of Kubrick's original, it is a respectful follow-up which knows when to dole out the fan service and when to cast it aside.
It's easy to imagine the popcorn-munching crowd complaining that the film is too slow and restrained, but if you're craving a thoughtful post-script to The Shining, this delivers the eerie, achingly humanistic goods more often than not.
If not an essential continuation, Doctor Sleep more than justifies its existence and has clearly been brought to the big screen with a ton of heart and care.
Belated sequels are always a tough nut to crack, especially with Kubrick's lead to follow, but in doing so Flanagan has confidently re-affirmed himself as one of the genre's top filmmakers working today...
Downs...
3. It's WAY Too Long
Does it feel like a disproportionate number of major Hollywood movies are releasing with indecent, undisciplined runtimes lately?
Following the recent 169-minute endurance trial that was It Chapter Two, Doctor Sleep clocks in at a beefy 152 minutes, and the movie's excessive length is likely to be the most common complaint from both critics and casual viewers alike.
Though Flanagan does a remarkable job keeping the audience invested, he doesn't quite earn all of those 2.5 hours. There are a number of protracted scenes which could've either been whittled down in editing or, better still, deleted entirely.
This feels like a home video Extended Cut which, semi-admirably, Warner Bros. actually allowed to be released in cinemas. But as a result, you might feel slightly tired and weary by the time it's all over.
2. The Overly Vague Script
The Shining certainly had its narrative ambiguities, but it also kept its core story incredibly simple, training the focus so intently that audiences were typically only puzzled by the things Kubrick wanted them to be puzzled by.
But Doctor Sleep's more sprawling narrative is a little tougher to nail down, largely because it's far more reliant on magic, yet without ever laying down firm rules regarding the mechanics of these powers.
As a result audiences basically need to be prepared to just go with all the supernatural hooey, as things frequently happen "just because."
The villains also feel a touch underdeveloped, likely due to the sheer wealth of content Flanagan is trying to cram in here.
Main antagonist Rose the Hat (Rebecca Ferguson) is compelling yet remains an enigma by film's end, and her band of followers largely amount to little more than props for the most part.
If you're looking for a horror movie with a clearly defined logic, this isn't the one for you.
1. It's Just Not Scary
If Doctor Sleep has understandably been marketed on the strength of its relation to The Shining with a keen focus on Creepy Moments, the final film itself is actually not very scary at all.
Flanagan seems acutely aware that he can't outdo The Shining, and so instead opts for a movie that feels less like a horror and more a character-driven fantasy-thriller, if that makes sense.
Long sections of the movie are almost pure drama, totally bereft of anything even close to a typical genre set-up, and as long as you're aware of that going in, you'll probably be captivated enough not to care.
But more casual-skewing audiences seeing the movie on a Friday night with a giant box of popcorn, however, might be disappointed by just how low-key a "horror" it truly is.
It certainly would've been nice to see the screws turned a little tighter than this, for sure.
These issues and concerns aside, Doctor Sleep is a mighty fine movie. Here's everything it gets right...
Ups...
7. Ewan McGregor's Fantastic Performance
Ewan McGregor adds another cracker of a performance to his under-appreciated catchet, proving spectacularly well-cast as an adult Danny Torrance throughout.
Perhaps the one major benefit of the lengthy runtime is that it doesn't force McGregor to be in every single scene: he's actually absent from a few fairly long stretches of the movie, but every time he's present, he knocks it out of the park.
It's a restrained performance that isn't very showy at all, but Flanagan allows McGregor to deepen the emotional well of Danny's character arc with some wonderfully human, poignant moments - especially when he's comforting some dying patients in a hospital - long before the inevitable chaos transpires.
His chemistry with young co-star Kyliegh Curran, who plays the shining-bearing Abra, is terrific and drives most of the movie, and considering how much affection fans have for this character, it's safe to say that McGregor gives him a dignified and sensibly restrained adult portrayal.
6. Mike Flanagan's Sharp Direction
Mike Flanagan has been making a major name for himself on the horror circuit over the last few years, cemented by his incredible work on Netflix's Stephen King adaptation Gerald's Game and especially last year's brilliant TV series The Haunting of Hill House.
Carrying the torch for Stanley Kubrick is no easy feat, but Flanagan's uncommon penchant for favouring quieter, more character-driven moments over outlandish horror serves him incredibly well here.
