10 Recent Video Game Villain Deaths That Made Us Cry

Did anyone have "Poison Ivy makes the save" on their bingo card?

By John Tibbetts /

Storytelling in video games has come quite a long way in the past decade or so, huh?

Advertisement

Sure, while every generation has one or two great examples of telling a story, the increase in technology available to even indie creators has allowed for more detailed characters, deeper world building, and of course, more threatening antagonists. But sometimes threatening isnt the only vibe you want to have for your villain, maybe you want your villain to be more sympathetic.

Maybe they have a point, or maybe there are extenuating circumstances forcing them into being this way. Or maybe they're just REALLY pretty.

Either way, when it comes time to finally put down your villain, making them more sympathetic is a great way to leave your players in tears as you rip out their hearts and stomp on them.

Only rule here is that they have to have been released in the last 10-15 years. Oh, and obviously, MASSIVE spoilers ahead.

10. Baldur - God Of War (2018)

Baldur was a psycho when we met him at the beginning of the game, but across God of War, we find out that - like most men with severe issues - it's mostly mommy's fault.

Advertisement

See, like in the original myth, Frigg received a vision that her son would one day be murdered. So in order to prevent that from happening, she made her son impervious to all forms of harm save for the seemingly harmless plant Mistletoe.

Where God Of War adds in its usual dark twist to the mythology is that this spell also took away any and all kinds of feeling, taste, touch, or smell. A sensory deprivation that ended up driving her son mad.

As well as set in motion the events that would lead to his death that she tried to hard to prevent. When Baldur leaves Atreus with no choice, he decides to live up to the true name his mother gave him, and shoots the bastard with an arrow made of Misteltoe.

At least before he died, he got to feel the sweet cold of snow one last time.

9. Poison Ivy - Batman: Arkham Knight

While the comics have been trying to rehabilitate Poison Ivy for years, the Arkham games - for the most part - mainly kept her to her traditional incarnation as a hardcore baddie. While the flavor text of Arkham City did show her trying to go straight, it also showed that it didn't last very long at all.

Advertisement

But then Arkham Knight came out and tried to jump on the "you know, maybe she ain't all that bad" bandwagon the rest of Batman comics had been on for almost two decades at that point. Near the end of the game, Scarecrow releases a bunch of fear toxin across literally all of Gotham, making the city basically uninhabitable.

In order to stop Scarecrow, Batman has to team up with Poison Ivy, who has a way to stop Scarecrow's plan and remove the fear toxin from Gotham. However, doing this ends up costing her her life. Pamela Isley dies in Batman's arms, her final words being "nature always wins".

8. The Great Grey Wolf Sif - Dark Souls

Now, it doesn't take deep lore or profound characterization to make most people not feel like a winner for murdering a dog. It's pretty much a universally agreed upon d*ck move, regardless of circumstances or context.

Advertisement

But that didn't stop Dark Souls from putting some deep ass lore in there anyway just to twist the knife. One of the most famous fights in Dark Souls' by now legendary rogues gallery is The Great Grey Wolf Sif, who attacks you when you get too close to a weird looking stone, armed with a giant sword in its mouth.

But as you learn when you dive into the flavor text and the context clues hidden throughout the fight itself, it gets even sadder, which is a feat considering this fight already has the poor pup start limping when you wittle down its health far enough.

Turns out that the grave belongs to Sif's now dead master Artorias and it's protecting the grave from you because it believes you to be here to defile it. And now you gotta put down Ole Yeller.

7. Loghain Mac Tir - Dragon Age

Depending on your view of the battle at Ostagar, the actions of Loghain Mac Tir were either that of an opportunistic villain sneering as good King Cailan fell, or a pragmatic veteran commander witnessing a doomed battle and choosing to not let anymore soldiers die for a lost cause.

Advertisement

Either way, Loghain Mac Tir is a complicated man. One who does many unforgivable things over the course of the story, but all with the aim of protecting the country he loves, the country he fought and sacrificed so much to liberate, from what he felt were encroaching enemies.

When you have him at the end of your sword, and if you choose to kill him to avenge your comrades, he has one last talk with his beloved daughter, the Queen of Ferelden Anora.

Though short, it shows that some part of Loghain truly was the hero that all of the tales about him spoke of.

6. Marlene - The Last of Us

Marlene - leader of the group known as The Fireflies - only wanted to save the human race from the zombie plague that brought its society crashing down. And if she had to kill one little girl to do that, then so be it.

Advertisement

But Joel, being The Worst, decided that he didn't like that, and so he went on a killing spree to rescue Ellie, ultimately leading him to murdering Marlene. ]

Sure, it's hinted that there's a chance that Ellie's immunity can't be made into a cure. But they're just hints, nothing concrete. And to be clear, we learn these hints from Joel's perspective so who even knows if even those hints are true or not.

Either way, Marlene - so close to finally saving the human race - gets shot in the head by a crazy dude and her body left to rot. At least Joel got his proper comeuppance in the second game.

5. Asriel Dreemur - Undertale

Undertale's final boss, Asrield Dreemur, might just take the cake for the most tragic villains in gaming history.

