Every Headline MCU Protagonist Ranked From Worst To Best
Is Peter Parker really the best MCU character we've had so far?
Over the last 80 years, superheroes have managed to touch the hearts of us all. They give us something to aspire to, people to look up to, and most importantly, they make us want to do and be better.
This is especially true when said superhero protagonists are headlining their own movie or TV show, putting them at the center of the story and showing us all their trials and tribulations, making it clear that they're just as human as we.
Though, at the same time, with the MCU expanding each year, some could argue there are a few too many inspiring heroes introduced and brought to the public eye. Of course, the MCU first served up greedy businessman Tony Stark, who started as a selfish playboy only to turn into Iron Man. On the other side of that, Steve Rogers proves that anyone can become Captain America with enough perseverance.
These characters are excellent in their own right and are hugely important to many people. Though, with the sheer number of protagonists who were the main focus of their stories out there, there’s a question some might ask: how do they stack up against one another? How do the likes of classic characters like Thor and Hulk compare to more niche protagonists like Moon Knight or Hawkeye?
20. Bruce Banner - The Incredible Hulk
The Hulk has been one of the most beloved supporting characters of the MCU with his depiction by Mark Ruffalo ever since the first Avengers movie; sadly, the same can’t be said for the only protagonist role the character has had in The Incredible Hulk.
Edward Norton is not a bad actor, but the superhero movie he’s in does not do him justice. The visuals are bland and colorless, while the script is problematic and fails to explain the plot to the viewer correctly. As a whole, it's boring, with the only saving grace being the massive Hulk vs. Abomination fistfight in the third act.
The movie also fails to characterize Bruce Banner; we don’t get to see much about him or his life before becoming the Hulk. Making it hard to get an idea of what the character is going through and, in the term, growing some attachment for him.
At the same time, his struggles with his love interest Betty Ross feel like a romance done millions of times before and doesn’t bring anything new to the table. This is even more disappointing considering the fact that this is the only thing the character has going for him outside of the conflict with the Hulk itself.
Mark Ruffalo might have brought Hulk's most beloved live-action incarnation to the MCU, but his original film needs much work.
19. Carol Danvers - Captain Marvel
In the comics, Carol Danvers is one of the most fun and lovable characters who always makes each issue she’s in memorable. However, her first live-action incarnation fails to deliver on multiple fronts.
While she has a compelling enough backstory, there’s not much to latch onto in terms of the actual character. She doesn’t show much emotion, lacks a defined struggle to overcome, and overall, it’s hard to care about her or what happens to her.
She also feels like a complete Mary Sue, which serves as a detriment to the story because, in fiction, characters need to go through an inherent struggle so that the audience is at the edge of their seats and wants to see her succeed. However, Carol Danvers never goes through anything like this and achieves everything with relative ease, taking away from her achievements and victories.
While she might not have been a great character in Captain Marvel, with The Marvels adding Kamala Khan and a brand new creative team sailing the ship, hopefully, we’ll see Danvers shine in the way she was always meant to.
18. Sam Wilson - The Falcon And The Winter Soldier
We didn’t know much about Sam Wilson for most of the films. He was more of a supporting character and did an excellent job at being that. This is why his switch into a central protagonist role was a little rough.
The Falcon And The Winter Soldier is a series that deals with many themes, so much so that it sometimes feels like it’s being crushed under the weight of its own ambition. It never really feels like the show (and, consequently, Sam Wilson) has one particular direction it wants to head in. Because of this, it’s harder to form an emotional connection with a character we already didn’t know much about.
Though, that’s not to say he’s a bad character. Notably, his transformation into Captain America was well written and appropriately foreshadowed back in Endgame, leading to a pretty satisfying conclusion that wraps his character arc nicely.
His struggle to accept what Captain America is and what he represents makes you get behind the character and want to see him succeed, something that’s a sign of a good protagonist.
While there have seen better in the MCU, the Falcon is still memorable in his own way.
17. Hope Van Dyne - Ant-Man Duology
The original Wasp was one of the most heroic characters from both the comics and the MCU itself, as she was the sole reason a missile didn't land and destroy countless lives. With this in mind, her daughter Hope Van Dyne had a lot to live up to, and for the most part, she did.
Hope is a character who originally comes off as antagonistic and even somewhat unlikable due to the way she treats Scott. However, through the course of the film, we get to learn about her and all the problems she's faced in her life, including the loss of her mother and detachment from her father, and it's through this that she grows and becomes a genuinely lovable character.
She got even better in the second movie once she properly turned into the Wasp and was able to fight right alongside Ant-Man in both their own films and in The Avengers.
