10 Video Game Rivalries That ALWAYS Had Clear Winners

Look away now, Xbox fans.

By James Metcalfe /

For consumers in any industry, competition can be a wonderful thing.

Advertisement

Not only does it increase the quantity and choice of options available, but it ensures companies are kept on their toes, pushing themselves to produce innovative and high quality products. This is just as true in the world of video games, where rivalries and competition amongst consoles, companies, games, characters and gimmicks have helped push the boundaries on what is possible.

The gaming industry can be more passionately opinion-based than most of its entertainment contemporaries, so proclaiming a 'winner' for the biggest showdowns can be difficult. Outright sales doesn't always indicate a better or more influential game, and even the very worst received titles will have their staunchest defenders leap in when any competitors show up.

Nevertheless, there are certain rivalries out there that most gamers will unite behind, and agree that the case of a competition between the two has been fairly rounded out, be it through units shipped, influence or overall reception.

Many of the most historic rivalries have some pretty definitive winners, if we're totally honest.

10. Mortal Kombat Vs. Street Fighter

WINNER: MORTAL KOMBAT

Advertisement

The two titans within the fighting game community, both Mortal Kombat and Street Fighter have long histories, impressive sales and, unlike other rivalries in this list, a decent level of respect for one another.

The roots of this clash were laid down during the "Console Wars" of the 1990s, where Nintendo's Street Fighter II proved to be an addictive, arcade-like experience on the SNES system and the SEGA Genesis' Mortal Kombat the more intense gory game to go to.

Both franchises have had their huge ups and miserable lows over the years, but always remained influential in the mainstream. Even audiences who aren't keen on fighting games will have heard of at least one of these games, and the continued sales of each franchise shows that interest in the genre overall isn't slowly down anytime soon.

Brutal cinematics and the overall feel of Mortal Kombat has become more like a big blockbuster release over the years, compared to Street Fighter. The ever-increasing array of crossovers and cameos helped it break boundaries and burst into wider markets, while Street Fighter has become laser-focused on the eSports scene over anything else.

9. Rock Band Vs. Guitar Hero

WINNER: ROCK BAND

Advertisement

With over twenty games released between both franchises between 2005 and 2015, it's clear the rhythm music scene was once a VERY lucrative one to be a part of. The rivalry between its two leading lights, EA's Rock Band and Activision's Guitar Hero, might have been hotly contested, but it was also a competition born from some pretty similar circumstances.

Harmonix Music System Inc. had actually developed both games along the same lines, with the initial Rock Band release looking and feeling a lot like the Guitar Hero debut that came before.

Whilst both games became exhausted with endless sequels, it's clear Rock Band's reach and popularity has always been much larger than Guitar Hero. Instead of shoehorning in one specific instrument, Rock Band has been able to pull in more fans by presenting them with every other instrument to grace a live stage performance.

On top of the broader scope and larger reach, this selection of instruments has also allowed for far more diverse and interesting spin off titles focused around specific groups and hardware. Combined, it helps make Rock Band feel that little bit more ambitious in comparison to its Activision rival.

8. GTA Vs. Saints Row

WINNER: GRAND THEFT AUTO

Advertisement

With both franchises boasting slightly cheesy and comedic tones, colourful characters and a collection of the best open worlds for exploration, it's clear to see why Rockstar's GTA and Volition's Saints Row have been locked in a rivalry since the mid-2000s.

Grand Theft Auto is the world's third highest-selling video game franchise of all time, with 310 million sales to date. It began life as a simple, but controversial, top-down driving game that involved the odd bit of killing and looting to get players from point A to point B.

GTA III and Vice City marked the franchise stepping into the world of 3D open worlds, and that's where the Rockstar era really kicked off, as the competition with Saints Row really emerged.

Saints Row and similar competitors certainly aren't bad games by any stretch of the imagination, it's just that there's absolutely no way to compete with the hype that comes with any GTA announcement.

GTA San Andreas, IV and V have all been declared as some of the most acclaimed and influential titles of their time, and the continued popularity of GTA V in particular - even seven years after its first release - goes a long way in highlighting just how far out ahead Rockstar have become.

7. Wii Vs. Kinect

WINNER: WII

Advertisement

Motion controls were the hot gimmick of the late 2000s. Most games that made use of this innovative new mechanic were little more than a collection of minigames that required a quick flick of the wrist or a wave of a hand to work. From Harry Potter potion classes to a simple air hockey table, they really left no stone unturned.

Whilst other companies did try to dabble in the craze, the great rivalry over motion controls was between the Nintendo Wii and the Xbox Kinect. The Wii has racked up over 100 million sales to date, with the likes of Wii Sports selling over 80 million copies. The Wii kept the cash flowing by introducing various extensions and accessories such as wheels and guns for fans to lap up.

The Kinect, on the other hand, initially attempted to compete with this popularity by developing its own series of specially-designed family friendly titles. However it quickly became clear with every release of a Wii Sports Resort or Mario Kart Wii, that Xbox were fighting a losing battle. This rivalry - much like most Kinects - was promptly shelved.

6. PS4 Vs. Xbox One

WINNER: PS4

Advertisement

It's fair to say that the Xbox 360 and PS3 were two genuinely solid options for gamers.

The PS3 was perhaps the more famous brand before launch, but the Xbox 360 gave the world Halo and the infamous Xbox Live craze. There's no denying that PlayStation hit back hard with the PS4, however.

Featuring the most powerful hardware seen to date, Sony practically shut Microsoft out of the gaming sphere for a time with the announcement of exclusives like Marvel's Spider-Man, Shadow of the Colossus, The Last of Us II and God of War.

