Fantastic Beasts: 10 Actors Who Could Replace Fired Johnny Depp

Johnny Depp has been FIRED, so who can take over as the new Gellert Grindelwald?

By Josh Wilding /

Johnny Depp has recently been embroiled in a legal battle against The Sun newspaper which he ended up losing (it boiled down to a judge deciding that the publication was well within its right to brand the actor a "wife-beater" following his divorce from Amber Heard). Over the course of that court case, Depp's dirty laundry was aired publicly, and he hasn't come out his libel battle looking good.

Advertisement

As a result, it was no great surprise on Friday when the actor shared a statement revealing, "I have been asked to resign by Warner Bros. from my role as Grindelwald in Fantastic Beasts and I have respected and agreed to that request." In case you can't read between the lines, that's a nice way of saying he was fired.

Production on the next Fantastic Beasts movie hasn't been halted in the UK, and the studio is now on the hunt for a new actor to take over the role so Gellert Grindelwald's story can continue.

Depp's been making headlines for all the wrong reasons for years now, and that's led to many Harry Potter fans wondering why he was cast in the first place. However, his are still big shoes to fill, but these ten possibilities stand a chance of taking the character and making him even better...

10. Robert Downey Jr.

Robert Downey Jr.'s time as Iron Man in the Marvel Cinematic Universe has come to an end, and with the next Sherlock Holmes movie on hold due to current world events, he could very easily squeeze Fantastic Beasts 3 into his schedule.

Advertisement

Like Johnny Depp, Downey is an actor who brings a similar sense of charm - and eccentricity - to each of the characters he plays. If Warner Bros. is keen to retain a sense of consistency with Gellert Grindelwald (without hiring someone to basically do an impersonation), then the Avengers: Endgame star feels like the perfect choice.

Making this even more likely is the fact that Downey is no stranger working with Jude Law thanks to those Sherlock Holmes movies, and Warner Bros. is likely all too aware that the chemistry they share on screen would be beneficial to Fantastic Beasts.

Plus, everyone loves the man who spent so long playing Tony Stark, and that alone would be a good way of moving on from the negative publicity generated by Depp.

9. Matt Bomer

Matt Bomer has to be one of the most underrated talents working in Hollywood today, but his work in the likes of American Horror Story, The Sinner, and Doom Patrol really is terrific. With many fans hoping to see the romantic relationship between Albus Dumbledore and Gellert Grindelwald explored in some way, hiring an openly gay actor to provide some insight into that would be smart.

Advertisement

There's much more to Bomer than his sexuality, of course, and the talented actor could put a fresh spin of the lead villain in the Fantastic Beasts franchise.

Depp portrayed him as a creepy weirdo, but Bomer is someone who could bring a lot of charm and flair to the role, explaining in the process why so many wizards decided to align themselves with him. Lord Voldermort ruled through fear, but Gridenwald was a very different beast, and it would be great seeing this actor bring a mixture of charisma and complete madness to the table.

Bomer may not be the biggest name on this list, but he's one who could bring a lot to this franchise!

8. Tom Hardy

Tom Hardy is one of the most charismatic and talented actors you'll find in Hollywood, and it's hard to find two of his performances which are anywhere near the same. That makes it hard to imagine what he might bring to a role like this one, but combine Inception with Legend and Venom, and you might have an idea of the batsh*t crazy things he could get up to as Gellert Grindelwald.

Advertisement

It feels like the main reasons Warner Bros. cast Johnny Depp is because they wanted him to deliver one of his signature, "strange" performances, but Hardy is someone who can both make Grindelwald his own, while also giving the studio the eccentric, unique villain they want for this franchise.

Whether it's Marvel, Mad Max, or even Star Wars (in a deleted scene from The Last Jedi which should have never been left on the cutting room floor), Hardy is no stranger to iconic franchises, and it's hard to imagine him saying no to the chance of being able to enter the world of Harry Potter!

If he were to play Grindelwald, here's hoping he'll be easier to understand than in some past roles!

7. Michael Fassbender

As Magneto in the X-Men franchise, Michael Fassbender did his best with the material he had to work with. Brought back again and again as a rival to Professor X and his team, fans ultimately got sick of his Master of Magnetism, often overlooking how damn good an actor he is.

Advertisement

Whether it's his scene stealing performance in Quentin Tarantino's Inglourious Basterds, or his awards-worthy performances in the likes of Shame and Steve Jobs, Fassbender is a bona fide star, but one who hasn't been as overexposed as some of the actors on this list!

That alone gives him something of an edge, and a mixture of Magneto's ferocity with David's cold, calculating nature from Prometheus would arguably make for a perfect Gellert Grindelwald.

The problem with Johnny Depp's quirky take on the character is that he didn't feel overly frightening or intimidating; Fassbender, on the other hand, could transform Grindelwald into a wizard who it feels really stands a chance of taking over the wizarding world. The actor budding heads with Jude Law's Albus Dumbledore is also an intriguing prospect.

6. Matt Smith

Rumour has it that former Doctor Who Matt Smith was once set to play a younger version of Emperor Palpatine in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker (likely after the villain had used Rey and Ben Solo to rejuvenate himself). That was reported by reliable sources, but it seems fans may never truly know what went on behind the scenes.

