10 Shocking Times Older Wrestling Games Did Graphics Better

It turns out THQ's artists weren't so bad after all...

By Jamie Kennedy /

2K Games

Screenshots of the upcoming WWE 2K20 show it's a bit of a mixed bag visually. Some wrestlers, like Roman Reigns above, look resplendent, and it's obvious that 2K's team put a lot of effort into crafting his model. Others, well, others range from solid to downright ugly. Still, it'd be easy to think newer means better when it comes to graphics generally.

Advertisement

Not so fast.

These examples all look at older pro wrestling video games that did it better than those that followed them years later. It's a scathing visual commentary on how game developers can occasionally half-arse character models and leave gamers feeling ripped off or unsatisfied by what they're playing. For most, you'd need an imagination to rival Ofelia's from Pan's Labyrinth to make them passable.

Advertisement

Worse, a few came from the same team that had worked their magic previously. Prepare to recoil in horror at a cast of fiendish faces so foul they'd give Bray Wyatt's new gimmick nightmares. Even his twisted dreams couldn't rival those of the sorry saps who had to pay for this criminal lack of effort...

10. Edge

2K Games/THQ

Games: WWE 2K16 (left) and WWE SmackDown vs. Raw 2009 (right).

Advertisement

Time Between Release: Seven years.

When 2K took the WWE video game reins in time for 2K14, the gaming public reasoned that they'd bring their know how of creating excellent sports titles to the wrestling world. Excitement was palpable, and everyone looked forward to better graphics than THQ had ever been able to produce, and presumably, a completely new engine.

Advertisement

A mere three games into their run, 2K were already phoning it in with horrendous creations like that one of Edge (supposedly) from 2K16. Compared to the model from SmackDown vs. Raw 2009, it's hideous. Honestly, it's like someone was trying to make the 'Rated-R Superstar' look terrible.

Either that or Edge could smell something nasty.

Advertisement

9. Vince McMahon

2K Games/THQ

Games: WWE 2K18 (left) and WWE SmackDown: Here Comes The Pain (right).

Advertisement

Time Between Release: 14 years.

This is even more embarrassing, because there was a much longer gap between WWE 2K18 and old faithful SmackDown: Here Comes The Pain. The latter was launched in 2003 to critical acclaim, but it's worrying to see that some of the character models (despite being rough around the edges due to the PS2's technical limitations) were arguably more polished than 2K's.

Advertisement

That's not Vince McMahon, it's former Russian President Boris Yeltsin.

2K18 doesn't capture the WWE figurehead's arrogance at all. Instead, he looks constipated. The PS2 creation, meanwhile, has that hard-nosed swagger fans have come to expect from classic Vince. Who knows what went wrong on the left?

Advertisement

8. Goldberg

EA

Games: WCW Backstage Assault (left) and WCW Mayhem (right).

Advertisement

Time Between Release: One year.

Oh, oh God. That is f*cking horrible to look at. It's like WCW icon and recent WWE Hall Of Famer Bill Goldberg has been in a car accident on the left. Fittingly, a car crash is exactly what EA's follow-up attempt on the totally fine Mayhem was when they unleashed Backstage Assault on the world in 2000.

Advertisement

It's worth experiencing just to see how badly wrong pro wrestling video games can go.

Mayhem's models weren't hi-res, but they were passable attempts considering the PSOne's hardware. Somehow, EA's skills got worse 12 months later when they all shared a crate of Scotch and rushed their way through another WCW release. Goldberg from Assault is a jagged, broken mess of pixels and developer contempt.

Advertisement

7. Hollywood Hogan

EA/THQ

Games: WCW Backstage Assault (left) and WCW/nWo Revenge (right).

Advertisement

Time Between Release: Two years.

Somehow, even Goldberg's model looks better than country-biker-meets-Willie-Nelson lookalike Hulk Hogan did in WCW Backstage Assault. There was literally nothing to tell players that they'd picked Hogan aside from a name plate above his energy bar. That was it. The thing bears no passing resemblance to one of wrestling's biggest stars at all.

Advertisement

Two years earlier, AKI were smashing it on the N64 with WCW/nWo Revenge, a game that (whilst hardly pretty) did a much better job of replicating WCW's roster. There, Hogan exuded Hollywood cool, had some of his nWo gear on and didn't look like someone had stretched a sock over their thumb.

Backstage Assault may be the worst "wrestling game" ever.

Advertisement

6. André The Giant

2K Games

Games: WWE 2K20 (left) and WWE 2K14 (right).

Advertisement

Time Between Release: Six years.

On the left is a bang up to date look at André The Giant's character model in WWE 2K20. Though it is difficult to properly evaluate the scale of his entire body without seeing it or trying him out in-game, that man with the furrowed brow there doesn't exactly look like the old 'Eighth Wonder Of The World'.

