Nintendo struck gold with the Nintendo 64 release of Super Smash Bros.. Mixing 2D brawling with a dozen of gaming's icons proved to be a gripping formulaso much so that the IP will soon see its fourth installment on Wii U and 3DS. The games have built a massive competitive following as well, backed by dozens of official annual tournaments and countless more small-time competitions among fighting game communities. Characters are tiered and moves are dissected down to their very animation framestop-level play is no joking matter. Impressively, the game also manages to deliver the simple fun of plopping down on a couch with friends for some good old fashioned bro smashin' (and occasionally controller, ego and friendship smashin'). However, as is the case with most fighting games, SSB isn't a perfect system. Many of the pro players consulted for this article remain adamant that Super Smash Bros. Melee made great strides in balancing the game, but there are still some pitfalls to its mechanics. And what seem like small cracks now could become gaping issues on Wii U and 3DS though, thanks to its adjustable move sets, a first for the series. Characters currently wielding overwhelming speed could very well be untouchable if equipped with all speed-type attacks. This also goes for heavy brawlers who are already tough to kill, hard-hitters who KO from low health, and exploitative fighters that can win with a single move. Creating custom attacks is uncharted territory for Super Smash Bros., and it may not come back from its trip to the jungle without a few ugly scars. Here are 10 characters that already push the limits of fair and fun that, if they're to return for a new round of bro smashing, could use an adjustment or two, or at least a limiter.
10. Pit
Kid Icarus star Pit has never seen much competitive play due to his lack of reliable finishers, but he's perfectly adept at whittling opponents down. Controllable projectiles, fast movement and high jumps make Pit one of few characters with a viable long-distance offense, which can be particularly infuriating in group fights. The danger here is for Pit to get too close to untouchable, to reach a level of agility that all but disallows close confrontations while allowing him to keep pressure on from a distance. Super Smash Bros. wasn't designed with archery in mind, and giving a single character monopoly over ranged battles could prove disastrous, or at least incredibly annoying. If nothing else, it would undoubtedly lead to countless cries of "Damn it, would you get back over here!" from couch contenders. And nobody wants to play that guy.
9. Sonic
True to his legacy, Sonic the Hedgehog is quite the spry combatant in Super Smash Bros. Brawl. His horizontal moves can completely control the floor of a map and high dodge ability keeps him safely out of reach. What's more, that rapid movement means he's tough to escape; he can edge-guard with the best of them, preventing skyward opponents from returning to the game without suffering a re-upped beating. As it stands, Sonic is far from a Tier-A character, but that could change with a custom move set. Sonic highlights a different risk than Pit: It's not about exploiting, it's about fixing. The Blue Blur's speed comes at a heavy price, but clever attack combinations could do away with much of that downside. Most notably, his ability to rack up minor damage quickly would become far more relevant when paired with a potent killing move, which he currently lacks compared to other characters. Then again, he may also then be able to put a stop to Dr. Egghead. Trade-offs.
8. Fox / Falco
From Link and Young Link to Mario and Dr. Mario, character duos are a defining characteristic of Super Smash Bros., but few see as much play as Fox and Falco. Both are known for their upward finishers, horizontal speed and offensively applicable recovery, namely Fire Fox (seen above). It's no grand secret that these two pilots love to juggle airborne opponents, nor is there any question as to whether they owe much of their competitive success to their aforementioned dash ability. In fact, that Side + B dash is part of what puts Fox and Falco at risk of becoming a bother in the next round of bro smashin', as it can effectively obviate many close to mid-range encounters. Spamming the same move is damnable though, and is also easily countered. More powerful is the pair's Meteor Smash, a move which sends airborne opponents crashing downward with heavy knockback and damage. Falco's Melee incarnation is most guilty of this, but there could easily be room for abuse from both sides on Nintendo's newest platforms. Much the same is true for Fox's Up Smash, which has been launching juggled opponents for well over a decade.
7. Ike
Like many of Fire Emblem's fighters, Ike has one move that's simply too good not to use. This heavy swordsman is tough to KO by design, dishes out huge damage from considerable range thanks to his massive blade and can be difficult to approach thanks to his sweeping forward slashes (forward tilt). Ike's Aether skill appears in several of the Fire Emblem games, but has never been as nasty as its SSB rendition. The move sees Ike throw his sword upward, grab it mid-air and crash back down, catching all enemies within a large vertical hitbox. It saves Ike from a falling doom as often as it sends opponents to theirs a degree of versatility highly sought after in the SSB scene. Aether holds annoying spam potential and works well against floaty opponents, and if Ike delivers the same cutting hits as his Brawl days, the Wii U and 3DS version may have a tough time keeping him grounded. Subbing in more agile skills without sacrificing his extreme launch potentialthat is, his potential for getting opponents intimately acquainted with the edge of the screencould be a deadly mix.
