Smile Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs

Behold one of the year's most pleasant surprises so far.

By Jack Pooley /

Paramount

It's been quite the year for horror fans, who've been dining out on the acclaimed likes of Scream, X, The Black Phone, Nope, Prey, Bodies Bodies Bodies, Barbarian, and Pearl, to name just a few.

Advertisement

But it's fair to say that few were expecting all that much from Smile, the filmmaking debut of writer-director Parker Finn, which has largely been marketed as a schlocky, low-effort genre offering in the vein of 2018's wretched Truth or Dare.

Yet armed with an R-rating and more importantly a skilled cast and crew, it's a pleasure to report that Smile is one of the year's biggest surprises so far, regardless of genre.

Advertisement

While hardly a towering effort on the level of the year's best horror flicks, Smile modestly splits the difference between the demands of grisly studio fare and something more cerebral and unsettling you'd expect from the "arthouse" realm.

For a film many had written off from the marketing alone, that's quite the achievement, and needless to say, Smile is much better than its lousy trailers would have you believe.

Advertisement

But first, here's where it nevertheless falls a little short...

Downs...

3. It's A Mash-Up Of Several Better Horror Films

Paramount

There's no denying that Smile's core premise is indebted to a bevy of horror films that preceded it, the majority of them ultimately quite superior.

Advertisement

The setup, of protagonist Dr. Rose Cotter (Sosie Bacon) being pursued by a supernatural curse which will force her to brutally commit suicide within a week, immediately recalls The Ring, while the chain-like transmission of the curse from victim to victim is clearly inspired by It Follows.

Throw in nods to Final Destination and the aforementioned - but certainly not good - Truth or Dare, and Smile doesn't exactly get full marks in the originality department.

Advertisement

But execution counts for a lot, and it's certainly a smart, well-made mash-up of all these films, even if anyone hoping for a truly ingenious remix of their respective rules might be left a tad underwhelmed by the fairly straightforward and familiar nature of the curse.

2. The Pacing Could Be Better

Paramount

Smile surprisingly clocks in at a beefy 115 minutes, and while this expanded runtime often works in the film's favour in allowing character beats to breathe, it does also result in some blatantly over-indulgent moments where the pacing egregiously sags.

Advertisement

Though the movie is focused quite tightly on Rose and her journey, there's certainly some fat that could've been trimmed, with the third act in particular arguably over-extending itself somewhat.

The central scenario is investing enough that the near-two hours aren't a drag for the most part, but shaving 10-15 minutes off this thing would make it feel so much more taut.

Advertisement

When considering a repeat viewing, it's easy to imagine some balking at that slightly overlong runtime given the modest-scale story the film is covering.

1. The Unnecessary Jump Scares

Paramount

Though Smile is certainly far more pared-down and restrained than your average studio horror flick, especially with a premise this unhinged, there are still some indulgences to speak of.

Advertisement

And more often than not, it's Finn's use of jump scares.

Now as we all know, jump scares aren't inherently a bad thing: when they're deployed well they can truly unnerve the audience in a deeply visceral way.

Advertisement

Yet mainstream horror tends to cheaply substitute them for smart, considered shocks, and while Smile's jump scares are definitely well crafted, they do feel a bit much in a film that subverts viewer expectations in several other ways.

Beyond one admittedly very good jump scare, most of them can be seen coming a mile off, and as such they feel like a feat of compromise, like something the studio brass insisted upon to give the film a little more "oomph."

Advertisement

These issues aside, though, Smile gets a lot more right than you probably ever imagined it would. And so, here's where it soars...

Ups...

7. Sosie Bacon's Strong Performance

Paramount

The undeniable glue holding Smile together is lead actress Sosie Bacon - daughter of Kevin Bacon and Kyra Sedgwick - who gives a remarkable performance in the role of Rose.

Advertisement

From the haunting opening sequence all the way through to the ending, Bacon gives a thoroughly convincing turn as a woman utterly immersed in traumas both past and present.

Bacon's steely turn ensures Rose quickly becomes a likeable, sympathetic lead, making viewers feel her frustration as those around her refuse to take her situation seriously, instead pawning it off as the ramblings of a mentally ill woman.

Advertisement

It's an emotionally demanding part and the film wouldn't work nearly as well with a less-capable actress in the lead, yet Bacon's in basically every scene in the movie and remains a transfixing presence for the entirety.

6. The Script Doesn't Over-Explain Things

Paramount

Horror films often make the mistake of assuming that the audience absolutely, positively needs to know everything about the focal malevolent force terrorising the protagonist, yet Smile thankfully appreciates the virtue of just... not doing that.

Advertisement

Though the rules of the curse are plainly laid out and we get some vague hints about its origins, Finn's script smartly avoids committing to an unnecessary, convoluted explanation for how it all came to be.

