10 Convoluted Video Game Lores Even The Creators Don't Understand
Even Hideo Kojima's confused by Death Stranding.
When it's done right, lore can elevate a good video game to greatness and beyond, while building a franchise which enraptures fans for years if not decades and decades.
At its best, video game mythology can boast more depth than any movie franchise, TV series, or book series you stand it up against.
But the ultra-collaborative nature of games development, with hundreds of people working on a single title, also ensures that internal inconsistencies are extremely common.
With so many different departments working in tandem on an ever-shifting pipeline, issues are inevitable. And though the person at the top might have a holistic view of how the project should be, sometimes that's not as true as you might think.
These 10 hit video games are all intensely lore-rich and have endured with millions of players to that end, even if the creators, directors, and designers have all confessed, at one point or another, that they don't really know as much as they probably should.
If you've ever played a video game and felt it was too hyper-convoluted for its own good, drowning in its own cumbersome mass of storylines and characters, there's a solid chance those at the top actually feel the same way.
But once the ball gets rolling, it's practically impossible to stop, especially with an insatiable fanbase clinging to your every word...
10. Kingdom Hearts
The Kingdom Hearts franchise has a mythology so ridiculously dense that only the most hardcore fans can really make head or tail of it.
Most players simply tolerate the absurdly convoluted storytelling in order to savour the fun combat and entertaining characters, even if having a clear idea of the overarching narrative is a challenge many just can't be bothered with.
This fact isn't lost on series creator Tetsuya Nomura, though, who himself has become tied up in knots trying to keep track of all the character relationships and how the cumbersome thicket that is Kingdom Hearts' lore all slots together.
In an interview, Nomura said, "What is the most confusing is that, because there are so many characters in this storyline now, it’s hard to keep track of who actually met who already. I’m always like, 'Okay, so who knows who in this situation, and who’s meeting this person for the first time?' And that always gets really confusing."
He added, "When I was writing the scenarios [for Kingdom Hearts III], I started to be confused with it as well myself. It is kind of complicated in that sense."
Well, that's a relief...kinda?
9. Dark Souls
There is an entertaining ambiguity to the lore of the Dark Souls franchise, though anyone trying to make entirely coherent sense of it will surely get a bad migraine.
Players are typically tasked with piecing together the full context themselves through environmental exploration, and it's fair to say that the series is better loved for its precise, brutally challenging gameplay.
Series creator Hidetaka Miyazaki spoke about his developmental philosophies at an industry event earlier this year, where he confirmed that visuals and gameplay take a priority to him over story and dialogue, which are typically finalised far later in the process than is normal.
He added that, for him, the creation of the game world has a massive influence on the story, and so nailing down concrete plot elements before the world is built makes no sense.
This explains the murky - and some might say incoherent - nature of Dark Souls' world, and hilariously, Miyazaki added that many of the developers working at FromSoftware don't understand the series' narrative much at all, due to his failure to adequately convey the plot to them during development.
8. Death Stranding
Death Stranding isn't merely one of the best games of 2019, it's also one of the weirdest.
Hideo Kojima's "AAA walking simulator" is like no other game released in this year or any other, and true to form for Kojima, its mythos is a bit of a headache to fully make sense of.
Though the basic, elemental aspects of Death Stranding are easy enough to understand, the game doesn't stray far from Kojima's penchant for word salad exposition, to the point where keeping track is so exhausting you just might give up trying.
In the months leading up to the game's release, though, Kojima cheekily confessed that he himself didn't have a firm bead on the intricacies of the world he created.
Kojima said in an interview, "Even now, I don’t understand the game…Its world view, gameplay, they are all new. My mission is to create a genre that does not currently exist, and which takes everyone by surprise. There is, naturally, a risk in that."
And there it is. If you believe Kojima to be an all-knowing super-genius whose stories make perfect sense in his own mind, clearly that isn't the case at all. And this isn't the only time we'll be seeing him on this list.
7. Half-Life
Though we're all excited about the recent announcement of the fantastic-looking VR title Half-Life: Alyx, don't expect the game to shed much additional light on the exact canonicity of the nebulous Half-Life universe.
Valve has always taken a suspiciously ambiguous approach to fleshing out the franchise's storyline, with series writer Marc Laidlaw infamously rubbishing the very concept of a concrete continuity.