6. Pikachu
Pikachu's infamy dates back to the N64 classic, but hasn't lost its luster over the years. Professional SSB player Isai brought the competitive community to its knees with his stunning performance with Pokémon's icon, trouncing nearly every contender with unstoppable aerial combos, best described as a "zero-to-dead" strategy. Everyone's favorite electric mouse found new balance with the release of Melee, which carried into Brawl, but is poised to make a comeback with the variable attacks of the upcoming installment. Players are sure to find a sweet spot between timing and damage on his classic tail uppercuts and quick horizontal jabs, which could spell disaster for the chances of other characters. Fortunately, Nintendo has had well over a decade to learn from the mistake that the original Pikachu build so clearly was, hence his lower ranking here.
5. Ice Climbers
Funnily enough, Sonic the Hedgehog isn't the fastest of the SSB bunch. With the release of Brawl, the adorable Ice Climbers stole that spot despite being tethered to one another. Lethal grabs also make these two strong fighters at lower tournaments where opponents are less likely to properly evade, but that same strength may undermine the meta game if mishandled. The technique of infinitely grabbing an opponentone exclusive to Ice Climbersgrew to such prominence that it earned its own name: wobbling. The term comes from competitive player Wobbles who, in a Northern California tournament, grabbed his way to 9th place with the Climbers. Not a bad result for what was effectively a violently one-sided hug fest. As the SSB Wiki reports, the controversy around this technique is heated. The jury is out as to whether it holds credible influence in tournaments due to its situational nature, but there's no question that strengthening the techniqueperhaps, oh, through dynamic movesets which better stun opponents thereby making them more vulnerable to grabscould do more than raise an eyebrow.
4. Wolf
Although Wolf does bear a striking resemblance to Fox and Falco, he's also packing two distinct moves that place him in a different class: his forward and down smash attacks. Though weak, the former is one of the longest-reaching smashes in the game and gives Wolf a formidable advantage in close quarters. His down smash, meanwhile, delivers solid damage and heavy knockback both in front of and behind him, making it more than just a reliable finisher, but a catch-all response to approaching opponents. Weak recovery works to balance Wolf; stun him in the air or push him off the map and he's all yours. Of course, that may not count for much if, say, his two aforementioned attacks get an upgrade. Directional smash attacks top the list of moves to be customized in the next Super Smash Bros., and higher damage on Wolf's forward or improved speed on his down could prove devastating.
3. Shiek
Shiek's Super Smash Bros. incarnation lacks the mystery of her first appearance in The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. There's no question as to her true identity: she's a master of close-range combat. Thanks to relatively low knockback and quick activation, all three of Shiek's smash attacks work together exceptionally well. Paired with her forward tilt attack (featured at 1:44 in the video above), she can be next to impossible to stopa trait which has taken her to great heights in competitive play. She clocks in as one of the top-tier Melee characters and holds quite a record in Brawl as well, but the real danger is what variation will do for her kicks. At the very least, players currently have familiarity going for them against a smash-happy Shiek. Strike that from the list and things get very nasty very quickly. Being unable to effectively anticipate and respond to her sweeping down smash or cutting forward smash due to inconsistent timings could make Shiek indomitable in many matchups.
2. Snake
Ironically, after deriding Nintendo for adding Snake, a Sony-centric character, to the Super Smash Bros. universe, die-hard fans of the the brawler quickly realized they were painfully correct in saying Metal Gear Solid wasn't a good fit. Snake doesn't belong in SSB or any other fighter as he is. Fighting games are all bound by a delicate border between powerful and broken, but Snake isn't a color inside the lines kind of guy. Certainly, every fighter can be beaten, but in a bout between players of equal skill, besting Snake can feel like trying to roll seven on a six-sided die. With an arsenal of both delayed and contact explosives, high KO potential prepackaged with nearly all of his attacks, and disproportionate hitboxes and weight, Snake is a veritable Frankenstein of sheer power. Players have already gotten creative with his bombs and grabs; who knows how monochromatic tournament lineups could become if he returns to SSB with, far from a drop in strength, even more options?
1. Meta Knight
Meta Knight's hatred for Kirby has nothing on the wrath he's incurred from the competitive SSB scene. For good reason: he's drop dead lethal. More specifically, he wields higher attack priority than any other character, meaning his moves will connect with and interrupt opponents. As IGN reports, his aerial combativeness and total edge dominance proved so peerless that he was banned from competitive play. He's also the proud owner of an invisibility exploit involving repeated use of a single move, which only worsened his reputation. Multiple tournament surveys showed that players found the game more enjoyable with Meta Knight gone. This is not the place for debate; Meta Knight is too strong, plain and simple. If all other factors are equal, Meta Knight is the stronger character by a frankly ludicrous margin. He can be beaten, but then again you can also win five-bullet Russian Roulette if you have enough lives to spare. Surely Nintendo wouldn't bring the little nightmare back for a second round, right? It's not as though he's already been confirmed to be returning to the next game, right (thanks Kotaku)? Right? Does a particular Super Smash Bros character seem broken to you? Is there one fighter you just can't seem to beat or avoid in competitive play? Let us know in the comments below!