X-Men Dark Phoenix - 8 Things It Must Do
The second time's the charm?
The X-Men franchise needs a new excellent entry into their series, following the colossal disappointment that was X-Men: Apocalypse. Although Deadpool and Logan were both highly praised and commercially successful, the more central X-Men films are much more uneven in terms of quality.
When Fox announced that the next film would focus on the incredibly beloved Dark Phoenix Saga, fans were immediately and appropriately apprehensive. After all, this is the studio that already completely failed their first attempt at it with the dismal X-Men: The Last Stand. Furthermore, both Origins: Wolverine and Apocalypse were terrible attempts to adapt popular comic book storylines to the movie screen.
It's important to remain optimistic, however. Days of Future Past was successfully adapted, even with the decision to make Wolverine the main character instead of Kitty Pryde. Even though Fox could very well mess everything up (again), they also have every opportunity to hit it out of the park, so to speak.
However, there are a number of things that absolutely must be done if X-Men Dark Phoenix is going to succeed. All of these are things that can still be accomplished, as the film is still in process of casting and has not yet begun filming as of this writing.
8. Focus Entirely On The Dark Phoenix Saga
One of the biggest problems with X-Men: The Last Stand was its insistence to cram two giant storylines into one movie. Jean Grey's transformation into the Dark Phoenix was completely sidelined so that the mutant cure storyline could take center stage. As a result, neither was done particularly well.
Shoehorning multiple stories into a single movie is still an unfortunate trend in order to appeal to a wider audience and increase ticket sales. Spider-Man 3, The Amazing Spider-Man 2, and Batman v Superman all fell victim to this as well. Rather tellingly, none of those films ended up being particularly popular.
In literally naming their film "X-Men: Dark Phoenix," perhaps Fox has already figured this out. Jean Grey should be front and center for the film, and although there can be sub-plots, they should in no way take precedent.
There's also the question of how the Dark Phoenix Saga will be adapted into a movie. Doing a page-to-screen translation ultimately might not work very well, especially given the cosmic and alien elements of the saga that have never been featured in any film of the franchise thus far.
The idea that Phoenix is a being inside of Jean Grey that will manifest if she ever loses control of her powers is an ideal approach, especially as it has already been set up in X-Men: Apocalypse. If done right, the movie could feature a new iconic take on the classic story.
7. Make The New Cast The Main Characters
The IMDb page for Dark Phoenix includes a few main characters from the previous X-Men trilogy: James McAvoy's Professor X, Michael Fassbender's Magneto, Nicholas Hoult's Beast, and, most bizarrely, Jennifer Lawrence's Mystique, despite her supposed indifference to being an X-Men following her bored performance in Apocalypse.
None of these four should be the main characters. Professor X should be taken out of the field entirely, instead advising from the X-Mansion. Magneto, Mystique, and Beast should all be in smaller roles as well.
As previously mentioned, the main focus should be Sophie Turner's Jean Grey, but the other new members should also be front and center. Tye Sheridan's Cyclops, Alexandra Shipp's Storm, and Kodi Smit-McPhee's Nightcrawler look set to become the new and most iconic incarnation of the X-Men. These four young actors (and hopefully Evan Peters' Quicksilver) are Fox's best bet to move the series forward.
The temptation to make Mystique And Her Super Friends 3 is obvious. Jennifer Lawrence is one of the biggest movie stars in the world and an ideal person to build a franchise around. In terms of longevity, however, banking on Turner and Sheridan, both of whom can lead the franchise for years to come, is the best long term plan.
6. End The Magneto/Professor X Drama
Six. That is the number of movies that have revolved around the conflicts and friendship between Charles Xavier and Erik Lehnsherr. Isn't that enough?
Yes, McAvoy and Fassbender are both magnificent in their roles, but the constant switching between friends and enemies became exhausting several films ago. Magneto vs. Professor X is a tried and true formula, but just like with every formula, it becomes incredibly stale. Magneto killed millions of people in Apocalypse and Xavier forgave his old friend almost immediately. What could Lehnsherr possibly do now to lose the allegiance of his best friend? There's simply no progression from there.
The solution is clear: take out the constant shifting allegiance and just put Magneto on the X-Men full time. He can work with Professor X and be a co-leader. The two clashing ideologies is not necessarily a problem, as long as the characters are written well enough where their conflict doesn't consume the entire movie.
The only other solution would be give Michael Fassbender a break and just have him leave for awhile. As he's already been signed on for Dark Phoenix, that isn't going to happen.
The X-Men deserve to have a chance to exist without Magneto as their primary foe. So make him a full time ally.
5. Have The Characters Adhere More To The Comics Than To The Original Films
In the original X-Men comics, Cyclops, while definitely adhering to a specific code of conduct, was the badass leader. Not only was he one of the most powerful X-Men ever, but he was also an expert strategist. Additionally, Storm was a force to be reckoned with, something that rightfully gave her the title of one of the most popular X-Men ever. X-Men: Dark Phoenix needs to start shifting towards that.
Cyclops especially absolutely cannot start to drift toward what he was like in the original trilogy. Because of the decision to make Wolverine into the main character, Cyclops was sidelined into a whiny wet blanket. Cyclops was essentially the Lori Grimes to Wolverine's Rick.
