Logan: Every Major Character Ranked From Worst To Best
Heroes and villains at the end of the world...
Logan is a lot of things to a lot of fans. For some it's the greatest comic book movie ever. For others, it's the perfect send off for the best ever character. For yet more, it's a harrowing, grim story of loss, hope and devastation that is as entertaining and brave as it is thoroughly unrepeatable. Nobody should want to revisit those wounds in a hurry.
What is not up for debate is the film's quality: it is a towering achievement in cinematography, performance and writing that absolutely deserves the Oscar attention that it unforgivably won't get next year. And even with limited bredth in its characters - because this is still supposed to be a post-apocalyptic journey and isolation and solitude are key parts to the claustrophobic feel - the film still feels satisfyingly populated.
Inevitably, not everyone enjoys the same kind of screen-time as the central three, but each adds something, and any failings in their characterisation mostly only tell in the wider context of the film's genius.
Forget calling it a three person road play, Logan has a surprising number of characters who are supposed to matter. It's just a shame that some of them are far more successful than others...
12. The Corn Syrup Hicks
Let's all be perfectly honest here, the "corn syrup is evil" is probably the least subtle and least successful part of the film, and while it ties to Shane as a primary influence on James Mangold's approach to the movie, it's little more than a distraction.
That makes it remarkably hard to care about the redneck corporate stooges introduced as antagonists for the Munson sub-plot. They're about as cliched as you're likely to find in a Western, drawing just short of calling Eriq La Salle's Will Munson "boy". They're good old boys, in a bad old boy outer casing, and their lack of screen-time makes it very clear that they're designed purely as cannon fodder to give X-24's arrival look even more brutal.
Sure, they're not difficult to dislike, but it's hard to really care about them too much when they're getting their heads sliced off.
11. Dr Zander Rice
It's rather a shame that James Mangold didn't want to use Mr Sinister as the real big bad of Logan - even just as an off-screen over-arching presence that it's clear Donald Pierce is answering to. Because his replacement - Richard E Grant's Dr Zander Rice - isn't really up to much.
He's unfortunately side-lined, and while he plays a key role in explaining the backstory of the mutant kids, that information is delivered in such cynically expositionary fashion that you wonder if that was his sole purpose.
Frustratingly, there's also a hint of something better here: almost in passing we learn that his father was one of Wolverine's victims when he brought down the Weapon X programme (in the comics Dale Rice suffers the same fate). But there isn't enough of Rice's personal tragedy in his characterisation: it's presented as almost coincidental to his arc, when it should have been definitive.
All-n-all, he's too cold and removed and not creepy enough by half, but then a grander character might well have been too distracting, so he's not at all fatal.
10. Gabriela
Fear The Walking Dead's Elizabeth Rodriguez does well to get much out of the material she's given to work with in the opening act. In truth, she's no more than a narrative device - and like Rice, her primary function is establishing the backstory of X-23 and her fellow mutants.
Gabriela opens a lot of questions - like why Alkali Transigen would hire real nurses to "care" for their clones when it's precisely that compassion that inevitably sees them rebel when the clones are being disposed of. And quite frankly, her function could have been replaced by the VERY handy videos she cut together as Logan's essential look at Transigen's backstory without the film really losing much.
But the performance is still raw and real, and there's a real sense of her fear for Laura while she's on screen. It's just a shame that her lack of development means her death doesn't really carry much tragedy (particularly as Laura barely seems to even notice it).
9. The Munsons
Nobody in Logan gets screwed quite as much as The Munsons. They open their home to the pretend Howlett family after they save them from the bewitched Canewell trucks that seem to have a thirst for their blood, feed them, give them sanctuary and are then slaughtered pitilessly by X-24.
Their involvement is little more than emotional manipulation - which is why we get very little development beyond knowing they're put upon small-holders at the mercy of a corporate land-owning enemy - but each of the actors play their roles well. And they offer just enough of a flash of normalcy to make Logan's situation all the more tragic, even if it all comes crashing down in brutal fashion.
The shot of Nate lying with his guts open is one of the most haunting of the entire film, and a big statement that the film really wasn't messing around.
It's slightly unfortunate that the whole sequence is a little ruined by Will's sudden, temporarily invincibility that sees him survive X-24's initial attack for just long enough to crash him into the combine harvester, but it's nice he got some revenge at least.
8. The Reavers
The Reavers are an interesting group: they look great, with their cyborg-like augmentations and hulking physiques, but in reality they're very possibly the worst set of mercenaries in the history of film. The great contradiction in their backstory is that we're supposed to believe that they were capable of bringing in mutants for experimentation when they can't shoot in a straight line, can't fight terrified kids and are generally wholly incompetent.
But at least they play the part of satisfying cannon fodder well: unlike, say, the Chitauri in The Avengers they're a malignant enough presence - as an extension of Donald Pierce - to make their demise actually feel good. And achieving that without much dialogue is actually quite impressive.
Just don't expect to remember a single line or act they're responsible for.
7. The Mutey Kids
Other than Rictor, and maybe Bobby the electrically-powered mutant (who is surprisingly chubby for a genetically "pure" clone, but whatever) it's hard to really feel much for the mutant kids. Sure, the IDEA of them is very compelling, and what they represent to Laura and to the future of mutantkind, but they're not really on screen that much.
