10 Incredibly Dumb Things Video Game Heroes Need To STOP DOING
Relentlessly pursuing revenge no matter the personal cost? Seems legit.
Video games can give players an experience that they simply can't get anywhere else, but it's also fair to say that where writing and characterisation are concerned, games generally still trail other forms of entertainment media by quite a distance.
This is due to one simple fact: games are designed around gameplay more than anything, because of course they are.
The problem is that this often means the story, molded around the existing gameplay systems, might see the hero doing something that seemingly defies logic.
And though video games are more diverse and creative now than they've ever been, and not every game forces players to become an all-out murder machine, the vast majority of games - especially those in the AAA sphere - routinely force their protagonist down the stupid path for the gamer's benefit.
As fun as the gameplay might be, you may find yourself practically screaming at the TV that your beloved hero is falling for the most obvious trick in the book, or doing the very thing you yourself never would in real life...
10. Failing To Question ANYTHING
Perhaps the most basic, all-encompassing element of video games is that they set players a series of tasks which they must duly complete in order to reach the end.
And while for the most part that's the only way to finish a game, it sure would be nice to see protagonists employing a little more critical thought considering some of the more eyebrow-raising instructions they tend to be given.
Take Shadow of the Colossus, whose protagonist Wander agrees to slaughter sixteen innocent Colossi without much discussion at all, all for the sake of reviving his love Mono. Shockingly enough, it turns out that he also awakened an ancient evil force in the process.
Doing what the game tells you is such an endemic part of game design, but a few titles have managed to play with this expectation in clever ways.
Spec-Ops: The Line paralleled video game objectives with "just following orders" in the Army to stirring effect, while BioShock similarly mocked players' tendency to comply blindly with anything an A.I. companion asked of them.
Games generally aren't nuanced enough for players to nope out of a questionable scenario while still reaching the end of the experience, but from a pure storytelling perspective, our protagonists really should think a little harder before just doing what they're told.
9. Needlessly Killing HUNDREDS Of People
The overwhelming majority of video games see the player killing their fair share of enemies, and while that's generally accepted as a given, it can sometimes be jarring, even draining, if that blood-thirstiness doesn't align with how the story or characters are presented.
This is where we come to the divisive issue of "ludonarrative dissonance," which was coined while discussing the Uncharted franchise.
In the series, the charming, Indiana Jones-esque adventurer Nathan Drake slaughters hundreds if not thousands of anonymous mooks without a care in the world.
Maybe, just maybe, if your pursuit of riches means you need to rack up a genocidal body count, it might be worth reconsidering your station in life?
As much as some players defend the chasm between story and gameplay in games such as Uncharted, there's no way Nathan Drake doesn't come out of the series looking like a total psychopath.
This is similarly true of Tomb Raider's Lara Croft, for though she is presented as more vulnerable and defensive in 2013's reboot, in the subsequent sequels she's basically a relentless killing machine not unlike Drake.
There's defending yourself, and then there's intentionally hurling yourself into scenarios that "force" you to kill entire armies of human beings, all so you can acquire a couple of shiny artefacts? Hmmm.
If you ever get to a place in life where you're comfortable killing hundreds of people for the sake of "adventure," you're probably beyond professional help.
8. Trusting That Totally Shady Suspicious Dude
There are few video game tropes more irritating than that character who makes only the most minimal effort to disguise their villainy - a fact the protagonist themselves seems completely oblivious to.
"It was me all along!" is one of the moldiest and most played-out twists in all of fiction, and given how few games are written or acted with the finesse of a great movie, TV show, or book, it's fair to say that our heroes often end up looking incredibly silly for not noticing the obvious.
Even in the first Resident Evil, did Albert Wesker - the guy who randomly wanders off and always wears sunglasses, even inside? - not seem completely and utterly suspicious?
What about Kevin Spacey's totally-not-sinister CEO Jonathan Irons in Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare, or Dr. Otto Octavius in Insomniac's Spider-Man? These characters threw up so many red flags, and yet the hero ends up being the last one to get the memo.
Again, this is more of a writing issue than anything, but it nevertheless makes our heroes look like damn fools.
7. Recklessly Disrupting Other Civilisations
Adventure games regularly send players to far-flung areas of the world to explore, climb platforms, fights monsters, and occasionally destroy the local environment.
Western video games have been curiously un-critical of this practise for the most part, paying little attention to the fact that folks like Lara Croft and Nathan Drake are pilfering from ancient civilisations who, more often than not, just want to be left alone.
Shadow of the Tomb Raider made something of an effort to engage with this, depicting Lara as responsible for kickstarting a calamity which caused considerable death, though ultimately let her off the hook by game's end.
Much like the indiscriminate murder of random mooks, if your life's work consists of screwing up the entire way of life of another group of people, stealing their prized artefacts and shooting up the scenery, then maybe it's time for a rethink.
As incredibly fun as these games tend to be, after a point you have to stop and consider the wider implications of their totally-not-harmless swashbuckling behaviour.
6. "Non-Lethal" Takedowns That Totally Cripple People
As violent as so many video games are, developers often introduce a non-lethal path for players who would prefer to put most enemies to sleep, either by knocking them unconscious or perhaps tranquilising them with a dart.