While Tye Sheridan's take on the character did make Cyclops infinitely more interesting, he can't be quite the rebel he was in Apocalypse. Because of the ridiculous timeline of the X-Men films, Cyclops should be in his 20s by the time Dark Phoenix takes place, meaning he has more than enough time to mature and start shifting into his comic counterpart. Ideally, the film would end with Scott Summers in place to take full leadership over the X-Men.
Similarly, while Alexandra Shipp's Storm was wildly superior to Halle Berry's, she needs more to do this time around. Someone that can control the weather should not be underpowered. There's no need to convince fans that she could be beaten by someone like Toad.
4. Don't Botch The Villain
Apocalypse is one the X-Men's all time greatest enemies in the comic books, an infinitely powerful being that effectively created an entire alternate timeline after murdering Professor Xavier.
Remember the fan excitement when renowned actor Oscar Isaac was cast to play him?
Remember the massive disappointment upon learning the movie completely messed it up?
Jessica Chastain is heavily rumored to play Lilandra Neramani, Empress of the Shi'ar Empire, and one of the biggest characters in the original Dark Phoenix Saga. Quite what Lilandra's role would be remains to be seen, but there's no question that Chastain would completely own the role if she were given the chance.
Lilandra might not be as iconic as Apocalypse, but if you get someone of the acting caliber of Jessica Chastain to sign on to a superhero film, you'd better utilize her correctly.
In the comics, Lilandra's goal is not one of global destruction, which is part of what made Apocalypse so generic. Rather, after Phoenix accidentally wipes out a planet, killing billions in the process, Lilandra sees Phoenix as the galaxy's biggest threat and vows to execute her, obviously pitting her against the X-Men hoping to save Jean Grey. If X-Men: Dark Phoenix follows similarly along these lines, Lilandra could be one the series' most relatable and sympathetic villains ever.
Please don't screw it up.
3. Tone Down The Excessive CGI And Action Scenes
X-Men: Apocalypse was less of a film, and more of an excuse to move between impressive set pieces. That was due in large part to the insistence to use so much CGI. Which wasn't even that good.
This film is obviously going to be PG-13 instead of an R, so we're not looking for the visceral realism of Logan or the gory carnage of Deadpool. Rather, it's time for a return to basics, like in Days of Future Past. While there were definitely massive CGI set pieces, there was space in between each of them that allowed the story and the characters to breathe.
Apocalypse, on the other hand, barely allowed a moment before cramming in yet another action scene. By the end of the movie, everything had blended together so effectively it just felt like one long battle. There was no room to process Havoc's death, because the movie immediately moved to yet another action scene.
Obviously, with Cyclops and Storm involved, there will be significant CGI. Instead of overdoing it, it would be better to make the fight scenes more memorable by having fewer of them. The phrase "quality, not quantity" comes to mind here.
Plus, we'd all really prefer it if as much money as possible was spent on making Dark Phoenix look look terrifyingly threatening.
2. Figure Out Sophie Turner's Accent
Sophie Turner's American accent in X-Men: Apocalypse split the room: some thought it was the worst accent ever to be heard on screen, while others thought it was merely mediocre.
Neither is ideal.
This is not meant as a slant against Sophie Turner's acting skills. Clearly she has the chops necessary to play Sansa Stark on Game of Thrones. But something must be done about her attempts to sound American.
One option is simply to hire a better accent coach and hope for the best.
The other option has already been done before. Halle Berry's attempt at an African accent in the first X-Men film was widely despised, so Berry subsequently dropped it for the sequels. Storm sounding American wasn't faithful to the comics, but the change was for the better.
Considering Days of Future Past essentially existed to wipe out The Last Stand, the X-Men franchise has precisely zero problems with retcons. It wouldn't be that far of a stretch for Fox to say that Jean Grey has actually had a British accent for the entire series.
Some purists may not approve, but Sophie Turner will be the main focus of the upcoming film. It would be much more preferable to change one slight part about Jean Grey in order to make Turner more natural in her role.
The alternative is running the risk of ruining the Dark Phoenix Saga by having a distracting accent.
1. Don't Cast Taylor Swift As The Dazzler
Please.
To be fair, Taylor Swift's acting career only includes three films, one of which was animated (The Lorax), while another was a sappy Holiday-themed ensemble movie (Valentine's Day). To be even more fair, it is doubtful that anyone ever thought that NSYNC member Justin Timberlake could ever be a successful actor. Could Swift actually be a good actor? It is technically possible.
But it is very hard not to be worried about what the marketing would quickly become.
Instead of focusing on a group of mutants fighting against impossible odds, it suddenly becomes Taylor Swift's Superhero Movie. With the high price tag that Swift is likely to come with, it wouldn't be too unexpected for Fox to make her one of the biggest parts of the movie to justify their large expenses.
Rumors have been swirling that Swift may be offered the part of the pop star mutant. However, it's difficult to believe that it is anything except a cheap ploy to get Swift's fans to go see the movie.
X-Men doesn't need the cash grab. It's a superhero movie. That alone is almost always enough to guarantee a high audience turnout. With the box office juggernaut that X-Men is, Fox really doesn't need the extra appeal to market their movie.
Also, it needs to be said: Dazzler is one of the dumbest ideas for a superhero ever.