They're pretty much an exact replica of the Mad Max future kids, and Logan is their temporary Fagin (without the stealing or the anti-Semitism), but they obviously score added points for the brief flashes of their powers we actually get to see in the film's climax.
There's a lot of promise for the group IF Fox decide to go with an X-23 led New Mutants future spin-off (not to be confused with Josh Boone's other New Mutants spin-off, mind you). You can definitely see them on a sort of Amblin-style adventure evading capture while trying to find their identities.
6. Donald Pierce
Donald Pierce probably could have been an even better presence in the film if he was given a little more to do. As it is, he's muzzled somewhat by a strange desire for nobody to shoot and kill the mutant children who he's attempting to kill to clear up his mess of letting the go. He's also sidelined when Zander Rice and X-24 start to play more prominent roles in the latter half of the film.
But up until that point, Boyd Holbrook's loquacious Southern rascal is an entertaining part of the film: he boasts near narrative omnipotence (which is important for the claustrophobia Logan feels), and he delivers his menacing threats through a smile and a roguish charm that isn't wholly unlikeable.
He's almost like the Child Catcher from Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, even if it's a shame that he doesn't quite get to flex his muscles in combat. That being said, he does show flashes of outright malevolence - particularly when torturing Caliban - and he's definitely the film's more convincing organic villain.
5. X-24
Though the revelation that Zander Rice also created a second clone of Wolverine is almost on the same silliness scale as the Weapon XI shenanigans in X-Men Origins, it's not completely unsuccessful, and it adds the right sort of explosive threat to help wrap the film up.
And at least the clone allowed for some impressive CGI de-ageing of Hugh Jackman, which really ought to impress the awards-givers next year.
The performance is also more than just pure rage, even if part of the point of the character is that he's a distilled, more one-dimensional weapon without the distractions of humanity. It's all surprisingly subtle, actually. There's a strange almost child-like quality to his animalism - and a fierce adoration for his "father" Rice - that basically makes him an extremely angry Frankenstein's monster, and it really is exhilarating to see flashes of the old berserker alongside the wizened broken version.
4. Caliban
Despite his traditional appearances in the comics as a morally complex character - and an outright villain at some points - Stephen Merchant's take on Caliban is a far softer creation, and an almost maternal influence on the other three main characters.
He plays his part almost comically - the archetype of a put-upon wife, washing Logan's clothes, tending to his wounds and feeding him and Charles - and the casting of the other-worldly Merchant is surprisingly perfect.
There's a layer of the character that possibly should have been explored a little more, as it's entirely implausible that this character would ever align himself with the bad guys, but he's still a very engaging presence, whose heroic sacrifice matters a lot. It's just a shame he wasn't allowed to kill off Pierce in revenge for the awful sun-burn sequence.
3. Laura/X-23
There are some accusations that Logan fails to establish any sort of positive female presence, but those have clearly come from people who didn't watch the film properly. Sure, Laura starts off as a very passive element of the story and she's not really the captain of the narrative until Logan opens his eyes, but that exchange is precisely the point.
She's barely human when she first appears, and it's through her relationships with Charles and Logan that she grows to realise she is more than X-23, despite the conditioning from Rice and Pierce. And Dafne Keen's performance nails both sides of the character: she's guarded, insular, violent and vulnerable - everything that makes Hugh Jackman's performances stand out, in fact.
Her little squeaky voice is as disarming as it is humanising: the revelation that she is just a little girl under all of the anger and the violence comes at exactly the right time to really anchor her into the emotional heart of the film.
2. Logan
After almost seventeen years, Logan is the absolute culmination of everything Hugh Jackman has put into his performances as Wolverine. Since X-Men in 2000, he's been an almost anti-superhero figure, cynical of the silliness and the theatricality and resistant to really get on board with grand, over-arching heroics unless they have a personal stake for him.
He visibly learned how to belong in the first three films, then we got to see him learn to detach in the stand-alone prequels, but he's never struggled with ideas of mortality before, and that's what makes Logan his best moment.
Robbed of the healing factor that was growing too cartoonish, Logan is like a dying gunslinger (which is no accident, given the links to Shane and Unforgiven). He's the last of his kind, simultaneously defined and haunted by his violence and the most poignant part of the film is a simple extrapolation of his power. The idea of what happens to an immortal when everyone else dies.
This was the perfect way to send him off, and the perfect end to his arc, and it would be a major disservice to him if Fox tried to get Jackman to continue.
1. Charles Xavier
Though this is Hugh Jackman's film, it's also Sir Patrick Stewart's last stand as Professor Charles Xavier, and he is arguably an even more interesting character thanks to his devastating back-story and the changes to his character.
Stewart has always been one of the most towering performers in the X-Men franchise (and indeed in comic book movies in general), but his Xavier was always regal and powerful beneath the charm. It was never really noticeable, but he missed something because his relative lack of complexity.
But in adding vulnerability to Xavier, and turning his powers against him, Logan affords him the chance to really play with some substance. He still has poise, but he's a broken man, physically, mentally and emotionally, and it's mesmerising to see the layers peeled back from his performance, first the cantankerous victim, then the doting father and finally the remorseful killer.
And I challenge anyone not to be utterly devastated when he celebrates a perfect night with Logan and Laura, reveals he knows he accidentally killed the X-Men (how mortifying for a care-giver) and is then slain unceremoniously by X-24. It's enough to take your breath away.
How would you rank the characters in Logan? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.