Star Wars: Rise Of Skywalker - Everything It Gets Wrong
How did we get here??
What a weird, history-making level of weird the new Star Wars trilogy has been.
Starting out as a New Hope clone for the sake of safety, only for Rian Johnson to turn in one of the riskiest sequels in all of entertainment, the resultant fan divide was seismic, and splits rooms down the middle to this day.
For Rise of Skywalker to succeed after such a divisive flick was something of a miracle, and the result... is certainly not miraculous.
Rather, as Johnson tied off every major plot thread that was supposed to be answered across all three films, it results in JJ Abrams essentially restarting a derelict vehicle and hoping you still want a ride.
To do so takes INSANE amounts of fan service; pandering scene setups that actively undo the last film's biggest revelations, plus a general attempt to smush two movies into one.
Clearly there was a plan for the whole trilogy from the beginning, but one that Rian Johnson didn't follow. While he's not entirely to blame for derailing such obvious momentum (I blame Disney for giving Johnson a carte blanche mandate), Abrams' insistence on doing everything he apparently had in mind anyway results in an abysmal final product.
-
-- FULL SPOILERS within --
16. Blowing the Palpatine Reveal In The OPENING CRAWL
Struggling to find anything worth doing that would ensnare those who despised The Last Jedi, at Star Wars Celebration 2019, none-other than Palpatine was confirmed to be returning.
Undoing Darth Vader's final good turn by making his actions in Return of the Jedi utterly pointless, Rise of Skywalker handles the Emperor's return with the care of a parent being late for their child's birthday.
No buildup, no payoff - no care or attention. Nothing but "Here he is, because we know you're overdue a present for What You've Been Through".
Thus, Palpatine's existence is folded into the first sentence of the opening crawl, and barely mentioned again.
Despite the fact Palpatine's return would be like finding out Hitler never died and has been hiding out on an island for the last few decades, what comes next is even more throwaway...
15. Retconning Everything So Palpatine Has Been Around Since The Beginning
As if flying through Palps' return in a sentence wasn't bad enough, his opening dialogue does its utmost to bash you over the head with the idea that all of this was planned since the beginning.
Heavy-handedly monologuing to Kylo that he was "the voice all along", Palps was Darth Vader's breathing from Force Awakens, AND the creator of Supreme Leader Snoke, who the Emperor grew in a vat .
The problem?
Not a single strand of this feels believable.
Despite Lucasfilm's Kathleen Kennedy stating that Palps return had been planned "for quite some time", the execution feels like the most forced thing possible.
Not taking the time to do him justice and instead falling back on "Actually it was me all along!" rings hollow, and nothing that happens afterwards makes Palpatine's "background agency" feel any more believable.
14. Luke's First Words Contradict His Lightsaber Throw
Another thing created to directly appease a former scene, the opening of The Last Jedi - where Luke tosses his lightsaber over his shoulder - gets retconned, with the character having a major change of heart.
Coming when Rey is raging out after the death of Leia, she flees to Ahch-To (for some reason) and after burning Kylo's replacement TIE Fighter, goes to throw her lightsaber into the blazing inferno.
What should appear in this moment though? Luke Skywalker, arm outstretched, to grab the saber and save it from burning.
His line of dialogue though? He states to Rey that such a weapon "deserves respect" and shouldn't just be callously thrown into the fire.
The whole thing is a blatant reversal of what happened in The Last Jedi, and only exists as another middle finger to Rian Johnson.
13. The INSANELY Bad Editing & Scene Geography
We can talk about forced fan service and falling back on established characters for plot twists or retcons, but when it comes to filmmaking, that's where Rise of Skywalker falls down hardest.
Simply put, the editing here is atrocious. So many times we have scenarios set up - characters in specific places, threats established or stakes raised - only for a screen wipe to change everything that was going down.
Besides never letting any scene breathe for even a second - be it dialogue or action-based - one notable battle between Kylo and Rey fighting over a troop transport results in the latter being saved by a cutaway, rather than anything logical. Kylo apparently stands in the same place, not chasing his quarry or the one person he's been asked to kill, as the movie moves on and everyone teleports to the next location.
Sadly, over time this only happens more and more - a consequence of Abrams cramming far too much into the movie's runtime.
12. Everything About Kylo Ren
Kylo is by far the most well thought out character in the new trilogy.
The son of Han and Leia who's trained by a nascent Luke and led astray by Snoke, Adam Driver plays Ren as a boy torn between the Light in his bloodline, and the fact all his most important role models have betrayed him.
This leads to being embraced by Snoke, but after killing his father and the Supreme Leader, then trying to partner with Rey in search of some sense of purpose, he's left broken and alone.
Rise of Skywalker's continuation?
To revert him back to the first movie - literally. Kylo is back to being a petulant teenager, thrashing in anger and killing all around him. His helmet is awkwardly reconstituted back to its original form - only for him to remove it all over again.
This wheel-spinning sense of repetition extends to recreating the scene where he kills Han Solo - only this time his cross-saber gets thrown into the sea instead.
We're then TOLD that "Kylo Ren is dead" and "Ben Solo lives", but the whole endeavour is unbelievably sloppy; the product of a trilogy handled by two completely different auteurs.
