Logan: 12 Theories That Were Utter Bull

No, Xavier is not a ghost.

By Jack Pooley /

Fox

Logan has been one of the most buzzed-about movies of the last year, and as is inevitable with any high-profile superhero movie, the fan theories reach an absolute fever pitch leading up to release.

Advertisement

From the delusional to the optimistic to the surprisingly believable, these 12 theories about various sequences and characters in the movie all turned out to be total bunk.

Now, blessed with the benefit of hindsight, fans can see just how ridiculous some of them were, but can concede that, actually, a few of them made a ton of sense and probably would've worked.

Advertisement

Obviously, it goes without saying that major spoilers for Logan will follow, and now that the film is finally out, comic book fans can devote every ounce of their energy to figuring out the next major movie on the slate: Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 2. Get busy...

12. Sabretooth Is In It

20th Century Fox

The Theory: Wolverine's half-brother Victor Creed aka Sabretooth was heavily rumoured to appear in the film, with Liev Schreiber reprising his role from X-Men Origins: Wolverine (one of the few things praised about that mostly terrible movie).

Advertisement

The Truth: Though Schreiber did enter talks to play a part in the movie (and it would've made a lot of sense for him to take the place of X-24 as the ultimate Big Bad), it didn't work out in the end and Schreiber doesn't appear in the movie in any way, shape or form.

A shame, sure, but the movie did just fine without him, and it probably would've just aggravated those who would prefer to forget Origins ever existed anyway.

Advertisement

11. Richard E. Grant Is Really Playing Mister Sinister

20th Century Fox

The Theory: Richard E. Grant's role in the film was kept fiercely under wraps for a long time before finally being confirmed to be Dr. Zander Rice, but even then, many fans still believed they were being hoodwinked, and he was in fact playing the supervillain Mister Sinister.

Advertisement

The Truth: Grant does indeed play Rice in a relatively small role, and the movie makes no direct references to Sinister at all, despite previous claims from Bryan Singer that he would show up in some form.

Director James Mangold ultimately vetoed a Sinister cameo as he felt it wouldn't be tonally consistent with the rest of the story, and that really seems like the right call here.

Advertisement

Also, don't expect to see Grant again, because Logan puts a bullet through Rice's head in the third act. He's done.

10. Logan Wears His Iconic Yellow-And-Black Costume

20th Century Fox

The Theory: You might remember a deleted scene from 2013's The Wolverine where Logan is given the iconic yellow-and-black suit from the comics, but he never actually wears it. Well, a segment of fans believed this to be a set-up for the next solo Wolverine movie where he'd finally don it for at least one scene, and even in spite of Logan's grittier tone, fans continued to believe it right up to release.

Advertisement

It didn't help that Hugh Jackman himself teased it by tweeting a mysterious image of a classic yellow-and-black Wolverine action figure just a few weeks ago.

The Truth: No, he keeps it simple with a white shirt and black jacket or blue overshirt for most of the movie. And thank God this didn't happen. Tonal dissonance much?

Advertisement

9. Deadpool Appears In A Post-Credits Scene

Fox

The Theory: It was long-rumoured that Deadpool would appear in Logan in a post-credits scene to further bolster Fox's Marvel Cinematic Universe, and even when Ryan Reynolds and others assured fans this wasn't the case, that didn't stop them assuming they were being tricked.

Advertisement

Plus, with the movie's final run-time being slightly altered ahead of release, some took this to assume a secret post-credits scene featuring the character had been held back until the very last minute.

The Truth: Deadpool is nowhere to be seen and isn't remotely referenced, mentioned or hinted at, and that's exactly the way it should be. Again, the mood whiplash would've been strong, even in a credits sequence detached from the rest of the movie.

Advertisement

8. Professor X Is Dead The Whole Time

20th Century Fox

The Theory: One of the more compelling and intriguing fan theories was that Charles Xavier was actually already dead before the movie even began, and appeared only as either a figment of Logan's imagination or, more likely, as a psychic projection Xavier created before his physical body died.

Advertisement

The Truth: Juicy and interesting though this is, Xavier is really just an old guy with the worst case of Alzheimer's in recorded history. There's no supernatural twist related to Xavier's existence here. He does die, but it's a very brisk, physical moment, and then he's simply gone.

7. There's A Flashback To The Mutant Apocalypse

20th Century Fox

The Theory: It was already known prior to release that mutants are largely wiped out by the time Logan begins, and many fans believed that the film would feature a sequence depicting the mysterious apocalyptic event that killed off most of the mutants, complete with cameos from many of the original X-Men stars.

