There's something spectacular about watching a highly anticipated and heavily hyped game flop. That may sound like a terrible thing to say, but if you were to be near the Titanic when it hit that iceberg (let's just say you were fishing in the north Atlantic or something), then you wouldn't be able to resist gawping at the unfolding catastrophe in horrified fascination, would you? Admit it! It's on a similar basis that commercially catastrophic video games are so fascinating, except you've got no reason to feel guilty about it, because in so many (though not all) cases, the publishers or developers brought about their own demise. You can't feel too much sympathy for a publisher that rented a $1 million a month luxury office space, only to end up creating one of the most underwhelming games of all time, or for another to spend many millions on a game with only a three-hour campaign. On the other hand, we should spare a thought for the developers who were at the mercy of crazy publishing deadlines to deliver huge titles, and emit a cry of rage over how the disastrous impact of a couple of games managed to send the entire industry into a dark age. Here are ten catastrophic games that lost money, ruined lives, and should probably never have been released.
10. Too Human
Anyone remember Too Human? That's ok, because the game pretty much came and went with the transience of a fart in a tornado. Before its release in 2008 however, Too Human had been in development since 1999, initially having been planned for the PSX then GameCube, before finally being spewed out on the Xbox 360. Too Human cost up to $100 million, ranking it in the top ten most expensive games ever made. In fairness, it vaguely looked the part for a AAA game, but was ultimately a generic futuristic hack n' slasher (save for an 'innovative' right analogue stick control scheme), its Norse mythology crowbarred in with the subtlety of a Viking pillaging party. The game didn't come close to recouping its costs, and didn't go on to become the blockbuster trilogy it was initially planned to be either. Its developer Silicon Knights never recovered from the failure and declared bankruptcy in 2014.
9. Sonic Boom
Sonic seems to be the franchise that just won't die. Or maybe it's more fitting to say that both it and he died long ago, but continues to be paraded around by Sega, who are hoping that no one notices the cute blue hedgehog is actually a dried-up corpse. Sonic Boom was made on a $20 million budget last year, making it the most expensive Sonic game ever. It was also the worst-rated and most commercially unsuccessful Sonic too, not helped by being a Wii U exclusive and being particularly awful when it came to attempting some semblance of speed. Taking away the pace and dynamism that made the series popular, only to replace it with tedious puzzle-solving and awful level design - maybe this game will finally make Sega realise that Sonic is in urgent need of retirement. Honestly, who would want to play as that soulless crew pictured above?
8. Uru: Ages Beyond Myst
Myst and its sequel Riven were a couple of the most loved puzzle games of all time. But after the turn of the millennium, it was clear that pre-rendered graphics just wouldn't cut it any more, so Ubisoft decided to overhaul the series and bring it into the third-person, real-time style that was all the rage in 2003. Sadly, the game's $12 million budget was never to be recouped. Despite being well received, Uru sold poorly, perhaps due to the boom of violent, action-oriented video games at the time. The highly anticipated multiplayer component was also dropped, leaving many people feeling that Uru wasn't the full product that was initially promised. Uru's development cost more than its three predecessors combined, but it failed to sell as well as any of them, leaving developer Cyan Worlds to nearly go bankrupt as a result.
7. E.T. The Extra-Terrestrial
Now this one is super-special, and in all probability needs no introduction. E.T. was released for the Atari in 1982, and its development was hurried through in five and a half weeks so it made it out in time for Christmas (at the same time as the movie). Even back in those days, that was an incredibly short turnaround time. The result was one of the worst and commercially disastrous games of all time. Atari ordered five million cartridges, but only 1.5 million copies were sold. That may not sound bad, but it was still such an extreme overproduction that Atari ended up burying hundreds of thousands of copies in the desert because no one wanted to buy them. The collapse of the video game industry in 1983 was attributed to the game's failure. In reality, there were many other factors that played a part in the games console crash; among these were the rise of PC gaming, and another, slightly less infamous game that ruined peoples' faith in the Atari...
6. Pac-Man
'How dare you speak ill of Pac-Man, after all he's done for the gaming industry?' I love Pac-Man as much as the next gamer - and have a tattoo on my foot to prove it - but the downgraded Atari 2600 version of Pac-Man was barely worthy of the illustrious name. Even the poorly rendered Pac-Man in the picture looks a bit peeved to be involved. The Atari version of Pac-Man was completely, terribly redesigned from the more technically demanding arcade version. It sold seven million copies, making it the best-selling Atari game of all time, but that still left five million unsold, and the Atari 2600's reputation in tatters due to the poor quality of this supposedly flagship game. Pac-Man's awful quality exacerbated the industry's worsening reputation, ultimately speeding up its downfall in 1983 - when overproduced, low-quality games plummeted in value due to lack of demand. Pac-Man itself may have sold well, but its impact played a big part in simultaneously destroying the console it was released for.