When quizzed about what is and isn't canon in Half-Life lore, Laidlaw memorably retorted, "canon itself is non-canon," and that neither he nor Valve has any "official stance" on "issues of canonicity", or what is a tangible element of the Half-Life universe.
The series has made many retcons to its own internal mythology over the years, effectively confirming that Valve as a whole has little interest in maintaining a continuity, and clearly has no issues with contradicting itself if it suits the agenda of a new game.
Despite how insane this answer has driven fans for years, it's actually weirdly refreshing for a major developer to shun the concept of a stringent continuity altogether. If nothing else, it certainly allows more freedom for future Half-Life media - despite its rather ironic scarcity.
6. World Of Warcraft
Blizzard's legendary MMORPG World of Warcraft has been going strong for over 15 years now, and no game would stay alive (or popular) for that long without a rich, vibrant world for fans to immerse themselves in.
With seven expansion packs having been released to date - and an eighth on the way - World of Warcraft boasts a depth of lore to rival even the most detailed series of fantasy novels, and so it's little surprise that those in charge of maintaining it have tripped themselves up on occasion.
Though Blizzard actually employs lore specialists to keep World of Warcraft's mythology consistent, the sheer vastness of the lore, spread across the game's expansions and dozens of novels and comics to date, makes it inevitable that mistakes are going to be made.
This hilariously came to a head at BlizzCon 2010, when during a Q&A with the game's Creative Director Alex Afrasiabi and one of its writers, Chris Metzen, a fan exposed a contradiction in WoW lore.
The fan mentioned that the new book "The Shattering" stated that Falstad Wildhammer would join the Council of the Three Hammers, yet Falstad was missing from the Cataclysm beta.
In a moment that became an instant meme, Metzen asked, "Isn't Falstad dead?," before the fan reminded him that, in fact, Falstad was very much alive and kicking, to the amusement of the assembled crowd.
Blizzard eventually fixed the issue and even commemorated the fan's knowledge by making him an NPC, knowingly named Wildhammer Fact Checker.
But this speaks to a wider issue that it's virtually impossible to keep track of everything in an ongoing game of this nature, even with Blizzard employing full-time lore keepers.
The game's current director, Ion Hazzikostas, stated in a recent interview that while working on the Cataclysm expansion, they were planning to have a red dragon, Krasus, show up. However, they had to scrap these plans when they realised that Krasus had died in a previous WoW book. Oops.
5. Halo
Halo is one of the most imaginative and beloved AAA video game franchises of all time, even if it's fair to say that the release of Halo 5: Guardians left many fans bitterly disappointed.
With more than 50 novels and comics printed to accentuate the Halo universe, it's little surprise that 343 Industries, who took over development on the franchise from Halo 4 onwards, lost sight of what fans were actually interested in.
Halo 5 attempted to deepen the Halo world by having players split their playtime between franchise icon Master Chief and new character Spartan Locke.
The consensus from fans and critics alike was that, in an attempt to expand the universe, 343 had only made it more muddled, while failing to understand just how much of the series' identity was embodied by Master Chief.
In a recent interview, franchise director Frank O'Connor admitted their mistakes. He said, "We took some digs for storytelling in Halo 5, but they were absolutely merited. We very much realized that people wanted Master Chief’s story of Halo 5...For some fans and certainly fans of Master Chief, it was a huge disappointment because they wanted more Chief."
He added, "People have become attached to him over the last fifteen years and they’ve started to sort of fill in the gaps that the character deliberately has for gameplay reasons with a genuine emotional attachment. We certainly underestimated that with Halo 5."
343 has since confirmed that the upcoming Halo Infinite will be a Master Chief-centric adventure, in the hope of avoiding the mixed reviews of Halo 5's campaign. Fingers are crossed.
4. Destiny
The original "vanilla" release of Bungie's Destiny was widely criticised for its baffling approach to lore, with most of the game's story not actually being available in the game itself but via the related Grimoire website.
Thankfully Bungie listened to the vocal criticism and ensured to ditch this approach for Destiny 2, while steadily building an intriguing core mythos which has kept the fanbase hooked ever since.
Bungie has an uncommonly intimate relationship with their fans, intently listening to criticism and fielding suggestions to the extent of actually holding meetings with hardcore fans to resolve issues related to the game's lore.
Last year, Destiny 2 director Christopher Barrett held a lore "summit" with a few fans, who were able to voice their concerns regarding various aspects of the lore which contradicted one another, typically discrepancies between the release of the first and second Destiny.
