10 Video Game Secrets That Tell HORRIFYING Stories

The cake isn't the only lie around here.

By John Tibbetts /

When it comes to instilling fright in your audience, sometimes it's best to be as subtle about it as possible. Especially when you're making video games, where easter eggs and secrets abound.

Advertisement

When making a video game where your audience would not normally expect something scary or even mildly terrifying to pop up, it's best to put that stuff in the background and let the player find it for themselves. That way it makes them feel all cool and smart and lets them make clickbait-y YouTube videos and online articles like - well - this one if I'm being honest.

It's a win win situation, so long as you do it correctly. Fortunately, there's a lot of cases of devs pulling it off with flying colors. While video game easter eggs are mainly known for being funny or weird, there are just as many that are infamous for giving a new layer of horror to an otherwise horror-free environment.

These video game secrets turn our favorite games into secret sneaky horror stories, and God bless them for it.

10. The Joker Gets Burned Alive - Batman: Arkham Knight

Despite being without question the worst of the Arkham games, Batman: Arkham Knight had a REALLY damn good opening screen, featuring the Joker being cremated after his death at the end of Batman: Arkham City.

Advertisement

The game literally refuses to begin until you physically press the buttons needed to ignite the furnace and roast the clown prince of crime to cinders. But of course, there is a second, more disturbing layer to this.

When you boot up a New Game +, when you ignite the furnace, the Joker's eyes will shoot open and he will begin screaming as his flesh burns off his bones and he is cooked like a Christmas turkey in the furnace.

This adds a whole new layer of horror to the end of Arkham City. the toxin didn't fully KILL the Joker, just put him into a deep coma resembling death. But he was in fact alive at the end of the story, and probably for the police autopsy that most likely followed Batman dropping him off on Gordon's car. Only to wake up just in time to be burned alive.

Gruesome.

9. The Cannibal - Assassin's Creed: Unity

Assassin's Creed Unity was infamously broken when it came out. Which is definitely a shame, because everyone rightly focused on how fundamentally unpolished it was, instead of the genuinely (and intentionally) horrific stuff you found in the game itself.

Advertisement

If you go to the Tuileres Garden and search along the coastline, you'll find an entrance that leads you to an underground cavern. Within this cavern is a cannibal preparing his next meal, and a bunch of poor unfortunate frenchmen and women about to be his next meal.

You're probably thinking that you should save these people, but unfortunately - for whatever reason - the game does not allow you to hurt the cannibal at all or free any of the prisoners. You just kinda have to look at these poor people begging to be set free by this dashing assassin who has found them...and then turn and walk away, leaving them to their fates.

The cannibal never shows up again, and is never brought up by any of the other characters.

See, this sh*t right here? This is why no one likes you, Arno.

8. P.T. Murder Reports - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Hideo Kojima REALLY wanted to make Silent Hills, which of course only makes its cancellation at the hands of Konami all the more infuriating.

Advertisement

But while he was working on Silent Hills, he dropped several hints to it in his other game at the time, Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain. Hints that carry certain...implications that no one really knows what to make of.

In mission 20, poking around the Ngumba Industrial Zone will lead you to finding a radio. This radio, unlike the others, is playing a news report. The report talks about a series of grisly killings, which eerily reflect the killings hinted at in the demo for Silent Hills, P.T.

And when you reach mission 28, you can find a different radio that follows up on the previous one. Except this time, instead of a news report, you get a chilling monologue from someone claiming to have been murdered by his father, and how he's coming back. Another reference to the events that would have transpired in Silent Hills.

This, among other things, implies that Silent Hill and Metal Gear Solid take place in the same universe. Which honestly explains way more than it should.

7. The Forgotten Crypt - World Of Warcraft

One of the most fun rabbit holes to fall down as a gamer is the idea of "secret" levels. Levels of games that aren't in the main game, because they were cut out during production for various reasons, but have just enough code left behind for you to access if you really know what you're doing.

Advertisement

Blizzard are no strangers to dark stuff in their games (the original Warcraft story saw the main character turn into the main villain over the course of its trilogy) but they've always been careful to not get slapped with an M rating when they don't want one. And since M ratings are the kiss of death to any MMO, of course they had to cut out an entire level from World of Warcraft.

However, if you know what you're doing, you can still access The Forgotten Crypt, and then deal with the consequences of that decision.

This author's personal favorite hell provided by this level is The Upside Down Sinners, where you're transported to a sunken barge filled with corpses tied to strings that are floating upwards and upside down.

Fun times!

6. The Infinity Killer - GTA 5

San Andreas in GTA 5 is one of the mot detailed and multi layered worlds in gaming history. A world so alive that you can find just about anything you're looking for within its limits. Including some genuinely creepy stuff.

Advertisement

Most people love to point to the ghost you find on the tallest mountain on the map as the go to example of creepiness in this game, but for my money, nothing beats the bread crumb trail of nightmares that is the Infinity Killer.

The Infinity Killer was a serial killer who targeted joggers, managing to go through 8 of them before being caught by the police. But the bodies were never found. Until, of course, whichever of the three heroes you're playing as investigates his burned down home in Sandy Shores.

