10 Things Nobody Wants To Admit About Dark Souls 3

Yeah, so, about that third act...

By Adam Hogg /

FromSoftware

Dark Souls 3 is not a bad game. In fact, it’s great, but when comparing it in the echelon of games that is the Souls series overall, it's far from the best. FromSoftware's supposed final instalment does a lot right, fixing a ton of broken mechanics and tweaking the important groundwork the game is known for. It has a fantastic world to explore too, but people tend to herald it as the best game in the series, surpassing the original and if its included, the masterpiece that is Bloodborne. But it’s just not the case. For all the bells and whistles it has, it has a lot of fundamental problems that hold it back from being the best game. And while being up there with the better games, it is still highly overrated by a lot of people.

Advertisement

So, for better or for worse, I intend to run down ten reasons why Dark Souls 3 is overrated in comparison to the other games and I do have to stress this. It’s a great game, just overrated. But all the same, feel free to hurl abuse at me in the comments for saying what I’m about to say!

--

Advertisement

10. It Feels Too Short

FromSoftware

This is a strange point, but bear with me. The game feels far too short and when playing through it feels like it is missing a whole third act too it. Even though it feels short, the game boasts some of the largest, winding and tightly woven levels of the series, with the amount of area to explore arguably larger than some of the other games. Yet It still feels far too short and the ending leaves you feeling void. It leaves you saying, “Is that it?”

The inherent problem lies in the manner that the game is structured, with the player tasked on collecting and bringing the four remaining Lords of Cinder back to their thrones, a premise and design very reminiscent to the previous titles. The problem is that is that in games like DS2 there was a whole third act after you collected to the four main souls/lords. With DS3 mimicking the same structure, but not following through with the third act, it feels empty, as if its missing the end of the game. Regardless of how much content the game has.

Advertisement

In the end, that feeling of emptiness and shortness makes the game feel rushed and incomplete. And in a game, that feels like it needed a bit more development time, an ending that feels incomplete doesn’t bode well for the title. Perhaps by spacing the world a little different and having portions that needed to be revisited after collecting the Lords, with new areas to explore to uncover the truth, the game might have not ended a little abruptly.

The Soul of Cinder kind of just comes out of nowhere and the whole ending seems a little tacked on at the end, as if there was meant to be an area linking it all instead of just warp bonfires.

Advertisement

9. Poor NG+

FromSoftware

Say what you will about the quality of Dark Souls 2, there were a whole host of things that the game did to improve the series. From making PVP work mechanically to some extent and refining the arenas and balancing for the online invasions to offering up soul vessels to revamp your character. The game did a lot right and one of the major things that it made brilliant, was NG+.

Advertisement

Instead of just giving enemies high HP and attack stats, the game introduced red phantom enemies, new harder versions of enemies that had new spawn positions, making the game fresh and much harder. Not to mention making NG+ worth playing! So why would Dark Souls 3 get rid of a system that worked brilliantly and had fans raving about it. It was one of the points that fans could agree was great about DS2, so why take it out in the sequel.

Undoubtedly due to time constraints and the game being rushed, the lack of a worthwhile NG+ is extremely noticeable, especially in the wake of the previous game. Being one of the most disappointing things about the game, the developers threw salt on the wound, when It turned out NG+ wasn’t even much more difficult than the base game.

Advertisement

With a system in place in the previous games that worked and was ingenious, not having it the sequel felt lazy and the void was noticed. All we had was some +1 rings and that was it. All you had to do was run NG+ once for the trophy and never had to touch it again! Quality game development!

8. Optional Boss Fights... Or Lack Thereof

FromSoftware

One of the major joys of the Souls series has been stumbling onto those hidden gems of a boss. Finding Pricislla and the unique position she puts you into, or discovering Darklurker -the best DS2 boss- hidden away in the abyss, were some of the high lights of the game. Or finding out that a boss you thought weren’t optional, has a way to bypass it entirely. The choice to fight bosses or not or finding a hidden boss was a major highlight of the first games, but DS3 fall way short.

Advertisement

Where both DS1 and DS2 have fourteen optional bosses (DLC included) and Bloodborne has upwards of twenty if considering the unique chalice bosses, it’s a crying shame that DS3 has only seven. And that’s including the Gravetender DLC boss. And the way most of those optional bosses are presented, in a single line, one optional boss after another as if they are their own chain of bosses, is disappointing. It often means that discovering one boss means you’ve discovered them all.

There isn’t that reward for exploration and finding those secrets hidden away in the depths of the game. Not when the supposed optional bosses are presented blatantly. There is no Gwyndolin who makes you jump through insane hoops to fight him. It’s disappointing when a game that is known for its secrets and its mentality of willingly hiding massive chunks of the game away from players, knowing full well most people won’t see it, suddenly had the urge to show us everything they had to offer.

