10 Hated Video Game Moments You're Totally Wrong About

These widely loathed video games scenes are actually wildly misunderstood.

By Jack Pooley /

No video game can be all perfect, but sometimes a single moment or scene in a game is so widely hated by so many that it takes on a life of its own, and in extreme cases even overshadows the achievements of the game otherwise.

Advertisement

Whether that's true or not here, these 10 games all have a single scene which fans are still eagerly hating on all these years, even decades later. 

However, there's an argument to be made that all that hateful energy is just being totally wasted.

While it'd be disingenuous to suggest that every single person dislikes these gaming moments for the wrong reasons, there are many who are choosing to approach them in an uncharitable way or simply buy into the meme of it all without knowing the full context.

Like what you like, for sure, but these scenes are all wildly overhated because, when you dig into what they're really about, they're more fun, interesting, and coherent than you might at first think.

And if you still hate these scenes after reading these explanations? Well, fair enough...

10. Mario & Princess Beach - Death Stranding

Death Stranding might well be Hideo Kojima's weirdest game to date, and he really tested the bounds of his fanbase's appetite for goofiness in the climax, when Sam meets up with his sister Amelie and sarcastically says, "So I'm Mario and you're Princess Peach?"

Advertisement

Amelie retorts by suggesting they run home together across the Beach "like Mario and Princess Beach," followed by an utterly ridiculous slow-motion sequence as the pair frolic along the shore.

Even for some who've stomached, even championed Kojima's silly eccentricity for decades, this was crossing the line - the combination of breaking the fourth wall and sheer corniness of the slow-mo run proved too much.

But most players have missed a crucial piece of context - the slow-motion run is actually a direct reference to The Bionic Woman, the 1970s TV show which starred Lindsay Wagner, the very actress who provides the likeness for Amelie in Death Stranding.

In the show, Wagner's protagonist Jaime Sommers would often be seen running in slow-mo to imply she's running at high speed, and this is very clearly a playful reference to that.

Sure it's still fundamentally absurd, but at least there's more thought and intent put into it than some might well think. Kojima isn't being random just for the sake of random.

9. Batman Mourns The Joker - Batman: Arkham City

Though Batman: Arkham City is one of the most beloved entries in Rocksteady's superhero franchise, many fans took umbrage with the ending, where Batman mourns The Joker's death, solemnly carrying his corpse and placing it on the hood of Commissioner Gordon's car.

Advertisement

Many criticised the scene for feeling out of character for Batman, that he appeared excessively depressed for witnessing the death of his most persistent arch-nemesis.

But there's so much more to it than that. Batman's quest to save even The Joker is about more than just one person - if he can save even his biggest enemy, then there's no reason he can't save anyone else.

With The Joker dead at the end, then, that's no longer true - it's a realisation of Bats failing to meet his own incredibly high standard for heroism, even if most fans are likely happy to let him off the hook.

And of course, it goes without saying that Batman and The Joker's relationship is just unhealthily co-dependent from top to bottom - with the Clown Prince of Crime dead, there's a void left behind.

Far from emotionally implausible as some might claim, it's really a perfect summation of how psychologically complex Batman is as a character.

8. "Not In A Million Years" - DmC: Devil May Cry

It's not wrong to say that fans had their pitchforks out for 2013's Devil May Cry reboot DmC long before it even released, largely due to the decision to give protagonist Dante an "emo edgelord" makeover.

Advertisement

And while the game itself was generally praised for its slick visuals and fluid combat, one scene during a boss battle was very pointedly intended to make light of the fandom's backlash to Dante 2.0.

At the carnival, Dante ends up with a silver wig momentarily hurled on top of his head, causing him to briefly resemble the O.G. Dante. 

As the moment sinks in, Emo Dante stares straight at the player and says, "Not in a million years," before tearing the wig off and cracking on.

Ever since the game's release, fans have complained about this scene, claiming that Capcom was taking the piss out of their own fans in "poor taste," but you know what's in poor taste? Sending a developer death threats because you didn't like a character redesign.

It was clearly just a light-hearted jab at the whole controversy rather than a mean-spirited flipping of the bird, and yet the overblown fan response is just further proof that gamers take games way more seriously than the people actually making them. 

DmC is a silly character action game about a dude fighting demons - it's not that big a deal.

7. Joel's Death - The Last of Us Part II

No single scene from recent gaming history has been as intensely and tiresomely litigated online as Joel's unexpected death just a few hours into The Last of Us Part II.

Advertisement

Many were left infuriated that Joel not only died, but died so early in the game, and furthermore was killed by a character largely unknown to the audience at that point in a decidedly un-heroic way.

More than five years after the game's release, many remain firmly embittered about it, to the extent that they believe this single creative decision ruined the entire game.

And while there are certainly more level-headed takes from folk who were disappointed with Joel's demise, his death was absolutely the right call for the narrative.

Much as fans have a certain connection to Joel, he's an undeniable anti-hero with a fair share of "red in his ledger," and so a violent death was far from a surprising outcome for him.

And so when we learn that Abby killed him because Joel killed her father at the end of the first game, it makes perfect sense - Joel's death serves as the lynchpin for the game's broader commentary on the futile cycles of violence generated by revenge.

To challenge players to think about who Joel is as a person, and then later encourage them to empathise with his killer by playing as her for many hours, is one of the boldest gambits ever pulled off in any AAA video game, even if it'll be whined about until the heat death of the universe.

6. Chris Punches A Boulder - Resident Evil 5

Resident Evil 5 is one of the more contested entries in the franchise, and by far its most polarising moment occurs at the very end of the game, when Chris Redfield straight-up punches a giant boulder repeatedly in order to move it out of his way.

