Suicide Squad: 8 Biggest Differences With Batman V Superman

They might be set in the same universe, but that is where the similarities end!

By Bevan Morgan /

Despite the recently-drubbed Batman V Superman and the highly-anticipated Suicide Squad movie are both set in the same universe, there appear to be quite a few differences between how the two properties are being handled – if the trailers and reports of ongoing reshoots are anything to go by.

Advertisement

This is a bold move on behalf of DC/WB, especially given that the standard bearer of the comic book film genre, Marvel, have opted for an entirely different route in how their films are produced. While there have been minor tweaks in tone and quality throughout the various phases of the Marvel Universe, the product has been remarkably consistent across the board.

If Suicide Squad is a failure and they decide to keep ploughing along with their extended universe, then we may eventually see something more in line with what Marvel are doing. On the flip side, if Suicide Squad is beloved then they might keep changing things up.

Regardless of what the future holds, there are going to be some significant differences between Batman V Superman and Suicide Squad that will probably define how DC/WB goes forward in the ensuing years. These are the eight most significant ones that stand out the most at this stage.

8. The Directors Have Totally Different Styles

One of the interesting things about the way that DC/WB does business is how they hire auteur directors for their distinct style. This stands in direct contrast to Marvel, who will hire a wide range of filmmakers, but keep them under a tight reign, ensuring their films are all basically the same in tone.

Advertisement

The merits of either approach can be debated for weeks, but that’s not what we are discussing here. What is significant is just how different David Ayer and Zack Snyder are as directors.

While both filmmakers tend to produce dark, gritty, and violent films, they are worlds apart in how they deliver their narratives. Snyder lives in a hyper-tinted universe exemplified by fantasy films like Watchmen, 300, and Sucker Punch. Conversely Ayer resides in a far more grounded reality that has produced films like Street Kings, End Of Watch, and Fury. Both groups of films might be violent and brutal, but that is where the similarities end. Visually, tonally, structurally, and quality-wise, they really couldn’t be any different.

Given how they are poles apart when it comes to directing, it is going to be fascinating to see how these two such contrasting auteurs tackle similar subject matter set in the same universe.

7. David Goyer's Writing Style Is Nowhere To Be Found

David S Goyer is one of the more divisive and controversial screenwriters in the movie business today. To many fans, there is a (perhaps unfair) perception that Goyer is still cashing in the goodwill that came from his involvement in the Dark Knight trilogy; while those three flicks were obviously some of the greatest comic book movies of all time, he was working with the two Nolan brothers, who had a huge amount of creative control.

Advertisement

Goyer’s fingerprints appear to be all over both Man Of Steel and Batman V Superman - from the valuing of themes over logic right through to messy and overly convoluted plots that leave massive plot holes. In contrast, Suicide Squad will be one of the fe recent DC properties that won't have Goyer’s hands anywhere near it. Unlike Snyder, David Ayer has taken on the writing role for Suicide Squad himself, and given what we have seen from his earlier writing efforts, this is potentially very exciting.

While he has written a few movies in his time that weren’t well received, Ayer's writing CV is predominantly stronger than Goyer’s and is diverse enough to demonstrate that he knows how to construct a screenplay for almost any genre.

6. Suicide Squad Will Have Proper Humour

This is possibly the most discussed issue surrounding the DC properties. Warner Bros. seem to have misjudged the success of the Dark Knight trilogy, taking itas evidence that people only want earnest takes on comic book properties. The truth is more nuanced - fans want earnest takes on sincere characters, like Batman. But for others (like Superman) that approach might be inappropriate.

Advertisement

The re-shuffling of Suicide Squad trailers since last year has been eye opening, as it shows that they are starting to finally pick up on the fan backlash against the lack of levity in their universe.

When the first trailer was released after Comic-Con, Suicide Squad looked like a big budget art film with almost no room for reflexivity. Two trailers later, DC are clearly in the process of recutting and reshaping the film as if to say "We have yuks aplenty, please don’t panic."

It's speculative at this stage whether or not the laughs will be on the increase. But if the news of reshoots and the constant tweaking of trailers is anything to go by, Warner are desperate to make sure that audiences think that this movie is a villain Avengers, rather than an even more depressing Batman V Superman.

5. The Expectations Are Very Different

A year ago it was assumed by many that Batman V Superman would be the jewel in the DC crown. The Comic-Con trailer was just so damn good that it looked as if the film could not be anything less than a cultural milestone. In contrast, Suicide Squad, a property that most casual observers hadn’t even heard of, was so far back in the distance, people just hoped it would be an entertaining addition to the Batman V Superman juggernaut.

