Every Muppet Movie Ranked Worst To Best

Which of Kermit, Miss Piggy and the rest of the gang's adventures is the best?

By Michael John-Day /

Jim Henson is one of the founding fathers of children's television, and in his time he generated some of the most notable characters ever seen in the medium. These iconic creations of his have gone on to become a big part of culture, and his legacy is truly secure in the knowledge that his work was beloved, and out of all the properties he made, it is hard to argue that The Muppets are not the most iconic.

Advertisement

This loveable group of puppets - led by the ever adored Kermit the Frog - have had a great career, and seem to be still somewhat popular. Although their original presence and subsequent revival in 2011 were the main highlights and their current position is muddled, it's hard not to fondly remember the group as a fantastic franchise.

Taking the characters and putting them to film was a big risk, but thankfully it paid off as the movies generated by this property are mostly beloved classics. There have been eight cinematic Muppet movie releases - not counting the two TV movies - and each one brings a charming adventure to life with the medium of puppetry.

They all deserve praise for the work and passion that went into creating them, but which ones are the cream of the crop?

8. Muppets From Space

A real black sheep of the Muppet family, this film was not a shining example of the standard that the characters usually brought, and even became their last theatrical project for another twelve years. While there is a lot of valid negativity around this film, it still needs to be said that the feature is entirely inoffensive. It's not a terrible movie, just an inadequate representation of the quality expected from this franchise.

Advertisement

Eventually, in a silly family-friendly series, there comes a time when sci-fi elements are introduced, and it often acts as a last-ditch attempt to make the property fresh again. In the case of Muppets from Space, this attempt feels misplaced, as the characters have always been grounded in reality, despite being puppets.

One of the most significant omissions from the film is the fact that it doesn't feature original music, opting instead to utilise classic Funk and Soul tracks. This instantly strips it of charm as the astounding musical numbers were a central selling point for the franchise, and this decision felt lazy.

When even Frank Oz says that the film was "not the movie we wanted it to be." then you know it's a weak point for the series.

7. Muppet Treasure Island

The Muppets have had many ventures into parodying TV and Film, but there have also been a few occasions where they have delved into the world of literature, and one of the most notable came from Muppet Treasure Island.

Advertisement

This was an ambitious film that sought to bring the classic Robert Louis Stevenson tale to life in a similar vein to the success they had adapting some of Charles Dickens work, but sadly it pales in comparison to Christmas Carol.

One positive highlight comes from the performance of Tim Curry in the role of Long John Silver. It's played precisely the kind of way you would expect Curry to tackle this iconic role, but surrounded by puppets. He loves every second that he is on screen, and plays to the nasty side of the character with the utmost joy.

However, the films biggest falter comes from the fact that it simply doesn't translate as well as it should. The characters don't fall into the slots they are given all too well, and the entire adventure is surprisingly mundane, despite the swashbuckling pirate fun to be had.

It seems that this classic children's story wasn't the right choice for the loveable group of puppets.

6. Muppets Most Wanted

The Muppets Most Wanted is a relatively underappreciated title. While it certainly has its drawbacks, there is a tonne of fun to be had in this film that often gets overlooked. It has many great jokes - mostly centred on attacking sequels - and a hilarious story of an evil version of Kermit.

Advertisement

Seeing all of the characters back again after the success of their first rebooted movie is exciting, and right off the bat, they make it clear that this film will not be taking itself too seriously. The incredibly catchy introduction song sets up the story quickly, and you are thrown right into the action. It then follows a similar trajectory, being always energetic and forward moving.

Sadly there are a few faults that bring it down, mostly from the fact that it overall is lacking some of the classic Muppet charm. The high budget and overload of pop culture references make it feel dated, and while the previous film faced similar issues, it worked well because the human side of the story was so well fused into the outlandish set-up. This movie doesn't have that same emotional core to keep it from feeling overly commercial.

Additionally, while Ricky Gervais is a great comedian, his position here is a little unnatural, as he often plays with reserved energy as opposed to the overly-expressive and goofy presence that the characters typically take.

5. The Muppets Take Manhattan

Seeing the Muppets focus on Broadway and musicals was an entirely appropriate direction for them to go in. Although this film ranks a little lower, it's mostly due to the high competition of the other titles in this franchise, as Muppets Take Manhattan is still a heartfelt and enjoyable movie that does something exciting with the characters.

