Over the years gaming has let us wield a huge variety of dastardly weaponry and mystical powers, from chainsaw-mounted machine guns to fingertips that spew jets of flame, yet it's only been in the last decade that varying degrees of weight have been applied to our consequences. All of this in the name of maturing the medium to such a degree that it finally be taken as seriously as the other artistic heavyweights such as film, physical art, and the written word. It seems nothing will divide interpreters of a particular experience or sequence more than literally letting them effect the outcome of morally gray areas, for example the death of a character or the doling out of punishment among a group of wrongdoers where only one can take the fall. As Stan Lee struck a chord in realising that if he put Spider-Man right in the middle of a moral dilemma, for example juggling an impending citywide destruction at the hands of an evil villain against getting home in time to give Aunt May her life-saving medicine, so to have video games. With their unique player agency to a given game world, they allow for those sorts of passive decisions to not just be represented on the page, but for an active outcome to be on none other than your shoulders. Thus while a list comprising all the moral quandaries that exist within the pantheon of gaming is one for much more than just 10 entries, this is one that narrows the focus to those games that offered you no way out, should you wish to experience the majority of the story. These are the titles that handed the shotgun of repercussion over to you, and laid out the choices in front of your (hopefully) unwilling hands, Old Yeller-style. Spoilers will follow for each entry on the list.
10. The Original Endings - Mass Effect 3
Oh Mass Effect 3, will you ever be forgiven? No, no you will not. Even if you were one of the 'lucky' few to have all the bonus downloadable content installed on your system by the time you played through this instalment of the franchise, later revelations surrounding what appeared to be EA's grubby mitts tangling with the release schedule to withhold necessary narrative content from us gamers, makes the entire proposition inexcusable. Anyway, back to the choice, as although ME3 does have many throughout its runtime, to me the one that stuck out was (somewhat obviously) was the final one. Out of nowhere we were asked to either sacrifice ourselves to become something of a hivemind for the Reaper fleet (how exactly?), merge all living beings with synthetic lifeforms (again...what?) or again sacrifice ourselves, yet take down the Reapers alongside us. Do you remember what that feeling was like? I'm not talking about reflecting back on the other endings in a post-credits Youtube rage-haze, instead I mean that moment when the Starchild barely explains your options, before leaving you to pick one and live with it. Regardless of 'Extended Editions' of the ending, no amount of Jamaican-accented aliens could save those of us who would forever know that bottomless-pit feeling of just sitting there thinking, "Well I don't wanna make ANY of these choices". Not only because they didn't make a lick of sense, but also because we desperately wanted the prompt to appear that would allow us to kick Starchild into outer space . Harrowing in a completely different way to the rest of this list, Mass Effect 3 is still one of the most talked-about games of all time when it comes to horrible choices forced upon the player.
9. Having To Kill Your Partner - Splinter Cell: Conviction
This one might have slipped you by, had you only primarily played the Splinter Cell series for its single-player content. However in what was a genius, Streets of Rage-esque manoeuvre, after you and a friend/loved one/random-from-the-internet have spent many hours enjoying each others' company, boosting off each other to reach ledges and synching up headshots, in the final level you were suddenly required to take each other down. It's a great reversal of expectation, and forces you to somewhat take all the skills you had been using in tandem and pit them against each other. There could only be one winner, and although there was nowhere near as much narrative structure supporting this particular scene, that moment when the call comes in, and it's either follow your orders or put the controller down, was genius. After all, would you want to be the one to surrender first, or worse, go straight to killing your friend while they're still mulling it over?
Mass Effect 2 remains, for me at least, the Game of the Generation alongside Red Dead Redemption, for missions such as this. After spending (in my case) literal days around a whole cast of diverse and very much loveable characters, you finally embark on one last mission, pitting your entire crew against unsurmountable odds, all with the always-teetering knowledge in the back of your head that "they can't let everyone die...surely?!" Turns out they can, and they will. Bioware were absolutely ruthless portraying the final mission of ME2, and should your supplies not be in full order, or those Thanix Cannons not fitted, amongst a raft of other elements that drastically effect the outcome, literally everybody can pop their collective clogs. As well as the preparation being key, there are choices on-mission where you must choose who to pair up with and send down certain paths. Pre-scripted deaths await those who are not 'supposed' to go down these routes, yet obviously you are not fully aware of this first time through. In my personal experience, I lost the Salarian soprano himself Mordin Solus to a stray bullet, as he attempted to close a door behind us. I'm just getting over this now, as long as I don't talk about it too much....oh I'm away again. Move on, just move on.
6. Killing Playboy X Or Dwayne - Grand Theft Auto IV
I've read many people saying this was actually one of the easiest choices they ever made in the game, yet for me I'd grown pretty attached to both guys, so even though this decision was telegraphed a few missions prior, when it came time to act, I went back and forth. Playboy is the seemingly carefree young-blood who should you kill you're awarded his pool-table-equipped house, as he's gone to hit the great black ball in the sky. However should you opt instead for the "oh woe-is-me"-spouting Dwayne, your reward is just that of a cash sum. Although this cash-incentive to kill him somewhat mirrors Dwayne's character, in that he's an old gangster who's been through and seen too much - therefore waving cash at another problem will make it go away - he really warms to your character of Niko Bellic. Therefore should you decide to take him out, his realisation that the one person left in his life he thought he could trust is now trying to kill him, is pretty heartbreaking.
