Ranking Every Hannibal Adaptation Worst To Best

Hello Clarice... which Hannibal Lecter adaptation do you like the best?

By Jonathan H. Kantor /

The Hannibal Lecter franchise is one of the most renowned to feature a cannibalistic villain audiences can't help but love. Most fans found the franchise thanks to the 1988 film, The Silence of the Lambs, but long before that movie was made, the first book hit store shelves and started it all.

Advertisement

The first book in the series to feature the tales of Hannibal Lecter was written by Thomas Harris, titled Red Dragon and it was published back in 1981. Since that time, there have been three additional books published, which have been followed by a number of movies and a televisions series.

While there have only been a total of four novels about the serial killer fans can't help but love, there have been five feature-length films and a television series, which has run for three seasons by the end of 2018.

Ranking these adaptations may be subjective, but each one is considered based upon the source material and the manner in which is was adapted. Overall, the Hannibal franchise has produced some of the best media products to hit television and movie theaters in decades, but not all Hannibal adaptations are created equally... some were fantastic, which others... not so much.

6. Hannibal Rising (2007)

Hannibal Rising is the fifth film in the franchise and was based on Harris' 2006 novel of the same name. The film details the life story of Hannibal Lecter and how he became the man we all know him to be: a cannibalistic serial killer.

Advertisement

Nobody is born a monster — they are made, and this film shows exactly how a young boy who survived the Nazi invasion of Lithuania during World War II went on to become a sadistic killing machine. Hannibal and his sister barely survived an explosion that killed the rest of their family, but they managed to endure for a little while before Hannibal's true origin story began.

In many ways, this is a revenge tale as much as it is a depiction of the titular character's devolution into the madness of cannibalism. Hannibal is played by Gaspard Ulliel whom critics agreed did the role justice. Unfortunately, the film failed to achieve widespread critical acclaim despite his performance, and it was the final film to be made from the novels prior to the development of the television series

Overall, this film wasn't particularly bad... but it wasn't particularly good either. The book handled the characters better in a more refined way, which is often an issue when adapting a novel into a film. If you want to learn about Hannibal Lecter's early days, it may be best to stick to the printed word, but a true completionist of the Hannibal franchise shouldn't pass this one by just because of its poor showing at the box office.

5. Hannibal (2001)

Hannibal is the third film in the series and was adapted from the 1999 novel of the same name. It is a direct sequel to The Silence of the Lambs and features the return of Sir Anthony Hopkins as the titular character, though the role of Clarice Starling was not played by Jodie Foster, but was instead taken up by Julianne Moore.

Advertisement

The film is set ten years after the events of The Silence of the Lambs. Hannibal Lecter has been on the run for a decade following the events of the first film and Agent Starling continues in her efforts to return him to justice.

Only one man has survived Lecter's violence and he is determined to capture his former assailant, which puts his efforts directly in the way of Starlings and the various law enforcement agencies hunting Lecter across the globe.

Financially, Hannibal did rather well pulling in $351.6 million on an $87 million budget. The film didn't fare as well with critics who had a mixed reaction to the "gory or grotesque incidents."

Of the three films starring Hopkins in the role of Hannibal Lecter, this is the weakest, but that doesn't mean it isn't a good film. Ray Liotta was especially delectable in his role and if you watch this for anything, see it for the dinner scene... it's delightfully horrific.

4. Red Dragon (2002)

Based on the 1981 novel of the same name, Red Dragon is the fourth film in the Lecter franchise, and serves as a prequel to the events of The Silence of the Lambs. This film marked the third and final time Hopkins took on the role of the notorious cannibal serial killer.

Advertisement

The story details the initial capture and imprisonment of Lecter due to his relationship with FBI Agent Will Graham. The two men worked together to create a psychological profile of a serial killer who was consuming various body parts of his victims.

As the profile develops, Lecter is implicated and the two men nearly kill one another in a struggle that leaves Graham almost disemboweled while Lecter takes a few arrows and a slew of bullets. He is subsequently tried, convicted, and sentenced to life in prison. Eventually, his expertise is needed once more when a new serial killer called the Tooth Fairy kills entire families on the full moon.

This film may not have worked had it not been for the performance by Edward Norton who could play a corpse and make the movie watchable. While this movie wasn't better than the film and novel it was based upon, it was still an exceptional movie and one every fan has to watch if they love the franchise.

