10 Video Game Reveals That Make You Wish You’d Given Up Instead

Is it possible to experience second-hand embarrassment for a game?

By Greg Hicks /

Plot twists and major story reveals are an integral part of gaming, much like they are in a good movie. For every Citizen Kane's "Rosebud is his sled" we've had some cracking comparisons: Bioshock's "Would you kindly?" or that Konrad was dead all along in Spec-Ops, to name but two.

Advertisement

But to every yin there must be a yang, for every up there is a down. And as you'll see from these examples, they are so far down on the shock-o-meter that they're just downright embarrassing.

It's always fun to play a guessing game when it comes to story-driven games. It's nice to sit there and work out who may be a secret baddie, or if there's even a twist at all, providing no one's already spoilt it for you.

However, some are so blatantly obvious that you've got to wonder who's patting themselves on the back for it. Worse still, when it's not so much obvious but just plain insulting that it makes you question why you bothered to get this far at all.

- Spoilers within -

10. Betrayal - Dishonoured

Silent protagonists are all well and good for us, as players, to project ourselves into... or something. The drawback is that you can shout, "Hell no, I don't want to be a loose end" until you're blue in the face and it'll still play out the same.

Advertisement

As is the case with Corvo Attano in the first Dishonoured: wrongly accused of a crime he didn't commit, he's rescued from imprisonment by a band of loyalists. The loyalists know what happened and set Corvo and his skills to right the wrongs the new leaders have put into place.

And as expected, these do gooders can't have any loose ends and subsequently try and bump our anti-hero off, lest he spoil their plans. So when the halfway point rolls round and the "good guys" are celebrating, and Corvo is offered a drink, every instinct screams, "Run away!".

But you can't. You have to accept the drink, accept the poisoning with a crud-eating grin and accept the fate we all knew was coming.

At least Samuel the boatman was on our side.

9. Jill Is The Masked Figure - Resident Evil 5

It's one of those cliched horror tropes that unless you see the body of the monster/villain, never assume it's truly gone.

Advertisement

Now, Resident Evil as a series has always tread a fine line between pseudo-serious and cliche, so this shouldn't have been a surprise. And it wasn't.

The biggest giveaway after seeing the hooded woman in the early stages of Resi 5 was Chris then lamenting that he never found Jill's body after the incident with Wesker at Spencer's mansion. Sure, you might think falling out of a window, over a precipice and that sheer drop alone would finish them off, but clearly this isn't your first Resident Evil rodeo.

But for the rest of us, when the camera pans in for that dramatic swoop and Wesker pulls back the hood to reveal it was Jill all along, everyone did a collective sigh. Not that she was alive, which is cool and all, but because it was so painfully obvious some several chapters prior.

No wonder Wesker couldn't achieve world domination when he keeps acting like a pantomime villain.

8. Alice Is An Android - Detroit: Become Human

The narrative of man versus machine, or man learning to work with machine, has been doing the rounds now for quite some time. As has the "Can an AI really love?" as a concept, that it's given us some great debate on the whole business.

Advertisement

So for the most part of Kara's story in Detroit: Being Human, we're presented with this when she helps Alice flee her abusive father and they both go on the lam. It presents the above argument: can a robot really care for a human and vice versa, will this be something it can be taught to make us and machine more alike?

Doesn't really matter when it's discovered that *gasp* Alice is an android too! In fact, it makes the whole bloody concept moot when you realise Kara's just been looking after one of her own. It also makes you wonder why she'd never picked up on this before. Surely androids can, for argument's sake, scan each other or whatnot?

It was peak Cage: shoehorn a pointless twist in just... well, for the sake of it.

7. Cereza Is Bayonetta - Bayonetta

If your first thought on seeing the above picture is, "That's just young Bayonetta, surely?" then congratulations. There is no prize though.

Advertisement

That's because it is. I mean, it's pretty obvious it is, right since we saw Cereza in the second mission of the game. The whole 'calling Bayonetta mommy' thing is a red herring that is fooling no one.

Yet Platinum really thought they were duping us with the whole thing, bless 'em. It's like when a child hides behind a curtain and you can see their feet poking out of the bottom: you go along with it because they think they've fooled you.

So of course it boils down to some convoluted nonsense about time travel and all that jazz, we discover that no really, she is a young Bayonetta and the world keeps on spinning.

Of course, there's more to it than that, as is the case with time travel. Without Bayonetta's guidance Cereza wouldn't grow up to be Bayonetta, that's standard paradox stuff.

But they could have at least made her not look the absolute spit of her if they were trying to convince us otherwise.

6. Lucy IS A Templar - Assassins Creed: Brotherhood

It had been established from the very first game in the series that there was a war between the Assassins and the Templars spanning centuries. Desmond, the reluctant assassin, was a prisoner of the Templars in their quest to find the Apples of Eden. But then we discover that lab assistant Lucy is actually on your side, as she helps you flee Abstergo at the end of the game.