Advertisement

Of course, Smith's goofy Terminator Genisys performance aside, and his work in both film and television is certainly proof enough that he has the potential to play an iconic big screen baddie.

If the plan is to continue portraying Gellert Grindelwald in a creepy, sinister fashion, then Smith is arguably one of the best possible choices. He has a unique look, and an aura about him which could ensure that Albus Dumbledore's one-time closest ally continues to stand out as a dark wizard who is, in many ways, even more terrifying than Lord Voldermort.

Smith may have seemingly missed out on Star Wars, but there's nothing to say he can't still land the sort of role which puts him on the map as a great movie villain; this might just be that role!

5. Benedict Cumberbatch

Benedict Cumberbatch is going to have a busy few months with Spider-Man 3 and Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, but considering the fact he shot his Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame scenes mostly by himself, there's really no reason he couldn't squeeze in Fantastic Beasts 3!

Advertisement

For many fans, he's now best known for playing the Marvel Cinematic Universe's Sorcerer Supreme, but don't forget, he's also pretty damn great at being a baddie (see Star Trek Into Darkness and The Hobbit movies for proof of that). Everyone loves the former Sherlock too, and his involvement in the Harry Potter spinoff franchise would give Warner Bros. some much-needed positive publicity.

As noted, having an actor basically impersonate Johnny Depp would be a mistake; however, there needs to be some similarities, and Cumberbatch is talented enough to find the right mix of new and old. Paying homage to what's come before, the British actor could put a fresh spin on Grindelwald too.

That feels like the best possible approach, and it's one which Cumberbatch would be a good fit for.

4. Dan Stevens

Dan Stevens was the actor hidden behind all those visual effects in Disney's live-action Beauty and the Beast, but chances are you'll know him best from FX's Legion. There, he played the unhinged David Haller, and it's that sort of insanity which could be essential for this new take on Gellert Grindelwald.

Advertisement

As sinister as the villain might be, there's definitely more than a few screws loose up there, and Stevens has proved himself to be an expert at jumping between charming and completely mad.

The fact he's well-known, but not necessarily an "A-Lister," could go in Stevens' favour; after all, it means that expectations on him are likely to be lower, and he's likely to have fewer reservations about following in Johnny Depp's footsteps because there are no preconceived notions about what he'll do with the role.

It might boil down to how much star power Warner Bros. is looking for, but if they want to do a risk and try something new, Stevens definitely deserves to be considered!

3. Jake Gyllenhaal

It felt like Jake Gyllenhaal spent years avoiding blockbuster fare after Prince of Persia bombed, but after some downright incredible performances in movies like Nightcrawler and Prisoners, he returned to the world of big budget filmmaking with Spider-Man: Far From Home.

Advertisement

As Mysterio, the actor definitely impressed. Charming, borderline unhinged, and a complete loon, Quentin Beck was a great baddie, and might have been a nice way of setting the stage for Gyllenhaal to take on another big screen villain. As Gellert Grindelwald, he'd offer a nice combination of madness with the sort of charisma that explains why Albus Dumbledore once considered following him.

Most importantly in some ways is the fact that Gyllenhaal is absolutely nothing like Johnny Depp.

While there's a possibility that Warner Bros. will want to have an actor follow his performance with a similar one, it makes far more sense to move on from that and let whoever is cast do their own thing. That would be easy for Gyllenhaal, especially when his performances are so often transformative.

2. Christian Bale

While Christian Bale has mostly avoided big budget blockbusters since his time as Batman in The Dark Knight Trilogy reached its end, the fact he starts shooting Thor: Love and Thunder early next year proves the notoriously picky actor won't say no to the right project.

Advertisement

With that in mind, it's easy to picture him boarding the Fantastic Beasts franchise if there's a way to make it work. Just like Johnny Depp brought a sense of madness to the role, so too could Bale. The likes of American Psycho and The Fighter have proved that, and it would be a blast seeing the sort of weird and wacky performance the actor could bring to this series.

The problem with Depp at this point in his career is that it feels like he's just playing different versions of the same character, but Bale is someone who constantly reinvents himself.

Because of that, it's easy to picture the former Dark Knight offering a fresh, weird new take on Grindelwald, while also bringing even more star power to the Fantastic Beasts movies.

1. Colin Farrell

In Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, Colin Farrell played Percival Graves, the Director of Magical Security for MACUSA, and an Auror who wasted no time in taking aim at Newt Scamander.

Advertisement

Of course, it was during the final act that it was revealed Gellert Grindelwald had been posing as Graves, with Depp's face revealed as a tease for what was to come in the sequel. With the villain once again on the run from wizarding authorities and more notorious than ever before, it would make sense for him to change his face again, and using some of his old Polyjuice potion might make sense.

A reason for a permanent change in his appearance could be explained with a few throwaway lines of exposition and, in all honesty, Farrell was a way better baddie in the first Fantastic Beasts movie than Depp was in the sequel anyway!

This is an obvious and logical choice for Grindelwald's future, and it might just boil down to the Irish actor's availability.

Advertisement