It's one thing to talk about how a game can come to be known as being 'overrated', but most of the time when we do so we're talking about general fan fervour and cultural reception - just try saying Ocarina of Time hasn't aged well, for example. But what of the titles that review so incredibly highly in the first place? With other respected artforms like film and music, chances are after you've spent time with a given property for a few months you're going to have a different opinion on it than when you first started - and this is also true of games. It's definitely a question that's prompted some extremely incendiary reactions when applied to the gaming press too; how much does pre-release hype and love for a genre/developer/art style influence a verdict? And is that increased tenfold when a reviewer gets their hands on something days or weeks before the rest of us? Many reviewers mention that the very point of them doing such a thing is so that certain readers identify with their particular tastes over time, seeking out specific reviewers for specific games to get the best information before a purchase. However it's still very rare that a score be altered or retracted after release, regardless of how much opinions can change thereafter. So we ask the question - which titles were showered with praise initially, only to fall apart when it comes to longevity? Are there any you got carried away with or had the rose-tinted glasses on when first playing?
10. Mass Effect 3
IGN: 95 Gamespot: 90 Eurogamer: 100 Before Watch Dogs took its crown as the go-to complainer's dream, Mass Effect 3 ruled the roost as one of the most disappointing titles of all time - birthing rants online from Youtube celebrities such as Angry Joe and Jeremy Jahns as forums across the board lit up with people feeling completely betrayed by a franchise they'd held dear for five solid years. And no, it's not just the ending that's at fault here - although that does play a huge part in providing one hell of a sour aftertaste - as it must be said if you can't stick the landing, many of us would say don't jump in the first place. From downgraded graphics with visual glitches to reduced dialogue options, poor pacing and forced dream sequences that went against thousands of peoples' custom character personalities, ME3 was an absolute mess that for the most part seemed to forgo a much-needed critical drubbing. Speaking of that ending though, one choice quote from Eurogamer's perfect 10/10 review is about as on-the-nose annoying as it gets when reflected back upon how much content was included in the DLC: "Despite all the DLC being thrown around, the basic game out of the box doesn't feel compromised in any way." Well, if you've seen the total shambles of an ending, or purchased the From Ashes DLC (that adds a character whose dialogue is essential to the wider universe), you'll know this to be completely incorrect. There are a few things contributing to why many gamers often turn to Youtube coverage in favour of 'real' journalist content these days, and this was one of the first times we really needed to see the bigger sites put this through an appropriate wringer.
9. SSX (2012)
IGN: 90 Gamespot: 85 Eurogamer: 90 Remember SSX Tricky? Remember how the gloriously OTT, celebrity-voiced characters were damn-near loveable, screaming out an endless stream of catchphrases as you pulled off some of the most satisfying moves this side of busting out a gun-mounted chainsaw? Well, EA didn't, as come time for a full reboot of the PS2 launch game (back when launch titles were killer apps) absolutely none of what made the franchise so euphorically appealing in the first place was anywhere in the new product. Did you like the old character designs? Eddie's big afro, Elise's sexy demeanour or Moby Jones'... absolutely everything? Well it's all gone now, as each character was reduced into being far more subdued versions of themselves in every way, from voice-acting to fashion sense. They literally stripped out all the character from a game whose biggest selling point was its identity and personality. That was just the first instance in a whole tsunami's worth of frustration that very quickly engulfed all but the most devoted fan. A rewind system that was supposed to let you rewrite mistakes took far too long to kick in and was also finite, so chances are if you messed up you'd never fully recover, which thanks to levels that actively flung you off into the surrounding depths, made for endless instant game-overs. A remixed trick system didn't help either, as even if you switched back to the shoulder buttons, loading screens didn't adapt, so you were reading one thing before having to re-map it in your head. The whole thing was a total mess, and short of having to sit and convince yourself it was worth continuing to play because of how much you liked the previous titles, it's shocking this did so well without any of its major flaws being noted.