The only downside is that she doesn't get as much screen time as she deserves, and in turn, her character can feel a bit underdeveloped at times.
16. Shang-Chi - Shang-Chi And The Legend Of The Ten Rings
One of the newest characters the MCU has introduced has already made a pretty big impression on fans, even if he’s only had a significant role in one movie. Shang-Chi is a highly compelling character that takes a new approach to storytelling in the MCU with a sins of the father storyline, the likes of which we haven’t seen before.
He’s a character with a lot of charm and wit who seems to know more than he leads on, while at the same time having a specific naïve nature to him. While the conflict with his father is a little supernatural, the family aspect of his story makes him a character easy to relate to and fun to be around.
His relationship with characters like his sister and best friend shows layers of depth in ways we haven’t seen in the MCU in a long time, and it’s great to see a down-to-earth character like Shang-Chi show up in the MCU at all.
However, he is still a relatively new character, meaning it's still too early to correctly say if he will become one of the all-time classics. Even still, Shang-Chi is a welcome new addition who can only go up from here.
15. Natasha Romanoff - Black Widow
Black Widow has been a fan favorite among Marvel fans ever since her debut in Iron Man 2, and she was deserving of her own film for a long time, even if it disappointedly came out after her death in Endgame.
In her role as a protagonist, Natasha has as great of a presence as she does in every other movie she’s been in. Except now, we get to know a lot more about her through the conversations with her family and deeper insights into her way of thinking.
Scarlett Johansson’s performance also elevates her character as she’s done before, creating a strong female character with all the fragility and emotion that protagonists should have—making us want to root for her and see her succeed more so than in any other film.
While it is disappointing that her movie came out after her death which somewhat lessens the impact of her role in the story, she’s still one of the more assertive protagonists the MCU has given us and one we won’t be forgetting anytime soon as her sister Yelena will continue the role of Black Widow in the future.
14. Scott Lang - Ant-Man Duology
Paul Rudd is one of the funniest and most beloved actors currently working in Hollywood, and his role in the MCU is one that, while relatively small, is still one that has made an impression.
Scott Lang is one of the most down-to-earth characters we’ve seen from the MCU. We see this through the care he has for his daughter and his willingness to do anything for her; a classic storyline done before in storytelling, yet it still tugs at our heartstrings to see Scott go the extra mile for her.
His relationship with Hope also shows us that he’s someone who can improve on himself, even if he’s made bad decisions in the past, and grow to become the hero we need.
While some were skeptical of this iteration of Ant-Man - considering the original hero was Hank Pym - Scott Lang still ended up becoming a lovable character who, while having a niche role in the overarching story of the MCU, is still one that is necessary as he gives us the perspective of the everyman which we don’t often see in these movies.
13. T'Challa - Black Panther
While Scott Lang is fun and whimsical, T’Challa is strict and closely adheres to his beliefs and way of thinking. Being the King of Wakanda comes with a lot of responsibilities, and because of this, T’Challa is a character that’s much harder to relate to compared to others.
However, this doesn’t mean he’s a lousy protagonist. Even though he’s a king, he’s still someone who has a defined and admirable outlook on life. He believes nobody deserves to die, or that if you have a different opinion from him on whatever topic, that’s not necessarily a reason to fight.
Even though he wants Wakanda to live in peace and strives to avoid jumping to violence, the conflict that arises from people like Killmonger shows that even he can grow and change like all human beings and learn from other people who think differently from him.
The Black Panther is very different from most heroes we’ve seen in the cinematic universe, but even so, he’s still someone who’s made an impression not only in his film but also in the MCU as a whole.
12. Vision - WandaVision
When Vision was first introduced in Age Of Ultron, while he seemed like a powerful force you wouldn't want to mess with, the reality was that he didn't have much of a personality to him, making it hard to form an emotional bond with the character. However, his inclusion in WandaVision changed everything.
Here, we see his relationship and bond with Wanda, letting the writers explore the character further and show that though he's an AI, he still has deep emotions like a normal human being.
His conflict with his wife and standalone scenes with other characters throughout the show never fails to be compelling content that makes us want to continue watching, especially as Vision goes off to try and discover the mysteries of Westview.
He also has one of the most satisfying conclusions to a character in Phase Four, with the acceptance of his own death and subsequent conversation with Wanda being one of the biggest emotional rollercoasters in recent times.
While it is sad that we likely won't be seeing Vision in future projects, he was still a great addition to one of the best stories we've had in the MCU so far,
11. Stephen Strange - Doctor Strange
Many admirable and noble superheroes across pop culture were once arrogant people who took what they had for granted, only to lose it all. Stephen Strange is a textbook example of one.
