No matter how good you are at your job, there will always be a point in your life when you'll look back on your career and think to yourself, "what the hell was I thinking?" Nobody is immune. Not even well-respected, cinematic legends like Michael Caine. If you're ever in the mood for some Caine action and decide look back over his early filmography, you'll find it extremely difficult to find an example of a bad film. The actor has appeared in so many classic British films over the years, that his résumé is a candidate for being almost perfect. If you're a fan of his earlier work, then you'll no doubt already know about his brilliant performances as Lieutenant Gonville Bromhead in Zulu, or as Charlie Croker in the original Italian Job. No stranger to the gritty realism of early British cinema either, Caine is known just as well for his character Jack Carter in Get Carter, a film that personified the darker side of 1970s Britain. But even with so many iconic films under his belt, Caine has never been afraid to branch out. His role in the 2006 film Children Of Men saw him play an ageing hippy stoner that content with a bohemian lifestyle in civilization that no longer cared about society. While Caine's winning streak has continued in recent years with films like Harry Brown and frequent collaborations with Christopher Nolan in the Dark Knight Trilogy and the soon-to-be-released Interstellar, there's bound to be gaps on an otherwise spotless record. Complimentary in nature, but poorly executed, both Get Carter and Sleuth - two of Caine's greatest films - were both subjected to the dreaded remake cycle in the 2000s, and perhaps against his better judgement Caine appeared in both, playing characters different to the ones he originally performed. But remakes aren't the only sub-par films Caine has been a part of. Roles in the awful Jaws 4: The Revenge and Bewitched are arguably even worse than both of the previously mentioned remakes. To celebrate Caine's latest collaboration with director Christopher Nolan, the legendary actor is the latest name to run the gauntlet of our 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked Friday column...
5 Awesome Performances...
5. Lieutenant Gonville Bromhead - Zulu (1964)
Michael Caine appeared in numerous films before he was cast in Zulu, but the historical war film was the first where the actor was credited as a member of the main cast and his breakthrough role. Zulu is as classic as classic films get, and other than being Caine's first major part, it still remains as one of his best. If you're still yet to see the film (seriously, you should get on that), the film is a semi-fictional retelling of the events of Rorke's Drift - a supply depot for British forces during their invasion of 'Zululand'. Cut off from the rest of the British army and short on manpower in the face of four-thousand advancing Zulus, Lieutenant Gonville Bromhead and the rest of his battalion fortify their depot for one last stand-off. Caine's character in the film may not be the leading one, but his performance, along with the rest of the cast of Zulu, has contributed to the lasting appeal of the film with the British public. Caine marvellously portrays a tense, fearful yet strong soldier as Bromhead, and watching each on-screen day pass as the inhabitants of Rorke's Drift grow ever more weary of their plight, Caine's charisma as Bromhead helps to bring a sense of relief to both the film's characters and audiences.
4. Alfred "Alfie" Elkins - Alfie (1966)
Alfie is not only a brilliant, unabashed comedy-drama film, but it also serves to remind us how extremely talented Michael Caine truly is. Oh and undeniably charming, let's not forget that part. Jude Law may have given the remake of Caine's classic his best shot, but it's this version that still shines the brightest. An early progenitor of the playboy, almost James Bond-esque womaniser, Alfie is a man that's almost allergic to commitment. One-night stand after one-night stand, Caine's performance as the unashamed ladies man is equal parts hilarious and tragic. As the film progresses, the suave and smooth talking bachelor eventually becomes a victim of his own promiscuous lifestyle; the irony of his inability to commit to a relationship hitting him hard in the face. But it's because of Caine that the film still persists today as a landmark in British cinema. The actor's ability to transition from comedy to drama and complete, tear-inducing emotional states in the film still persists as one of the greatest examples of his versatility.