11. Sacrificing Rose To The Altar Of Toxicity
What happened to Kelly Marie Tran was ugly, unnecessary, and a sad reflection on the current state of fandoms in the modern age.
Being hounded by those who hated her character's role in The Last Jedi, Marie Tran eventually left social media, rather than face a barrage of complaints and hate-filled messages all day, every day.
Going into Rise of Skywalker, it was immediately interesting to see what stance JJ Abrams and Disney would take.
Would they continue Rose's character as a fan of Finn who slowly gains agency as a hero herself, saving his life and even kissing him as the beginning of a potential relationship?
... HELL no.
Rose is practically written out the film entirely. As a response to being asked if she wants to go on the next big adventure, she literally points out that she has to stay at the new base to help out - an exchange that could not be more ham-fisted if it came from an abattoir line worker.
From here she's given a handful of additional lines, but nothing of consequence, ending the movie as a background character.
10. Chewbacca's Forced Mourning Scene
"He didn't do it in Force Awakens, so I guess we do it now?"
That seemed to be the mandate for Chewbacca's "reaction to Leia" scene, as scores of fans complained that we never saw Chewie's "real reaction" to losing Han in The Force Awakens, so here he was going to act even more OTT, just to hammer it home.
Sadly though, after Leia randomly dying comes out of nowhere, it leads to Chewie losing himself over what should've been the most emotional moment in Star Wars history.
Instead, because of the forever rushed feeling that pervades the movie, Leia passes away and we immediately cut to Chewie being informed, only for him to throw his arms around, drop to his knees, pound the ground and be distraught.
The camera lingers throughout as if to say, "Is this right? Did we get it?? Is this enough?!"
9. ANOTHER Skybeam?!
Go-to "final set-piece" of every big budget film this decade, everything from The Avengers to Suicide Squad, Ghostbusters to Big Hero 6 has an arbitrary "giant sky beam".
It can be anything - spectral energy, a giant weapon that needs stopping - but for whatever reason, Hollywood has decided that oversized beams of light are terrifying and imposing, thus even Star Wars is reduced to doing the exact same thing.
Coming after Palpatine achieves unlimited power after sucking the life force from Rey and Kylo (as you do), he fires a ginormous blast of lightning up into the sky, taking out half the rebel's armada in seconds.
It's a neat enough visual, but Abrams playing it safe with yet another expected element was thoroughly lame.
8. Palpatine's Stupid Death
Speaking of Palpatine, his death feels way too happenstance, considering the power he was just wielding.
We're talking about someone who killed both main characters at the same time, re-grew most of his own body and de-aged, then summoned a skyscraper-sized amount of lightning.
The way he's defeated?
Rey holds up a lightsaber and blocks the initial wave of lightning, only to accompany that with a second lightsaber... which is enough.
Palps ultimately blows himself to pieces, as both lightsabers uniting creates enough of a super-powered counter-attack to obliterate him in one go.
The problem though - and this is nitpicky as hell - is that HE was the power source. Just stop trying to fry Rey for a second and you could've kept your face.
After over 30 years of planning and resurrection, Palpatine leaves the saga as a moron.
7. Finn's Wasted Everything
Remember when Finn was the core of the new trilogy?
The centre of the posters and with a backstory centred around realising the First Order weren't the nicest of people, The Force Awakens folded his former slave-adjacent tale into going toe-to-toe with one of the leaders of his oppressors, Kylo Ren.
This was masterfully subverted when Rey took the lightsaber and defeated Kylo instead, but The Last Jedi then reframed Finn's goals as striking the ultimate blow against the First Order, by sacrificing himself to save the rebellion.
Obviously Rose undoes this and makes a valid point about dying for the sake of dying, but this was apparently something JJ Abrams just couldn't further iterate on. Even the kiss with Rose is forgotten about, and Finn's only motivation script-wise is thirsting for Rey, which also goes nowhere.
As if teasing a version of the script where something could've happened, in Rise of Skywalker, Finn meets up with new character Jannah, and discovers an entire group of former stormtroopers who abandoned their posts due to "a feeling".
That's it though. No partnering up with Jannah, no scene of them embracing at the end. Nothing other than a fun enough battle scene and a hug between him, Rey and Poe at the climax.
What a waste of time.
6. What Happened To The Green Lightsaber?!
Perhaps a small point, but what the living hell happened to Luke's green lightsaber??
We see it in The Last Jedi when he's thinking about murdering Kylo in his sleep, and again in Rise of Skywalker's flashback to a young Luke and Leia practicing their fighting skills together.
However, when Luke walks out to face the armada in TLJ, his lightsaber is blue - and this is the one Rey repairs and wields in RoS, which is ALSO the saber held by Force Ghost Luke in his interaction with her.
Do you see the issue?? Where the hell is the green lightsaber? It's the one Luke makes in between Empire and Return, yet its last appearance is being held above Kylo when Luke ponders whether to kill him.
After Luke retrieves Leia's lightsaber from Ahch-To, it means the combined power of Anakin and Leia's lightsabers are the ones that defeat Palpatine, NOT the pairing of Luke and Leia, which would've made a TON more sense.