Rather than try to ape Kubrick's style, he compliments it with his distinctly minimalist approach, honing in on quiet human moments and, yes, occasionally letting loose with the more heightened madness audiences expect.
Flanagan is an expert at building atmosphere, and off the back of his work here, there's no reason to believe he won't confirm himself to be an all-timer genre great - if he hasn't already - within the next few years.
5. Rebecca Ferguson's Sublimely Creepy Antagonist
Though Rebecca Ferguson's villainous Rose the Hat feels a tad underdeveloped as a character, Ferguson's imposing screen presence nevertheless does a fantastic job compensating for that.
Her slightly iffy Irish accent be-damned, Ferguson otherwise makes for an intensely unsettling villain, desperate to consume the shine of children, and because prolonged torture makes the shine more potent for her and her cronies to subsist on, she doesn't hurry putting her victims out of their misery.
But Ferguson's charm and sex appeal also makes Rose a delightfully seductive and fun baddie, especially during her inevitable third-act showdown with our heroes.
While audiences will likely be wishing they knew more about Rose by the time the end credits roll, Ferguson takes a potentially cartoonish, comical character and makes her dynamic and unpredictable.
4. It Handles Fan Service (Mostly) Well
Fans will mostly be excited to see how Doctor Sleep ends up connecting to The Shining, and for the most part Flanagan handles a difficult situation well.
Obviously, the temptation to over-indulge in fan service speaks for itself, but for most of the film's first two hours, the references to Kubrick's film are actually relatively restrained, and the focus is trained on telling a totally different story.
Most of the crowd-pleasing fan fodder is reserved for the film's finale, and though some (admittedly spot-on) recreations of classic moments from The Shining with new actors might feel like overkill to some fans, you can't really deny the love and care that has gone into the production.
The Overlook Hotel is painstakingly recreated for the film's final stretch, and while absolutely a case of "giving the audience what they want," that does feel rather earned after two hours of relatively pared-down storytelling.
3. The Remarkable Supporting Cast
In addition to the fine performances of Ewan McGregor and Rebecca Ferguson, there's some terrific work from a top-notch ensemble cast.
Flanagan has proven himself extremely capable of working with young actors in the past and, in this case, gets incredible work out of Kyliegh Curran, who makes for an extremely likeable young "sidekick" to Danny for most of the movie.
Elsewhere, Cliff Curtis is fantastic as Danny's pal Billy, Jacob Tremblay gets a brief but memorable role as one of the children preyed upon by Rose, and Twin Peaks/Addams Family legend Carel Struycken - who previously appeared in Flanagan's Gerald's Game - gets a neat role as one of Rose's aged followers.
There are also a few welcome cameos for horror fans to keep their eyes peeled for, but spoiling them would be telling.
2. The Excellent Cinematography & Sound Design
In addition to Flanagan's direction, Doctor Sleep is one hell of a gorgeous movie. For starters, Flanagan's regular DP Michael Fimognari shoots the absolute hell out of this thing, favouring the rich, dark tones which made The Haunting of Hill House such a visual treat last year.
Fimognari's recreations of classic Kubrick visuals are giddily enjoyable, yet like Flanagan's direction, he resists the urge to simply copy-paste The Shining's lensing 1:1, and allows his own beautifully bleak style to shine through.
This is all accentuated by top-tier sound design, always a must for a great horror movie: it takes a concerted effort to make the quiet this unsettling.
Elsewhere, The Newton Brothers' musical score invokes many of Wendy Carlos and Rachel Elkind's original compositions for The Shining while also injecting plenty of their own sinister personality.
1. It's A Totally Worthy "Sequel" To The Shining
Though it feels slightly weird to call Doctor Sleep a sequel to The Shining given that so much of it is so thoroughly divorced from the events of that movie, Flanagan has absolutely made a film that feels consistent with it stylistically, thematically and character-wise.
It is an unenviable task for any filmmaker, to live up to such a towering cinematic legacy, and while few will proclaim Doctor Sleep to stand tall alongside The Shining, it is nevertheless a welcome addendum to Danny Torrance's story.
Don't go in expecting a mile-a-minute scare-fest or a film as richly taut as the original, but it certainly does enough to feel worthy of belonging in the same wheelhouse.