10 AWESOME Video Game Trailers (Then The Game Sucked)
When the trailer is the best part, you have a problem.
The cinematic trailer has been a thing since 3D modelling became less expensive to use and also... far less laughable to behold, for the average viewer. Cinematic trailers are the industry's go-to standard for showing off a game that's still early in development, but far enough along that press hype can now begin.
Everyone knows on some level that these trailers are not indicative of what will be in the actual game, but some are far more deceitful than others. For instance, sometimes the trailer is really good, while the game it's teasing is really, REALLY bad.
It's a really funny experience watching a trailer for a game you now know is trash in hindsight.
Especially when the cinematic trailer kinda actually works on its own as a short film for a MUCH better experience than what came out. These ten trailers had the most glaring difference in quality with the games they were advertising.
10. No Man's Sky
The Trailer
Never let it be said that Hello Games doesn't know how to pitch its ideas. The trailer for No Man's Sky, that first released during the 2014 E3 showcase, promised the entire universe and everyone bought in.
It positioned itself as being essentially Minecraft but on the grandest scale imaginable, a game solely about space exploration and discovery instead of conquest and warfare. Wrapping up with a perfect quote by Carl Sagan, the gaming public was left utterly stupefied by what they'd seen, and thus the wait began.
The Game
No Man's Sky was not a bad game when it was released, and it's only gotten better as the years have gone by. But due to a mix of the usual game press hyperbole that all studios do and other issues such as their entire office FLOODING, the No Man's Sky that came out on August 9th, 2016 was not the game that was promised.
The universe of the original build of NMS was remarkably dry and empty. While there was stuff to do, it was so reliant on the RNG the whole game is built around, that players would go hours without encountering anything.
It was definitely something resembling the game that was promised, and would be eventually delivered in the coming years, but that first impression left a very bad taste in folks' mouths.
9. Star Wars: The Force Unleashed 2
The Trailer
The cinematic trailer for Force Unleashed 2 actually does manage to capture the tone and story of the game. The trailer features Starkiller walking down a hallway, as voices from the previous game play in his mind. The more they play, the more angry and anxious Starkiller becomes, causing his force powers to run amok, tearing the hallways to shreds. Finally, the voice of Juno Eclipse slices through all the myriad voices, calming him enough to rein in his powers. Roll title and release date, and boom, ya got yourself a winner.
The Game
While the trailer was good at conveying the overall mood and story of the game, it of course failed to warn audiences that Force Unleashed 2 would be a failure to recreate God Of War (ya know, instead of a failure to recreate Devil May Cry like the first one was), with forgettable linear hallway levels and writing that just flat out couldn't compare to the original.
And mind you, the original was okay at best so that's a problem.
8. Overkill's The Walking Dead
The Trailer
Overkill's The Walking Dead game had an interesting idea with its ad campaign where they would make a full cinematic trailer for each character. These trailers got a lot of fans of the show and comic hooked thanks to their rich atmosphere and brutal depiction of the universe it was adapting.
It was a depiction of the world that the more successful Walking Dead series by TellTale couldn't really achieve with their engine.
The Game
The game that came out wasn't bad, necessarily, but it wasn't even half of the game that the trailers promised. While the trailers showed The Walking Dead, the game was nakedly determined to be some inhuman hybrid of Left 4 Dead and World War Z (the movie version).
And unfortunately, Overkill was not very good at recreating the anarchic zombie fighting of Left 4 Dead, and the writing - while not terrible - was not enough to justify the shallow gameplay that surrounded it.
A shame too, since a fully open-world, survival based Walking Dead game could absolutely work, this just wasn't it.
7. DC Universe Online
The Trailer
This underwhelming but admirably stubborn MMO that refuses to die made waves when it was first announced thanks to its cinematic trailer. The trailer featured the Secret Society, led by Lex Luthor, finally conquering the Justice League, with Luthor even getting to lay the final blow on Superman. Only for his actions to be immediately rewarded with Brainiac coming down to invade the now undefended Earth.
The trailer ends with the reveal that this is being relayed to the Justice League by the now-repentant Lex of the future, who tells them that they need to prepare for what is coming. A bold as hell mission statement for an MMO, so much so that it was the opening cinematic for the game for many years.
The Game
DC Universe Online just wasn't up to snuff compared to contemporaries like World Of Warcraft. Although it has managed to survive, even getting regular updates to this day, including an upcoming ground-up graphical update, it's just never managed to get people invested.
A lot of this, to be fair, is likely due to lack of marketing. If you know about this game, it's because someone told you, WB has left this game out to dry for YEARS, and why they even keep the servers running at this point is anyone's guess.
6. Destiny
The Trailer
One of the most legendarily madcap and chaotic game development stories was momentarily covered up by a truly magnificent trailer directed by Jon Favreau.
Bungie's fanbase, made up entirely of people who had grown up on the company's military shooter magnum opus Halo, didn't know what to expect from its big follow-up. Needless to say, the trailer for Destiny - with its operatic, almost whimsical atmosphere, and themes of exploration and discovery - left them all in awe.
This promised to be a departure from Halo in the best way possible.
The Game
But we all know the punchline to that gag, don't we? While the franchise has found its footing with Destiny 2, the only Live-Service game to actually pay off financially, the original was a disaster.
