10 Video Game Franchises With ONE Game Everyone Hates

The entire fanbase loathes That One Game.

By Jack Pooley /

No video game franchise is perfect - it's just not possible. Even the greatest video game series of all time have their sure flaws, and then, there are those franchises which have That One Game most fans would generally prefer to ignore.

Advertisement

It's unreasonable to expect developers to knock it out of the park every single time, especially with franchises releasing annually or close to it, and yet, sometimes there's just a single dud game that stands out among all the others.

These franchises may have had divisive or polarising entries before, but only one was near-universally rejected by the entire fanbase, enough that it's firmly held up today as the black sheep of the series. A lesson in not what to do in future, basically.

Perhaps these games tried to do something different which abjectly failed, missed the mark creatively, or cynically tried to milk more money from the IP without putting in the required effort.

Whatever the reason, they're the single game in their respective franchise which just about everyone can agree is the one trash instalment. No matter how bad it gets, it probably won't get worse than this ever again, right? Right?...

10. Hitman: Absolution

The Hitman franchise has maintained an impressive consistency for more than 20 years, albeit with one glaring exception - 2012's Hitman: Absolution.

Advertisement

Though Absolution certainly looked the part, it also saw developer IO Interactive severely water-down the series' popular action-stealth formula, presumably in an attempt to make it more appealing to a broader audience and rake in some extra cash.

Yet almost every change made was for the worse, from its more linear levels to its frustrating disguise system, divisive instinct mechanic, and risible mess of a story.

The six-year wait after fan favourite entry Hitman: Blood Money certainly did Absolution no favours at all, and for it to then feel like a supremely dumbed-down experience ensured it became the de facto franchise black sheep.

Absolution isn't a bad stealth game per se, but it is a bad Hitman game, and even the mechanical clunkiness of the 2000 original far outpaces what this cynical sequel had to offer.

9. Metroid Prime: Federation Force

Much as there are many who have little love for Metroid: Other M, that game does at least have its defenders, and even its staunch haters can surely appreciate the potential of a third-person Metroid game starring Samus.

Advertisement

Yet it can't be understated just how pissed off Metroid fans were when Nintendo finally announced the first new game in the series in six years - since Other M - in 2015, only for it to be... Federation Force.

Metroid Prime: Federation Force was a co-op spin-off which fans collectively - and rightly - dogpiled for deviating from the series' much-loved formula, paring down the expected exploration elements, being too multiplayer-focused, having an excessively cartoonish art style, and most criminally lacking Samus herself as a playable character.

It just wasn't what fans wanted after so many years of waiting for a new Metroid, ensuring it was dead-on-arrival sales-wise.

8. Yakuza 3

The Yakuza/Like a Dragon franchise has downright exploded in popularity in the West since the release of Yakuza 0 in 2017, prompting Sega to commission remakes of the first two games in the series and remasters of the third, fourth, and fifth.

Advertisement

Yakuza 3's remaster exists in something of an awkward spot for the franchise, then, for while Yakuza 4 and 5's remasters are also based off PS3 games, Yakuza 3 feels considerably more dated in every fiber of its being.

Even if you can excuse the game's excruciatingly slow opening, the combat is painful, given the tendency for enemies to excessively block every incoming attack, to the extent that boss battles end up being infuriatingly tedious 15-minute endurance trials.

Beyond that, the gameplay is incredibly game-y, filled with generic runaround fetch quests and poorly implemented chase missions, ensuring that Yakuza 3 is the one entry into the series that genuinely feels like a chore.

More than anything, it's egregiously obvious that Sega rushed this remaster out in favour of spending additional dev time completing the remake everybody wanted. Yakuza 4 and 5 are very far from perfect, but they don't feel nearly as archaic as this.

7. SimCity (2013)

SimCity is one of the most impressively consistent video game franchises of all time - or was, until 2013's much-anticipated reboot fell totally flat on its face.

Advertisement

Given Maxis' rock solid track record with the series, there was every pre-release reason to believe that they'd deliver on the promise of fully 3D visuals, a whole new game engine, and online multiplayer functionality.

But then it came out, and to call SimCity's launch a disaster is an embarrassment to disasters.

EA's requirement that players remain connected to the Internet while playing, even in single-player, caused massive headaches upon release, with network outages preventing players from using the game they'd paid hard-earned money to play, while save data was also lost for some.

Even EA themselves later called SimCity's launch "dumb," yet took an entire year to remove the always-online requirement.

In addition to all this, the game was filled with bugs and the much-ballyhooed multiplayer suite was ultimately a shallow assembly of features at best.

The near-universal disdain from fans led to the game flopping commercially, effectively killing the franchise dead, which is surely the saddest outcome from the whole debacle.

EA took the game's failure to mean that fans weren't interested in the series anymore, rather than acknowledge that they made a shallow cash-grab which was soundly rejected.

6. Devil May Cry 2

The Devil May Cry franchise has been impressively even across its six main titles, with one glaring exception.

Advertisement

On paper, Devil May Cry 2 had the easy potential to build on the solid foundations of its predecessor and deliver a bigger, more badass sequel.

Yet the fanbase was left collectively agape when DMC2 hit stores, given that Capcom severely simplified the original's skill-based combat, in turn massively nerfing the sequel's difficulty.