Advertisement

I will admit that Archdragon Peak and The Nameless King was one of the best hidden secrets in the whole series, even if it was coupled with an absolute abhorrent first boss. Ancient Wyvern was a joke. A massive joke.

7. More Of The Same

FromSoftware

Now, more of the same for Dark Souls isn’t a bad thing, because who the hell doesn’t want more of which is ostensibly a great game. The more the better. But when it comes to DS3 it’s a little different. Exploring the world of Lothric feels far too familiar and it all feels like we’ve done it before. Nearly every area has been done before and in some cases, done better.

Advertisement

Farron Keep and Blighttown. Irithyll and Eleum Loyce. The Catacombs of Carthus and the Catacombs. It doesn’t help that some areas are straight up ripped from the first game and while in some cases that can be consider beneficial, like in the case of Anor Londo, in others it’s not. Like when DS3 copied Demon Ruins, an area that can be argued as the worst area of the first game. If you’re going to port areas, make them the good ones.

It feels kind of like FromSoftware were running out of ideas, pulling from their past bank of areas and tying loose lore connections for it to make sense. Which is a crying shame since most people we riding down from Bloodborne and the fresh new world it offered, where visiting an area that reminded you of DS1 game you a sense of nostalgia and didn’t make you say, “Again?”

Advertisement

It did get tedious after the third poison swamp area Dark Souls 3… The third one! In one game!

6. Poise!

FromSoftware

I didn’t want to have to include this, but it really does have to be said. And anyone who is even remotely familiar with Dark Souls 3 knows exactly what this is all about. But where is poise? Why the hell does it not exist, considering how it was a major element in balancing the game, more specifically the armour? Why get rid of it? Why get rid of it, but still have the stat in the stat menu as if it exists?

Advertisement

Poise might seem like a tiny little thing when looking at the whole game for some people, but it is very important. For those who don’t know, poise was the stat that directly correlated with how easy it was for an enemy to stagger you. The higher the poise, the more likely you could tank a hit and not be staggered. Simple. Heavier armours had higher poise, giving players a reason to invest in wearing a bulky piece of armour.

By taking it out, there was no reason for any player to choose a heavier piece of armour when you got the same stagger. By removing poise, FromSoftware completely nullified a whole range of armours in their game, making them pointless to use. And what’s worse is that they left the stat in, making players think that poise mattered when the number in the stat screen meant absolutely nothing!

Advertisement

It might be small, but by god is it infuriating!

5. Excessive Bonfires

FromSoftware

Whilst an improvement on the completely unnecessary number of bonfires in DS2, DS3 still suffers greatly from giving players bonfires that are entirely null and void. Admittedly it is a far lessened problem than in DS2, but it is still an incredibly annoying problem.

Advertisement

Bonfires are key to the entire functioning of the game, acting as safe havens and checkpoints for the player. This means that ensuring they are in the right place is incredibly important. And Dark Souls 3 has a habit of giving the player bonfires in quick succession. Beat a boss? Have a bonfire? Found an elevator? Have a bonfire. Turned a corner? Have a bonfire.

Whilst maybe a little over-exaggerated, the game gives out bonfires left, right and centre with them appearing to come from nowhere. Going from the dancer to the next bonfire is just a few steps, almost trivialising the bonfire given too you after you beat the boss. The problem could be solved simply by removing the need for every boss to have a bonfire after they are defeated.

Advertisement

You know it’s a problem when you can see the previous bonfire twenty feet away from the one you just discovered. Cough… Grand Archives… Cough…

4. Doesn't Feel Like An End

FromSoftware

While the ambiguity of whether there will be a sequel to Dark Souls 3 hangs in the air, it was heavily implied that DS3 was going to be the last in the series. Hidetaka Miyazaki was adamant that they were not returning to the game and several interviews made it clear that there was no intention of having a Dark Souls 4. And to that end looking as DS3, it doesn’t feel much like an end.

Advertisement

Instead of tying up the story -as loose as it is- it left more unanswered questions. And while the story telling style of FromSoftware is unique, it doesn’t lend itself to tying up a story and it leaves the world in an ambiguous state with fans not really knowing what happened. And while that can be alright, for the last game in a series to provide no tangible answers and details to the world, is a massive oversight.

True, the game does treat itself more like a second instalment to the first game and completely overlooking the second game in favour of believing it doesn’t exist. But even then, it doesn’t round anything off. It feels like the middle of the story and as if the end is coming later. But if it’s the last in the series, there can’t be a later.

