10 Things NOBODY Wants To Admit About Battle Royale

Is the genre just a flash in the pan?

By Paul Mills /

In the current age of video games, it is almost impossible to go anywhere without yet another Battle Royale popping up to remind you that, no, they're not dead yet, and yes, you're wrong for not playing one right now.

Advertisement

But not everything is perfect with the poster boy of modern day multiplayer. The BR genre is rife with problems that seem to go unanswered by both its players and its detractors, everywhere in the world and across each subsequent release.

Obviously the only solution is to crank out yet another bloodthirsty free for all, with bog-standard cartoonish graphics in place of any evolution on the gameplay side.

Whether you love them or hate them, Battle Royale just can't seem to be toppled from its place at the top of the multiplayer food chain - but they be can analysed and moaned about in a way that might eventually, somehow, make the whole thing more palatable to all involved.

10. The "Loot, Kill, Die, Repeat" Loop Is INCREDIBLY Fatiguing 

It's always the same: You drop in, pick up whatever scraps you can find, pray that you find something decent instead of that same pistol again, run for 5 minutes, inevitably die to someone you didn't even see.

Advertisement

This is your average game of any of the currently available choices on the market.

Sure, there's that 1 in 100 chance you'll win and feel a sense of personal satisfaction that can only come from proving your superiority to a group of strangers on the internet, but most of the time that isn't going to happen. Most games will end with a few kills and hopefully a place in the top 10, but hardly ever that coveted victory.

Then it's time to do it all again. Back to the main menu you go...

Repetition isn't always the end of the world, but in a video game it runs the risk of burning out its player base and making the genre stale. The only reason Battle Royale hasn't fallen victim to this is due to its hugely addictive quality; that "one more game" attitude. It's strong within the likes of Fortnite and Apex Legends' player bases, but for how long?

9. Minecraft Did It First

When it comes to video games, everyone seems to forget one the originals of the genre. Back in the distant past that was 2012, hit film The Hunger Games smashed its way onto the screen and into the collective subconscious of pre-teens everywhere. Obviously the only way to capitalize on this audience was to create hundreds of Minecraft servers that all followed in the film's footsteps.

Advertisement

To this day, Minecraft: The Hunger Games stands apart from its more recent kin in a couple of unique ways. For one there is no "drop" - every player (or Tributes as they call themselves) begins the game stood around a chest filled with supplies and gear, while a timer ticks down.

Once it hits zero absolute chaos ensues. It's a mad dash to grab as much as you can and get out of Dodge before some mad woman with a bow snipes you from the other side of the map. After that it's your typical Battle Royale affair: kill, loot, repeat until you're the last person standing.

Amazingly, this mode faded into obscurity over the years and almost nobody talks about how it came before the current market. Maybe it's time to ditch the smooth edges of Fortnite and go back to the OG block builder, at least until Lego World: Hunger Royale is released.

8. It's One Big Twitch Machine

Twitch has effectively become the place to be if you're an online game. At the time of writing there are two Battle Royale titles in the top 5 most watched games on Twitch, with Fortnite almost exclusively holding the top spot.

Advertisement

The genre almost begs to be spectated and enjoyed beyond playing, to the point it has even spawned its own pseudo-celebrities with the likes of Ninja being a household name amongst younger gamers. This once again ties into how the genre belongs as an e-sport - players and spectators can get behind the teams or individuals that inspire them via gameplay.

But no matter how you look at it Twitch is the monopoly holder for this market and as such The Battle Royale basically advertises the platform, just without any official support beyond a few cosmetics and Twitch integration services.

The action can be watched on other streaming services like YouTube, but there's nothing quite like live spectatorship with thousands of other viewers all spamming the same three emotes over and over again, just like any other live event.

7. They're Padded With Gimmicks

Every couple of months, Fortnite throws out a new gimmick which splits the player base directly in half - only for them to promptly forget about it a few weeks later (until the next gimmick is announced and it all happens again).

Advertisement

The problem here being that these gimmicks are the only ways that the game can continue to work without feeling stale. Every so often, Epic Games throws in something like a crossover event and suddenly the big purple lunatic Thanos himself is playable. Or the Infinity Sword is released.

This isn't completely exclusive to Fortnite either, Black Ops 4's Blackout recently released a Heist mode where players hop in a criminal vehicle, or a police car, and chase each other down with the promise of even more loot.

Dependent on which way you spin it, this can be seen as pure fun, or desperate attempts to make their game seem relevant in such an oversaturated market.

6. It Doesn't Know Where It Stands

In the world of video games there is a clear divide down the centre of every community and that is casual vs. pro, or in other words fun vs. rage induced self hate.

Advertisement

As it stands currently games like Apex, Fortnite, and even Blackout all exist solely within the realms of the casual game with only brief forays into the world of e-sports. They are played for enjoyment and that's what the developers focus on first and foremost, but the genre itself is ripe for the e-sports crowd.