Red Dragon was the story that began the franchise and while it wasn't the first adaptation of the novel, it stands as a highly successful adaptation.

3. Hannibal (TV Series) (2013–15)

Hannibal was a television series based on the characters from Harris' novels, Red Dragon and Hannibal, but not directly based on a specific novel itself. The series ran on NBC from 2013 until 2015 when it was cancelled due to a decline in ratings, with 39 episodes aired in total across three seasons.

Advertisement

The primary focus of Hannibal was on the relationship between Special Investigator Will Graham and Dr. Hannibal Lecter who was played by Mads Mikkelsen. The series primarily played off the relationship as it developed in Red Dragon, but over a much longer period of time than indicated in the novel.

Overall, the series received widespread critical acclaim with emphasis placed on the lead actors and the visual style of the show. It won numerous awards including Saturn Awards for Best Network Television Series and Best Actor for Mikkelsen.

It's easy to watch this show and fall into Mikkelsen's trap. You can find yourself asking... is he really the bad guy or is he a good guy who does bad things? The answer is pretty obvious - he's a monster - but the way Mikkelsen plays him, it sometimes makes that difficult to remember as he captivates the audience's attention with his creepy charisma.

While the series was cancelled due to declining ratings, it remains acclaimed as one of the best series of the horror genre. One of the reasons the series lost ratings was due to online piracy, which indicates people were watching the show, but not being tracked. Due to the series' popularity, it may be revived or go on to inspire a new film, though nothing has happened in this regard since formal discussions began in 2017.

2. Manhunter (1986)

Long before Hopkins was cast as Dr. Lecter, the film Manhunter hit theaters in 1986 as the very first adaptation of Red Dragon. In this adaptation, the character was portrayed by Brian Cox whose take on Lecter was as chilling and frightening as the Hopkins' in The Silence of the Lambs only four years later.

Advertisement

Like the remake, Red Dragon, this movie followed the events of the book with a focus on the relationship between Lecter and Agent Graham, though more focus is placed on the hunting down of the Tooth Fairy with slightly less emphasis placed on the time prior to Lecter's imprisonment.

When the movie was released, it flopped at the box office. With a budget estimated to be around $15 million, the film only managed to make $8.6 at the domestic box office marking it a commercial failure. It also received mixed to negative reviews, but things have changed since 1986.

Due to the popularity of the subsequent films in the franchise, Manhunter has gotten something of a second life as a cult classic. The film now holds a rating of 94% on Rotten Tomatoes and is considered to be far better than its remake despite its poor showing when it was first released.

This is one of those movies you may have watched when it came out and didn't like, but need to go back and watch it again. Anyone who enjoys the franchise who hasn't seen Manhunter is doing themselves a disservice and anyone who had, but discounted it, is equally as wrong. Brian Cox's performance was astounding and this film established Hannibal Lecter as a true movie monster even if it took Hopkins' performance to make it stick.

1. The Silence Of The Lambs (1991)

The Silence of the Lambs was the second film to be made in the series following 1986's Manhunter. It was based on the 1988 novel of the same name and featured the first time Hopkins took on the role that would forever associate him with "fava beans and a nice chianti."

Advertisement

The film follows a similar structure as Manhunter in that it involves a working association between a psychopath, Hannibal Lecter, and a Special Agent of the FBI, Clarice Starling, who are working together to track down a serial killer. In this film, the monster they are hunting is known only as Buffalo Bill and his signature is the removal of his victims' skin.

The Silence of the Lambs was one of the most successful films ever made in its genre and the only horror movie to win the coveted Academy Award for Best Picture. It also won Best Director, Actor, Actress, and Best Adapted Screenplay.

The film is regularly cited as one of the most important and best films of all time. It was selected for preservation by the National Film Registry in 2011 and holds a rating of 96% on Rotten Tomatoes. It is, by many accounts, the greatest adaptation of Harris' work and its success led to every adaptation on list list with the exception of its predecessor.

The Silence of the Lambs was the obvious choice for number one on this list simply because it's the film that truly solidified Hannibal Lecter as a movie monster. He may not be like Freddy Kreuger, but that's why he is so compelling. Everything about him could be real, which is what makes him so frightening and he was so perfectly played by Anthony Hopkins, many might find being in the same room with the actor more than a little intimidating.

Advertisement