Advertisement

If André was the eighth and Chyna was the ninth, then the tenth is 2K's hatchet job of their own work.

Six years earlier, they produced a much more realistic Giant in 2K14. It's clearly based more on André before he started wearing the classic one-strapped singlet, but it's facially more recognisable at first glance. The one from 2K20 is a caricature rather than a faithful recreation.

Advertisement

5. Randy Orton

2K Games

Games: WWE 2K19 (left) and WWE 2K15 (right).

Advertisement

Time Between Release: Four years.

Randy Orton must be smelling the same foul farts as Edge in an earlier entry. Apparently, someone dropped one so bad that it hung around from 2K16-2K19 and caught the back of Randy's throat. How else can his po-faced expression be explained in last year's game?

Advertisement

It's amazing to see these characters side-to-side and realise that the much-maligned current-gen debut for 2K's series had better luck fashioning Orton in 2K15. He has that familiar sheen and well-groomed face. Plus, there's a more piercing stare to his eyes instead of the annoying zombie look favoured now.

2K15 has 2K19 licked, at least when it comes to presenting a Randy Orton models his fans will appreciate playing as.

Advertisement

4. Kurt Angle

2K Games/THQ

Games: WWE 2K20 (left) and WWE SmackDown vs. Raw 2006 (right)

Advertisement

Time Between Release: 14 years.

One has to wonder what in the name of Olympic gold happened here? Why does Kurt Angle resemble a reptile made of plasticine rather than the wrestling machine he is? Feast your eyes on THQ's work for SmackDown vs. Raw 2006 on the right to see a more well-crafted take on the now-retired legend.

Advertisement

Obviously (before someone points it out), these are different eras of Angle's career. 2K20 is going for the start of that career, whereas SmackDown vs. Raw '06's model was current when it launched and didn't have the hair. Even so, it's unforgivably poor that 2K consider the face scan on the left acceptable for a video game released 14 years after the one on the right.

If this is "photo-realism", then waxy, larger-than-life action figure replications of WWE stars win this round.

Advertisement

3. John Cena

2K Games/THQ

Games: WWE 2K20 (left) and WWE SmackDown vs. Raw 2007 (right)

Advertisement

Time Between Release: 13 years.

It's not that the John Cena character on the left in WWE 2K20 is awful. It's really not. It's that one created by someone else over a decade before it on inferior hardware tops it in terms of presentation, quality and finishing touches (sweat, eyes etc). Had Cena with the green t-shirt shown up in ads for SmackDown vs. Raw 2007 back in 2006, people would've lost their minds with excitement.

Advertisement

Unfortunately for 2K, it's 2019, and their graphical work hasn't moved on as much as WWE gaming fans would like. They're not doing well with aging stars either; Cena's skin is rumpled rather than wrinkled, and he's another victim of the dead eye club.

THQ did this one better 13 years ago. They're not the only ones who did JC better than 2K20 either...

Advertisement

2. John Cena (Again)

2K Games

Games: WWE 2K20 (left) and WWE 2K15 (right).

Advertisement

Time Between Release: Five years.

The team working on WWE 2K15 absolutely nailed John Cena.

Advertisement

It shouldn't escape your attention that this is another victory for 2K15, a game that was panned heavily for its lack of content and progression on modern systems like PS4 and Xbox One. At the time, folks thought 2K just needed some more experience with those consoles under their belts. Five years on, they're still struggling to convince.

Cena's steely glare on the right looks current-gen. His low-texture expression on the left could pass for something from the final year of PS3 or Xbox 360 production. Why is that, so many entries into the PS4/Xbox One lifespan for 2K, they're actually getting worse at graphics? It's inexplicable.

Advertisement

1. Booker T

2K Games/Midway

Games: WWE 13 (left) and TNA iMPACT! (right).

Advertisement

Time Between Release: Four years.

THQ aren't getting away without a stern telling off themselves, don't worry. They're to blame for whatever that Booker T character model in WWE 13 was all about. It was more car-boot-sale action figure knock off than world class video game character. Seriously, there's no justification for those eyes, the teeth or the lack of definition on his face and body.

Advertisement

TNA iMPACT! from Midway, released in 2008, fared better when it came to building a satisfying in-game Booker. His expression was more realistic (compared to the comedic Donkey from Shrek feel of THQ's effort), his skin glistened with sweat and his hair was hanging down naturally over thick shoulders.

If only Midway had been able to stick around long enough to make an iMPACT! sequel. Their character models were second to none at the time.

Advertisement

-

What other times can you think of when older wrestling video game graphics were better? For more on WWE 2K20, check out the 10 Biggest Roster Omissions!

Advertisement