Advertisement

Used and sacrificed by his own sibling, Asriel was cursed to a wretched existence as a sentient flower. And, since apparently flowers are naturally sociopathic, violent creatures in the world of Undertale, "flowey", as he started calling himself upon his transformation, set about messing with all the monsters of the Underground across multiple timelines.

This sociopathic behavior really comes down to an all too relatable need to keep everything going and avoid endings at all costs. Which is why, when you show up and start advancing the plot towards, le gasp, an actual ENDING, Asriel confronts you at the end of the true pacifist run and traps you in a never-ending final boss fight.

But with your determination, you manage to push through, and soon you have the depowered God of Hyperdeath at your mercy.

And then you give him a hug. Because this kid really just needs a freaking hug, okay?

As penance for what he'd done, Asriel gives himself up to finally bring down the barrier keeping the monsters in the underground.

4. Count Bleck - Super Paper Mario

Easily the most complex villain in the Mario franchise, Count Bleck is at first shown to be your typical over the top, wonderfully hammy Mario baddie. But over the course of the game, you get bits and pieces of the man behind the cape. Turns out Count Bleck was once a man of the tribe of darkness, who fell in love with an outsider named Timpani.

Advertisement

Obviously such a union was destined for tragedy, as Bleck's father banished Timpani to parts unknown out of a misguided bid to keep his son "strong".

Well, he got what he wanted, as Bleck proceeded to go mad with grief, take the dark tribe's most powerful weapon - The Dark Prognosticus - and use it to set about the end of all things. Because if he cannot live with the ones he loves, then no one gets to live at all.

Fortunately, however, Timpani survived the banishment, being reborn as Mario's moody companion throughout the game Tippi. Once she realizes her true identity, Tippi managed to talk Bleck down off the mountain enough for him to realize what he's done. Bleck and Tippi sacrifice their lives to undo what Bleck had set in motion.

It's a touching death and proof of what can be done with Mario when story is put first.

3. Goro Akechi - Persona 5

JRPGs are the undisputed masters at making you feel sorry for running a broadsword through the chest of a bad guy. And one of the most famous examples of this in recent memory comes from Persona 5, and fan favorite character Goro Akechi.

Advertisement

Goro Akechi hated his father. And to be fair, his father made hating him the easiest thing in the world, leaving his mother to raise Goro all by herself. And since Japanese society is famously uh, "tough" on single parents, the stress led to his mom having an emotional breakdown.

Akechi then dedicated his life to ruining the man who cursed him with such a wretched existence. Even going so far as to allow himself to become his dad's personal metaverse assassin, just to get into the most advantageous position possible.

All of which was for nothing, of course. Shido pegged him as his bastard son the moment he walked into his office, and has been planning on cutting him loose from the start. And after a boss fight with Akechi, that's exactly what happens, Akechi being murdered by his father's perception copy of him just to add insult to injury.

The most solace Akechi gets in the end is that Joker never once gave up on the chance that he could be a better man.

2. Edelgard - Fire Emblem: Three Houses

Fire Emblem: Three Houses has a lot of choices for who ends up as the main villain depending on the choice you pick.

Advertisement

The saddest is Edelgard, who, if you don't side with her, spirals out of control due to her self loathing and guilt over what she feels needs to be done, either finally self destructing, or turning herself into a demonic entity to burn Fodlan to the ground with her.

The latter scenario - found in the Blue Lions route - is by far the sadder due to Edelgard not only accepting her death at the end, but making it look like she was about to strike Dimitri. Doing so ensures that when he killed her, her death would not be seen as an opportunist striking down an unarmed 23 year old woman, but instead as an act of self defense from a worthy successor to the throne.

Edelgard always acted, all the way to the end, with the aim of dragging Fodlan, kicking and screaming, into the future. It only makes sense that she would choose to die in a way that would ensure that that would happen. So, in a way, even when Edelgard loses, she still wins.

1. Elidibus - Final Fantasy 14

Emet-Selch may be the better overall villain, but in terms of a video game villain death in recent years that utterly destroyed players, this author can't think of a better example than the death of the Ascians resident long game schemer, Elidibus.

Advertisement

Elidibus, like the rest of the Ascians, only wanted to bring back his people and civilization, which were wiped out in a random, devastating cataclysm. Unfortunately, bringing their people back - they're convinced - requires more or less collapsing the entire multiverse in on itself. A goal which Elidibus had been working towards for untold millennia. Until you kill all of his friends.

Once that happens, Elidibus - understandably - puts all of his plans on hold until you are dead. Even though you have to stop him, you can't help but feel deeply sorry for Elidibus. All he wants are his friends and family back, leaving you to wonder if you'd really be any different from him were you in his shoes.

And sure enough, you do kill him, leading to him giving one of the saddest final sentences I have ever heard, delivered with heartbreaking beauty by Matt Stokoe. I won't spoil it, but have some tissues on hand when you get to this part.

Shadowbringers is one of the greatest stories in gaming, and the death of Elidibus is one of the saddest villain deaths, not just in recent memory, but in the history of gaming as a whole.

Advertisement