Development was a nightmare, and its launch was riddled with problems ranging from the mundane (casting celebrities who fell flat as voice actors) to the bizarre (nixing the ENTIRE story campaign right before launch). It ultimately paid off with the sequel, but Destiny utterly failed to capture the wonder proposed by its initial trailer.
5. Cyberpunk 2077
The Trailer
Cyberpunk 2077 was one of the most built-up video games in the entire industry in recent memory. Your scribe was 15 when the first trailer for this game dropped on YouTube, and it was one of the most unreal things I had ever seen.
It stayed in the back of my mind until 2018 when proper gameplay trailers started being shown off. All of them were fantastic, showing the game as everything those years of waiting had promised.
Complex RPG mechanics, gorgeous visuals, and Keanu F*cking Reeves. How could this possibly go wrong?
The Game
Well, the game was a buggy, barely playable mess, for one thing. While recent patches have cleaned the game up to better resemble the game we all thought we'd get, that original release lives in infamy and the game has yet to fully live it down.
The glitches were so wild that, for a lot of people, they stopped being aggravating and just became funny. And also, I'm sorry, I love Keanu, but he was just the wrong choice for Johnny Silverhand.
Johnny Silverhand is cool, but he's also a huge prick, and Keanu just can't match that energy.
4. Fallout 76
The Trailer
Fallout 76's trailer was so good that it got Gen Z into John Denver. Country Roads straight-up became a meme after that original trailer dropped simply by the sheer strength of it being a damn catchy tune.
And even barring that, the idea of a multiplayer Fallout game, potentially taking the settlement-building mechanics of 4 to its logical conclusion as you patrol the wasteland with your friends and build up your own massive settlement was a tantalizing prospect.
Of course, the idea that you could get your hands on your own nuclear warheads and drop them on other players was an idea too ultra-violent to pass up.
The Game
Well, it was definitely a multiplayer Fallout game. It was definitely...one of those. But as for the quality thereof, I think we all know how that song and dance went.
Regardless of the quality of life improvements made in the years since, Fallout 76 has proven to be an utter failure on pretty much every level. The game is practically deserted, it doesn't take nearly enough advantage of the idea of multiplayer building mechanics as it could have. And the glitches, oh dear god the glitches.
3. Dead Island
The Trailer
The trailer for Dead Island is one of the best cinematic trailers for a game out there. The trailer focuses on a family on vacation on the island of Banoi, where the zombie outbreak is about to begin.
The rest of the trailer is just the family struggling to stay alive, the viewer quickly becoming invested in this young family as they try to avoid an entire island that wants them dead. Definitely a great setup for a harrowing survival horror game, but how did the game itself follow it up?
The Game
The answer, according to Deep Silver apparently, was to nix the entire concept the trailer set up, including all the characters established in the trailer, in favor of a more generic band of highly trained badasses.
Talk about blowing a good thing. The game itself is fine, if a bit rote, but the characters are just not that interesting and you don't care about them nearly as much as the family shown in the trailer.
Not the most dishonest trailer out there, but still a letdown.
2. Assassin's Creed Unity
The Trailer
A running gag with Assassins Creed is that the better the trailer, the worse the final game. Assassins Creed 2? Forgettable trailer, awesome game.
Meanwhile, Assassins Creed Unity's trailers popped the f*&% off, brilliantly showing off the game's characters, enemies, and revolutionary tone with bombastic aplomb. The Ezio trilogy was well behind us by this point, and Black Flag had brilliantly refined what 3 set up.
Seeing the trailers for Unity promising another radical but interesting shift in the AC formula, as well as taking fans to one of the most interesting periods in European history, was too tantalizing an idea to pass up.
And then the game came out.
The Game
Unity is by far the most infamous entry in the Assassins Creed series to date. A broken, buggy mess of a game riddled with predatory microtransactions, and a nothing plot that fails to take full advantage of the time period it's set in.
Top all of that off with people bringing up how the game has four identical male protagonists and not a single woman and Ubisoft being, well, Ubisoft in response, and you get the Assassins Creed game that even most hardcore fans won't stick up for.
1. Aliens: Colonial Marines
The Trailer
Everything about this game's marketing, down to the last YouTube banner ad, was an outright lie. It's legitimately impressive how effectively dishonest the ad campaign was for this infamous flop of a game.
The trailers, obviously, did everything in their power to sell people on the idea of taking up arms as one of the colonial marines working for Waylun-Yutani, going head to head with the Xenomorph scourge.
Dripping with military machismo and sci-fi shoot-em-up goodness, when Gearbox followed up with "gameplay" trailers, it looked even better. Surely this would be a win for both Gearbox and the Alien IP as a whole.
The Game
It is legitimately hilarious that most of the bugs that came about in the final release of Colonial Marines were the fault of one typo in one line of code. Removing it in the PC version of the game tightens the whole thing right up.
Shame then, that even without that, the game is still just flat-out bad. The guns have no kick to them, the story reeks of the worst kind of fanfiction, the Xenomorphs are nowhere near as interesting as enemies as they should be, and the military machismo posturing lacks even the bare amount of charm it had in the trailers.
It's impressive about how much of a bald-faced lie the marketing for this game was.