We know enough to tickle our curiosity beyond the bounds of the film itself, yet the script as a whole avoids tiresome exposition in favour of largely communicating its ideas visually.

Advertisement

Given that the fun of the film lies largely in following Rose as she attempts to outwit a seemingly unstoppable curse, we really don't need a groan-inducing deep dive into how it started, which would've only added more bloat to a film already close to two hours.

5. Parker Finn's Impressively Restrained Direction

Paramount

As a calling card for a first-time filmmaker, Smile is very impressive indeed. Newcomer director Parker Finn shames horror directors with considerably greater experience than himself here, delivering a film that's slick and stylish yet also surprisingly restrained for the most part.

Advertisement

Sure, Finn delivers those shocking funhouse moments that filled up the movie's dubious trailers, but the bulk of the film is really much quieter and more character-driven than that.

Finn has a refreshing confidence in his story to not race through it at mach-speed or resort to the genre's laziest tricks to keep the audience perked up.

Advertisement

There are several long, violence-free stretches in Smile which consist simply of characters talking to one another, and yet aided by a strong cast, Finn keeps them totally captivating.

Combined with his penchant for slow, deliberate camerawork, Finn creates an atmosphere of unease that at times feels more akin to your average A24 horror than a studio romp.

Advertisement

Don't be surprised if Finn becomes an in-demand horror filmmaker in the years to come, because he does an exemplary job in his debut here.

4. The Compelling Ensemble Cast

Paramount

In addition to Sosie Bacon's stellar turn as the lead, the supporting cast is absolutely packed with strong performers turning in rock solid work.

Advertisement

As a cop investigating the violent incident which kicks the movie off - who also happens to be Rose's ex-boyfriend - Kyle Gallner is a supremely likeable sidekick of-sorts.

Elsewhere Caitlin Stasey makes her scant screen time count in the movie's opening sequence as one the curse's prior victim, while Jessie T. Usher, Kal Penn, and Robin Weigert are on-point as Sosie's doubtful fiancee, boss, and therapist respectively.

Advertisement

Yet perhaps the stand-out supporting parts go to two actors who appear in just a single scene each.

Scrubs' Judy Reyes is excellent in a short sequence as the bereaved wife of one of the curse's earlier victims, and Rob Morgan is terrific as a man who plays a crucial role in helping Sosie understand the precise nature of the curse.

Advertisement

Nobody's phoning it in here and everyone's instead giving genuinely effortful, worthwhile performances, which is a damn rarity for this type of movie.

3. It's More Thoughtful Than You're Expecting

Paramount

Smile certainly isn't a deep character piece on the level of your average A24 horror, but it is considerably more thoughtful and contemplative than the marketing would ever have you believe.

Advertisement

Trauma may be the tired genre buzzword of the decade, but Finn is clearly committed to exploring its impact upon the human psyche in a more-than-superficial way.

Beyond that, he examines the continued stigmatisation of mental illness in wider society, and also the unspoken psychological toll suffered by those working in the mental health field.

Advertisement

Again, it's not the smartest character-driven horror movie you'll see this year, but for a film many had dismissed as no-effort trash from the trailers, that it tries and mostly succeeds at being about something is wildly admirable.

2. The Brief But BRUTAL Violence

Paramount

Probably the biggest surprise and most polarising aspect of Smile is that it's far from the relentlessly violent gore-fest you're probably anticipating from the marketing.

Advertisement

There's actually not much death directly shown on-screen throughout Smile at all, yet what we do see is wrought in such nauseatingly brutal detail that it more than compensates.

Finn does such a solid job of dousing the entire story in so much dread and unease that even the seconds-long bursts of brutality leave a bruising, scarring impact.

Advertisement

Anyone lured in by the promise of a movie filled with gnarly death scenes might be left a touch underwhelmed by this approach, yet the story and execution are ultimately compelling enough that many won't even notice, let alone care.

1. The AWESOME Sound Design

Paramount

Killer sound design can truly elevate a horror film to the next level, and it's another aspect of Smile's aesthetic conception that's basically a home run.

Advertisement

Award-winning composer Cristobal Tapia de Veer's ominous score is so brilliantly integrated with the wider soundscape, in turn massively heightening the thick air of dread.

Rose's ever-present anxiety is palpably felt through clever manipulation of environmental sounds: clicks reverberate slyly in the background of even the quietest and most inactive scenes, and in one inspired moment, a loud cheer at a birthday party segues seamlessly into a haunting refrain.

Advertisement

While many prefer to watch horror movies at home, it's clear that considerable care has been put into delivering an adventurous sound mix here well worth checking out on a huge screen with a high quality sound system.