10 Biggest PlayStation Risks (That Totally Backfired)
Sometimes the big S makes a few mistakes.
When it comes to critical and financial successes, Sony surprised everyone when it went into the console market in the 90s. Back when Nintendo and Sega dominated, Sony's little grey box had a lot riding on it.
Cue some twenty five-or-so years and four more home consoles later, and Sony are still up at the top. The PlayStation 2 being the best selling console of all time, with the PS4 in fourth, are good indicators of that.
Despite the success, it hasn't always been smooth sailing for the Japanese tech giant. Not one but two handheld console failures, for example, mar their track record.
Whilst PSVR is a growing market now, there was a time when Sony jumped on the gimmick bandwagon too soon as well, or put out some nostalgia bait that failed to even do that.
It's not all hardware though, as there have been some total misfires when it comes to launch titles, or competition killers over the years too. Worse yet is trying to emulate the success of other retro offerings and failing at that as well. Which is shocking, given Sony's early gaming pedigree.
So whilst they may be flying high now, there have been some failures throughout the decades. Here are ten examples that maybe aren't the most financially devastating, but certainly the most memorable.
10. The PS3 Launch Price
As a rule of thumb in business, it tends to be "wait for the competition to launch, then undercut the price a bit to sell more". Sell at less, but sell more in the long run.
However, it seems someone in Sony's marketing didn't get the memo when the company was launching the PS3.
Already lagging behind the Xbox 360's launch, Sony had to do something to catch up. However, offering the 60gb model at £425, nearly £150 more than the Xbox, was not the way.
Even at that price, Sony were reportedly working at a loss per unit.
Eventually they balked, and the price was lowered to something more consistent with the competition. But for a time, the PS3 was considered too expensive compared to the relatively manageable Xbox 360 price.
It took a few years, with Sony finally starting to see profit on their third console in 2009. Lessons were learnt with the PS4, which managed to sell a whopping 110m units over its lifetime.
But had Sony stuck to their expensive guns, they may have pushed themselves out of the market in 2006.
9. Taking Too Long To Deliver Streaming
With gaming services nowadays, the services that are offered a relatively straightforward affair. Microsoft and Sony's forerunners, Game Pass and PS Now, respectively, both offer good services. Players are able access titles both old and new, across devices, at a decent price.
Whilst it's taken as a staple of gaming now, back in 2012 it was seen as a bold, new way to play that sounded too good to be true. What didn't help was Sony's grandiose boasts about how streaming could work across mediums, as well as for backwards compatibility for many of their titles.
It did come to fruition, eventually, after Sony sunk a huge amount of money into streaming service Gaikai and created PS Now, which offers a vast range of games to play. The problem is, Microsoft has done it better than Sony has, with completely different infrastructure to boot.
A much bigger catalogue of backwards compatible games to download rather than stream, as well as many new and exclusive games at launch, sees Game Pass miles ahead of PS Now.
PS Now has improved, greatly, over the years. But had it not been boastful, and let Microsoft pip it to the post, it could have been much better a lot sooner.
Let's see what this supposed Spartacus is going to bring...
8. Crippling Backwards Compatibility On The PS3
The PlayStation 2 was great for many reasons, but one of its biggest successes was allowing fans to keep their PSone collection. This was a "good move", as it allowed those on the fence to keep their classic games without fear of them becoming redundant.
So, it would be fair to assume the PS3 would follow suit. To which it did... kind of.
PlayStation games were fine, at the sacrifice of lack of memory card support. Which was a fair-ish compromise, as internal "cards" could be made from storage. No biggie, unless you had a 100+ hour Final Fantasy VIII save.
The same couldn't be said for PlayStation 2 games, though. There were only two PS3 models that could play them: the paltry 20 and 60gb models. As such, these became desirable and therefore hard to find.
It seemed like an odd move from Sony to skip a generation, considering that the PS2 had such a massive library of games. What made it more insulting was releasing said PS2 games on digital library down the line.
Nothing more annoying than paying twice for a game that's sat right there on your shelf.
7. Relying On The Move Too Early
After what some could call the moderate success of the EyeToy and its line, Sony thought the next step up would be full body motion with its Move system.
While now the Move controllers are an accompanying feature with the PSVR headset, prior to that... they weren't anything special.
Released way back in 2010, the PlayStation Move was just another gimmicky motion controller. Whilst it did "survive" and make the leap across the consoles, it was still seen as a tacked-on dalliance that wouldn't really amount to much.
Technically, it was a functional bit of a kit, but the games that supported it were a bit naff. Whilst selling sufficiently, it wasn't until recent years that the Move has found its footing with VR.
One could argue that the Move was the precursor to Sony's VR push, as it wasn't a commercial failure like, say, the Vita. Yet at a time when the Kinect was also trying to capture that motion-market, it was just seen as a competitive move (pun intended) from Sony.
Not a failure in the strictest sense, but pushing them so hard backfired in the short term.
6. Banking On A "Halo Killer"
Halo, Microsoft's first person shooter series, is a behemoth. No bones about it, it's built up a fandom and millions in revenue since its 2001 debut.
As such, it has shifted Xboxes. Naturally, the competition want some of that, with Sony trying not once but quite a few times. So far we've had:
Killzone; which was an ambitious but poorly executed PS2 title in 2004. It started a franchise, but not as groundbreaking as expected.
Resistance; three arcade-style FPS' and two handheld games later, currently shelved by Insomniac since 2012. Fun, but no cigar.
