Veteran screenwriting guru Robert McKee has a lot of opinions about what makes a good story, but perhaps the most important is making sure you've got a strong third act. In his non-fiction tome Story: Substance, Structure, Style and the Principles of Screenwriting, essential text for all aspiring screenwriters and adapted from McKee's own lecture series, he makes the point that you can have a film that's strong all the way through, but if the ending sucks? That's going to be people's lasting impression of the film. The last part was crummy, so their most recent feelings towards the film are negative. Video games and films have a lot in common, and increasingly the big budget storylines are pretty much identical between AAA titles and blockbuster movies. Sure you get to control the protagonist from time to time, but the actual structure of the plot is entirely guided by scripted cut scenes that are pretty much identical from your average box office botherer. With lower-res actors. Which means that, increasingly, our lasting impressions of video games are coloured by how they end. It's not like gamers really need much to kick off about - remember when people were calling for the head of the reviewer who dared give Grand Theft Auto V a 9.5 rather than a perfect 10? - but this new era of weighted expectation on video game climaxes is giving us plenty more to get upset about. There are endings that don't feel earned, endings that take characters to places we didn't want, endings that weren't endings - these are the ten most disappointing in video game history.
10. Rage
You don't hear a whole lot about iD Software's other games, do you? The Doom games is the well from which pretty much the whole first person shooter genre sprang from, and the long-gestating third in the series ended up being almost as big a hit as the original, bringing the space horror into the third dimension and scaring the pants off of everyone in the process. Their follow up was a new property called Rage, which took the same engine and put it onto a post-apocalyptic Earth where you could switch from shooting to driving as quickly as...well, as a Borderlands game, against which Rage was unfavourably compared. Despite that, the game was generally well received...until it got to the ending.The open world was well rendered, the controls were pretty solid, the driving mechanics actually weren't awful, surprising everyone. The story was pretty basic, but there was something reassuring about that. You were pretty sure where it was going, which made it all the more disappointing when it failed at that one job. You're going to save the world from bad dudes! At the end it turns out you've awakened a whole army to fight back against the repressive military government that control the world, and just as you're gearing up to finally take the bad guys down...it ends. Roll credits. It's like they cut the story off before the third act could even happen. Major gaming blue balls.
9. Batman: Arkham Asylum
Rocksteady's Arkham Asylum was definitely the Batman game we deserved, and the one we needed right now, after decades of uniformly terrible video game adaptations for the Dark Knight had us doubting it was even possible. The Arkham series are the first titles that actually made us feel like the comic book hero, letting us glide about the place on his cloak, firing off the wonderful toys, chucking Batarangs at people, all that fun stuff. Plus the mechanics did a great job of mimicking how we imagine being Batman is, with the fighting system and the detective mode covering the rest of the bases. The story was pretty good and all, penned by comic book and cartoon veteran Paul Dini and taking in all the major members of the Caped Crusader's rogues gallery.Plus the voice acting was top notch, with the classic Animated Series' stars Kevin Conroy and Luke Skywalker himself Mark Hamill as Batman and The Joker, respectively. Which made it all the more disappointing when a game full of clever puzzles, smooth fighting and some genuinely unique aspects - especially those nightmarish Scarecrow sections - along with the decent plotting all chucked out the window by a crappy final boss. The Joker isn't supposed to be a physical threat to Batman - it's all about the traps he puts other people in, the psychological stuff. Which doesn't work in a game, so they dosed the Clown Prince Of Crime up with steroids and had you fight him. It was terrible. And that was how it ended. Snore.
8. Alan Wake
After they relinquished control of the Max Payne series to Rockstar the Finnish games studio Remedy Entertainment proved they were anything but one-trick ponies by coming up with new franchise Alan Wake, a survival horror third person puzzler type thing where you play as Stephen King. Except he's younger and fitter and called Alan Wake and never gets hit by a van. You play as the bestselling novelist Wake who's searching for his missing wife, and whose books seems to becoming true. Pretty spooky! There's some goofy gameplay elements, like using your torch as a weapon against villainous bits of paper, but overall its an effective little chiller.At least it is until you get to the end. Capping off a horror story is especially difficult, as the multiple endings that come with each new Silent Hill game will attest to. People have compared the finale of Alan Wake to that of Donnie Darko or 2001: A Space Odyssey, suggesting its open to interpretation. Which is all well and good for those films, but is a lot less satisfying when you've been controlling the main character for forty odd hours and then it turns out that there isn't actually a proper ending. Seriously. When you type "alan wake ending" into Google and it completes it with "explained" and everybody has a different idea of what jumping into a lake, finding a cabin with a typewriter and then saying "It's not a lakeit's an ocean" means. It means nothing.
