Two weeks ago, I wrote an article about offensive portrayals of women in gaming, a controversial, hot-button topic that always stirs up debate among gamers and the press. Despite how far video games have come over the years, many are still stuck in the past with regard to their depictions of females, opting for the cynical yet tried-and-test method of "a pair of guns and a pair of double Ds", along with the least amount of clothing they can get away with. But in the comments section of that article, a question arose: what about the flipside? What about offensive portrayals of men in video games? It's a much tougher topic to tackle, that's for sure (as I found in my research), and many object to the idea of "reverse sexism" on the grounds that men generally don't really seem to care all that much about stereotypical portrayals. That doesn't mean that out-of-touch archetypes don't exist, and now I'm going to attempt to tease out the 10 biggest ones of all. Feel free to chime in with your own views in the comments!
10. Chris "Roids" Redfield - The Muscle (Resident Evil)
In the original Resident Evil game, Chris Redfield had a perfectly "normal" appearance: he was a well-built S.T.A.R.S. operative, who (if you played as him over Jill) saved the day, and that was that. The same is true in both the follow-up, Code Veronica and the GameCube remake of the original game: Chris looks like he can take care of himself, but is still grounded in reality. Then we move on to 2009's Resident Evil 5, and for no reason whatsoever, Capcom have decided to give him a massive steroid injection, with his arms now the size of tree trunks! The change in appearance was widely derided by gamers and the gaming press alike, and though it's fair to argue that Chris' performance enhancement would certainly help him fight off the zombie horde, it's just a little too over-the-top. Sure, make his arms a little bigger if you like, but there's no need to make him look like a roided-up member of the WWE roster. I don't think many men would complain that he shows off an "unattainable" standard, but simply that he looks freaking ridiculous.
9. Commander Shepard - The Emotionless Shell (Mass Effect)
Mass Effect is a test case for a video game which offers up the option of a male or female protagonist, and the female equivalent is easily the better of the two. Jennifer Hale's gutsy performance as the female Shepard is just light years ahead of the male Mark Meer version, which is extremely wooden and meshes awkwardly with Shepard's already generic, buzz-cut grunt look. His voice has the same boring cadence through pretty much every line of dialogue during the games, and though one can argue it suits his no-nonsense demeanour, it's just not very interesting to listen to. To avoid falling asleep during the dialogue segments, I instead will opt for "FemShep" as fans love to call her, who without question has far greater conviction and emotion. Instead, Male Shepard is boring, bland, completely lacking in personality and adhering to most of the stereotypes we associate with a soldier of this kind.
8. Tidus - The Brainless Surfer Jock (Final Fantasy X)
I suppose by the end of Final Fantasy X, Tidus did prove his worth as a fighter, but that's not really enough for me to like him. Tidus instead adheres to the affable yet unintelligent surfer-dude jock stereotype, with his perfectly-styled hair, quirky dress style, and rather inane dialogues throughout the game. The most complained about scene featuring the character is when Yuna tells Tidus to force himself to laugh when he feels sad, and the resulting horrible laugh causes them both to genuinely laugh: though that makes sense, it doesn't make the scene seem any less awkward and silly. On the plus side, he's a lot more upbeat and optimistic than most of the Final Fantasy protagonists, and he's a great athlete as far as Blitzball is concerned, but it's easy to forget all that given how insubstantial he is as a character. Yes, he has a little growth throughout the game, but he's still incredibly annoying, and more to the point, as dumb as a box of rocks.
7. Marcus Fenix - The Meathead (Gears Of War)
Marcus Fenix, the protagonist of the Gears of War franchise, is one of the most ridiculous walking stereotypes of the last gaming generation. He might be able to get things done, but just look at him: he's every jock meathead stereotype rolled into one, without even a lick of a satirical undertone. It's not like Fenix even proves the stereotype wrong when he opens his mouth either: most of what he says comes in awkward grunts, and he prefers to let his actions speak much louder than anything else. Like the male Commander Shepard, the guy just doesn't have much personality (though BioWare at least tried to characterise Shepard well), and his sole purpose is to look bad*** and blow things up. For a video game series so modern and popular, it's a shame they reverted to a character who unintentionally parodies the shooter heroes of yesteryear.
6. Squall Leonhart - The Emo (Final Fantasy VIII)
The Final Fantasy series has caught an increasing amount of flak over the years for its use of depressing sad-sack characters and anime-bait "emo" storylines, but we can go all the way back to 1999's Final Fantasy VIII for one of the franchise's most annoying male characters, in protagonist Squall Leonhart. As much as I love FFVIII, it pales in comparison to the previous and subsequent games in large part because Squall is such a misery-guts. He's hard to warm to, with Square trying to portray him as edgy and mysterious, but mistakenly characterising him as a disconnected introvert of few words. Even ignoring his emo-esque flamboyant hair style and wacky dress sense, he's just not very likeable, which is really the major problem above all else: had the game at least done us the service of giving Squall a redemptive arc of sorts, perhaps this would have worked, but for the most part he's an impenetrable whiner and the sort of maladjusted twerp who shouldn't be the protagonist of anything. Had we even the remotest sympathy for the guy, all this could have been salvaged, but no.