This is ultimately a textbook example of a game's lore being so absurdly detailed - and, yes, convoluted - that only someone following it as a passionate hobby could possibly have the obsessive attention-to-detail necessary to find all the inconsistencies.
The fact that there are obvious tonal and thematic disconnects between the two games speaks volumes about the difficulties of keeping "live service" games consistent.
3. Detroit: Become Human
Developer Quantic Dream has cornered the market on big-budget AAA "interactive dramas," at the behest of company founder David Cage, who has also served as writer-director on every single game the studio has ever produced.
During the press tour for his most recent game, the gorgeous Detroit: Become Human, the controversial Cage came under scrutiny for glaringly inconsistent interviews he gave while talking about the game's themes.
At E3 2017, Cage made bizarrely contradictory statements within mere days of one another.
In an interview with The Verge, he implied that the game's story of an android rebellion was really an allegory for real life events, stating, "People will see [Detroit] as, 'Oh this is about androids and the revolution,' and honestly I don't think this is the story I wrote. I think it's really a game about us. Humans. It's about what it means to be human. It's about identity. It's about civil rights."
Yet when speaking with Kotaku the same week, Cage seemingly changed tack, declaring, "The story I'm telling is really about androids...They're discovering emotions and wanting to be free. If people want to see parallels with this or that, that's fine with me. But my story's about androids who want to be free."
It's quite telling, then, that the game's messy story was its most criticised element, and no matter what Cage actually intended to say - or not to say - he did it in a rather confused way.
Given that Cage's games have a tendency to boast compelling ideas but flop on the follow-through, this is pretty much on-brand for the auteur.
2. Metal Gear Solid
Before there was Death Stranding, of course there was Metal Gear Solid, and since Hideo Kojima's stealth-action franchise became a AAA mainstay some 20 years ago, its storylines have become increasingly ridiculous and, let's be honest, coke-huffingly insane.
But that has in many ways been Metal Gear Solid's charm, to combine state-of-the-art visuals and gameplay with an overwrought, knowingly daft narrative to rival the most overbearing anime.
And the icing on on the cake? Just as with Death Stranding, Kojima wilfully admits that it doesn't really make a lick of sense.
Shortly after the release of Metal Gear Solid 4, he said, "I personally get confused too about the whole timeline and saga of Metal Gear Solid...This is especially tricky when you create the future first and then go back in time to create something new. There are a lot of small aspects where sometimes it doesn't match completely."
It's a fitting comment given that Metal Gear Solid V's flagrant retconning saw the series at its most impossibly convoluted yet. And yet Kojima, the absolute maniac, clearly loves torturing his fanbase so.
1. Assassin's Creed
And finally, we have Assassin's Creed, a series which launched under the guise that it was an historical stealth-action game, only for the 2007 original to reveal a shocking and unexpected sci-fi twist.
The series' exploration of "genetic memory" has allowed it to visit disparate time periods all while maintaining a central narrative throughline, even if doing so also presented a considerable continuity challenge to franchise co-creator Patrice Désilets.
Désilets, who served as director on the first and second games, also consulted on the next mainline game Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood, though departed Ubisoft before the game was shipped.
As the major creative force behind the franchise, he took all of his ideas with him, and the consensus among fans is that the main series took a major nosedive after the completion of the Ezio trilogy (comprising ACII, Brotherhood, and Revelations).
As it turns out, Désilets had mapped out a wider roadmap for the series' present-day Abstergo storyline, and without him, Ubisoft had little concrete idea of how to follow it up.
Voice actor Nolan North confirmed that the original plan was for series protagonist Desmond Miles (voiced by North) to learn from all the historic assassins and then use those skills to take the fight to Abstergo in the present.
That obviously didn't end up happening, and with Désilets' departure, the role of Desmond was quickly de-emphasised as a revolving door of new creative leads were brought in to offer their own decidedly worse spin on the series.
Without a clear "Godfather" to create a single unified vision across the games, Assassin's Creed had lost its "special sauce," and despite the acclaim the more recent games have received, many core fans remain disappointed at the original storyline being discarded so aggressively.
That's not to forget the sloppy treatment of various key lore concepts, namely "those who came before" - aka the Isu, who were responsible for creating the human race. The result for those still sticking with the series, narratively speaking, is a tangled, undisciplined mess.