10 Best Video Game User Interfaces

When gorgeous fashion meets glorious function.

By Jack Pooley /

Perhaps the single most under-appreciated aspect of video game design is that of the user interface (UI), because when it's great, you don't really notice. You can effortlessly glide through menus and play the game precisely as the developers intended.

Advertisement

UI design tends to be more noticeable when it's poor, in turn affecting the user experience (UX) and potentially making even simple tasks a hellish slog of nested menus and arcane navigation.

But what, exactly, defines a good UI? There certainly isn't an all-catch answer and to an extent it's subjective, though most will surely agree that it revolves around the pitting of fashion against function, of creating a menu system which is stylish yet not at the expense of ease-of-use.

We've all played games with gorgeous-yet-clunky UIs or interfaces that were snappy and efficient yet hideous.

These 10 UIs, however, generally achieved an impressive fusion of the two, reinventing typical design conventions in ways which were often massively influential throughout the industry.

Whether they drew attention to themselves or not, these 10 games are all striking examples of what a masterful, first-rate UI looks like...

10. Metal Gear Solid

It cannot be understated just how influential Metal Gear Solid was upon the third-person action game, and among its many highly-lauded features we shouldn't forget its terrifically ground-breaking UI.

Advertisement

The brilliance of its interface lies in its creative simplicity: holding L2 or R2 allows players to cycle through their items or weapons respectively in a manner quite unlike any other game.

Between the satisfying snappiness and fantastic sound effects, it became an instantly iconic mainstay for the series - albeit with variations - such that it's surprising more games haven't shamelessly ripped it off over the years.

In a series that affords so many combat and stealth options to the player, being able to quickly cycle through your gear is absolutely vital, and this was a genius solution to a potentially daunting design problem: too many toys, not enough screen real estate.

Aptly, the interface is as sleek and versatile as Solid Snake himself.

9. Destiny

In an age where so many AAA games inundate players with over-designed menus filled with far too many digits and Things To Look At, Destiny's extremely clean and easily understood UI is an absolute marvel.

Advertisement

Despite the original game being a console exclusive, Bungie managed to come up with a PC-style interface which allowed players to quickly navigate a wide gamut of options even while using a controller.

Rather than having to cycle through options in a strict order, the use of a free-flow cursor let players quickly hover over their desired option, cutting down on frustrating busy-work and ensuring players only spent as much time in menus as they really needed to.

It is an exceptional balancing act that neither alienates traditional console players nor those used to navigating menus with a PC mouse.

Bungie have spoken extensively over the years about the enormous amount of development time they devoted to getting the UI right, and that's abundantly clear from the fantastically intuitive end product.

8. Firewatch

Over the last decade-or-so, diegetic UIs - that is, interfaces which exist within the game world itself - have become far more common, and one of the most evocative examples to date is in Campo Santo's brilliant 2016 adventure game Firewatch.

Advertisement

Players control Henry, a fire lookout at Shoshone National Forest who spends almost the entirety of the game in isolation as he performs various tasks around the forest.

And in order to enhance the eerie immersion of Henry's solitude, the game ditches a traditional HUD in favour of a largely in-game, diegetic interface.

The map, for instance, is an actual map which Henry will get out and read whenever you decide to view it.

Rather than constantly throwing on-screen waypoints at the player, everything you need to navigate through the game is presented within the world of the game itself - there are signposts guiding you along, and Henry will mark off useful information on the map as you go.

It isn't the first game to employ such a tactic - Far Cry 2 was widely lauded for doing so back in 2008 - but in terms of an interface which actually helps crystalise a game's core themes and mood, none feels quite as ingenious as Firewatch.

7. Metroid Prime

It cannot be understated just how groundbreaking and influential Metroid Prime's UI was when the game first hit shelves back in 2002.

Advertisement

Though it's easy to take for granted now, at the time the idea that the player's HUD could also be how the game's protagonist sees the world was positively Earth-shattering.

In the game, every piece of information the player needs access to is displayed as a holographic projection on Samus' helmet, providing an unprecedented level of immersion and truly allowing players to feel as though they were stepping into Samus' Power Suit for themselves.

Because that wasn't inventive enough, the various visors - thermal, x-ray, and scan - further made the UI feel less like it existed for the player's sake and more because it was exactly what Samus needed in order to get the job done.

Players paying close attention might even catch a brief reflection of Samus' face in the visor when the lighting conditions are right. That level of detail was unheard of in 2002, and so many games since have lovingly imitated it.

Given the recent resurgence of mech games in VR, this type of UI has been tremendously popular - and incredibly effective - in that space.

6. Mirror's Edge

Mirror's Edge and its belated follow-up Mirror's Edge Catalyst took the notion of the diegetic UI to a stunningly creative new realm by more or less ditching a traditional interface entirely.