Advertisement

Reality has worked itself out to be quite different, however. While Batman V Superman has made boatloads of money, it has not closed in on the fabled billion-dollar mark as basically everyone assumed it would – which is actually kind of a disaster. Worst of all, though, the reaction has been so weak that even the most die-hard fans have been struggling to find reasons to be optimistic.

All the pressure is on Suicide Squad to now become what Batman V Superman was meant to be. Everyone involved is hoping that it will be DC’s Guardians Of The Galaxy and reinvigorate the franchise. The problem, of course, is that expectations were set deliberately low for Guardians, which is part of the reason it was such a staggering success. When you don’t expect much, it doesn’t take much to exceed expectations.

4. There's Going To Be Real Diversity

One of the best parts of Batman V Superman was the appearance of Wonder Woman. She was fresh, she was entertaining, and she looked like a total badass. Aside from her, though, the film was still very much a white male dominated affair. Even key characters that weren't white men (like Lois Lane and Perry White) were completely ineffectual in the grand scheme of things.

Advertisement

Suicide Squad looks like it’s going to be not only the first DC film that has some real diversity, but it also is the first comic book movie in general that will finally break the tired mold of generic white males fighting. In the film, there is an incredibly diverse array of non-white and mixed gender actors carrying the load and sharing the charisma.

This is exciting news for anyone interested in something even slightly original and progressive in a genre that is starting to get very repetitive. Batman V Superman struggled to do anything fresh with its two leads because they’re basically the same characters we have seen in every action movie ever. Suicide Squad appears to be unburdened from this problem, so if it does nothing else, it will finally put some other talent in the limelight that has been hogged by white men for too long.

3. They're Anti-Heroes

Batman V Superman is unambiguously focused on heroes. By any literary definition of what heroism is, Batman is a hero. Even in Batman V Superman, where we have probably his most fascist incarnation; in the movie, he still goes to fight Superman without even a hint of fear, and he is driven by a strict idealism that guides his actions. This is heroism defined.

Advertisement

Additionally, regardless of how much Goyer and Synder might have tried to tweak Superman's character, he is still undoubtedly the most iconic superhero ever created.

Task Force X, however, are legitimate antiheroes. They are dishonest, aggressive, disagreeable, and only fighting for right under the threat of having their heads blown off. It appears there will be the odd exception – Deadshot, for example - but, by and large, these are literally villainous protagonists.

This is a radical departure from Batman V Superman and also comic movies in general. It's not only a nice novelty, but it also provides the chance for rich characterisation and quirks that would have been impossible with the characters in the former movie. The moral flexibility with these characters is enormous, and there is plenty of potential to test audiences on how much they can truly relate to them.

2. The Marketing Strategy Is Already Very Different

From the very first teaser, Batman V Superman came across as a bit of a stake in the ground from DC. We already knew that they were trying to go uber serious when they released Man Of Steel three years ago, but Batman V Superman always looked like a doubling down of that strategy.

Advertisement

If the new trailers and subsequent reshoots of Suicide Squad are anything to go by, though, that strategy has taken a bit of a back seat to adopting what has worked for Marvel.

The second trailer for Suicide Squad was clearly an attempt to mimic the success of Guardians Of The Galaxy. Part of the success of that film came through its ingenious use of retro music, so the bright sparks at Warner tried to beat Marvel at their own game by editing the trailer to Queen’s legendary Bohemian Rhapsody. For the third trailer, they refined the approach even further, and the entire focus of the film seems to be in combining witty banter with explosive set pieces and catchy tunes.

Time will tell if the film actually succeeds in meshing the two approaches together with any real success, but it's clear that at the moment, DC are finding new potential in the old saying "If you can't beat them, join them."

1. The Future Of The Franchise

It is not entirely clear at present what role Suicide Squad has in setting up the DC future, but based on the slate it appears pretty minmal. It can not be emphasised enough, what a good thing this is.

Advertisement

Batman V Superman collapsed under the weight of trying to do too much, with too little time. The shoehorning in of the Justice League and the adaptation of the Death of Superman storyline was poor planning of the highest order; Goyer and Snyder were essentially left to do the impossible with that film, and the results were not good.

While it is certain that Suicide Squad will have to contribute to that wider universe narrative (obviously), this has not been its main focus. Predominantly, Ayer has been allowed to focus on building his own film that focuses on these characters and their own story.

While it is a little bit nerve-wracking that the film has to introduce so many characters at once, the vast majority of these are at least lesser known villains who can afford to divide up screen time. The liberation from having to carry the entire universe on its shoulders gives the whole property a completely different feel to the one that lingered over Batman V Superman.

How different from Batman V Superman do you think Suicide Squad will be? And what are you expecting from the supervillain team-up? Share your thoughts down in the comments.

Advertisement