Paul Rudd: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked

What were the Ant-Man's biggest roles, and which deserve to be squashed?

By Tom Baker /

Paul Rudd: Man. Actor. Owner of a weird computer. Not to be confused with the DJ of the same name. The comedian hasn't exactly been short of high-profile roles, having had a recurring part in Friends and remaining a key part of Judd Apatow's revolving roster of actors, but he's about to find himself launched into the stratosphere - he's in a Marvel movie. Despite that, it's Rudd's involvement in the eponymous role of Ant-Man which'll get the punters in spite of that unspectacular title and stories of behind-the-scenes finagling. That's exactly why Marvel cast him as Scott Lang in the first place; Rudd just has something, that indefinable movie star x-factor which makes him effortlessly enigmatic and endearing whatever film you put him in. Well, almost any film. As with anybody who's been working steadily in the industry for twenty years, Rudd's had some duds. That average rises ever higher for comedic actors, with a decent feature length laugh-fest harder to pull off than you think. His highs have been very high, seeing him involved in some of the most successful comedies of his generation! But his lows have been almost as epoch-shakingly low, complete with requisite early appearance in a crappy horror movie. From the pinnacle of Anchorman to the less-than-pinnacle of Dinner For Schmucks, here are five awesome Paul Rudd performances...and five that sucked. Let's start with the Awesome Performances....

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Josh - Clueless (1995)

Along with being one of Rudd's earliest screen roles, looking back at his portrayal of Josh in valley girl comedy Clueless, it's also clearly the moment the actor made a Faustian, Picture Of Dorian Grey-style pact which means he never aged. This film came out twenty years ago and he looks pretty much the same in it as he does now. What gives? Despite being such an early part, Rudd also exhibits all the goofy charm that he's become known for, a confidence not even seen in actors when they're just starting out. He's mostly a background character in Clueless, biding his time until his ex-stepsister Cher (Alicia Silverstone) realises she's totally in love with him. Even with such a small role, Rudd wrings the most comedy potential possible from his Social Justice Warrior law school student. He's witty, he's charming, he's sort of an irritating, holier-than-thou d*ck at times. Forget Cher, everybody who watches him in that film falls in love with him. No small feat when Turk from Scrubs is also on screen.

4. Bobby Newport - Parks And Recreation (2012-2015)

Paul Rudd played against type again in his second broadest comedic character, idiot rich boy Bobby Newport in Parks And Recreation. NBC's political sitcom is one of the smartest, warmest, and most downright hilarious shows in the network's history, and that was largely down to the titanic comedic talent of its ensemble cast. Rudd slotted nicely in there, as the rival of Amy Poehler's Leslie Knope in the race for city council. Mainly because, opposite the driven, intelligent and sharp-witted Leslie, he was a complete moron with no real interest in local politics besides ensuring that his family's Sweetums candy company continues to be allowed to make unhealthy crap. In the guise of Bobby, Rudd gets plenty of great one-liners exposing his total idiocy, like a modern-day Woody from Cheers. He also has a couple of moments of genuine sweetness, like revealing he's voting for Leslie instead of himself, and becoming visibly upset by an attack ad against him.

3. Brian Fantana - Anchorman: The Legend Of Ron Burgundy (2003)

A large bulk of Rudd's filmography involves him playing dudes that are as handsome and naturally endearing as he is. One of the major exceptions is Brian Fantana, field reporter, namer of testicles and lover of aftershave from improvised comedy Anchorman. The €œimprovised€ part is important. Both Anchorman films had loose structures, but the lion's share of the dialogue and jokes are come up with on the fly. Which means not only did Rudd play Fantana to a tee, but he basically invented the character and all of his best lines. The shaggy-haired, misogynistic, idiot wannabe-lady's-man is about as far from Rudd's usual wheelhouse as its possible to get, and he still nails it. The whole Sex Panther episode probably would've worked whoever was wearing the Bigfoot-genitalia-smelling scent, but it was Rudd who cooked up and really sold the idea.

2. Scott Lang - Ant-Man (2015)

Rudd's casting in Ant-Man pretty much set the tone for Marvel's new movie - it may boast explosive action and comic book reverence, but it is most definitely a comedy. That was always going to be the score somewhat (Edgar Wright was famously involved for a long time), yet it's hard to imagine anyone grounding it as well as Rudd; he works equally well as the shmuck alongside Michael Douglas' Hank Pym and the almost straight guy to Michael Peña's Luis. But while Rudd does get to use his effortless joviality in Peyton Reed's film, that's not what makes his turn as Scott Lang so impressive. An ex-con who restarts his life of crime, Scott isn't your basic superhero character (even by Marvel's grounded standards) and Rudd knows when to rein in the silliness to deliver actual emotion, something we've never seen from the actor on this scale before. Ant-Man is set to return in Captain America: Civil War, and could conceivably be a part of The Avengers much longer after that. Given how great Rudd is as the character, it's hard to complain.

