10 Video Game Secret Endings That Weren't Worth It

200 quests for a cutscene? Pass.

By Michael Fincher /

There's always something thrilling about discovering that the game you're playing has a secret ending. It's a nice reward for those who put in extra effort to get 100% completion on their save file or for those who were simply inquisitive enough to look for alternative ways to play.

Advertisement

Getting a secret ending is supposed to be difficult and not easily accessible by everyone. However, sometimes the challenge is so great that it completely undermines the payoff.

It especially hurts when the ending itself is rather underwhelming, and you realize that all of those sacrifices you had to make along the way didn't really amount to anything special.

Sometimes it's just better to stick to the conventional way of finishing the game, as going the extra mile isn't really worth the effort. That way, you can spare yourself hours of frustration that will only end in even more anger and disappointment.

If you ever considered reaching these ends, don't bother. It'll probably be more satisfying to just look them up online, anyway. And in case it wasn't obvious already, there will be spoilers ahead!

10. Precursor Door Ending - Jak And Daxter

Like many other platformers of its time, Jak and Daxter had special collectible items called power cells that the player had to obtain in order to progress through the game.

Advertisement

There were a total of 100 power cells to find, and while you only needed 76 in order to finish the game, collecting all of them would unlock a special secret ending... or as anyone who actually got to see it would call it, a complete RIP-OFF!

In the ending of the game, the characters teased an ancient precursor door that could only be opened with a hundred power cells. There was this whole aura of mystery surrounding it, and you really wanted to find out what lay on the other side.

Well, too bad, because Naughty Dog decided to turn the secret of the ancient door into a bad tease for their next game. Once all the power cells were in place, the door would open, a bright flash of light would shine and... nothing.

Want to find out what all of that was about? See you in Jak and Daxter 2! And no, none of that collecting you did mattered in the sequel either.

9. The Gathering - Kingdom Hearts II

Teasing the sequel with a ridiculously hard-to-obtain secret ending must have been a trend in the PlayStation 2 era, because Kingdom Hearts II did so with an even greater amount of cruelty.

Advertisement

There were two ways to reach the secret ending. One was to simply beat the game on its hardest difficulty setting, called "Proud Mode." The alternative was to complete the entries in Jiminy Cricket’s journal, which contained information on every single thing in the game. In other words, you were either forced to break your controller trying to fight against significantly tougher enemies or break your mind searching through every nook and cranny in every location you went to.

Your reward for doing either of those things was a pre-rendered cutscene showing three ironclad warriors looking cool in the desert as a bunch of cryptic messages popped up on the screen. Some diehard fans of Kingdom Hearts would probably call this an awesome lore drop, but in reality, this was just a promo for another Kingdom Hearts game, "Birth by Sleep."

Well, after doing all of that stuff, most people would be dozing off regardless.

8. No Survivors - Mass Effect 2

Sometimes you're just curious to see if the game has something prepared for when you fail spectacularly.

Advertisement

Mass Effect 2 has a secret ending made specifically for when you manage to kill all of your crewmates in the final mission, but it comes at a price. And no, it's not just the lives of your companions.

First off, killing everybody on your squad is more difficult than it sounds. You need to be really underprepared for the final assault on the Collectors and then know exactly which companion will be the worst suited for a particular task. Once you figure that out, you can watch as all of your closest friends get killed, which will trigger a scene in which Shepard sacrifices him/herself to buy Joker, Normandy's pilot, some time to escape.

Great. You got that out of your system, and now you can move on to the next game, right? Actually, you can't.

Since Shepard is dead, your save file can't be imported into Mass Effect 3. If you want to continue with your Shepard from 2, you'll have to go back and redo the mission, which will probably set you back at least a couple of hours.

Moral of the story? Don't kill your friends out of curiosity.

7. Jacob's Confession - The Quarry

2022's Supermassive game, The Quarry, was a mixed bag of hilariously cheesy writing and some decently staged horror sequences. One of the biggest criticisms the game received was for its poorly executed ending: An unskippable, 30-minute podcast in which two "paranormal experts" were too busy cracking jokes to summarize the story.

Advertisement

If this doesn't sound like the most disappointing finale already, wait until you hear the secret ending cutscene you could unlock for Jacob and Emma.

It wasn't as terrible as the actual ending to the game, but its payoff was so minimal, given how much you had to work for it, that you almost wished it could have been summarized by an aspiring podcaster.

To trigger the cutscene, you had to follow a step-by-step guide on which QTEs to succeed at and which to fail. After that, Jacob would come clean to Emma about being responsible for trapping everyone in the camp. It sounds interesting, but Emma's reaction to the big reveal is so nonchalant that it ruins the purpose of having this conversation in the first place.

Come on, girl! That guy is the reason you were chased by werewolves all night! At least get a little angry.

6. Grim Reaper - Way Of The Samurai 3

Way of the Samurai 3 is the third instalment in Acquire's action RPG franchise, set in feudal Japan. There are 22 possible endings, including a secret one, but for the most optimal experience, you should probably just skip it and stick to the other 21.

Advertisement

The secret ending, appropriately named "Grim Reaper," can only be discovered after you kill every single NPC in the game.

Since the gameplay of Way of the Samurai is all about mowing down rows of enemies, this shouldn't sound all that bad, but there is a catch to this ordeal that makes it an absolute nightmare.