Haze; the loudest proclaimer of the "Halo killers", it absolutely flopped on launch. Terrible story, worse gameplay and a mostly-brown colour palette saw it lambasted quickly enough.
The problem is the title itself: "Halo killer". It attaches a certain stigma, an expectation that a game will come along and topple the Chief. A game so amazing that it'll make Xbox/PC fans flock to PlayStation in droves.
Instead, Sony need to stop chasing that halcyon dream. Make something original (in as much as you can with an FPS) that stands on its own merits. Innovate, especially now Sony have acquired Bungie...
5. Botching The Vita
Speaking of killers, Sony tried to break into the market with their "DS killer" AKA the PlayStation Portable in 2004/5. It didn't topple Nintendo's handheld empire, yet it didn't deter Sony from trying again.
The Vita had the potential to be something great. Dual thumbstick control, superior graphics and a host of PS3 and 4 compatibility.
On paper, it was an impressive bit of kit. First party games like Uncharted and Killzone: Mercenary were great showcase titles, whilst retro fans could play their digital PSone archive on the go.
It should have been Sony's redemption, such that if it didn't beat the DS' ranks, it could join them. Nintendo were doing their 3D thing, Sony could gone for the "technical powerhouse" angle instead. Instead, a convoluted online payment system for multiplayer and a proprietary memory card gimmick were the first detrimental hurdles for the handheld.
Despite selling moderately well, the lack of support from Sony towards the PS4's launch saw the Vita's flame start to burn out. As such, it's regarded as a failure in the mainstream's opinion, and Sony have never tried again in the handheld market.
4. Lair's Early Insistence Of Sixaxis Controls
It seems redundant pointing this out now, some fifteen years and better support later, but Lair was a mess on arrival.
Meant to be Sony and now-defunct Factor 5's big technical showcase for the PS3, Lair instead drew critical derision on its release. Why?
Its massive reliance on the PS3's Sixaxis controller gameplay. Before the Move, the Sixaxis was Sony's way of incorporating motion controllers into its games.
To some degree, it did add a touch of novelty in a few games. But in Lair's case, it was intended to be used throughout the whole game as primary control system.
And you couldn't change it.
Reviewing badly, Sony thought to try and placate those darn stuffy journalists by sending them a book telling them to, "Open their minds and hands" to the experience.
As you can imagine, that went down like a lead balloon tied to a gangster wearing lead shoes. Tell a journalist they're wrong, expect to be called out.
Over time, Lair did get some TLC and controller support. But for the most part, the review scores were in and the damage was done.
3. PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale
Another prime example of Sony chasing Nintendo, but this time not in the hardware stakes.
It's not unreasonable to assume that most gamers are aware of Smash Bros. in some capacity. Nintendo's beat 'em up franchise has a massive fanbase, to the point where even some familiar (but not owned by) PlayStation faces have dropped in. Solid Snake and Cloud Strife, to name a couple, are in various Smash entries across the years.
Sony wanted in on that action, pitting first party stalwarts like Nathan Drake, Sly Cooper and... Killzone 2's Colonel Radec against each other.
It was already off to a rocky start with its limited line up, but perhaps the gameplay could make up for its less-than-stellar cast?
Sadly not. Yet whilst not terrible, it just wasn't very good. Nowhere near as fun or engaging, it failed to hit the mark with fans and critics. Many saw it as Sony's attempt at cashing in on something Nintendo made popular, and rightly so.
This saw All-Stars only sell about a million units, leading to Shuhei Yoshida canning any hope of an All-Stars Ultimate in the future.
2. Almost Removing Old Titles From Sale
When it was announced that Sony's Spartacus would be offering tiers to play older games, old school fans were pretty jubilant. However, it nearly came at a massive cost to the same fans.
For you see, Sony were also going to abolish all the old classics from its stores. All the PSone and PS2 titles readily available now were going to be discontinued on the older consoles. That meant that if players had already bought them but not downloaded, fine, but otherwise they'd be lost.
Presumably this was to incentivise people to adopt newer consoles, but as one can imagine, did not go down well. The PS3, PSP and Vita still function well enough as a go-between for the classics, so to remove that entire catalogue would be a massive blow.
Sony recanted, fortunately, but not without adding a caveat: you can't just "buy" them anymore. Players will have to go through the wallet/credit system via console, rather than just outright purchasing a title.
Had the uproar not been loud enough, Sony would have deleted an entire era of seminal gaming, all to push a new subscription service.
1. PlayStation Classic
Again, not to repeat myself, but this does seem another example of "Sony see, Nintendo do" and try to emulate it. In its defense though, this could have been a good thing, considering the PSone's back catalogue.
So when it was announced that Final Fantasy VII, Resident Evil and Tekken 3 were on there on Sony's retro PS1 emulator, appetites were whet. But then... so were Rainbow Six and Kurushi, weirdly. Why not Gran Turismo, or at a push, Tomb Raider? Or even the vastly superior Resident Evil 2?
Throwing the controllers back to pre-analog sticks pads didn't help matters, as did the poor emulation across some of the titles. Whilst licensing plays a big part, there could have been a better selection of titles from the little grey box's lifetime.
It didn't shift well at its entry price point, nor did it after several cuts. What could have been a lovely little collectible, fuelled with nostalgia, was instead a commercial flop for Sony.
Which is a shame, because as this list has established, Sony has had many a good opportunity to not balls it up. And yet, they still did.