8. Batman: Arkham City
IGN: 95 Gamespot: 90 Eurogamer: 90 The debate will rage on as to which title holds up better over the coming years - and those bygone since release - as two now-legendary Arkham titles (and one slightly-naff cash-in) continue to divide gamers. Which is better; Arkham Asylum, or Arkham City? There are many who stick with Asylum as the stronger of the two; it had a better drip-feed of characters who felt meaningful, the combat was still fresh and revolutionary and the overall atmosphere and experience was far tighter. For City it's clear developer Rocksteady needed to go bigger and better than Asylum, thus they set about drawing up a list of almost every single Bat-villain they could think of - without giving some of the most interesting ones centre stage. Still, Joker's eventual fate remains one of the ballsiest moves ever seen in any piece of Batman fiction, but the run-up to his final revelations can be spectacularly scattershot, throwing random villains at you for one or two missions before the core narrative returns to jolting along. Some loved this idea of touching upon the wider aspect of just how many enemies Batman had, but for the rest of us it just wasn't as immaculately polished as Asylum, although the critical response didn't seem to reflect this very well.
7. Shadow Of The Colossus
IGN: 97 Gamespot: 87 Eurogamer: 100 Cry WTF, and let slip the dogs of fanboy-defence, as we attempt to say that Shadow of the Colossus' was something other than the second coming of the Messiah himself. There are a great many things that Colossus does very well - one of which being a to-this-day unmatched sense of scale and weight when it comes to watching the titular Colossi amble about their respective lands. Some take to the skies as you attempt to hold on for dear life, others drag you into the depths of the sea, and the rest remain on-land readying various-sized slabs of concrete to thwack you with - should you attempt to take them down. These battles are the good stuff. What's not so great, and instead can be incredibly repetitive, is after felling either of these creatures your character blacks out, only to reawaken back at a temple in the centre of the land. You'll then hop on your horse and take off for another 20-odd minutes to find another creature. And that's all you do, 16 times. Sure the whole thing was a huge breath of fresh air when it came to a pretty interpretational narrative, a gorgeous soundtrack and some very heavily repercussive final moments, but part of the reason these did so incredibly well was due to a gaming landscape that was still staring slack-jawed at the likes of God of War. So much so that - you could say - we didn't want to acknowledge Shadow's great message of player agency and consequence was done greater service on player forums than in-game.
6. Watch Dogs
IGN: 84 Gamespot: 80 Eurogamer: 70 This is one of the most easily agreed-upon entries on the list, as regardless of how much you let the shiny new console, shinier new game-hype get to you, after you'd clocked the story there was absolutely nothing to do. Recently Ubisoft trotted out their additional DLC of letting you take control of T-Bone (who?) for the sake of some more high-tech GTA-style gameplay. The problem though, is that for all of Watch Dogs' hacker-lite, "F the man!" mentality, the whole package feels like one of the most soulless, corporately gutted titles there's ever been. Whereas Mass Effect 3 sold back core elements of the story to an on-disc experience that still had a beginning, middle and end - and Destiny is attempting to sell us an entire narrative after the fact - Watch Dogs plays like an exercise in box-ticking elements from Ubisoft's other games. It's definitely easily playable and enjoyable, and in the essential title-starved landscape we find ourselves in, it was suitably lapped up by thousands to the tune four million copies sold throughout its first week. However it's very easy to identify the many, many things it does wrong on many levels.
5. Bioshock: Infinite
IGN: 94 Gamespot: 90 Eurogamer: 100 You'd be forgiven we'd entered into a whole new state of existence when Bioshock dropped last year. All of a sudden games were being talked about as artforms, and Infinite's half-baked attempts at philosophising heralded in a wave of indie titles such as Gone Home and Papers, Please that would help propel video game narratives to entirely new levels. Unfortunately underneath all that hype is the notion of wanting to love the newest entry in a series because the previous entries had been so good. Is Bioshock: Infinite a quintessentially gorgeous slab of game design, to be held up there with the Final Fantasys, Ocarina of Times and Half Life 2s of this world? We'd say no, as although you can read more unpopular opinions over here, the more you look back on Infinite as a whole, the more it shows itself to having a wealth of elements that in any other franchise would've been chastised and criticised. Things like the upgradeable Vigors not feeling like they belong in a utopian society, the city itself feeling more like a series of combat arenas than a vibrant cityscape, a boss battle with a flippin' ghost and a few final plot revelations that fall completely flat - critics seemed more than willing to lavish praise on what Bioshock was supposed to be, regardless of its many faults.