You see, some NPCs can only spawn after you talk with another NPC first, so you have to pay attention to who you kill and when you kill them. There is no quick way to do this without a guide, and even using one won't spare you from reloading the game after you accidentally kill a character you were supposed to leave for later.

Your reward for all of this struggle is 30 seconds of scrolling text over a still image talking about your rampage becoming the stuff of legends.

What? Were you expecting a parade in your name?

5. The Origami Craftsman's Final Gift - Paper Mario: The Origami King

The regular ending to the 2020 Paper Mario game, the Origami King, is a surprising emotional and bittersweet moment in an otherwise silly experience. The secret ending, on the other hand, is a 30 second disappointment that is needlessly separated from the rest of the final cutscene by pointless collectibles and absolutely brutal requirements.

Advertisement

To get the secret ending, the player needs to complete 100% of the game before the final boss fight, and let's just say that the road to 100% is quite a journey.

It involves beating fifteen special challenges, some of which are just downright sadistic, unlocking all of the art and sound samples in the gallery, maxing out your HP, and finally, completing four separate missions involving finding hidden objects scattered throughout the world.

Suffice to say, a long list of objectives like this should come with a proportionally amazing reward, right? It's only fair, seeing as some of these lost Toads you're looking for are hidden in out-of-bounds areas...

Well, Paper Mario's secret ending is just a short cutscene of the Origami Craftsman, the Toad creator of the titular Origami King and his sister Olivia, placing small replicas of his two creations atop a celebratory cake. Yay...

4. The Song's Offer - Furi

Furi's secret ending doesn't require you to fully finish the game, and yet achieving it can feel like an even bigger waste of time than other entries on this list, simply because of this one really annoying mechanic that is connected to it.

Advertisement

The ending can be reached halfway through your run, right before the boss fight with the sixth Jailer of the game, the Song. She will ask you to cease your quest for freedom and instead stay inside her sanctuary with her. At that point, more curious players might feel tempted to oblige Song's request, just to see what happens.

Indeed, remaining still for a couple of minutes within the area leading to the boss fight will trigger a special scene - a secret ending in which the Rider, the main character of Furi, chooses to stay with Song forever.

After the credits roll and everything fades to black, the player is taken back to the main menu, where, surprise, surprise... your save file is gone!

Curiosity is the first step to hell, they say. If taking on the first five bosses of Furi twice is anything to go by, it seems like an accurate statement.

3. John's Goodbye - Red Dead Redemption 2

Unlike some other entries on this list, the secret ending in Red Dead Redemption 2 is by no means terrible. It serves as a nice sendoff for those who fully complete the game; however, trying to get 100% completion just for the ending itself is certainly not worth it.

Advertisement

Fully completing Red Dead Redemption 2 requires finishing all of the missions in the game, filling up your compendium, gathering all of the collectibles, and, in essence, doing everything there is to do under the Midwestern sun. The number of tasks on the to-do list is so large, in fact, that you could easily finish the main story three times while completing it. What you get in return is a one-minute cutscene.

Now, to be fair, the cutscene makes for a rather touching moment. It's a scene where John visits Arthur's grave and gives him one last goodbye by telling him they're "just about done" with their business.

If you reached this moment by simply enjoying your time exploring the Wild West, the scene feels pretty sweet and rewarding. However, if you went through the struggle of beating the game expecting some kind of specific reward, then it will probably leave you fairly disappointed.

2. Ending E - NieR: Replicant (2021)

This pick might be a controversial one, not only because of how beloved the NieR series is, but also because of how well this secret ending actually ties into the narrative of the game. However, for as great as Replicant's ending E is, it does have one major flaw that needs to be addressed.

Advertisement

To quickly describe the details to those not in the know, ending E is a secret ending introduced in the remake of NieR: Replicant, that happens after the player's save data gets erased.

By that point, you have already made it through endings A-D and have basically replayed the game four times. The save deletion is meant to emphasize the finality of ending D, and that all hope is essentially lost.

However, if the player chooses to start another game after that, some things will start to change and trigger ending E, which restores the deleted save.

When you experience this ending for the first time, it really does fill you with an unexpected sense of hope and completely subverts the narrative.

But here's the problem: The gameplay up until this point is incredibly repetitive. You're forced to do the same stuff for hours upon hours, four times in a row!

With so much player investment borne from curiosity, it might've been good for one run, but actually reaching ending E isn't such an inspirational tale.

1. The Knightfall Protocol - Arkham Knight

To get the true ending to Arkham Knight, called the Knightfall Protocol, the player had to capture all of the villains on Gotham's Most Wanted list before finishing the main storyline. The list was quite long and filled with some pretty tough boss fights, but in reality, only one of Batman's nemeses proved to be so annoying that most players didn't even bother to reach the true ending.

Advertisement

Just as in any other Arkham game, Arkham Knight's Riddler could only be confronted after the player collected all of his trophies—a total of 243 green question marks scattered all over Gotham City along with irritating puzzles. Since Riddler made it onto the Most Wanted list, the players had to get all of his trophies if they wanted to unlock the true ending.

Those who had the mental fortitude to spend hours scouring the city and solving Riddler's puzzles were rewarded with what had to be one of the most disappointing payoffs in the franchise's history.

The true ending turned out to be a slightly altered version of the regular ending cutscene, and while it did shed some more light on the Dark Knight's fate, it certainly wasn't worth putting up with Riddler's nonsense.

Advertisement