5. Saving Ashley Or Kaiden - Mass Effect
Okay hands up, who saved Kaiden? Me neither. The thing is, back when I first played Mass Effect, I (and clearly thousands of others looking at the many pieces that have been written about this scene) instantly gravitated to 'The Hot Chick', in a rather Leonard n' Penny kind of way. Thus when Kaiden was determined to stay with a bomb that was about to go off, and Ashley required help elsewhere, the decision should have been obvious. I must say though when this happened in the game, I did stop to wonder who's life I was condemning, and I also pondered whether or not Bioware would be bringing anybody back later in the game (this was in a pre-Mass Effect 3 Ending world of hopes and dreams, and it was a large-scale sci-fi fantasy). In the end though we all went with Ashley, only to get snubbed in Mass Effect 2 when we all failed to call her back whilst doing the whole Jesus Christ thing.
4. Choosing Your Own Method Of Limb-Loss - Heavy Rain
Before the narrative has you deciding whether or not you want to shoot an innocent father to appease the person who's holding your son captive, the initial real taste of "holy bad accents, this is some gritty stuff" comes with the 'first test': Choosing an implement with which to remove a section of your own finger. Although many, and I do stress MANY people, never fully got on board with Heavy Rain due to its laughably off-putting voice acting and the initial killing off of the Jason child character in a scenario that we're fairly sure a dying old man could survive, personally speaking I loved it all the way through. Of course you could make the case that you were 'free' in a way to just get up and walk out of the room, it's blatantly obvious you need to go through with the 'choose-your-own-torture' scene, picking from either a pair of scissors, a cleaver, a pair of pliers an more to do your dirty work in front of a camera that was linked directly to The Origami Killer. Disgustingly cringeworthy stuff, which I'm sure is the description many use for father Ethan's plaintive "JAY-SON" soundbite.
3. Weighing The Needs Of The Few - Papers Please
Don't let its vintage graphics fool you, Paper's Please will get inside your mind in the most relatable and affecting of ways, and stay there. Placing you in the shoes of a border-agent deciding who can come in to the 'glorious nation' of Arztotska, gameplay consists of (mostly) innocent people coming into your booth and presenting their case for asylum, only for your anonymous rubber stamp to determine their ultimate fate. The genius of the game comes in the constant balancing act of trying to appease your governmental oppressors by way of processing as many people as possible so that you get paid enough to afford medicine and food for your family, as well as keeping your personal morals in check. The morals in question are not put upon you by dialogue or narrative exposition, instead your character is essentially mute, responding in textual statements to those in front of you after you pick a response, therefore you find yourself answering to the citizens in real life. The real kicker is after a few in-game shifts start to actually get you used to how things work - as you may do should you be tasked with such a thing in real life - a middle-aged couple arrives whereby one has their papers in order, and the other does not. Do you take the financial hit, and potential third strike of the day just to let a wife pass through illegally with her begging husband, or do you separate them, 'safe' in the knowledge that you were just doing your job? Papers Please is one of the many landmark titles from last year that proves games can offer experiences available in no other medium.
2. Using The Napalm - Spec Ops: The Line
Another subtle progression the shooter genre made was through this relatively unknown title, rather than the overblown, "Hey mam, look at me kicking things!" attention-seeking of Call of Duty's No Russian level. Spec Ops told the gradual degradation of one Captain Walker as he is exposed to a war-torn Dubai-gone-mad under the regime of a former Lieutenant John Konrad. The Line walks a fine one, having on one side the always-present voice of contention, yelling that 'just another Gears-style shooter' is not in a suitable place to make enough waves. Yet on the other was the inspirational Apocalypse Now, the novel Heart of Darkness, and Paul Haggis' fantastic The Valley of Elah, all artistic works that explore the psychological effects of increased exposure to desensitisation and warfare on the human mind. Spec Ops succeeded immeasurably at making the player have medium-specific revelations, re-appropriating a scene inspired by Call of Duty's AC-130 gunship levels i.e. staring at a group of blips through a heat-vision scope, and pulling the trigger. The twist in this case though, was that after resorting to using napalm to vanquish a large number of soldiers up ahead by your own trigger-happy 'enjoyment' of those mechanics, you finished the sequence by targeting the largest group of icons all clustered together, and wiped them out. This was only to find out upon removal of the scope that it was a huddled-up group of hostages, one woman still clutching her child as she was immolated by your actions. It's incredibly heavy stuff, so much so that the creator of the game Walt Williams talked about how the alternative no gamers partook in, was to put the controller down and refuse to carry on playing. Which is such a powerful/potentially stupid thing for a creator to say, that you can draw your own conclusions.
1. Killing Your New Best Friend - The Walking Dead
Now it might be because I'm a huge animal lover, or it might be because no part of me whatsoever saw it coming, but the section in Walking Dead's season 2 episode 1 where your once-loyal canine friend suddenly goes feral and you're forced to stab it enough to stop it mauling poor Clem's arm off, is genuinely the most harrowing thing I've ever played in a game. Granted there's the scene with the child Duck in season 1 which had a certain finality and silence to it that was very affecting depending on how attached to his character you'd become (I hadn't much as it turned out, Clem was the one I was looking after the most). However now that she's out on her own and trying to find some companionship whilst dealing with Lee's death, the immediately visceral nature this encounter has, alongside the sudden tonal switch from sharing your food only for an encounter to come out of nowhere, really encapsulated the world of The Walking Dead perfectly. I'm sure I'll have missed some out, so please throw them down in the comments below, and let's all take a collective exhale that everything's alright...for now.