Advertisement

Fast forward a few games and we find our gang at a temple and within reach of one of said Apples. This causes some mystical goings on, some exposition about the race of other beings behind all of it, right before Desmond stabs Lucy (well, Juno guiding Desmond stabs Lucy, at least).

That in itself was a pretty big twist, not diminishing that. We were all aghast, wide eyed and wondering why the hell this would have happened?!

Turns out, Lucy was a double-double agent. That's right, she was really a Templar all along!

...oh. Well, that just makes it alright then, does it?

5. Your Wife And Child Are Already Dead - Deadlight

Deadlight, if you haven't played it, is an atmospheric puzzle/platformer in the Limbo/Shadow Complex vein and well worth checking out.

Advertisement

Now, I'm aware that it seems like I've given away the biggest twist in the game with the title, but it's really not.

Our man Randall is looking for his wife and child in the midst of a zombie apocalypse. That's fairly standard, we've seen this plenty of times before. But the "twist" is that every memory he has of them is scarce, with no real established reason for them not being with you from the start.

It's also a bit odd that Randall pics up profiles on famous real-world serial killers along the way, almost as if he has something in common with them...?

Yeah, because he killed his wife and child and then repressed it. Any unreliable narrator that can't account for his actions is going to have a dodgy past, with this one being apparent as soon as the game started and he couldn't remember where they'd fled to.

James Sunderland convinced us he'd done nothing wrong, Randall Wayne was only trying to convince himself.

4. You've Got Super Powers - Condemned 2: Bloodshot

The first Condemned doesn't get as much credit as it deserves. As one of the Xbox 360's early titles, it was pretty rough around the edges but had some charm in its combat and crime scene elements, as well a story that wasn't too bad.

Advertisement

Then, the second game happened. Whilst it improved on the forensic elements, it threw away a lot of the darker elements of the first game for sillier combat and ludicrous plot.

One such element of the original was the mysterious force known as The Hate behind Serial Killer X and his motives. Fine, I think. Bit supernatural but we'll go with it. By the time of the second game, we're introduced to the bigger picture and the mysterious Oro and their shouty powers.

O-kaaay...

Then there's the reveal that protagonist Ethan is "The Remedy", a legend foretold to have the "perfectly evolved vocal chords" capable of harnessing the Oro's true power. Basically, you get a sonic shout special power.

It was so daft that it tainted any semblance of decent narrative the series had built up to that point. Hardly surprising that we haven't seen another one.

3. Celeste Is The Assassin - Mirror's Edge

As previously mentioned with the Resident Evil one, never assume someone's really gone until you see it for yourself.

Advertisement

The same goes for games that only have about a handful of established characters, as it really narrows down who could come back to bite you in the arse. Even more telling, don't make your mysterious, masked assassin wear clothing that gives it away, either.

Yet that's what Mirror's Edge tried to pull on us when they introduced us to Faith and Celeste, the only present female runners in the first game. Honestly, it was insulting when the assassin first popped up, that anyone who's ever seen a Bond film could (and would) have figured it out.

I don't EA were going for Tinker, Tailor... levels of intrigue and espionage when they wrote this, but at least give us a bit of credit when it comes to suspense. They could have made her "assassin outfit" a bit more androgynous to keep us guessing, but nope.

The only other Runner we really encounter who tries to warn us off near the start of the game? We're not falling for that one.

2. Mislaid Intentions - Enslaved: Odyssey To The West

Enslaved is one of those games that deserves more attention than it didn't get on release. For me, it had the potential to be the next Beyond Good & Evil, but it didn't quite reach that status. It came and went, without as much as a passing glance from some.

Advertisement

Which is a shame, as it's a great action adventure game, full of lush landscapes to explore and some pretty weighty combat. It also gave us the unlikely pairing of Monkey and Trip (if you don't know your fable history), as they find out what's causing all the evil robots and such.

Is it some evil AI, or some big nasty corporation hell bent on the usual world domination schtick?

Err, not quite...

As it transpires, it's one man in a pyramid who has people hooked up to a "happy thought machine" for fear of exposing them to the harsh realities of the real world.

Considering the previous scene included giant mecha scorpions, it was slightly deflating to see that there was no evil force or whatnot - just a chap with mislaid intentions of keeping people warm and fuzzy.

1. Scott Shelby Is The Killer - Heavy Rain

The twist that Scott Shelby is/was the killer wasn't a bad one, all things considered. I'd had it spoilt for me, but I can see where it would surprise a few.

Advertisement

No, the disappointment in the reveal comes from taking a step back and wondering why he had to play out the seemingly innocent bits of Scott's story in the first place. Perhaps it was Cage's idea to throw us off of the scent, but having Scott care for a baby whilst also being a child killer was a weird juxtaposition.

Or shooting up an entire mansion to get to Charles Kramer, which seems entirely redundant when we're already playing as the serial killer.

Again, it could be to throw us on the scent. But when you discover our boy Shelby's motives, it's only afterwards you think, "Well why did I need to do all of that other stuff?" and it renders it a bit of a wet fart of a twist in the grand scheme of things.

Someone give David Cage a script editor.

Please.

Advertisement