Advertisement

The competitive and soul-crushing world of Broadway and showbusiness is made clear in this movie, and despite the happier moments, it doesn't sugar-coat the more depressing side of the world they are exploring. The only real drawback is its lack of originality, as the story of a group of aspiring performers attempting to put their show on has been seen plenty of times before - even within the Muppets series.

With that being said, what it lacks in originality, it certainly makes up for in excellent character work and fun songs. The focus on musicals meant that the score for this film needed to be good, and in true Muppet fashion, the musical numbers are one of the biggest highlights.

Again, it only ranks lower as despite being a wonderfully wholesome and fun adventure, it is mostly a standard paint-by-numbers Muppet film.

4. The Great Muppet Caper

As the first Muppet movie sequel, this feature needed to prove that it's predecessor wasn't beginners luck, and thankfully it did so. Overall the title played it safe but proved that the Muppets were more than capable of generating great on-screen memories.

Advertisement

The focus on crime and journalism gives the title a unique edge when compared to the other films, and allows for some darker humour. But ultimately it acts as another simple and straightforward outing for the characters, but a well achieved one at least.

As is to be expected with a Muppet movie, one of the best dynamics and highlights of the film is the love angle between Kermit and Miss Piggy. Their connection is always full of good humour and heart, and that is no exception here as the instant chemistry between the two puppets is tested as Miss Piggy lies about who she is. This leads to some great conflict and a fun resolution.

The film proves that sometimes sticking to the formula can work, even if it strips the final product of a distinct personality.

3. The Muppet Christmas Carol

The classic tale of Ebenezer Scrooge - written by the iconic Charles Dickens - is a story that has truly transcended literature and become an integral part of Christmas. It's an essential story about the spirit of generosity, compassion and charity, which is entirely in keeping with the themes and wholesomeness of The Muppets.

Advertisement

Many people think of this adaptation as their definitive version of this tale, and that is understandable. The Muppet Christmas Carol is a perfect blend of the traditional story with a cute and wholesome collection of characters, all of which are slotted into the story perfectly.

Seeing the creativity of Jim Henson brought to the supernatural story is fantastic, as the designs for the ghosts of Christmas still hold up to this day. The entire look of the film juxtaposes the sweetness of the Muppets with the darkness of the original tale through its fantastic set design and wonderful characters.

It also did a lot for the future of Muppet movies, as it was the first one to use a green-screen. This not only allowed for beautiful blue skies but meant that the characters could be brought to life more convincingly. The method also gave the cinematographers the chance to use a variety of camera angles in a way they hadn't been able to before.

2. The Muppets

When audiences found out that Disney would be bringing the Muppets back to the big screen, there was a sense of hesitance and reservation. While the characters have always been fun and wholesome, there was still a dark edge that kept them going, and it was thought that Disney might misunderstand this. However, the rebooted Muppets movie was a fantastic new story that was nostalgic and progressive simultaneously.

Advertisement

Feeling more like a large-scale Broadway musical, this film took the characters and pushed them to the max. Each central Muppet was given an important part to play and was treated with the respect they deserved. In addition to this, the introduction of Walter and his brother Gary delivered a great new Muppet and forged an emotional story.

The leading roles being characters outside of the Muppets was a wise move as it allowed the audience to enter the film as an outsider, no matter how familiar they might have been with the series. Although some of the cameos make the film feel dated, they also act like a time-capsule for the early 2010s, which is charming in its own right.

For all of those reasons, this surprisingly good reboot of the franchise ranks as one of its best entries.

1. The Muppet Movie

This film released to scores of positive reviews and still proves that sometimes the first outing can forever remain the best. The Muppet Movie is an extremely fun production that combines the charm of the characters with a simple story that gives them each an opportunity to shine.

Advertisement

The film tells of Kermit's journey to make it to an audition in Hollywood and picks up almost every major character on the way. It also features a great antagonist in the form of Doc Hopper, an entrepreneur who feels cheated after Kermit refuses to endorse his french-fried frog legs restaurant.

The feature combines this simple road-trip with a funny and petty villain well and allows for the main focus to be on the relationship and humour shared between the iconic characters.

Again the dynamic between Miss Piggy and Kermit is hilarious, Fozzie is on top form as the cheesy comedian, and Gonzo delivers on his usual antics but pushed to the max. It all culminates with a fantastic sequence singing The Rainbow Connection, which is quickly the most emotional and memorable song in the franchise.

The Muppet Movie shows how simplicity can be the best way to approach the introduction of a beloved property to the big screen and is easily the best of the bunch.

Advertisement