1. Peter Klaven - I Love You, Man (2009)

Really, though, you can't get better than Rudd as his dorky, endearing best. His ultimate charming slacker role has to be Peter Klaven in I Love You, Man, the €œbromantic comedy€ where his groom-to-be realises he has no male friends to make his Best Man. Thus begins the search for a BFF, full of awkward man-dates and mixed signals. A lot of the time Jason Segel threatens to steal the spotlight as Syndey, the prospective pal who the actor based on his experiences working with Russell Brand on Forgetting Sarah Marshall, but Rudd's beleaguered everyman remains the star. Especially when he starts playing prog rock band Rush around the house and playing unconvincing air bass. There's plenty of genius, hilarious tics like that €“ Peter's inability to come up with suitable nicknames on the fly when parting ways is a rich comedic vein €“ but there's also a believable, dramatic warmth to his loneliness, his search for a male best friend, and his relationship troubles with fiancee Zooey (Rashida Jones). Mainly it's the Rush stuff though. Even better: when Segel and Rudd reprised their roles for a Funny Or Die video where they actually got to go backstage with the band.

And 5 That Sucked...

5. George - How Do You Know?

Once upon a time, James L Brooks was considered one of the most talented directors, producers and screenwriters and Hollywood. He helmed acclaimed, sharp romantic dramedies like Terms Of Endearment and As Good As It Gets. He produced Wes Anderson's debut Bottle Rocket, and Cameron Crowe's Say Anything. Talent, it seems, has a tendency to fade with age in the same way eyesight and bowel strength does. That's the only way to explain how Brooks's sixth film, 2010's How Do You Know, is an incredibly dull and poorly-written melodrama that can be livened up even with an all-star cast of Reese Witherspoon, Owen Wilson and Jack Nicholson. And Paul Rudd, obviously, who is saddled with the sad sack role of George, a business executive who gets fired when the company is investigated by the FBI and broken up with on the same day. Obviously he's not going to be cracking wise when facing considerable jail time, but Rudd's George doesn't offer anything to make you feel his plight.

4. Tim - Dinner For Schmucks (2010)

It appears that, not unlike crops, Paul Rudd has his ocassional fallow periods. There are entire years where he just appears in crappy films: 2007 had I Could Never Be Your Woman and The Ex, but far worse is 2010's one-two punch of How Do You Know followed by Dinner For Schmucks. The latter being the knock-out blow in that combo. Dinner For Schmucks is one of the worst comedies ever made. Which is an easy thing to measure objectively, because comedies are supposed to make people laugh, and nobody laughs at Dinner For Schmucks. It's not helped by the unwholesome premise of a dinner party where powerful people compete to bring the biggest freak they can. Rudd's mid-level financial executive Tim is already pretty unsympathetic when you learn his profession, and it only goes downhill as he recruits Steve Carrell's hapless weirdo Barry for the dinner. It's a singularly nasty, misanthropic film and even Rudd struggles to make his character in any way likeable.

3. Adam - I Could Never Be Your Woman (2007)

Somehow it took Rudd a good ten years to reunite with his Clueless collaborator Amy Heckerling, in the director's romantic comedy I Could Never Be Your Woman. Hecklering used her own experiences as a a 40-year old divorced mother who works as a scriptwriter and producer to write about Michelle Pfeiffer's Rosie, who is... well, all those things. Paul Rudd is Adam, an actor several years Rosie's junior who she takes a shine to her whilst auditioning for a new part in her crappy TV show. So the film becomes a romantic comedy of errors where Rosie doubts their suitability, thanks to the age gap, and the budding couple try not to become gossip fodder. At least, that's what it seems like the film's going for. Heckerling's script feels like it needed a redraft, and perhaps a higher budget, because it instead feels like a rushed rehearsal for a TV pilot with Rudd's character particularly underwritten. He doesn't even get to be all that funny, just a pretty face in need of a personality transplant.

2. Leon - The Ex (2007)

A romantic comedy where the jealous ex of the lead character's new girlfriend is a guy in a wheelchair? That could provide the fuel for a truly provocative, interesting film which challenges preconceptions of disabled people on film. Except The Ex craps out on its own premise halfway through, when it turns out Jason Bateman's faking his disability. Still, Bateman's Chip and Zach Braff's Tom still continue to battle over the affections of Amanda Peet's Sofia, but the jokes don't come nearly as thick and fast as you might expect from that impressive central love triangle. Then Paul Rudd turns up in a minor role and it's like, hey, Paul Rudd's always funny! He's not a miracle worker though. Here plays an intentionally unlikeable kitchen manager for one scene, and it turns out Paul Rudd cannot play somebody who isn't at least a little charming.

1. Tommy Doyle - Halloween: The Curse Of Michael Myers (1995)

Everybody has to start somewhere. Paul Rudd's breakout role was in Clueless, which remains one of the best performances of his career. That same year, however, he managed to also provide his worst-ever performance. Although, admittedly, by the time you reach the sixth Halloween film, nobody's really on their A-game. Paul Rudd took the part of Tommy Doyle, the kid Jamie Lee Curtis was babysitting in the original Halloween, and who was suitably disturbed in the process. In place of Curtis's Laurie Strode Rudd's Tommy takes the role of hero, realising that Michael Myers has returned to his hometown of Haddonfield. Wait, why does anyone still live there? It's an incredibly dull and half-baked part that could have been something interesting. Instead of being a kid haunted by his traumatic past, though, Tommy quickly becomes your garden-variety horror movie hero, figuring out Michael Myers was possessed by a Pagan spirit who forces people to murder. This is the film that ruined Halloween as it nearly did Rudd's career. Then again, if you ever wanted to see a teenage Paul Rudd creeping out schoolgirls and stealing babies whilst dressed in a series of awfully nineties outfits, this is the performance for you... What's your favourite Paul Rudd performance? And what's the worst? Share your thoughts down in the comments...