Paramount PicturesSergio Leone is rightfully regarded as the patriarch of the Spaghetti Western genre, spawned in the wake of his massively popular films set in the sandy American frontier. A Roman-born director who first gained popularity directing sword-and-sandal epics, Leone soon turned to Westerns with the Dollars Trilogy and inadvertently changed the genre forever. Oddly enough, Leone had never even been to the American West until after he had already singlehandedly emblazoned his mark on the Western film. His trademarks are numerous and oft-imitated to this day: extreme close-ups, wide shots with incredible depth and clarity, prominent scores and memorable rogues. Leone's West was a gritty, sweaty place, populated not by charming cowboys but by scruffy gunslingers. The Spaghetti Western - a term often used for Italo-Westerns alone - was certainly born out of Leone's style, but the Western genre on the whole owes a credit to his filmography. Leone found success with other genres as well, and his association with Westerns shouldn't cloud the fact that his mastery of technique and tone could have been applied anywhere. By focusing on Westerns, Leone was able to breathe new life into a lagging genre. What follows is a rundown of the filmography of Sergio Leone, highlighting the elements that make his best films so deserving of praise nearly half a century after their release.
7. The Colossus Of Rhodes (1961)
MGMLeone's true debut film is The Colossus of Rhodes in 1961, a peplum epic from the Hellenistic period starring Rory Calhoun as the Greek hero Davios. Boasting one of the largest budgets to date, The Colossus of Rhodes is impressive in the scope of cast and set design, and turns out to be one of Leone's most grandiose products. Despite this being his first credited work as a director, Leone already had plenty of experience in the sword-and-sandal genre. He served as replacement director on The Last Days of Pompeii when Mario Bonnard fell ill and also served as a second unit director on Ben-Hur in the same year. The Colossus of Rhodes was the first film he had nearly full control over, and it was also where he first established the visual style that would become his trademark. Much of Rhodes drags, unfortunately, and at times it does seem to be one of the more dated pieces from the era of peplum epics. Still, along with The Last Days of Pompeii, The Colossus of Rhodes is primarily worth watching for an early glimpse at a director who would soon master the medium.
6. Duck, You Sucker! (1971)
United ArtistsThe last Western of Sergio Leone came in 1971, following his massive success in the genre with his previous four efforts. Leone was initially hesitant to direct the project, as he had reportedly become tired with the genre. After a series of refusals from other directors, stars James Coburn and Rod Steiger eventually resorted to threatening to drop out of the film unless Leone directed. Such arm-twisting and marionette-string-pulling would unfortunately become a characteristic of Leone's productions, and it would eventually drive him to early retirement. Also known as A Fistful of Dynamite (suggesting a connection with Leone's Dollars Trilogy) and also Once Upon a TimeĀthe Revolution (suggesting a connection with the Once Upon a Time films), Duck, You Sucker! nonetheless manages to slip away from under the shadow of Leone's other successes. Again, Leone himself was sick of Westerns - and this may explain the fresh elements involved that certainly work in favor of the film. James Coburn plays IRA revolutionary John Mallory, who flees to Mexico and finds himself embroiled in another revolution spurred along by Rod Steiger's bombastic Juan Miranda. While the characters aren't nearly as memorable as those of Leone's other westerns, Duck, You Sucker! is considered by some to be the hidden gem in Leone's filmography.
5. For A Few Dollars More (1965)
United ArtistsThe Dollars Trilogy (or The Man With No Name Trilogy) is nothing less than one of the most important trilogies in film history. Although connected in a somewhat loose sense - primarily by the gunslinging, rug-wearing protagonists played by Clint Eastwood - the themes of one film resonate through the others, and the three films taken as a whole paint a formidable and beautiful portrait of the American West. There are many ways in which the middle entry in the series, 1965's For a Few Dollars More, exhibits more passion and sophisticated technique than either the predecessor or the successor. The antagonist of the film, Gian Maria Volonte's ruthless Indio, is perhaps what most separates For a Few Dollars More from A Fistful of Dollars - his tortured, hyperactive, bleary-eyed villain proves himself to be a worthy match for the Man With No Name, and the motivation to take him out drives much of the film. Interestingly, Volonte was credited as "Johnny Wels" in the American release of the film. Many trilogies that exist today peter out after the first film, or have a middle entry that must be dealt with before reaching the final chapter. The Dollars Trilogy presents strength throughout, and For a Few Dollars More is a great film even without the bookends.