He’s a man who loved being a surgeon more than anything, so much so that he pushed away the people he loved and ended up becoming somebody unpleasant to be around as he slowly grew consumed by greed. But the moment he lost the ability to operate was when his life began to break down.
We all love seeing somebody come from a dark place and see them rise, and this is precisely what Strange does in one of the most compelling character arcs in the MCU as he learns to appreciate the people around him and realize that there are other ways he can help the world.
By the end of the movie, he’s become someone entirely different from who he was. Now he’s somebody we can all look up to, and he’s also someone that teaches us that we can all be something great no matter where we come from.
10. The Guardians Of The Galaxy - Guardians Of The Galaxy Duology
When Guardians of the Galaxy first came out in 2014, people didn’t know what to expect. This was a superhero team most didn’t know much about; they were niche, and even some dedicated comic book fans didn’t have much attachment to them.
However, James Gunn was able to bring a unique charm to the unexpected hit film in part due to the great protagonists in the form of the Guardians themselves.
The story of these characters is a classic among superhero teams, the tale of opposites learning to work together and, consequently, finding a family-type love between each other.
Peter Quill is fun and goofy but has also gone through a lot of pain due to the death of his mother; Gamora has gone through similar issues with her father Thanos, and these kinds of problems can be seen in all the other Guardians, which makes their bond feel even more special.
By the end of the second film, you grow a massive attachment to each individual member, which makes emotional moments like Gamora's death hit even harder.
9. Clint Barton - Hawkeye
We didn’t know much about Clint Barton for most of the MCU, and because of this, he was a character that was hard to grow attached to or even care about for that matter. But all that changed with Hawkeye and the expansion of his character through the struggle he faces after the events of Endgame.
Here we can finally see the frail man that is Clint Barton. He’s afraid of many things, including the loss of his family and the fear of himself, as he still lives in regret over what he did in his years as the Ronin.
But when Kate Bishop enters his life, everything changes as she brings out all the best parts of him. She makes him believe in something greater once more and has him face the Ronin and his fear of being vulnerable with the people he cares about.
Clint is a character many of us didn’t care about, but after seeing his human side and what he truly cares about in life, he’s become one of the best and most emotional characters in the MCU.
8. Steven Grant/Marc Spector - Moon Knight
While the Moon Knight TV show is currently still airing, even with an incomplete number of episodes, it’s easy to tell that both Steven Grant and Marc Spector are some of the best protagonists in the MCU.
It’s easy to be on Steven’s side starting with the first episode; he’s just some random guy with not much going on in his life other than a simple job as a clerk at a museum gift shop. More than anything, he wants to live without problems. That is until Marc Spector takes over and he’s forced to live his life as Moon Knight.
The characters' struggles feel unique compared to what we’ve gotten from the MCU, focusing on both the battle from the outside and the conflict between the two leads, making it easy to get hooked along for the ride.
Emotion has played a massive role in making most of these characters great, but Marc and Steven are more about their stories' thrill or mystery. They’re two characters at odds with each other, and seeing how they interact is what makes them some of the most compelling to date.
7. Thor - Thor Trilogy
While Thor has been a beloved character in the comics ever since his debut in the 1960s, his first two forays in film weren’t received very well, with Thor and Thor: The Dark World often considered some of the weaker films the MCU has given us.
However, even though he wasn’t a character people loved at first, Thor: Ragnarok came around and completely changed the public perception of who the Thunder God is. Now he was a protagonist who was taken much less seriously and had more personality. He was fun and funny, with Taika Waititi bringing an entirely new light-hearted air to the character compared to his more serious nature in other films.
Even though he's goofier, we still get to see him in his most vulnerable as Mjolnir is destroyed and his father Odin passes away—giving us an emotional edge to the character previous movies tried and failed to deliver.
Because of who Thor has become, Love and Thunder will likely become a big hit for the franchise as it will give a proper conclusion to the story of the god of thunder.
6. Kate Bishop - Hawkeye
Kate Bishop was one of the most unexpected standouts from the Hawkeye TV show. Not only did she instantly become one of the most lovable characters in the franchise, but she's also one of the best-written ones we've gotten in a long time.
The young girl lost a lot when her father died during the first Avengers movie, and it's this grief that inspires her to pick up a bow and arrow and train to be like the person she idolizes most: Hawkeye. However, even though she constantly strives to be better, she still feels like a failure in many aspects, such as her hero Clint Barton often not approving of her way or how she's never able to find a healthy relationship with her mother.