Advertisement

To many, this was a step too far for the franchise, by taking one of its central characters and pretty much turning him into a damn superhero.

And while it's undeniably over-the-top and a wider sign of the series' shift towards more action-orientated gameplay, it's also important to step back and remember what Resident Evil is and always has been - pure, unabashed camp.

This is a series where we've fought giant sharks and fled massive, murderous robotic statues, not to mention that the boulder-punching escapade itself takes place in the middle of an active volcano.

Is having a thoroughly yoked Chris Redfield punch a boulder that big a deal? Isn't it just really funny and tonally of a-piece with Resident Evil's B-movie vibe from the get-go?

5. Venom Snake ISN'T Big Boss - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Hideo Kojima strikes again, this time with the jaw-dropping secret twist at the end of Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain, that Venom Snake actually isn't Big Boss at all.

Advertisement

Rather, he's the combat medic who was caught in the helicopter explosion in prologue Ground Zeroes, and through plastic surgery and hypnotherapy was transformed into a Big Boss decoy, all while the real Big Boss covertly continues his operations elsewhere.

Many fans were naturally angry that they'd spend dozens, even hundreds of hours playing not as Big Boss but somebody else, yet from a meta-narrative perspective, it's actually one of the smartest things Kojima has ever done.

Our own stunned amazement at this revelation puts us in a parallel position to Venom Snake as he learns this truth. 

It also ties quite perfectly into so many of Metal Gear Solid's overarching themes - identity, heroism, legacy, and player agency.

It was never a twist that was going to work for everyone, but far from a random shock value rug-pull, it was clearly cooked up by Kojima with some serious consideration.

4. The Kid Dies - Shadow of the Tomb Raider

Shadow of the Tomb Raider kicks off with Lara Croft grabbing the Dagger of Chak Chel and triggering an apocalyptic event called the Cleansing, causing a massive tsunami which floods the Mexican island of Cozumel.

Advertisement

This causes considerable death and damage, and in a massively controversial moment, even results in a young boy falling to his death right in front of the player's eyes. 

While many players reported reloading the game in an attempt to reach the boy faster and save him, there's actually no way to rescue him - you simply have to watch him die.

And it's ultimately a vital moment for the narrative, for Lara to see the un-fixable consequences of her tomb raiding actions. 

After all, this is the only game in the series that really reckons with the wider implications of Lara pilfering ancient artefacts and her general "white saviour" status, even if it ultimately lets her off the hook a little too easily at the end.

To see the real, ugly human cost of her adventuring feels necessary considering the series' history of being totally blinkered to it, even if it was always going to rub some players the wrong way.

3. Rubber Bullets - Yakuza 4

Yakuza 4 features the single most hated moment in the entire series, with its utterly barmy plot twist where it's revealed that the apparent massacre of the Ueno Seiwa clan by Taiga Saejima didn't go down how we thought.

Advertisement

Rather, Sejima unknowingly used weapons loaded with rubber bullets, meaning he didn't kill the 18 men but simply knock them out, after which Katsuragi entered the shop and legit killed them all.

Now, this twist is as close to objectively stupid as one can possibly get, and it also marked the point where many felt that Sega had quite literally lost the plot, that they genuinely thought players would take such silliness seriously.

Yet are we really about to pretend that a franchise with boss fights against construction equipment and characters with names like "Walking Erection" is really above... rubber bullets of all things?

Yes, it's contrived and absurd, but isn't that Yakuza/Like a Dragon in a nutshell? 

It's a big, daft, cheesy melodramatic soap opera crime thriller franchise, and if you approach the twist with that in mind, it doesn't feel excessively out of place at all.

2. Tidus' Laugh - Final Fantasy X

Pretty much any discussion about Final Fantasy X will only go so long before someone brings up the infamous laughing Tidus scene, which is regularly posted online out of context as an example of apparently poor video game voice acting.

Advertisement

Yet that's not true, like, at all.

Tidus' stiff, robotic laugh is precisely the point - he lets out a deliberately over-the-top, ridiculous laugh in an attempt to cheer up Yuna, resulting in her joining in with her own fake-laugh.

Most of the meme clips unsurprisingly cut off before the pair genuinely laugh together in decidedly less-robotic fashion. 

It was clearly intended to be nothing more than a goofy slice of comic relief as two downtrodden characters work through their feelings, but it's been rather uncharitably reinterpreted outside of its full context as merely bad acting.

That still doesn't mean the scene is going to work for everyone, and that's fine, but for the great many who dismiss it out of hand, they're often doing it for the wrong reason.

1. Trevor's Torture - Grand Theft Auto V

Beloved though Grand Theft Auto V is, there's one story mission which caused considerable ire among the fanbase and critics alike.

Advertisement

In the mission "By the Book," Trevor is instructed to torture a man in order to ascertain the whereabouts of another man the FBI claims has links to terrorism.

You're given no option but to partake in brutalising the man via a multitude of gnarly methods - including waterboarding, electrocution, and removing his teeth with pliers - and after finally getting the required info, you switch to Michael and shoot the alleged terrorist dead.

By the Book remains one of the most-loathed missions in the entire franchise, many finding enormous discomfort in having to torture someone - a not unreasonable feeling, in honesty - while others felt that the mission was effectively endorsing "enhanced interrogation" in the real world.

But of course, it's important to remember that Trevor straight-up talks about the ineffectiveness of torture in the lead-up to the mission, and a Weazel News broadcast later reveals that the assassinated man was a totally innocent philanthropist.

Evidently Rockstar wanted to satirise the very American notion of using torture to gather intel, and did so in an incredibly edgy way where the player was offered no option not to participate.

Hating the mission for its discomfort is fair enough - though that's very much the point - but hating it for misreading its politics? Not so much.

Advertisement