4. Killzone 2
IGN: 94 Gamespot: 94 Eurogamer: 90 And there you were, thinking things like Watch Dogs' release day graphical downgrade and Mass Effect's ending were the pinnacle of misdirection in pre-hype gaming PR. Nope, any who watched the footage for Killzone 2's reveal back in 2005 were treated to Sony showcasing a fully-CG 'gameplay' trailer that was rendered to look as if it was in-game - when in fact the whole thing was pre-made as a touched-up cutscene. Therefore what was thousands of jaws dropping to the floor in excited unison quickly turned into fire-eyed accusatory "How dare you?!" responses when we found out what the real thing looked like. Then, when K2 finally released, it was inevitably another brown and grey trek through character-less environments, populated by even more sterile teammates - just like the original. Was this reflected in the majority of reviews though? Barely at all. Sony's 'Halo-killer' was remarkably dull for a flagship system-selling shooter, and even for those who managed to stick with it until the very end, the terribly nonsensical ending was a rather large middle-finger to their efforts in the story anyway. All together now; "F**k Rico."
3. Final Fantasy XIII
IGN: 95 Gamespot: 90 Eurogamer: 100 Remember when Square knew what the hell they were doing with the Final Fantasy franchise? Before that awful Spirits Within movie tie-in that had nothing going in common except the name, before titles like Dirge of Cerberus attempted to cash-in on one of the coolest side-characters you'd ever come across, and before cack-handed attempts at transforming the franchise into an MMO had become a thing? It had a damn good run did Final Fantasy - for ten straight titles no-less - as even if you really didn't like X's Tidus to the point of turning it off, it still retained the series' trademark combat and overall tonality, feeling like a joy to explore and become indulged in, despite the often awful voice-acting. For XIII though for some reason following the previous iteration's relatively positive reception and a new spin on combat that attempted to visualise turn-taking whilst also letting you run around the battlefield, XIII did away with this in favour of slapping some menus over the top of a Kingdom Hearts-style active battle mode. Add that to environments that funnelled you down one pathway and a cast of characters about as memorable as the tattooed chick in Watch Dogs, and this remains one of the steepest divides between critical reception and user-reviews going.
2. Destiny
IGN: 78 Gamespot: 60 Eurogamer: 80 The debate rages on with Destiny - so far alongside Watch Dogs and Titanfall it either completes the trifecta of failure that detractors of the new consoles need to say the whole generation-change is a total waste of time, or it's the first title you've invested a real chunk of time into, loving almost every second. Gamespot managed to get this one spot on, as amongst the sea of hatred spewing forth about just how annoyingly repetitive it can be - or how the campaign is nigh-on non-existent - Destiny is the very definition of a 6/10 game. Artistically it's a few notches above anything sci-fi tinged from the last few months, but in terms of a complete package that lives up to Bungie's pedigree as the studio that left Microsoft exclusivity for the sake of working on a new IP, the fact that 500 million dollars later it's morphed into this... is a bit disturbing to say the least. Where do you sit on how well it plays vs. how much impetus there is to play it at all? So far we've covered both sides of the debate alongside how some elements such as Peter Dinklage's voiceover work end up affecting the game far more negatively than it should.
1. Grand Theft Auto IV
IGN: 100 Gamespot: 100 Eurogamer: 100 So according to the three main gaming press outlets we chose for this article, GTA IV is the perfect game, an unmatched masterpiece that even the expansive and award-winning GTA V doesn't match up to (getting 100, 90, 90 from IGN, Gamespot and Eurogamer respectively). However, is this idea of absolute gaming perfection deserved? There's certainly a huge amount of effort that's gone into every square inch of Rockstar's fourth main entry into the series (the seventh overall), and everything from Niko's potato-faced scowl to the Brooklyn Bridge itself is a joy to explore. It's within this act of exploring that for many of us, things just didn't sit well. That poignant shift from San Andreas' completely ridiculous second half that saw you robbing casinos before donning a jetpack to disappear off up the mountains wasn't anywhere to be found in IV. That's fine of course, but the terrible handling on the cars along with a character who's in-game actions were the polar opposite to his cutscene representation meant things definitely felt a little off. So it remains that one of the highest-ranking and critically-championed games of all time is also one of the most divisive, with just as many people backing the more serious tone Rockstar chose to employ as there are casting this one out as something that doesn't 'feel' like a GTA game in the first place. Which other games did you feel the press championed way too much on release, or did you really want to like something so much that you didn't notice any flaws right away? Let us know in the comments!