These issues give the character depth in ways that make us grow an extreme emotional attachment to her. Combine this with a young and naïve nature, and Kate is easily one of the most fun additions we've gotten in the MCU.
Luckily, she just debuted in Hawkeye, which means we'll likely see her in future projects.
5. Loki - Loki
Outside of Thanos, the only other villain that has become one of the most iconic in the MCU is easily Loki. He was conniving, clever, and somebody you always wanted to see more of, especially in phase 1 with his more prevalent role.
However, it wouldn’t be until Phase Four that Loki finally got his debut as a protagonist with the Disney+ series, and it is one of the best to come out.
Like in Ragnarok, Loki shows that even though he’s destined to be evil, there’s still a side of him that's good, a deeper part of him that has been tucked away for years but comes out to light during the conflict of the series that shows us that even a guy like Loki can be noble and find love in unexpected ways.
The romance with his alternate self Sylvie feels somewhat uncanny at first, but we get to see a deeper side of the character because of this; through this, we learn that even though he’s the god of mischief, he’s still just as human as us.
4. Wanda Maximoff - WandaVision
Like other characters, Wanda is also someone who shined on the small screen after the MCU decided to explore more of her after having a relatively minor role in the films, and she is easily the best character to have gotten this treatment.
Wanda has gone through many things in her life, including abusive experimentation and the loss of everyone she’s ever cared about, and yet, through all of this, she continues to fight and even holds her own against Agatha Harkness.
She’s a character with one of the most well-defined backstories of the MCU, the likes of which we haven’t really seen all that much of in the films and could only be done by an extensive TV show like WandaVision—seeing her struggle to come to terms with her reality and eventual acceptance of her suffering developed her character in a natural way that was engaging to watch and served as the best part of her series.
While it’s probable that we’ll see her as a villain in the future, she’s still someone who’s proved to be one of the best-written characters in the MCU and will likely make a significant impact in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness.
3. Peter Parker - Spider-Man Home Trilogy
Before we got Tom Holland as Spider-Man, we already had two versions of the Web-slinger in the beloved Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield, meaning that the Spidey who would fill the void of the character in the MCU had a lot to live up to. Luckily, Tom Holland delivered.
It was clear from his first appearance in Civil War that this Spider-Man would be much more child-like than what we’ve seen before, with his goofy attitude and naïve nature being at the center of Civil War.
While Homecoming and Far From Home expanded on the character significantly, it wasn’t until No Way Home that we truly got to see the character turn into the Spider-Man he was always destined to be.
Peter Parker went through some lifechanging events here, including the death of his mother figure, the loss of MJ, and even the loss of his own identity. He was forced to live the life of a broke Peter by the end of the film and make it out on his own as classic Spider-Man.
He’s a well-written character whose past trauma helped build him up and turn him into who he is, making Tom Holland an amazing Spider-Man.
2. Steve Rogers - Captain America Trilogy
Everybody loves the story of an underdog. There’s something that we humans love in seeing someone nobody believed in making it up the ranks to become something great than himself. This is what makes the story of Captain America a quintessential one.
Steve Rogers was a small skinny man who wanted to fight for his country and do something with his life. But because of his stature, that wasn’t possible, which makes us sympathize with him; we want to see him achieve his goal and prove all the bullies wrong. Something that he eventually reaches through nothing but his noble nature.
However, the story of Captain America doesn’t end there as we see him deal with the struggles to live in a time you don’t belong to or feeling like everything you once loved is now gone beyond your reach. Deep themes and struggles that feel right out of classic stories.
Steve Rogers is one of the most relatable characters in the MCU and one of the heroes most of us will never forget, especially after Endgame gave him one of the most poetic endings in recent times.
1. Tony Stark - Iron Man Trilogy
Few characters have defined the MCU as a whole in the same way that Tony Stark has. He's the character who started the cinematic universe as we know, giving us a story of a man who took what he had for granted until he almost lost all of it.
However, this moment of near-death made him realize the problems in the world, and it was because of this that he turned into the Iron Man we all love. Tony Stark might still be egotistical and selfish at times, but he’s also highly emotional. His love for Pepper Potts can be seen across all three Iron Man movies, and later on, in Infinity War and Endgame, we see his love for Peter Parker.
He’s already a character that fans loved more than anything by the end of Iron Man 3. Moreover, his subsequent role in Infinity War and Endgame made him an icon across all cinema.
His fight against Thanos and subsequent sacrifice is something none of us have forgotten even after the many years since it originally happened, and we all shed a tear when he said the faithful words: I Am Iron Man.