It's common in superhero games like Batman: Arkham and newer Spider-Man titles for the games to heavily imply that you're not killing these people you're braining in the face with a gauntlet or swinging around at lightning speed - you're just horribly maiming them.
As much as you can't expect superheroes in particular to just stand there and take a barrage of bullets or always be stealthy, they're also held to a higher standard due to their abilities - they're generally a lot more capable than some scrappy survival horror protagonist desperately trying to survive.
There's little denying that many of the "incapacitated" random goons in the aforementioned games would likely suffer serious, life-changing injuries, such as permanent loss of limb function, brain damage, and possibly persistent headaches requiring the use of medication.
The point is that if these games want to boast the moral superiority of their characters, having them cripple people and otherwise ruin their lives isn't that much better.
But then, we wouldn't have much of a game otherwise, would we?
5. Coming Back For "One Last Job"
Another hero cliche that's widespread throughout movies and video games in particular - the veteran gunslinger who gets lured out of retirement or inactivity for one last job.
It's a tale as old as time, and an entertaining one admittedly, albeit one that so often makes the heroes look like naive idiots.
The ultimate culprit is probably Grand Theft Auto V's Michael, who despite living a cushy life in witness protection just can't resist being lured back into The Life to pay off a debt.
Our old friend Nathan Drake is another fine example, risking life and limb in Uncharted 4 despite being comfortably retired, to save his doofus, believed-dead brother Sam from the chopping block. You know what's worse than one dead brother? Two.
Both John Marston and Arthur Morgan in the Red Dead Redemption games are on the fringes of the outlaw life when they're dragged back in, and the results are ultimately disastrous.
Knowing when to quit and really meaning it is an undervalued virtue in society, as these over-eager heroes made painfully clear.
4. Agreeing To Escort Helpless People ALONE
Escort missions are some of the most widely loathed mission types in video games, generally saddling players with a frustratingly incompetent, pathetically weak character to guide around a locale filled with enemies and possibly even hidden traps.
It's never a good look, especially given that most of these sections need to be completed by the hero solo. Metal Gear Solid 2's Raiden has to get poor Emma Emmerich to "safety" on his lonesome, while Resident Evil 4's Leon is saddled with the frustratingly lame Ashley Graham for most of the game.
While some might argue that a true hero adapts to their situation and handles it accordingly, a high-value target like Ashley - that is, the President's daughter - clearly needs more than one pair of hands, and there's certainly no shame in asking for some extra help.
Gamers everywhere would thank developers for it, honestly, because babysitting useless escort characters sucks.
3. Mid-Combat Banter
One of the silliest things that so many video game characters do is spend half the battle dropping "witty" and "funny" quips, apparently for the player's benefit.
In the world of the game, though, this rarely makes sense - why would anyone waste precious breath and energy cracking wise during an extremely physical fight, and one which could very well end with the hero's death?
This trope is everywhere: Insomniac's Spider-Man, Final Fantasy, Mass Effect, and Xenoblade Chronicles, to name just a few.
Even if you accept that the heroes are somehow able to catch a breath and spit out a quippy one-liner, do they really think anyone can actually hear it in the heat of battle?
Better to let your fists do the talking until the battle is won, no?
2. Pursuing Revenge No Matter The Personal Cost
Revenge is the motivation for a huge number of video games, and seems to confirm the depressing reality that we humans are nothing more than animals driven by our basest desires.
The Last of Us Part II's depiction of revenge, hate, and the violence that spills from it was widely debated by fans and critics, some appreciating it as a self-reflexive meditation on the utter empty futility of blood-thirsty vengeance, while others couldn't stop screaming at Ellie and Abby to just stop.
The game, in its brilliance, is perhaps the medium's greatest example of characters doing something that infuriates players to make a wider thematic point: the ending isn't supposed to be satisfying as much as it is true to the characters.
Did Abby feel any better when she beat a defenseless Joel to death with a golf club? What was Ellie reduced to by the time she was forcing an emaciated Abby into a fight to the death at game's end?
But The Last of Us Part II is just one example.
Take the original God of War trilogy, which basically shows Kratos caught in a looping spiral of revenge and death, or Max Payne, which sees Max fail to fill the void in his life by littering the streets with literally thousands of corpses.
Revenge is a great excuse for a video game to give players the power fantasy of going full scorched Earth on a fleet of adversaries, but how often is it really the right or smart thing for the character to do?
1. Wearing Ridiculously Impractical Clothing
And finally, we're taking practically every JRPG ever made to task here, given how many of them dress their characters - especially the ladies - in clothing that makes no tactical or practical sense whatsoever.
Final Fantasy is the chief offender with its array of improbably-clothed heroines, most infamously Final Fantasy X's Lulu, whose costume is basically a series of belts which somehow clings to her body - possibly by way of her large bust.
Elsewhere there's fighting series SoulCalibur, which pushes fan service to self-parody levels with characters like Sophitia, Taki, and especially Ivy, who bears so much skin it must surely be a massive combat disadvantage, leaving her wide open to easy wounding.
You can argue that a lot of people love the fan service and it's supposed to make sense within the context of these worlds, but in 2020 it's tough not to view such character designs with something of a side-eye.
Characters can still be sexy without abandoning basic combat logic, after all.