10 Overused RPG Mechanics That Must Die Next Generation

Preston Garvey, moustache twirling villains, fetch quests and boring combat, get it gone!

By Jordan Rylins /

In a gaming world where Fallout and The Elder Scrolls are quickly becoming less and less sought after, and with Cyberpunk on our tongues for the past decade, it’s time we take another look at RPGs as a whole.

Advertisement

We’re very close to a new generation thanks to the imminent arrival of the PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X, and with that will come a plethora of RPGs, small and large alike that are all vying for your attention. Before they compete, though, they’re going to need to take note about the dos and don’ts of the past. What we’ve loved and more specifically, what we’ve hated over the past generations.

Radiant quests, bullet sponges, random mechanics and Preston Garvey are just a few of the things we think could be changed about the RPG genre. Mechanics and features which need a bit more motivation, to be given a new wave of inspiration that will actually mean something to the player. Instead, some developers choose to rest on tradition, using parts of RPGs that have become commonplace for reasons we can’t explain.

10. Uninspired Fetch Quests

Uninspired is the operative word for this entry. The Witcher 3, for example, had a lot of, “Go here. Do this. Grab that. Kill. Come back.” And that’s okay. If that’s the gameplay loop the developers want the player to be comfortable with, it’s understandable as there’s only so much you can offer. What makes The Witcher so special, though, is that there’s a huge difference between being told to go and grab or kill something and motivating said request. If you’re motivated to track down a wolf in the woods because it used to be someone’s loving husband who ran away, then there’s at least the tiniest bit of intrigue there. Extra points if the writing is well done.

Advertisement

What doesn’t work, though, is simply making the protagonist go and get s**t for the sake of it just to pad the length so you can now brag about more side-quests being in your game. Ultimately, we want something interesting. I don’t care if Geralt is off finding a sandwich in Kaer Morhen, if it’s a magical sandwich that could transform the evil beggar into a mouse, then it becomes more enticing. Maybe a poor example but the point is there. Motivate the player, show them why the protagonist and more specifically, the player, would want to do this quest.

9. Weapon Durability

There’s a time and a place for durability. From a developer’s standpoint, there are obvious gameplay benefits to having equipment such as lockpicks, hacking tools and supplements being limited use. Weapons, especially swords and guns? What's the point, besides the fact it’s tradition or it somehow extends the game. The problem only gets worse when every enemy you encounter has a weapon identical to yours that you can pick up but not use as a means for repair. Either it’s an oversight or developers are just stuck in their ways and honestly, I’ve never liked it.

Advertisement

Combining, upgrading and modifying weapons in certain ways is a great spin on weaponry. I could even see the idea of durability being appropriate for said spin. An upgrade is meant to be powerful, if it adds lightning or fire, make that effect wear off after X number of kills or attacks. Don’t, however, make me constantly run back to the gunsmith, the merchant or the crafting bench to repair my gun I just had polished an hour ago. That, is neither realistic nor fun.

8. Inconsistent Mechanics

Mechanics and abilities are the lifeblood of role-playing games. From spells to shooting, hacking to hunting, arguably, the more things for the player to do, the better off your game is going to be. This isn’t always the case, as throwing in every half-assed idea you can think of won’t bolster your game. In fact, it’ll do more to make it look shallow as opposed to rich in features. Adjacent to this sentiment is that of inconsistency, mechanics in the game that don’t make much sense when paired up with other things you’ve seen or done.

Advertisement

In recent years, we’ve seen a rise in survival elements in gaming, RPGs especially. Survival is one instance of a mechanic which doesn't always work. Sure, if you’ve built the game to your audience from the get-go that this is a hardcore-survival-wilderness game, we’ll let it slide. If you just want to jam food, water, stamina, sleep, sex and dog-walking stats into your RPG - particularly those which need to be tended to every five minutes - then that isn’t appropriate. Random, unnecessary and inconsistent mechanics pushed into games they aren’t welcome in do not add depth, and it can often ruin an otherwise fun, more casual experience.

7. Radiant Quests

Another settlement needs your help. The Thieves Guild needs you to get the same item from the exact same building you just went to. You need to go and kill another wanted criminal.

Advertisement

Similar to that of the uninspired fetch quest, radiant quests - also known as Todd Howard’s ability to justify saying, “You can play this game forever.” - are unneeded. I can’t think of a single justification for radiant quests besides grinding experience or items. So, I think we can say they’re worse than fetch quests. Let’s break down an example: whenever you go within a five-mile radius of Preston Garvey, he will sprint at you, passion burning in his eyes, to let you know a settlement is being attacked. That’s your motivation, a settlement you don’t even remember clearing is in danger.

You could go and help them, clearing any enemies and earning pennies. However, you could just as easily not do that. Instead, try to stay as far away from Garvey as humanly possible with zero consequences. This style of quest is present throughout many, often lacking, RPGs and they can give you something chill to do between outings. The main issue with radiant quests, though, is that they aren’t just repetitive, they’re repeated quests that offer no change, benefit or consequence.

6. Tanky Enemies For The Sake Of It

This entry has become a huge part of many games, some not even specifically in the RPG genre. Tank-like enemies, bullet sponges, you know them, you probably don’t like them, unless there’s a quick way to get rid of them. If an enemy has a lot of health just because, then there’s something painfully wrong in the design of said enemy. Throughout this list the word motivation has come up plenty and I feel it works here, too. Why is this enemy such a tank? If it’s because they’ve got a lot of armour, perfect, that makes sense. If it’s because they’re big, I might also accept that as an answer.