5. Dante - The Man-Child (Devil May Cry)
One of the favourite male stereotypes in movies and TV is that of the "man child", played to perfection by actors like Will Ferrell, Kevin James, Adam Sandler and John C. Reilly. Despite clearly being grown adults, they're stuck in a stage of emotional arrested development, and the same can be said of Devil May Cry's Dante, a guy who without question is an excellently skilled fighter, but has all the emotional resource of a baked potato. Dante loves sitting around eating pizza and goofing off, and frankly, who doesn't? But that doesn't make him a man-child: it's his aloof arrogance to everything going on around him, and the fact that, especially in last year's reboot, he defers to foul language far more often than necessary. Hearing Dante having swearing matches with other characters just makes him seem immature and stunted: yes, adults swear a lot in reality, but as much as I liked the DmC reboot, this was probably my least-favourite aspect of the game. Dante's youthful personality accounts for a lot of his charm, but sometimes it's a little grating too.
4. Vincent Brooks - The Commitment-Phobic Scumbag (Catherine)
One of the more peculiar games to come down the pipe in recent years is puzzle adventure game Catherine, which revolves around one of the most interesting if bizarre premises in gaming history. Vincent Brooks is a young, aloof male who is being pressured to get married by his girlfriend, Katherine, yet he ends up cheating on her with a woman he meets at a bar, Catherine. His waking life and a series of nightmares begin to blend together and cloud his judgement, serving as a metaphor for the crushing pressure he feels to "seal the deal" and marry his girlfriend. In the end, Vincent ends up questioning his sanity once it appears that Katherine is not real, before he finds out she is a creature created to tempt men who intend to cheat, therefore "saving" their partners from lousy relationships, and holding the men captive in a tower. In short, though Katherine is far from perfect either (she fakes a pregnancy), Vincent is just an immature douche, something of a male stereotype in being averse to moving the relationship along and being controlled by his genitalia. Nevertheless, it's a game like no other, and worth checking out if only for its innate weirdness.
3. Every Male Character - The Slab Of Meat (Duel Love)
While researching male nudity in video games, I was greeted with the bizarre Japanese video game Duel Love, essentially a visual novel where you play a girl who is trying to hook up with boys from the local fight club. The end goal of the game is to form a relationship with one of the boys, but it's the mini-games which totally turn the whole sexism argument in video games on its head. There's fairly innocuous things like treating their post-fight injuries, but then things escalate to wiping sweat from their chests, and eventually even watching them in the shower. In a way I suppose it's refreshing that it's the male body being objectified for once in a video game, but at the same time, is it really any better? Granted, the game is a very niche Japanese product that most Westerners won't ever have access to, but still...
2. Larry - The Sleaze (Leisure Suit Larry)
The Leisure Suit Larry games walk a very fine line ideologically. They are frequently called out for being sexist due to their depictions of women as nothing more than objects to satiate lust, as protagonist Larry goes about trying to get laid, and these critics aren't really wrong. Similarly, though, their depictions of the male aren't a whole lot better: Larry is a rather unattractive middle-aged man driven seemingly by his sole desire to have sex, and is without question extremely sleazy and even a little creepy. It's arguable that the game's somewhat satirical bent excuses it from being truly sexist, and the developers themselves have admitted that though the game may appear sexist, it is actually advising against Larry's approach to women, given how often his attempts fail. Still, it makes men look pretty awful on the whole, all the more so given that there are so many of these games.
1. Duke Nukem - The Sexist Pig (Duke Nukem)
Does a sexist protagonist make a game sexist? It's a difficult question, complicated by the fact that Duke Nukem is such an in-your-face character, and it's difficult to separate him from the goals of the game itself. A foul-mouthed bad*** Duke might be, but he also treats women almost exclusively as objects for his own satisfaction, even if that could almost be said about pretty much anything he does, including exploding pig-cops with an awesome gun. Some will argue that the games are a satire of the muscled-up action hero, and to an extent that seems to be true, though the recent Duke Nukem Forever really dropped the ball in this regard. It featured a "Capture the Babe" mode which raised a lot of eyebrows, and begs the question: is the satire defense really adequate? More to the point, the failure to update Duke for the contemporary era was hugely disappointing, and instead of subverting the ways in which the gaming arena has changed over the years, Duke just feels like an old pro-wrestler stepping back into the ring well past his prime. It's just a bit embarrassing as a male gamer these days: we want the medium to be taken seriously (while still entertaining a satire that actually works), and games like Forever just hold us back. What do you think? Is it all a bit reactionary and non-sensical? Or should men stand up for their depictions in video games more? Let me know in the comments!