3. Jack Carter - Get Carter (1971)
Before Sir Michael Caine became the go-to guy for Christopher Nolan when he needed someone to play wise, elderly characters, the actor played extremely controversial characters like Jack Carter. The film follows Caine's titular character - a London gangster - as he returns to his home of Newcastle to investigate the suspected murder of his brother Frank. The film is as famous for its violence and intricate plot (for a British crime drama) than it is for Caine's brilliant performance. Jack Carter is the quintessential anti-hero. Crime is all Jack knows, and he's not afraid to get his hands dirty to find the truth of what happened to his sibling. A deep sense of irony and morality runs deep throughout the film's narrative, and Caine plays Carter so well that you'll find it hard to hate him, even after witnessing him murder multiple individuals. His one-man vendetta against both the London and Newcastle gangs reveals a grim conspiracy about the death of his brother, and Carter succumbs to the exact same fate that his dear departed brother does. Gritty, intriguing and so very British, Get Carter remains another of Caine's best films due almost entirely to the actor's performance of a man with nothing to lose rebelling against the very world that has earned him a living. Caine's stellar performance makes you understand that while Carter's actions are abhorrent in every sense of the word, they're understandable in his quest to uncover the truth.
2. Jasper Palmer - Children Of Men (2006)
Children Of Men is a great film in its own right, but the reason why it's one of Michael Caine's best performances is largely due to how different the role was for an actor who was largely known for playing stern and serious roles. The film focuses on a dystopian, future world where the human race has become completely sterile. With the death of the world's youngest person (eighteen) punctuating the start of the film and humanity facing extinction, protagonists Theo Faron (Clive Owen) and Julian Taylor (Julianne Moore) discover a woman that has become pregnant, and attempt to escort her to safety. Theo eventually decides to visit his old friend Jasper, a bohemian, stoner hippie that spends his days caring for his catatonic wife. Caine stated during interviews at the time of the film's release that he based his performance on the interactions he had with Beatles star John Lennon. Aside from the fact that Caine's performance was a little unflattering for Lennon, it helped Caine to gift us with a performance that enabled him to let loose and be an ageing bum. Caine's character smokes cannabis and nonchalantly passes wind during the film, and watching the British stalwart do such things on-screen is such a stark contrast to his previous roles is what makes the performance so memorable.
1. Charlie Croker - The Italian Job (1969)
Consistently voted as one of the best British films ever made and one of Caine's greatest films, we have a lot to thank The Italian Job for, not least for giving us Caine's brilliant performance. The film not only has some of the most fondly remembered action scenes (the Mini Coopers escaping through the streets of Italy is what usually comes to mind) and a literal cliffhanger ending, it also features Caine's Charlie Croker. Recently released, career criminal Croker attempts to grant the wishes of his deceased friend Roger Beckermann, and pull off a heist worth four million dollars by stealing Chinese gold in Italy. As you watch Croker progressively builds up his band of misfits and devises his foolproof plan to lift the gold from under the nose of the Italian authorities, you'll suddenly realise that you're rooting for the criminals due in large part to Caine's magnetism and the extremely likeable persona that he displays as Croker. The 'band of brothers', closely-knit relationship between Caine and his fellow thieves is a theme that's been replicated many times since The Italian Job, and the more recent Fast & Furious films have undoubtedly been influenced a great deal by the film. Caine's suave, jack the lad and subtly humorous performance as Croker is one not to miss, and if you're part of the younger generation around, The Italian Job is most certainly worth a watch, if only so you can see Caine before he became the loveable Alfred in Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy. Unfortunately though, even some of the world's greatest actors can make mistakes...
And 5 That Sucked...
5. Cliff Brumby - Get Carter (2000)
Actor's playing characters in remakes of their own films (especially when they play a different role) are rarely ever received well. Caine appears in the remake of the 1971 Get Carter not as Jack Carter, but as Cliff Brumby - the man indirectly responsible for Carter's death in the original film. The remake generally follows the basic narrative of the original, but aside from Stallone not being a suitable replacement for Caine's original, the film is extremely light on the subtext and themes that appear in the original. Adding on to this, Caine's performance as Brumby just simply isn't particularly memorable. Caine's presence in the film feels largely due to the remake's creators wanting to feature the original Carter as fan-service, but it just feels flat. Caine's performance isn't awful,but playing Brumby in the remake almost takes away from the original by imagining the British stalwart in the role of the villain. Just to make matters worse, Get Carter isn't the only example of Caine appearing in a remake of his own film...
