10 Tiny Video Game Decisions With HUGE Consequences
When the butterfly effect slaps you in the face.
Sometimes, players just don’t appreciate the lack of control they have in video games. Granted, they usually directly lead the protagonist through a given title’s world, but in terms of story and plot development, they’re sometimes powerless.
Many action-heavy titles lead a player from dramatic setpiece to dramatic setpiece, active participants in the unfolding plot but ultimately surrendering to its whims.
Franchises such as Mass Effect allow more influence by offering up decisions that can have substantial impact on how the games progress, while others simply add a morality system that affects how a protagonist impacts their world and its fellow inhabitants.
Whether the player has any input or not, though, the fact remains that the tiniest decision can sometimes have enormous repercussions.
What if Dr. Neo Cortex hasn’t chosen a bandicoot of all creatures for his experiments, inadvertently creating his own worst enemy in Crash?
What if the player hadn’t chosen Charmander in Pokemon Red and Blue, thus giving their starter some kind of chance of damaging Brock’s Rock-types in Pewter City’s Gym?
In video games as in life, sometimes the most seemingly simple decisions can have huge consequences.
10. Life Is Strange - Warning The Homeless Lady About The Storm
When it comes to emotionally wrought narratives that are heavily influenced by the player's choices, this is the big one. Max Caulfield's story is powerful, poignant, joyful, and tragic. The thing that truly lends the game its weight is this: regardless of how things turn out, the player made it all happen.
Max's extraordinary ability to manipulate time is explored in various intriguing ways, as the plot shifts and reverts to account for it. Along the way, decisions that seem natural or trivial have consequences that the player may never have foreseen. One example is the opportunity to develop a friendship with an unnamed homeless woman who lives in Arcadia Bay.
Max can encounter her a maximum of three times, in Episodes 2, 3 and 5. If she takes the time to speak with the woman and learn more about her, in Episode 3, the player has a chance to warn her about the approaching storm.
This may not seem to be a major decision, but the she will believe Max and, in Episode 5, she will have disappeared from her usual spot near the diner. Otherwise, she will instead discover the woman's body there.
In a sense, the homeless woman makes clear the human cost of some of Max's decisions more clearly than any cataclysmic event could.
9. Resident Evil - Jill Doesn't Give Barry His Gun Back
Jill Valentine and Barry Burton (who brought fans the legendary Jill sandwich moment, pictured here)meet again just prior to the battle against the unfortunate Lisa Trevor.
Wesker's chicanery is revealed (at least, some of it), as we learn that he manipulated Barry into betraying Jill by threatening his family. In the tense stand-off in that underground lair, the player is given two options: give Barry back his gun, or don't.
This might seem like a simple decision (the Colt Python/Barry's 44 Magnum is a very powerful gun, after all), but keeping it renders Barry unable to defend himself against Lisa. In the Resident Evil remake, he is immediately knocked from the precarious platform to his death.
The photograph of his family that he drops as he falls is heart-wrenching enough, but what of the implications for the rest of the series?
Barry wouldn't have been there to rescue his daughter Moira Burton in Resident Evil Revelations 2, for one thing. All because the player wanted this mighty magnum for themselves.
8. Bioshock - Harvesting Little Sisters
The wealthy Andrew Ryan founded the city of Rapture as a sort of utopia for society's best and brightest, where the people became corrupted by ADAM. A substance acquired from ocean creatures, this is the source of Plasmids (the special powers you can collect and command in-game).
To acquire ADAM, the player must subdue the iconic Big Daddies and take it from the Little Sisters they're protecting. The choice to Harvest or Rescue can be a tough one, as the former gives more precious ADAM but the Little Sister won't survive the process.
With Atlas convincing the player that Little Sisters aren't human any more and that doing so is necessary for survival, it's tempting to Harvest them, but the consequences are surprisingly severe.
If more than the 'tutorial' Little Sister are harvested, the player is on course for the bad ending, in which Jack turns on them and Splicers take control of a US Navy submarine equipped with nuclear weapons.
The implications for the world are devastating, and all because the player wanted more resources to spend on upgrades.
7. Bloodborne - Taking Survivors To Iosefka
If the player returns to their original starting point, Iosefka's Clinic, a little later, they will speak to a kindly voice identifying itself as doctor Iosefka. She wishes the Hunter luck on their hunt, but regrets that she can't open the door to them as she has sick patients to tend to.
After Father Gascoigne's defeat, though, Imposter Iosefka secretly takes over the clinic. Like the lumpen creature in Oedon Chapel, she will announce that she instead wants the Hunter to send any survivors they find to her. 'Iosefka' claims that she will take care of any such unfortunate souls.
Later in the game, it transpires that the few remaining survivors meet a grim fate if the player directs them to 'Iosefka.' She experiments on them, and on the true Iosefka, eventually transforming them into Celestial Minions.
In true Bloodborne fashion, even if gamers think they're doing a good deed, FromSoftware makes them inadvertently transform innocents into hideous alien blobs.
6. Heavy Rain - Ethan Doesn't Forgive Madison
Heavy Rain is most notable for its wide variety of possible endings. The player's choices will affect many aspects of the cast's lives and destinies, potentially determining whether they survive at all. Endings can hinge on the slightest decisions.