For the Xbox One, they had another Forza and... more Halo or Gears.

The results of these exclusives have been pretty damning for Xbox fans. To date, the PS4 has just surpassed over a 107 million sales (compared to 87 million for the PS3), whereas the Xbox One is stuck at 46 million units - just over half what the Xbox 360 sold and even putting it behind the Nintendo Switch.

With both consoles being laid to rest at the close of 2020, it's hard to think of a console war quite as one-sided as the PS4 and Xbox One.

5. Call Of Duty Vs. Battlefield

WINNER: CALL OF DUTY

Advertisement

Activision's Call of Duty began back in 2003 and quickly grew from a simplistic shoot 'em up set during World War II to a diverse and influential collection of titles, covering a whole range of historical times and settings. The series has sold over 250 million copies and pulled in over $15billion over the years, so it's understandable why so many rivals have tried to compete.

And no games company likes cashing in more than EA. Their Battlefield series began life as PC-only title, but by the mid-2000s it was in direct competition with Activision and CoD across all the major consoles.

Call of Duty has been able to pull in Hollywood A-List stars and Academy Award winners to their games over the years to generate hype and increase the scope they possess. This allowed COD to really taking over the multiplayer scene once thought to be Battlefield's unreachable fortress, far surpassing its rivals in terms of overall sales and positive reception.

4. FIFA Vs. PES

WINNER: FIFA

Advertisement

Every year, gamers all around the world unite in slating the annual release of EA's Fifa, promising themselves and everyone around that they're definitely switching it up by buying its rival, Pro Evolution Soccer.

And then the next year rolls around, everyone buys Fifa, and the process repeats.

What makes this all the more harder to swallow is the fact that, by all accounts, PES is the far superior game in terms of gameplay. Games run much smoother, feel more realistic, feature more detailed visuals and offer far more interesting and creative modes to play through.

Fifa, on the other hand, has descended into a series that is increasingly short on new content, but painfully invested in cash-grabbing microtransactions on the likes of Ultimate Team and Draft Mode.

Sadly though, the last few years' sales are pretty damning on which of these rivals is coming out on top. Fifa 19 sold 20 million copies compared to less than a million recognised sales for PES 2019.

At time of writing, the state of these rivals is pretty lop-sided, with over 280 million and just over 100 million copies in favour of Fifa and Pro Evo respectively.

3. Dota 2 Vs. League Of Legends

WINNER: LEAGUE OF LEGENDS

Advertisement

The pillars of Massive Online Multiplayer Battle Arenas, the League vs. Dota debate is one of the longest-standing and fiercest back n' forths in gaming. Both games have huge fanbases and active competitive scenes, though League has constantly found a way of edging it out against its rival over the years.

Whilst it's generally agreed that Dota has the higher competitive skill ceiling, is more challenging for newcomers to simply pick up and play and boasts the most lucrative Esports competition in the world with its International tournament, it still doesn't have the player or event count of its Riot Games counterpart.

League of Legends currently boasts an active player count of 80 million users per month, earning it the nickname of the most played video game in the world. In comparison, Dota has been on a steady downward spiral in terms of its player count since 2016, dropping as low as just 615k in January of this year.

It's clear that League is chartering a path to becoming the absolute go-to for MOBA fans, whilst Dota's collection of passionate, but far smaller, group of fans continues to shrink with each month and patch that goes by.

2. Mario Vs. Sonic

WINNER: MARIO

Advertisement

Arguably the most famous mascot rivalry of all time, Nintendo's Super Mario was the most famous and successful 2D platformer of its day by the time SEGA rolled around with rival, Sonic.

It's fair to say that Sonic initially had the edge to this rivalry, stunning the world with impressive visuals and lightning-fast speed in comparison to Nintendo's current game engine. Mario was the safe, family-friendly title, but Sonic was what the cool older brothers were all playing.

However, from that initial rush onwards, there's only been one winner. The success of Super Mario 64 on the N64 put SEGA on the back foot in the race to mastering 3D gaming, and the Sonic series has arguably never really found a steady home in the scene to this day.

With 3D conquered, Super Mario made a triumphant return to 2D platforming with the ultra-popular New Super Mario Bros. series which hit sixty million sales for its DS and Wii titles on their own.

The final nail in the coffin for this rivalry probably came a little earlier however when the SEGA Dreamcast was discontinued and the recently released Sonic Adventure 2 became the first Sonic game available to play on a Nintendo console when it was re-released for the Gamecube.

1. PS1 Vs. N64

WINNER: PS1

Advertisement

Nintendo had some seriously high hopes for the N64 when it released all the way back in 1996.

Boasting seriously legendary games like Super Mario 64, Mario Kart 64, Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time and Pilotwings 64, its hardware capabilities were front, centre and obvious as the next step in the evolution of gaming.

It saw off competition from the SEGA Saturn, but Sony's shiny new PlayStation promised to be a much harder rival to dismiss.

In comparison to the N64's use of cartridges, Sony changed things up by using CD-ROMS. This immediately made producing games faster, didn't eat into memory and, for developers, was much cheaper too.

Third-party developers such as SquareSoft, who had been planning to release titles like Final Fantasy VII on the N64, switched allegiances to Sony, and companies such as Konami ended up releasing nearly fifty titles for the PlayStation for every two or three they made for the N64.

The titles Nintendo released remained solid throughout the N64's lifespan, but it was clear that the production and profit margins were with Sony.

Advertisement