4. Andrew Wyke - Sleuth (2007)
The original Sleuth, in which Laurence Olivier and Michael Caine face off in a battle of wits and misdirection to outwit each other is a classic British film of the 70s, and while the remake (featuring Caine and Jude Law) is a passable film, it never reaches the heights of the original. Caine assumes the part that Olivier performed in the original, that of a novelist that attempts to frame his wife's lover for the theft of his valuables under the guise of simply letting Law's character take the jewels for the purposes of letting him leave with a wife he has grown bored of. Unlike the original, the chemistry between Caine and Law simply isn't as tantalising, and the addition of a bizarre homosexual sub-plot between the two characters just doesn't fit. The film is notable for two reasons. One: Sleuth marks the second time that Jude Law performs a character originally played by Caine and two, the film marks the second instance of Caine appearing in a remake of his own film but in a different role. It's one of Caine's worst films not only for the reasons stated above, but because of the same reason that his starring in the remake of Get Carter wasn't received awfully well - Caine's recurring appearance simply takes away from the original.
3. Hoagie Newcombe - Jaws 4: The Revenge (1987)
Jaws 4: The Revenge isn't just one of Caine's worst films, it's also arguably one of the worst films ever made. The film was almost universally panned upon release, with critics citing awful inconsistency issues, hammy acting and laughable special effects. If you want an idea of just how excruciatingly bad the film is, this is a feature that suggests a shark can travel from New York to the Bahamas in three days, and that non-humans are capable of understanding the concept of revenge. Caine plays Hoagie Newcombe in the film, a carefree aeroplane pilot that assists in the protagonists' efforts to hunt down the shark that has haunted their family for a generation. Aside from the cringeworthy dialogue exchanges between Caine and the rest of the cast, the acting just wasn't even remotely close to the actor's previous efforts. Caine himself has admitted in interviews since that the film wasn't one of his best, stating that he still fondly remembers filming it due to the free holiday he got by filming on-location in the Bahamas.
2. Nigel Bigelow - Bewitched (2005)
Panned by critics and scorned by fans of the original TV series, the film adaptation of Bewitched did little to set audiences alight with its screen time. While most of the criticism aimed at the film involved the almost total lack of chemistry between the film's two main characters Isabel and Jack (played by Nicole Kidman and Will Ferrel respectively), Caine's performance as Isabel's father, Nigel Bigelow, wasn't particularly enthralling either. Caine may be the warlock father of a witch in the film, but there's almost zero magic on-screen, and Caine as an intrusive father just isn't a role that fits him particularly well. Being typecast as an actor is rarely something you should look forward to in Hollywood, but if Bewitched is anything to go by, Caine would have been far better suited to sticking to what he knows best; playing a morally complex gangster or a charming, charismatic bachelor.
1. Victor Melling - Miss Congeniality (2000)
As we all know by now, financial success doesn't automatically make a film good. Miss Congeniality may have been a hit with audiences across the world, but the film failed to draw in praise from critics. Detailing the transition from tomboyish cop to beauty pageant superstar, Sandra Bullock plays the title character Gracie Hart. Caine plays Victor Melling, the eccentric pageant coach that reluctantly teaches Bullock the ins and outs of the beauty pageant world. The role was a break away from the norm for Caine, but the film was hampered by a predictable and generic plot akin to that of an American sitcom, doing nothing to extend the actor's extensive back catalogue of cinematic classics. We're all for a more unreserved Caine in the same ilk as Children Of Men, but Miss Congeniality completely missed the mark for one of Britain's favourite stars.