4. Once Upon A Time In America (1984)
Warner Bros.Again, production woes became a real problem for Leone in his late career, and the production and release of his New York epic Once Upon a Time in America essentially caused Leone to resign from filmmaking altogether. Starring Robert De Niro and James Woods as Prohibition-era gangsters, the multi-decade journey through the streets of NYC still manages to be an impressive achievement despite its troubles. Originally cut by Leone at a staggering 269 minutes (nearly four and a half hours), the film was recut for European cinemas - and then recut again by American distributors against the wishes of the director. When the film premiered in the States it ran at 139 minutes (two hours and nineteen minutes), and the restructured version was panned by critics. Yet, as some reviews recognized at the time, cutting a four-hour Leone film is akin to chopping an opera or two out of Wagner's Ring Cycle - that is to say that some masterpieces are meant to be lengthy. Indeed, a film set in 1968 that spends a great amount of time in flashback to the 1920s and the 1930s needs time to establish each of these eras. There are several versions of the film available now, and the 229-minute restoration is one of the closest available to Leone's original cut (although Leone's children still seek to restore his original 269 minutes). Regardless of the actual length, Once Upon a Time in America is one of the best depictions of Prohibition in New York City ever set to film.
3. A Fistful Of Dollars (1964)
United ArtistsThere are so many iconic moments in the first film of the Dollars Trilogy, and it's easy to see why the films that followed became so successful with such a strong foundation to build upon. Clint Eastwood became a star because of his performance as the casual, cigar-chewing cowboy Joe, and although Eastwood initially refused future Leone films on the grounds that the characters were so similar he still made a career out of Westerns in the years following. The plot of A Fistful of Dollars is relatively simple - two warring families are further pitted against each other by Eastwood's fast-drawing gunslinger. But Leone's first Western was real in a way that the genre had previously not seen - the men were sweaty and poorly-shaven, the streets were sandy, the taverns were smoky and full of sin. Since then, nearly every film about the American West has followed this formula. And when Clint Eastwood passes a coffinmaker, orders three new boxes, and then corrects himself upon shooting a fourth man, it's hard not to recognize how important the script is to the flow of the film. Plus, if he had never used a cast iron plate as a bulletproof vest, Marty McFly would never have been able to get out of that pickle with Buford Tannen.
2. The Good, The Bad And The Ugly (1966)
United ArtistsThe culmination of the Dollars Trilogy is 1966's The Good, the Bad and the Ugly, a film which many consider to be the greatest Western of all time. Clint Eastwood returns as The Man With No Name (referred to as Blondie over the course of this film) and is joined by Lee Van Cleef as the villainous Angel Eyes and the indomitable Eli Wallach as the petty thief Tuco. Separately they are the Good, the Bad and the Ugly - and together, under Leone's careful direction, they're nothing short of brilliant. Composer Ennio Morricone has been conspicuously absent from this article thus far, but some of his best work comes in this film. Though he composed music for every Leone film, no compositions are as recognisable as the whistling theme or the climactic Ecstasy of Gold suite. Likewise, special mention should be made of Eli Wallach, an incredible actor who passed away last week. His Tuco is the heart and soul of The Good, the Bad and the Ugly, and his fervent rapid-fire diction plays perfectly off of Eastwood's brooding silence throughout the film. Wallach intended to appear in Leone's last Western film Duck, You Sucker! as Juan Miranda (ultimately played by Rob Steiger), but a schedule conflict ensured only Wallach's Tuco remained atop the high pedestal of memorable Western rogues.
1. Once Upon A Time In The West (1968)
ParamountWhile The Good, the Bad and the Ugly provided an epic conclusion to an epic Western trilogy, Leone's following film Once Upon a Time in the West remains the ultimate epic tale of the American frontier, recalling as many Western classics as it influenced in the decades since. Charles Bronson turned down roles in the Dollars Trilogy only to actively seek the role of the enigmatic protagonist Harmonica, a role for which he certainly takes a page from the Eastwood Brooding notebook. But the more brilliant casting is with Henry Fonda, who had previously been the handsome good guy in Western films. Leone cast him as the seething, purely evil Frank, and after seeing Fonda in the role many questioned why he had never played a villain before. The collision course of Harmonica and Frank is colored by a dozen other characters, including Jason Robards's bandit Cheyenne, Gabriele Ferzetti's crippled tycoon Morton, and Claudia Cardinale's beautiful Jill McBain. Rightfully, though, the tale is ultimately a battle between two men, and the reveal during the final shootout approaches a level of epic grandeur that no Western film, not even The Good, the Bad and the Ugly, has ever reached before or since. What are your favorite Leone films? Do you agree with our rankings? Let us know in the comments section below.