Advertisement

What won’t be accepted is them having a lot of health being their only characteristic. Make this type of enemy unique, give them a weakness or even… multiple weaknesses, thus lining up with the role-playing side of the game. A certain kind of spell they don’t like, a chink in their armour you can shoot or a mannerism you can exploit. It’s not rocket science and having a larger-than-normal enemy with more health is not exciting, nor does it make us look forward to the next boss.

5. Clichéd Dialogue And Characters

This one pains me to have to list because characters, dialogue, writing in general are usually the most enjoyable parts of a game’s creation. Figuring out who the characters are, what’s their driving force, their intention, who will they brush shoulders with and who will they oppose? Fun questions to answer that define the entire story’s direction.

Advertisement

Yet, somehow, in a genre as rich as role-playing games, some developers completely miss the mark. Worse yet, they don’t even bother to look for it. Let’s use Fallout 3 as an example, not the best RPG game ever made, especially now it sits in the shadow of New Vegas, but the characters are on another level.

If you ask anyone to name a few characters from Fallout 3, they could do. This is because even though the story itself was a fairly simple chase, the world was crammed full of memorable NPCs. Moira Brown, Lucas Simms, and Mister Burke are three found in the very first settlement you’ll reach. To think, there are characters like Dave, Harold, Eulogy Jones and the AntAgonizer that some players never met. It goes to show, your world can be as grey as gravel but if you can place vibrancy in character, then players will be engaged and remember your game for years to come.

4. Unnecessary Weight Limitations

Weight limits and encumbrance are potentially the most arguable entry in this list. On the one hand, they’re a pain, stopping the flow of the game to make you hike back to town to store those special potions and sell the nine swords you picked up. On the other hand, they can be a really interesting feature when paired with realism. For example, working very well with the aforementioned survival mechanics of managing hydration, hunger and sleep. If you have to worry about your backpack, it’s not too far of a stretch to be worrying about eating or even warmth.

Advertisement

Where it becomes stupid, though, is when you can carry two missile launchers and a Fat Man, but not a Power Fist along with it. If we take a step back we can appreciate that there’s a weight limit for the sake of game design, so you don’t pick up literally everything you come across. However, if you really think about it, how much of a problem would raising or removing the weight limit, in these situations, affect the game? Plenty of people would play along, holding as organised and neat a backpack as possible. In regard to the hoarders, so what if they can truck their pockets full of flowers and bugs back home to craft a couple hundred potions?

3. Swinging, Repeatedly (Boring Combat)

Combat can often be quite difficult to make exciting. Guns are undoubtedly easier in the sense that there’s a lot of variety to work with. The same cannot be said for swords and in most cases magic throughout RPG games. The former is usually limited to the same three strokes of swinging your metal at someone else who may or may not have a shield to deflect. Shields definitely make the encounter more interesting but if the combat is left to something as dull as two directional and a strong swing, then we’ve got some issues.

Advertisement

Mordhau, although not an RPG, is a beautiful example of how you can make a long list of somewhat similar melee weapons all feel unique. Stabs, thrusts, parries, slow and heavy, rapid, low or high, maybe throw a dodge-roll in there and you’re looking much better.

Now, although melee weapons are the prime suspect of dull RPG combat, magic is an accessory to the crime. Different types of potions add variety but spells are often the biggest culprit. The dreaded blasts of: fire, ice, poison, all the exact same animation of holding your hand out but with a different colour. To conclude, if a developer can master combat, making something as common as action exciting, then they’ve already laid an engaging foundation for their RPG.

2. Choose A Faction

Factions are sneaky little ways for developers to neatly categorise and manage which quests you do and how that impacts the game. Usually locking off other quests and areas once you reach a certain loyalty, factions not only limit gameplay, but also player choice. What if I don’t want to join a faction? “Well, that’s just part of the game, sorry”, might be the response you get. To that I say, fair enough, you did design it and spend all the money creating the game. Still, it’s hard to call your game an RPG if your choices are so firmly decided for you through the side you choose.

Advertisement

Outward was the worst for this type of mechanic. You spend 30 (real-life) minutes walking only to get to an exclusive faction you don’t particularly align with. Now, you can either walk back to another city or forfeit your choice for time management. This situation can only be worsened if the player has no interest in any of the given factions. Skyrim used a similar approach, though, the differences between the Stormcloaks and the Imperial Army were so drastic it could arguably warrant two separate playthroughs. It also included isolated, unique factions like The Dark Brotherhood, College of Winterhold and Thieves Guild, each having their own special quest-lines.

1. Meaningless Character Stats

Similar to inconsistent and unnecessary mechanics, meaningless character stats are another part of RPGs which need to be worked on. Obviously you can’t get rid of character stats, these are the very essence of a player’s build and how they choose to tackle the game.

Advertisement

What you can do, though, is make them mean more than just extra padding for your game. Random, unique stats that a developer liked the name of are all well and good but if they don’t do anything new, then what’s the point? Disco Elysium embraces its wacky character stats and gives every single one of them a purpose, impacting your character at different times.

Shivers? Well, that’s a tingle you get as the cold coastal wind hits your bare neck, helping you remember something from your speed-fuelled stupor the night before. Inland Empire? Bit of a weird name but ultimately, it’ll let you open your imagination, animating the inanimate and allowing for conversation with your own clothing or items around you. So, not only are those two stats unique, they’re also a little bit out there and they contribute to the game’s focus on detective work. If there’s one game RPG devs need to take note of, it’s Disco Elysium.

Advertisement