7. The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening
Man, those Legend Of Zelda games are awesome, right? The story may be a pretty standard fantasy bildungsroman narratives about a young dude with pointy ears called Link realising he's actually all that, donning a green cap and getting sent off into the world to either retrieve the Triforce or Princess Zelda or both. Along the way he slowly upgrades his arsenal of weapons, skill set, and possibly even his height and age if you plump for the Ocarina Of Time version. That means, for the most part, the endings of the Zelda games are Link saving the world, vanquishing the ultimate evil, getting the girl, yadda yadda yadda. All is as it should be. You get that feeling of accomplishment you were expecting. Yeah, you didn't get that with the Game Boy edition in the series. The Legend Of Zelda: Link's Awakening is the fourth installment in the saga, and the first handheld game to boot. It's also one of the few to break away from the traditional narrative and see Link not in his usual Hyrule setting with Zelda and the Triforce and all, instead seeing our hero stranded on Koholint Island, a place guarded by a creature called the Wind Fish. You go through all the usual Zelda rigamarole of solving puzzles and avoiding chickens and at the end, once you've conquered these various challenges, you wake up after the Wind Fish reveals it was all a dream. Which is the sort of ending we were warned off writing, oh yeah, in primary school. Because it is the worst and basically renders everything that happened totally null and void.
6. Zone Of The Enders
Hideo Kojima has a bit of an iffy history when it comes to story in video games. A frequent criticism aimed at the creator of Metal Gear Solid is that he should be making games instead of films, since the majority of Solid Snake's story has been told through cut scenes and long treatises on the nature of war rather than actually letting players affect or play through the narratives at all. Possibly because the serious points might be undermined a little by a gruff dude running around in a cardboard box and humping sexy posters on locker doors. He saved his worst, however, for Zone Of The Enders, a fairly average giant robot title on the Playstation 2 that tends to be forgotten amongst the whole Metal Gear saga.ZOE is another of those games that has a fairly rote plot that anybody who's watched a mecha anime will recognise: reluctant hero is forced into piloting a big robot (as if you'd need to be convinced, that would be amazing) in order to fight some bad guys and there's explosions in space and love triangles and stuff. Again, though, they turned things on their head when it got to the climax, and not in a good way. Facing the full military force of the villainous BAHRAM our hero Leo - piloting robot Jehuty - the player has to, erm, run away. And then your robot self-destructs and kills loads of people. So everything you've been fighting for was completely in vain and you can't do a thing to change it. Yay!
5. Shenmue 2
If you're a gamer of a certain age, you're probably already sick to the back teeth of hearing people bang on about Shenmue. The epic series that began on the Dreamcast and...well, died with the Dreamcast, visionary writer/director Yu Suzuki coined the phrase "nonlinear gameplay" to describe the games. Which was just a fancy way of saying they went nowhere fast, as they were supposed to chronicle the grand revenge story of Ryo Hazuki, who is tracking down the man who murdered his father, but mainly saw you working as a fork lift truck operator so that you can afford your bedsit flat. With occasional fights.The Guinness Book of World Records listed the first Shenmue as the most expensive video game produced for its time, with a production budget of US$70 million, and the sequel followed suit. Despite all those excess dollars flying around they didn't manage to give the second game a decent denouement, however, as it ends on a cliffhanger about dragons and mirrors or something. You definitely don't get any closer to finding out who your dad's killer was, and so the whole thing feels like you've been treading water for hours and hours. Plus it's a decade later and there's been no third game, so that's technically the actual ending to Shenmue. So, so disappointing.
4. Batman: Dark Tomorrow
Remember how we said that basically all of the Batman games before Arkham Asylum were a big pile of butts? Well, Dark Tomorrow was at the top of said pile. It was the buttest of the butt. Supposedly adapted directly from the comic books - nearly every other Batman game was based on one of the films or TV shows - the Xbox and GameCube title was developed by the London-based HotGen, who have since made basically nothing. It certainly had potential, bringing in classic villains like the Joker, Mr. Freeze, Poison Ivy, Killer Croc, Scarface and Scarface. Plus hope springs eternal with Batman games, y'know? He's the best superhero. We really, really wanted to be him. That's why we kept foolishly buying his games, even though they were butts. The story was ripped straight from the comics, too, with a gang war breaking out between Scarface and Black Mask whilst Commissioner Gordon is kidnapped by the inmates of Arkham Asylum. It's up to he player, in the guise of the Caped Crusader, to fight his way through this mess and, ultimately, put a stop to The Joker, who is behind the whole thing. Except it totally isn't The Joker who's in charge but Ra's al Ghul, the immortal Batman villain who's a perpetual thorn in the Dark Knight's side. And he's going to destroy the world! DUN DUN DUN.Dark Tomorrow offers three alternate endings, and it's unlikely you'll get the good one. Because you get no indication as to how you get the good ending without looking at a walkthrough beforehand, which means that after hours of gameplay you're either going to get stabbed through the heart during the climactic sword fight with Ra's, or the world will end. Seriously. If you avoid the stabbing you nonetheless have to watch the bad guy set off a doomsday device, which you could've disarmed, if the game had told you that was a possibility. Disappointing, and more than a little frustrating.
3. Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge
This one's going to take a little more explaining. The LucasArts Monkey Island series is the crown jewel in the studio's point-and-click adventures, finessing the offbeat humour and ingenious puzzles that they had become known for through the likes of Day Of The Tentacle and the Indiana Jones games. For many the second in the franchise, LeChuck's Revenge, served as a high water mark of the six games, and it's being discovered by a whole new generation thanks to a HD remake from a few years ago. Set in the fictional Tri-Island Area of the Caribbean, several months after The Secret of Monkey Island, the story picks up with our roguish pirate hero Guybrush Threepwood captured by the eponymous villain, recounting the series of unfortunate events that lead to him being suspended upside down above a bottomless pit. It all starts off being the usual Monkey Island brand of weird, and then it gets to the ending and turns out to be a whole other kind of strange. One we're less a fan of.The big twist comes after your final confrontation with LeChuck, who reveals that he is actually you long lost brother, in dialogue which is line-for-line identical to the big Darth Vader reveal from Empire Strikes Back. So far, so typically wacky. Then the zombie pirate bad guy reveals he has a voodoo doll of you and you eventually put together your own doll of him, looking forward to sending each other to a dimension of "Infinite Pain". You tear the leg off your doll and crippled LeChuck, who then begs you to take off your "mask". The big reveal is that the whole game was actually being played by a couple of kids in a pirate-themed amusement park. With Threepwood and LeChuck masks on. So...does that mean both games were all imaginary? Because that might actually be worse than the "it was all a dream" reveal. Bad form, Tim Schaefer. Major disappointment.
2. Ghostbusters
The NES game tie-in for Ghostbusters is infamously hard. How hard? Hard as balls. The way that old timey video games were, when they didn't need to worry about bad online reviews or people sending their games back or whatever. Back in the day if you couldn't complete a game, you just didn't complete it. There were no walkthroughs, no cheat codes, no downloadable save states to let you skip difficult levels. In most cases, though, actually muddling through these impossible missions will eventually reward you with a cool ending, like Metroid's Samus reveal or the meme-tastic Professional Wrestling's "A WINNER IS YOU!" Ghostbusters was a special kind of Old Video Game Difficult. It was a lot worse. Ported by Japanese developer Micronics from the original Commodore 64 title, the NES Ghostbusters was riddled with bugs, translation mistakes and dodgy controls that made the game even more impenetrable than it already was. Once you got past the most challenging boss battle ever - the mighty ZUUL, minus workable controls - you would hope you get a pretty good ending, right? Maybe the fun "I love this town!" musical montage over credits like the film, rendered in 8-bit form?Nope, that's it. A "conglaturation" followed by the rather arrogant (and totally incorrect) assertion that you've just completed a "great game" and that you have now earned yourself a rest, great hero. That's literally it. Then you get kicked back to the main menu. Even the usual feeling of accomplishment from beating a particularly tricky title is robbed by this totally awful disappointment of an ending. The only thing worse would be if all life as you know it stopped instantaneously and every molecule in your body exploded at the speed of light. But only marginally.
1. Mass Effect 3
You can't really talk about video game endings without mentioning Mass Effect 3. We're not sure if it was necessarily the worst finale to a video game we've ever seen - like, it was technically done well and all - but boy howdy, was it disappointing for the end to a series and a story that players had invested more of themselves in than, like, one of those weird Sims families where they recreate themselves, their crush, and play out their weird marriage fantasies. Shut up, we've never done that. Anyway, you know that the Mass Effect 3 ending was disappointing when so many fans got ticked off by it, they hassled developers Bioware to the point that they made an entirely new ending to placate them. It's a bit of a fallacy when games suggest that you can actually have an affect on the its story - like, Grand Theft Auto is an "open world" title in environment only - but Bioware actually managed to deliver on that promise to a degree. Not only did the way you created your character have an effect on how other NPCs interacted with you, but the choices you made through the series did make a genuine change to the plot. People died, planets ended, and those things got carried over with each title, so long as you kept your save files.Therefore it wasn't totally beyond the pale for players to expect those decisions to be carried through to the ending of Commander Shepard's epic space-faring adventure. Or you wouldn't have thought so, but apparently Bioware did, and thus served up a totally unrewarding and disappointing ending possible. The same thing happened a few years earlier with Bethesda's Fallout 3, which also got fixed with downloadable content, but with Mass Effect - where people had been building towards the ending over three games - it was all the more egregious. Not only did Mass Effect 3's ending ignore your choices on a personal level, but also on a cosmic scale. You even make a choice immediately prior to the ending, with each of them seemingly hinting at radically different scenarios - except they're all pretty much the same, and so no matter what you did across all the games, you got the same ending. Biggest. Disappointment. Ever.