Advertisement

Instead, players were guided around the game's vertiginous locales with "Runner Vision," which highlights pathways and potential traversal objects in the colour red, allowing players to perform jaw-dropping acrobatic feats at the drop of a hat without being hand-held by exterior waypoints and markers.

Better still, players could turn off Runner Vision entirely if they craved a more challenging experience. But no matter how you played it, the game's lack of intrusive icons and alerts only made leaping from rooftop to rooftop that much more intense.

And though EA sadly hasn't patched in official VR support for either game, a fantastic-looking VR clone of Mirror's Edge is currently in development.

5. Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4 is typically credited with modernising the classic survival horror series, though there is perhaps one aspect of the game which was still designed to embrace the wilful restrictions of the earlier titles - the inventory.

Advertisement

While RE4 allows players to carry a fair amount of gear compared to the three prior mainline games, inventory management can still be a challenge. In fact, it's basically a mini-game in of itself, as fans have lovingly named "Inventory Tetris" over the years.

To make the most of their attache case, players have to arrange items for maximum storage efficiency, because in a pinch you'll absolutely need that extra green herb you spent an indecent amount of time squeezing in there.

Despite the potential to frustrate, it was such a smart revision of the previous games' more rigid inventory system that it actually made item management - whisper it - fun.

Upgrading the attache case was, dare one say, genuinely exciting. It's a shame, then, that the system was ditched for all future Resident Evil games, because it remains one of the best in all of gaming.

4. Persona 5

Whatever you make of Persona 5 as a game, there's little disputing the claim that it boasts one of the most brilliantly artful UIs ever. After all, is there any other user interface in gaming history that fans have actually cosplayed as?

Advertisement

Though a cursory glance at the game might suggest an overly busy, cluttered interface designed to bamboozle players, this is an entirely intentional conceit on the part of developers Atlus.

The menu transitions, full of gorgeously fluid, stylised animations, are as wilfully over-the-top as the game's own story and just as implacable as its tortured characters.

This does of course mean that players may need a little time to fully acquaint themselves to navigating each aspect of the interface, but even with its heavily focus on aesthetics, it's still extremely snappy and intuitive once you get used to it.

There's perhaps no better argument in the medium that a UI can aspire to be a work of art in its own right. More like this, please.

3. The Last Of Us

Though The Last of Us' UI is basically the polar opposite of Persona 5's - it's subtle and only announces itself when you need it - like that game it also compliments its own narrative and tone perfectly.

Advertisement

Naughty Dog's survival horror masterpiece is of course all about immersion in a post-apocalyptic landscape, so it follows that the UI and menus should be as unobtrusive as possible.

The UI was changed numerous times during development as Naughty Dog sought to make it as tidy and un-cluttered as possible, with the final design pushing the various crafting and inventory options to the background, such that they're only visible when the player needs them to be.

After a short while, navigating these menus becomes second nature through muscle memory, and this carries through terrifically to the recently released sequel, too.

Were either game clogged up with nested menus or excessive on-screen icons, it'd feel entirely counter to the immersion intended by their cinematic visuals.

2. Dead Space

No discussion of gaming UIs could possibly be complete without Dead Space, which in many ways remains the gold standard for third-person action game menu design.

Advertisement

The sci-fi survival horror classic ingeniously ditched all manner of a traditional UI, instead injecting all the vital information into the game world itself - another killer example of a diegetic interface.

Most brilliantly, protagonist Isaac's health and stasis meters are displayed on the back of his armour, ensuring players never have to peer away from the focal point of the action to manage their vital statistics.

Better still, every other aspect of the UI - inventory management and maps, for example - are holographically projected in the game, which also never pauses while you navigate them.

It's a design choice which not only provides a plausible and appropriate explanation for the menus, but also heightens the tension by allowing players to be attacked in a state where they'd typically be safe.

More than a decade later, it's surprising that more developers haven't wantonly ripped off such an inspired aspect of game design - it'd be tough to blame them.

1. Into The Breach

Though it's completely understandable that more casual gamers might be turned off by Into the Breach's high level of difficulty, the challenge is mitigated considerably by the turn-based strategy game's best-of-class interface.

Advertisement

Developer Subset Games reportedly spent roughly half of the game's four-year development cycle working on its UI, as they attempted to strike a balance between ensuring players knew exactly what was happening and not overwhelming them.

Various elements of the game and its interface were ultimately stripped back after testers found them confusing, yet the end result is still an extremely deep and intelligently designed title.

Co-designer Justin Ma put it quite brilliantly himself by saying, "We would sacrifice cool ideas for the sake of clarity every time."

And yet, Into the Breach certainly doesn't want for cool ideas regardless, managing instead to be both difficult and accessible by not burying players in an avalanche of arcane systems and vague visual "tells."

Advertisement