Advertisement

The Truth: First off, there's not a single legacy cameo here, so no sign of Famke Janssen, James Marsden, Halle Berry, Ian McKellen or anyone like that, and secondly, no, there are no flashbacks to the mutant extermination.

It's really better off this way, because the eventual implied reveal, that Xavier himself accidentally killed a large portion of the mutant population during a psionic episode, is so much more powerful when we have to imagine the horror ourselves. It's brilliantly done.

Advertisement

6. Laura Kills Xavier

Fox

The Theory: One of the more mysterious visuals from Logan's marketing was the bizarre event presumably caused by Xavier's deteriorating mind, which some assumed might've forced Laura, who was seemingly crawling towards him in this shot, to kill him and stop potentially millions of people being wiped out.

Advertisement

The Truth: The scene in question is fantastic, but it's ultimately resolved by Logan administering medication to Xavier just in time. Xavier is eventually stabbed to death by the Logan clone X-24 later on, and Laura thankfully doesn't have to make such a dire choice.

5. Time Travel Is Involved

Fox

The Theory: This theory was always pretty out-there, but entertaining enough that it warrants inclusion. A heavily-upvoted Reddit theory stated that Logan would take Laura back to 1983 at the end of the movie and leave her to be trained by Xavier, which would create a new unpredictable timeline for future movies.

Advertisement

Another compelling theory also suggested that a time-traveling Cable might show up in order to recruit Laura for the X-Force, a movie of which is currently in the works.

The Truth: On both counts, a resounding no. Time travel is so messy that it's probably for the best that Logan just stuck to doing its own thing. There's no time tinkering and no Cable.

Advertisement

4. Daken Is The Main Antagonist

Marvel

The Theory: The first trailer briefly showed a pair of claws attacking Logan, and this caused rampant speculation that his mutant son Daken would appear in the film, considering he's one of the few major X-Men characters to have three claws in that specific arrangement on each hand and, well, it just honestly made a lot of sense.

Advertisement

The Truth: Despite a lot of fans being quite understandably convinced that Daken would definitely appear in the film, he's actually nowhere to be seen, and the claws in fact belong to X-24. More on that in a moment, though...

3. Logan Attends A Mutant Funeral

Fox

The Theory: A shot from the first trailer shows Logan suited up and boozing it up at a graveyard during a funeral, causing many to assume he was attending the funeral of a fallen mutant.

Advertisement

The Truth: Though this is one of the more grounded and plausible theories on this list, it's sadly still wrong. Logan is working as a limo driver at the start of the movie, and he's only at the funeral in order to pick up one of the attendees for his next job. Not quite as haunting as it looks, but the drinking is still pretty damn grim.

2. Donald Pierce Gets Turned Into X-24

Fox

The Theory: A last-minute avalanche of theories and "spoilers" came down the pike when the movie's soundtrack listing was released about a week ahead of release.

Advertisement

Two of the soundtrack's 25 titles caught fans' interest in particular: "X-24" and "Logan vs. X-24", which made it clear that Logan would be fighting a mutant antagonist at some point.

This combined with the pair of claws attempting to stab Logan in the trailer fanned the fanboy flames, and got some thinking that perhaps after unsuccessfully defeating Logan, Donald Pierce would be transformed into a test subject by Zander Rice.

Advertisement

The Truth: Pierce doesn't undergo any additional transformations throughout the film and honestly doesn't really do much combat-wise against Logan either.

X-24 is actually just a clone of Logan, with a more youthful appearance and short, shaved haircut, who shows up about half-way through the film and has two fights with Logan before being dispatched in the finale.

Advertisement

1. Logan Is Responsible For The Deaths Of The X-Men

Fox

The Theory: This theory is drawn straight from the Old Man Logan comic so it's undeniably well-founded. In the original story, Logan is actually the cause of a mutant massacre, killing the residents of the X-Mansion after Mysterio tricked his mind into believing that an attack on the mansion was taking place.

Advertisement

This of course explains Logan's seeming exile in the movie and the fact that all of the iconic mutants fans know and love aren't around anymore.

The Truth: Logan isn't remotely responsible. As mentioned, Xavier basically suggests that the onset of his dementia caused an incident in West Chester that killed at least most of the X-Men if not the majority of the mutants residing in the U.S. also.

Advertisement

Which Logan theories are you most surprised turned out to be total bull? Shout them out in the comments!