Beyond being hilariously easy, Dante's personality was changed to be more stoic, environments were more sparse and less-detailed than before, the boss battles required less strategic finesse, and even the addition of a second playable character just felt like a lazy attempt to pad the game's play-time.

As such, it came as little surprise that DMC2 was the result of a brutally troubled development, including a change of director mid-production.

The critical and player response caused the game to underperform commercially, enough that it risked killing the franchise altogether, ensuring it instantly became the fanbase's consensus punching bag.

Thankfully Capcom returned with the fantastic Devil May Cry 3: Dante's Awakening two years later, in turn repairing the series' wobbly rep.

5. Silent Hill: Book Of Memories

While there are certainly a number of divisive entries in the Silent Hill franchise, there's only one which most everyone can't stand, and that's the PS Vita-exclusive Silent Hill: Book of Memories.

Advertisement

For starters, did anyone in their right mind ever want a dungeon crawler spin-off to the hit survival horror series? And even if you're willing to accept that this is basically a Diablo-like wearing a grimy Silent Hill skinsuit, it's not even a good take on that.

From the clunky controls to the mediocre visuals, generic gameplay, and utter lack of Silent Hill's signature atmosphere, this is a failure in every way that it could be - a baffling attempt to diversify the franchise which was loudly rejected by the fanbase.

The best thing that can be said about it is that it's playable, but when the rest of the series is right there, why would you put yourself through it?

That this was the final taste of Silent Hill fans had before Konami hibernated the franchise for an entire decade only makes it that much more exasperating.

4. Call Of Duty: Ghosts

There have been many divisive entries into the Call of Duty franchise - especially those which ditched boots-on-the-ground combat in favour of high-wire action - yet only one which has been collectively accepted to be "the dull one."

Advertisement

And that's 2013's Call of Duty: Ghosts, which as the series' first entry on the PS4 and Xbox One, was expected to offer a glossy, high-tech update to the FPS franchise's well-trod formula.

But what can you really say about Ghosts? It didn't make the visual leap many fans expected, the campaign is a forgettable bore that basically just rehashes prior better ones, and the multiplayer is... whatever.

Ghosts marked the first time that Call of Duty truly felt like it had no compelling new ideas to offer, opting instead to spin its wheels and complacently wait for fans to fork over their cash regardless - which they did, even with sales failing to exceed those of its predecessor, Black Ops II.

Ghosts is the potato salad or tapioca pudding of the franchise - fulfilling its most basic purpose while being completely unremarkable.

3. Fallout: Brotherhood Of Steel

Fallout 76 may have been bad upon launch, but at least there's a contingent of players who are now having a genuinely good time with it. The same can't really be said for the franchise's first foray onto consoles - Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel.

Advertisement

A depressing swan song for the series' original developer, Interplay Entertainment, this spin-off took a sharp left-turn away from what players expected of Fallout, opting for a stripped down, ultra-linear take on the action-RPG formula these games are known for.

Even with Interplay using the Snowblind engine which previously wrought solid success on Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance, this is a yawn-inducingly threadbare offering, defined by tedious combat, repetitive enemies, drab environments, and painfully boring quests.

It was so egregiously obvious that Interplay was pandering to the console market with a needlessly "dumbed down" experience with effectively nobody - die-hard Fallout fans or console neophytes - vibed with.

Desperate cynicism drops from every pore of this thing, resulting in it flopping at retail and putting the series on ice until 2008, when Fallout 3 brought it back bigger and better than ever.

2. Gears Of War: Judgment

After the original Gears of War trilogy was released, Epic Games began developing a prequel spin-off centered around a younger Damon Baird, which precisely zero fans asked for. At least, not like this.

Advertisement

Judgment is often jokingly referred to as the "straight-to-video" Gears of War game - an entry that feels less-than in just about every way, from its more linear, arcade-style campaign to its simplified controls, forgettable story, and disappointingly bland multiplayer suite.

It was dead-obvious that Epic commissioned Bulletstorm developer People Can Fly to churn this out with less time and money than a mainline Gears game, resulting in a title that felt like an assembly of the trilogy's off-cuts put into a blender and served up as generic slop.

Were this sold as the DLC that it basically was, fans would've likely been much kinder to it, but instead it came off as a craven cash-grab that evaporated from the collective consciousness in record time.

1. SOCOM 4 U.S. Navy SEALs

For an entire generation of PS2 owners, the SOCOM series was their gateway drug into online multiplayer on consoles, with the first two entries into the series boasting immensely addictive SEALs vs terrorists multiplayer shooter action.

Advertisement

While many of the following sequels and spin-offs were polarising, it wasn't until SOCOM 4 that the wheels well and truly came off the enterprise.

In the titles leading up to SOCOM 4's release, it became increasingly clear that developer Zipper Interactive was chasing the glory of the Call of Duty franchise, resulting in the more contained, straight-forward multiplayer sorties being expanded into larger affairs, albeit with more arcadey, fast-paced gameplay than most fans wanted.

It didn't help at all that SOCOM 4 released a day before the 2011 PSN network outage, which ended up lasting over three weeks and effectively left players holding a disc they couldn't use - unless they wanted to try their hand at the atrocious single-player campaign, of course.

Even fans able to look past the network issues were left with a game that didn't really feel like SOCOM at all, causing it to flop badly enough to kill the series outright. Many sure would love to see a reboot, though.

Advertisement