5. Shenmue
This game really deserved better treatment. The Sega Dreamcast deserved better treatment. With that said, when your budget for a game hits the $70 million mark over a painful five-year production, you've got your work cut out in trying to make it break even. Shenmue was critically acclaimed and sold 1.2 million copies. It was as close to an open-world game as anything around at the time. Set in a small Japanese town, it followed a martial arts wizzkid called Ryo on a revenge quest, letting you can play tons of mini-games, enter buildings and interact with most characters, and hang around bars looking for fights. But Shenmue's admirable qualities and big sales were simply not enough, and Sega's aims of it being a console seller never came to fruition. With Shenmue's and the Dreamcast's fates so closely intertwined, both of the ultimately flopped, marking Sega's exit from the home console market. While Sega's initial plans to make Shenmue a trilogy never materialised, a second game was released to little fanfare. However, a recent Kickstarter campaign for the third and final Shenmue received $6 million, making it the highest-funded video game Kickstarter of all time. Shenmue III is currently in development for the PC and PS4.
4. Daikatana
I remember when I first heard about the mysterious Daikatana. The great John Romero (of Doom fame) was to be at the helm of this first person shooter, which took players on a time-travelling romp through ancient Greece, the Dark Ages, near-future San Francisco and distant-future Japan. It sounded incredible, promising to take the FPS genre to new technical and gameplay frontiers. Like every FPS fan at the time, however, I was to be disappointed, as the final product was a flop, and the most memorable thing about the game was its insane development story. Romero was treated like a king while the game was being made, working from a $1m a month office at the top of a Dallas skyscraper, living a lavish rockstar lifestyle, and even being allowed to bring his girlfriend, pro gamer Stevie Case, onto the development team. Everything about the making of the game went wrong, from the weird 'John Romero's About To Make You His Bitch' marketing campaign, to the engine change some way into development. Eventually, publisher Eidos lost patience with the developer, Ion Storm, and bought them out in 1999 to get more control over the project, after having already pumped $44 million into development. The end result was a mess, and the game sold a disappointing 200,000 copies. Daikatana made a huge loss and became known as one of the epic industry failures of all time.
3. Aliens: Colonial Marines
It was supposed to be the triumphant return of the Aliens franchise to video games, but it ended up being one of the big scandals and financial disasters of video game history. It's thought that around $60 million was spent on Colonial Marines, but even though it sold over a million copies worldwide, it was not nearly enough to make back its budget. Nor did it deserve to, because the final product was shambolic. The only thing it had in common with the legendary movies was the fact that xenomorphs were scampering around all over the place (despite the developers claiming it was faithful to the film canon). Infamously, the final game looked far inferior to the pre-release demos Gearbox had shown off at E3, leading plenty of the game's buyers feeling cheated. There were also controversies surrounding the development itself, with one Gearbox employee claiming that the developer was channelling Aliens' budget into the Borderlands series. In his defence, Gearbox CEO Randy Pitchford said that he'd invested $10 million of his own money into Aliens: Colonial Marines, and "lost it all". Ouch. Whatever the case, the game was an unmitigated disaster, though at least the beloved franchise didn't suffer too much and made a great comeback a few years later with the excellent Alien: Isolation.
2. Driv3r
The Driver series is a bit of an unsung hero of the video games scene. It in many way started the formula that GTA III came along and admittedly did much better, offering players an open world to drive around in, and vehicles to steal as they pleased. Driver 3 had the misfortune of being released soon after GTA III, which revolutionsed open-word gaming and completely redefined peoples' expectations of similar games. Suffice to say that Driver 3 just didn't match these lofty expectations. But beyond that, Driver 3 just wasn't very good, with a laughable three-hour story campaign, awkward controls, and shoddy shooting mechanics. In its defence, Driver 3 looked pretty damn good, but that's the least you'd expect for a game that cost $50 million to make. The game sold a not-bad two million worldwide, but the fact that Atari reported losses of $16.9 million in the six months after its release, puts into perspective just how badly it tanked.
1. APB: All Points Bulletin
Right up there between Red Dead Redemption and Max Payne 3, this online shooter sits not-so-pretty in ninth place as one of the most expensive games ever, made for a substantial $100 million. Why is it then that the majority of people won't eve have heard of APB? It was a great idea, touting itself as a kind of Grand Theft Auto-style MMO, pitting cops against robbers in a large, vibrant city, and was in development for around five years before it came out in 2010. You have to wonder what the hell that development budget was spent on when the game launched with just two action maps and a severe paucity of mission types. Its developer Realtime Worlds went broke a few months after the game was released, and the servers were shut down by the end of the year. Worse still, you were expected to pay a subscription fee for the privilege of shooting people online, which understandably no one really wanted to do. Online games publisher K2 Network eventually nabbed APB for £1.5 million, renaming it APB Reloaded and putting it up as a free-to-play game on Steam. A humiliating fate for a game that promised so much yet delivered pretty much nothing. Are there any we missed? Sign up to create an account if you're a fan of the section, and let us know in the comments!