This will lead you to the Bolingbroke Penitentiary, which will then give you the clues needed to finally find out where the bodies are: buried out at sea.

The fact that you have to endure looking into this killer's broken, violent subconscious through these poems and clues makes this already creepy Easter egg all the more disturbing.

5. The Sunken Scrolls - Splatoon

The world of Splatoon is - like pretty much all of Nintendo's worlds - friggin BIZARRE. It's exclusively populated by sentient squid people, whose only form of entertainment seems to be cutesy death matches where squid people shoot themselves with ink guns until one side wins.

Advertisement

And it is AMAZING!

But of course, as you travel the world of Splatoon, you start to notice more than a few similarities between the world the squid people inhabit, and a sunken Japan. Turns out, that's no accident.

One of the collectibles you can find in the single player campaign of the game are the Sunken Scrolls. These scrolls lay out, quite clearly, the almost hilariously bleak backstory behind this brightly colored world. Turns out that the fan theories were 100% true, and this game DOES take place in a post-apocalyptic Earth.

Humanity has long been extinguished due to climate change and global warming, the planet has been flooded, and squids have evolved to take the place of humanity as the dominant species on the planet.

4. The Story Of Ish - The Last Of Us

The Last Of Us is a game almost doggedly determined to make you as sad as possible. Every inch of this damn game is depressing front to back. So it stands to reason that any secrets you uncover would only make things more depressing.

Advertisement

Enter the story of Ish.

Looking around the suburbs chapter of the story will slowly unravel the story of a man named Ish. Ish was a fisherman who was out at sea when the proverbial feces hit the high powered A/C unit, leaving him unaffected, but also VERY homeless, forced to build a home for himself in the sewers.

Over time he built up a community with other survivors, becoming a beacon of hope and survival for anyone lucky enough to find their way to him.

But of course, this is The Last Of Us, where nothing good happens to anybody ever, so due to a simple mistake, a horde of infected got into the settlement Ish had in the sewers, resulting in a LOT of people dying and Ish just barely managing to get away with some survivors in tow.

His buddy Kyle, on the other hand, was nowhere near as lucky. Trapped in a room with a group of children, the infected right outside about to knock down the door, Kyle killed himself and all of the kids to spare them the fate of becoming one of them.

3. Milla Vodello - Psychonauts

Psychonauts is one of the best examples of being kooky and quirky on the outside, and being just flat out messed up on the inside. There's tons of examples I could choose from on this list, but the one that by far stays with people who play this game the most is discovering the secret chamber of Milla Vodello's mind.

Advertisement

When we first meet Milla, she's a nice breath of fresh air from the stern Oleander and the always serious Sasha Nein. An optimistic flower child and life of the party, whose mind heavily reflects this worldview. But do not mistake her kindness for ignorance, because this woman knows the true meaning of pain and loss.

There's a secret room you can discover in her mind that shows Raz a vision of Milla's past. But unlike the others you find in the level, this one tells of a younger Milla, who once tried to raise an orphanage in her homeland of Brazil. But one day she came home to the orphanage in flames and the children trapped inside. All of them died that night.

And if that wasn't heart wrenching enough, since Milla is psychic, she could hear every. Single. Scream.

2. Headcrab Zombies - Half life 2

If you want the best in the business at knowing how to be both subtly and explicitly horrific, you look at those ever frustrating perfectionist hat makers, Valve.

Advertisement

Even the most lighthearted of their games always carry this edge to them, as if something is always going on behind the scenes. This of course all started with Half Life, so it stands to reason that the next Half Life game would one up their underlying creepiness.

In the first game, we all rightly just kinda assumed the headcrab zombies were thoroughly dead, with the head humpers using their dead, mutilated bodies as their equivalent to giant robots.

But then Half Life 2 came along and laughed as it gave us all nightmares.

The headcrab zombies now make horriyfing noises when you encounter them. Worse yet, if you record the noises they make and run them backwards, you'll discover that they're not just garbled nonsense, but cries and pleads for help. The headcrab zombies are still alive as they shamble around, in more pain than the human mind can possibly fathom.

Makes blasting their heads off with a shotgun a lot more merciful, if nothing else...

1. Pretty Much Everything - Portal

The secret so shocking it became one of the most famous memes in the history of the internet, Portal's many hidden secrets make an already dark comedy downright bleak.

Advertisement

Portal, even more than any other Valve property, balks at the idea of telling its story straight, instead smartly putting its dark humor front and center. But through pieces of dialogue, context clues, and of course, the famous Ratman's dens, you find a much deeper, darker story at play here.

Not only is this how you learn that GLADoS plans on killing you, but that you're the latest victim in a decade spanning killing spree. Starting with GLADoS killing everyone else in Aperture Science, and kidnapping Chell as a little girl - whom we learn in Portal 2 was the daughter of one of the scientists - and making her run her little mazes forever.

There isn't a single plot point, character, or detail in these two games that isn't secretly terrifying. Turning what was a fun - if VERY morbid - sci-fi comedy into a horrifying tale of being at the mercy of a psychotic AI with a body count in triple digits.

Advertisement