The relationship between Ethan and journalist Madison Paige is just one that hangs in the balance. The pair meet several times over the course of the game, and on their fifth encounter, they have a heated argument when Ethan discovers that Madison had been gathering information on him in hopes of releasing a big scoop.
The pivotal decision here is whether Ethan forgives her or not. If so, they embrace and their relationship can continue. Several other interconnected issues factor in too, but sacrificing the chance to reconcile with Madison can also mean losing out on perhaps the 'happiest' ending (as Heavy Rain goes) possible:
An eventual marriage - and life - with her.
That may have seemed to be just a brief spat, but it can have incredible repercussions.
5. Crash Bandicoot 2: Cortex Strikes Back: Collecting Gems For N. Brio
Joining forces with Dr. Neo Cortex in Crash Bandicoot 2: Cortex Strikes Back wasn't a minor decision. The interesting thing, though, is the fact that N. Brio also returns from the original title.
In this game, he's working against his former associate. Like Coco, he contacts Crash in the game's hub world, beseeching him to collect the Gems rather than the Crystals (the latter being Cortex's prize of choice). With the power of the Gems, Brio states, it's possible to focus a laser on Cortex's space station and destroy it.
If players do manage to gather them all, the secret ending shows that the space station is indeed destroyed. However, this ending (Cortex plummets to the ground and inadvertently shatters the seal to Uka-Uka's underground prison) is revealed to be the canon beginning of the next game, Crash Bandicoot: Warped.
It's a small decision that seems to just involve tackling optional objectives, but it was actually the key to the continuation of the series, in a way.
4. Hades - Bonding With Everyone Inside The House Of Hades & The Olympian Gods
Hades' character-building surprised many genre fans.
With each return to the House of Hades, one of its NPCs (from lovesick warrior Achilles to the crotchety Hades himself) will have something new to say, providing an interesting new branch of the narrative to help unravel.
By offering gifts and taking time to speak with them all, the player will be amply rewarded with Keepsakes and even Companions to aid him in battle.
Sidequests and great swathes of the narrative can only be unlocked by taking the time to advance Zagreus' relationship with all of these characters.
The true ending, involving the estranged Hades and his Olympian family, can only be unlocked by developing these relationships, which takes time and requires a different objective to be completed for each character.
The same is true for unlocking the legendary weapon of each class.
Put simply, there's a surprising amount riding on the player's willingness to engage in what may appear to be an entirely optional part of the game.
3. Fire Emblem: Three Houses - Skipping Dedue's Paralogue
Depending on the house players choose to teach, the missions they opt to tackle and the bonds they forge with different students, things can end very differently for all Fire Emblem: Three Houses' major players.
In one run, Byleth may become the new ruler of Fodlan and marry a trusted member of their house, while in another, they may become the new leader of the Church instead, killing that very same character in battle. Three Houses tells a tale of bitter warfare, and it's just not possible for everyone to enjoy a happy ending.
For players on the Blue Lions' path, it would be very easy to overlook one particular mission: Dedue's Paralogue, War For The Weak. This mission is only available on the White Clouds route after Chapter 5, and sees the class trying to resolve bloodshed between Duscur rebels and Kingdom troops.
Paralogues can offer some nice loot, but are generally entirely optional and can be skipped by impatient players. Dedue's is completely unique, though, in that not finishing it will result in his death when the five-year skip in time takes place.
He is the only unit in the game that can be lost in this way, and there's no warning for players that it will happen.
2. Dungeon Keeper - Adding A Horned Reaper To Your Army
A wide range of minion species are available to fight the good (that is to say, bad) fight in classic 1997 Bullfrog strategy title Dungeon Keeper. They range from dragons and orcs to the grotesque, gelatinous Bile Demon. Of them all, though, none are more powerful than the monstrous Horned Reaper, which is capable of taking down droves of do-gooding enemies singlehandedly.
In the original game, it can't be recruited via conventional means, only summoned by sacrificing a Dark Mistress, Bile Demon and Troll at the Temple. It might seem like a no-brainer to do this whenever possible, given the creature's tremendous strength, but the Horned Reaper can be as devastating to your own forces as to the opposition.
The Reaper is, as one look at its face should make plain, an angry, angry soul. Its mood turns southwards very quickly, and is not appeased with gifts, it will quickly become enraged and fight any allied minions it comes across.
If a player doesn't have a contingency plan for this, they'll probably regret ever summoning one as it decimates their own forces.
1. Metal Gear Solid: Submitting To Ocelot's Torture
PS1 classic Metal Gear Solid was, in many ways, far ahead of its time. With its deep and involved plot, tactical gameplay and several-month-long Codec conversations, it was a remarkable experience that popularized the franchise and still holds up incredibly well today.
As its legions of fans will know, the game offers more than one ending. Solid Snake will escape Shadow Moses Island with a different companion, Meryl or Otacon, depending on the player's actions during the pivotal torture scene during Snake's capture.
At the mercy of Revolver Ocelot, he's subjected to several bursts of controller-vibrating electricity, with the player having to mash a specific button to ensure his survival.
Here's the rub: at any time, they could hit another button to end segment. Players whose health was running low and didn't want an unceremonious game over could be easily tempted to hit it, perhaps unaware how much influence this small decision would have over the fate of Meryl Silverburgh (who would ultimately die as a result of this choice).
On top of which, this decision also changed the special item Snake would carry into new game plus: the infinite ammo Bandana from Meryl or the stealth camouflage if escaping with Otacon.