Advertisement

The story of the game and world of Lothric is good and the lore behind it is exceptional as always and If standing as its own game in the series, it can hold a lot of merit. But the game portrayed itself as the climax of the story, the rounding of off the tale. And when judging whether it did that, you have to say it did that poorly.

3. Weak Covenants

FromSoftware

This is more of a series problem rather than wholly a DS3 problem, but a lot of people have blindly sung the praises of the game for fixing this problem when it isn’t fixed. The Covenants have always been a poor show from the Souls series and while to a certain extent, they were improved in the second game, FromSoftware took a few steps back with the next instalment.

Advertisement

Not having decent rewards and simply serving in a way that didn’t benefit the PVP systems in the game. Not being able to learn from the previous successes, FromSoftware seem adamant not to get it right. When they had a working forest hunter covenant in the first game that meant there was infinite opportunity for PVP in the forest, why wouldn’t they reimplement that mechanic. Or the Covenant of Champions in DS2 that provided additional challenges and worthwhile rewards. Or the Pilgrims of the Dark that offered a story covenant and a new boss to fight. The games have had good covenants, all DS3 had to do was emulate them and add some new ones that worked.

Admittedly, the Mound makers seemed like a great covenant, but if you didn’t play at launch, then it quickly became worthless as players clued into how it worked and didn’t summon them. The rest of the covenants were carbon copies of some of the weaker covenants in the game and often nullified each other by simply existing. Rivalries between covenants was toyed with, but never implemented to a degree that matter, having it fall by the wayside.

Advertisement

They made step forwards by allowing covenants to be switched on the go, but that’s about as far as it goes. Also, who’s genius idea was it to make the invasions work so that you almost always invaded a group of gankers? That guy deserves a medal for almost singlehandedly ruining invasions for a lot of people.

2. It Was Rushed

From Software

As I alluded to previously, it Is obvious that a lot of the game feels rushed and there is a whole load of little problems embedded in the game. Of course, you have your small graphical glitches that are to be ultimately expected in any game, but there are inherent mechanics that are overlooked in a rush to get the game out.

Advertisement

Bosses with unfair moves that literally have no wind-up and hit you instantly. (Pontiff Sulyvahn for one.) Bonfires that are completely made null and void by bosses dropping their own bonfires. Areas that feel like they are missing and others that seem tacked on in places and feel like they have been designed separately with no clear drive beyond the fact that they should exist.

The Profaned Capital is one of the most unique locations in the game and an area that was in desperate need of more, instead of a cookie-cutter gimmick boss. The whole game feels like its missing the content and polish that would come from a month of added development. And when you look at all the cut content that is sitting in the game files, ready to be used, you must wonder if FromSoftware wanted more time as well. And while the original was rushed in places, the game felt like a whole, even with the rushed content.

Advertisement

The recent DLC, feels less like added content and more like content that was chopped off from the game and thrown in as DLC in a vain attempt for money, which is a shame coming from a developer that is known for high quality DLC practices.

For as good as the game is, It needed more time to be refined. Maybe then it would have been better than the original. Maybe…

Advertisement

1. Lack Of Interconnectivity

FromSoftware

When it comes to Dark Souls one of the massively impressive things it managed to do in its first title was present an incredibly rich and detailed interconnected world that fit together as if it were a puzzle. The way you could traverse the world and get from one place to another through a series of well placed and executed short-cuts was ingenious and one of many joys of the original.

Advertisement

But when DS2 came along it threw that design philosophy out of the window and adopted its own. So fans were expecting a return to tradition in Dark Souls 3. But instead we got a slight improvement. By removing the hub world of Firelink shrine, the game lost that sense of traversal and the scope of grandeur. Exploration was broken up by jumping back to Firelink to level up and upgrade, ruining the flow of the game.

The biggest disappointment for a lot of people was realising that the game world was as segmented as Dark Souls 2 and we wouldn't be getting a joyous world like the first game to explore. The way the bonfires worked didn't lend themselves to the detetched hub world in the same was Bloodborne did and in the end felt more like a tedious return to a necessary area rather than a joyful one to a safe-haven. The game lacked that brilliant sensation of adventuring and suddenly stumbling back on Firelink shrine through a new shortcut like the first did.

Advertisement

Not to mention that some of the levels were linear and lacked the creative ingenuity and woven level design of past games. Levels like Archdragon Peak were far too straight forward, which was frustrating as the game had shown us interconnected levels already with the Cathedral of the Deep.

At least the cut down the load times between the hub world and the game space and didn't make us wait for hours like Bloodborne did. Silver lining to every cloud...

Advertisement

--

Do you agree that Dark Souls 3 is a overrated? Even just a little bit? Or do you think i'm a complete pillock for even suggesting so? Let us know down in the comments below!

Advertisement