Apex most recently has made its claim for the crown of the Battle Royale genre and is gearing up to be the first on the pro scene, everything from its mandatory 3 person squad limit to the intricate hero combinations people are dreaming up practically screams e-sports.

However, the genre's refusal to conform to a specific side means that it is just that much more accessible. Just look at one of the biggest e-sport genres on the planet: MOBAs (Massive Online Battle Arenas). The only thing that could make Fortnite more salty is the attitude of a League of Legends player.

5. No Genre Is Safe

If there's one thing in this world that makes absolutely no sense upon initial impression, it has to be Tetris 99. On the surface everything looks okay, but wait, why are there miniature versions of Tetris being played all around the screen?

Advertisement

Most importantly, how have 4 hours passed in the blink of an eye?

Tetris 99 really pushes the boundaries on what exactly a Battle Royale is, while also managing to be one of the most fun and innovative variations on the subject.

However it also brings with it the horrifying realisation that this is just the tip of the iceberg. The floodgates are now open for a variety of bizarre variations on classic game formula.

Imagine the dystopian future of video gaming ushered in by this Epic Games regime, a new region of Pokemon set on a giant circle with poke balls scattered everywhere, getting a Rattata is a death sentence. Or worse Breath of the Wild with 100 players all on the map of Hyrule, shield surfing and paragliding everywhere.

Actually hang on that's not a bad idea, someone get Nintendo on the phone.

4. They're Threatening The Single Player Experience

The Battle Royale has made its mark on video games as being one of the most accessible and fun forms of multiplayer on the market, to the point where the likes of Black Ops 4 has ditched its single player mode entirely for a little taste of the high life, with more almost certain to follow. The truth is while single player games do still sell, they simply don't continue to sell.

Advertisement

Multiplayer is an investment that players can return to time and time again. Forever, if they want. Its hard to believe that there are still people out there playing Unreal Tournament 2003 and loving it, but they're real, they exist, and they're legends.

The genre itself offers seasonal based content that simply keeps adding and adding to the base game that people love so much. With this much free content it's hard not to justify spending a little money on their in game stores, or buying some cosmetics that would otherwise take days of lootbox attempts to get.

£5 isn't much after all, and it's going to a game that you love and repeatedly play, but it all adds up. Try getting players to buy boosts and cosmetics in a single player game and see how well that works. Looking at you, Shadow of Mordor.

3. Progression For The Sake Of Progression

There was once a time when it wasn't considered mandatory for every game created to have some sort of level system. This was also the time when there were linear games that felt no need to make you traverse a map 3 times bigger than Texas, just to pick up some random guys dry cleaning.

Advertisement

Now however if you aren't levelling up constantly in a game, what's going to make you come back? While games like Fortnite and Black Ops 4's Blackout mode do reward the player for levelling it all just seems unnecessary. The point of leveling was originally intended to let the player watch their power grow in a tangible way.

However in competitive multiplayer games such as these doing this would simply encourage level 100 trolls to roam lobbies looking for fresh players to stomp on.

The level system exists simply due to necessity at this point, a box to be checked in every slightly RPG-esque game released and frankly it shows. The only reward here being that of cosmetics, like a slightly more orange tint for your gun, or a chance for some free lootboxes, speaking of which...

2. It Propagates Loot Boxes

Even if you hate Apex and love PUBG (PlayerUnknown's BattleGrounds), there's one simple thing that ties them all together in one nice anti-consumer package:

Advertisement

Loot boxes. Everybody's favourite form of random chance rewards. The loot box at this point has become a staple of the genre, and simply refuses to die a thousand deaths like it truly deserves.

Each iteration of Battle Royale includes the coveted money-making machines in one way or another - a system so despised by the gaming community that Disney itself had to step in a few years ago and make EA sit on the naughty step after the Battlefront 2 fiasco.

You know something's went wrong when the mouse himself makes an appearance.

However, the difference here is that this version of the loot box serves to reward only cosmetics, removing the advantages over other players, but ensuring that loot boxes as a mechanic remain relevant in the current market. Following in the footsteps of industry loot box titans like Overwatch means the practice is only gaining in popularity with every release.

1. They're Here To Stay (For The Worse)

Just like Tetris 99 has proven, there is no other game mode that has the sustainability and sheer consumer support as the Battle Royale.

Advertisement

As long as they continue to innovate and challenge the status quo of classical multiplayer, the genre will strive on to newer and bigger heights.

This is most certainly is a bad thing.

The genre is inherently based on anti-consumer practices and general frustration, whether it be the microtransactions, leveling systems, or even the massive concentration of 12 year olds regularly dominating the leader boards, dropping slurs left, right and centre as they go.

But in this never-ending nightmare there is no escape. The only thing to do now is bide our time and hope there's another, less awful trending game mode on the horizon.

Where we dropping? Hopefully straight to hell where you belong Battle Royale, and I'll see you there, whether I want to or not.

Advertisement