5. Young Leia's Flashback CGI
Hollywood have a problem with modern day CGI, in that video games have long since caught up and - in some cases - overtaken the former leader in digital entertainment.
In Rogue One's case, Grand Moff Tarkin looked notably off, and Princess Leia - whilst admittedly better - still had a ways to go when it came to convincing us her model wasn't a CG puppet.
In the new movie's case, there's an otherwise awesome flashback to young Luke and Leia sparring together, that results in a look at the pair of them as they take their blaster helmets off.
Young Mark Hamill actually looks pretty spot on. The low lighting compliments what the filmmakers are going for, and it's believable enough.
Young Leia though? It's Rogue One all over again. Simply because of the way the scene is edited, you're then panning up to the "reveal" of "young Leia", and the result is a model that looks straight out of 2017's Battlefront 2.
4. Deaths Have No Weight, And Death Itself Is Meaningless
Back to a fundamental issue with making a movie that needs to serve not only a film trilogy, but an entire empire of merchandise and now a theme park, Rise of Skywalker plays everything as safe as possible.
Yes, there are a couple of deaths like Kylo and Leia, but multiple times we have fakeouts in regards to an earlier Kylo scene, plus Chewbacca AND C3P0 teasing the audience with a sense of finality and weight, only to rip it away.
Chewie's comes from being held captive on a transport that gets accidentally blown up by Rey - only to reveal he was on a different ship all along in the next scene. C3P0's memory wipe was centre of the second round of trailers, but his "amnesia" is played for laughs, until R2D2 restores the vast majority of his files 20 minutes later anyway.
Kylo gets some of the worst examples, going from being stabbed through the stomach by Rey, only to be healed back to normality. Later he gets his life force drained by Palpatine, who throws him across a room and down a chasm, but manages to crawl back to transfer MORE life back into a dead Rey for one kiss, then FINALLY dying in her arms.
Can you feel how exhausting this plotting is?
3. Rushing "Reylo"
Of all the things Rian Johnson messed up, the chemistry between Rey and Kylo across The Last Jedi was actually spot on.
Though the "shirtless Kylo" scene came out of nowhere, it did sew the seed of the pair being romantically involved, and after they slaughter Snoke and his guards, the notion of pairing up was supremely well executed.
However, as the idea of them being together clearly wasn't supposed to be a thing until the VERY end of the trilogy, JJ is forced to retcon their relationship and reset them back to The Force Awakens'-levels of opposition.
All sense of romanticism is ditched as they yell at and attack each other for 99% of the movie, eventually ending up in close proximity after Kylo brings Rey back to life.
It's here where the kiss happens, but it feels borne entirely from box-ticking than any throughline buildup or earned payoff.
In the very next scene you wouldn't know a former "lover" of Rey's had passed away, as she immediately moves onto hugging everyone else and revisiting Luke's house on Tatooine.
Kylo and Rey could've been "Anakin and Padme" done right - forbidden love crossing light and dark side boundaries to create something altogether more powerful, yet forbidden and tragic.
And yet... we got a shirtless scene, some finger touching and a random kiss.
Good job guys.
2. Carrie Fisher's Terribly Used Footage
Obviously this is a majorly sensitive issue, and obviously JJ and all those involved did what they could with the unused footage of Carrie Fisher's takes in Force Awakens to create a new role for Leia.
But, if I'm honest, it was very poorly handled.
Multiple scenes from the original Force Awakens trailers are used, with Leia awkwardly cut out and pasted into scenarios and locations she was never in before.
A reused version of the Leia/Rey hug from the close of TFA gets used from a different angle, and multiple things that Leia says make no sense, given what's being said to her, or what comes after.
Essentially, while the production crew were in between a rock and a hard place deciding what to do, writing a script that asked way too much of this footage stands out as a notable negative.
1. Making A Movie In Direct Response To "The Fans"
Hollywood is in a terrible place right now. Like the gaming industry's biggest companies, they're obsessed with playing things as formulaically as possible.
In the case of blockbuster film that means endless reboots and sequels, with social media backlash being factored in to guarantee "strong word of mouth" after the release of any given flick.
Whilst we forgave Force Awakens for retreading A New Hope because it was a structure we hadn't seen in decades, The Last Jedi shaking everything up meant Disney and JJ Abrams became extra gunshy.
I've touched on elements like Luke's lightsaber comments or Rose being written out, but EVERYTHING from The Last Jedi gets addressed, through the filter of "who moaned about what the most".
Luke lifting his X-Wing out the Ahch-To lake, Holdo's lightspeed suicide run getting hand-waved away as a "one in a million" technique, Rey's father actually being the son of Palpatine and her being his granddaughter, THEN her taking the Skywalker name, because Luke and Leia had a few days' worth of time in her training.
It's so... synthetic, so corporate and lacking in passion or a need to exist.
Rise of Skywalker wasn't created to fulfil any sense of artistic necessity; its script was sellotaped together under an incredibly tight schedule, with plot holes, inconsistencies and incredibly important moments squandered in the name of profit.