10 Video Games That FORCED You To Be Cruel

The only way forward is leaving morality behind.

By Jules Gill /

It's fair to say that when it comes to video games, as a medium, they're based around escapism. You can leave behind the doldrums of your day to day and instead engage in unadulterated fighting and fantasy.

Advertisement

They're also platforms that allow you to let go of the moral anchor and set sail on the high seas of being a sour souled bastard, killing innocents and making kids cry just for the fun of it, made all the better when some video games actively reward being an absolute rotter.

What's not so fun, however, is when video games FORCE you to be a true and blue bad boy, stripping the player of their agency or just dictating events through the needs of the plot that come across as cruel and in many cases unnecessary.

These moments create a bit of a brick wall for some players, as suddenly they find themselves acting like a total dick without even wanting to!

The games on this list dove especially hard into this gimmick, forcing you to commit actions that even Dick Dastardly would shy away from, so let's take a look at video games that FORCED you to be cruel.

10. Shaming An Uruk-Hai - Middle Earth: Shadow Of War

The beasts and baddies of the Lord Of The Rings universe may indeed be a horrible lot, threatening to either kill you or eat you at any given moment (or indeed both when the meat's back on the menu), however, it still feels pretty horrible each and every time you're given the option to "shame" one of these rampaging rotters in the fantastic Shadow Of War title.

Advertisement

"Shaming" in this sense sees our pair of heroes dominate the mind of one of their defeated Uruk-Hai enemies in such a manner that it quite literally obliterates their brain and lowers their rank by five, or by ten with some naughty nifty upgrades.

However, when the other options available to you involve turning the former enemy into an ally, it becomes very questionable as to why you'd even perform such a horrible action, especially seeing as it leaves the victim in an almost catatonic or deranged state.

Hell, if you do it enough you can quite literally ZOMBIFY an enemy. So why commit such a cruel act?

Well mainly because in the first instance, the game FORCES you to use this power. Unable to proceed by any other means you have to literally break the will of an Uruk captain known as Bruz, and the game even notes this as being a fate worse than death. Horrifying and unavoidably cruel.

9. Breaking Up Emmet's Relationship - Back To The Future

There may be no crueller aspect of human existence than to deprive another person of love, as after all it's these types of personal bond that allow brilliance to flourish and for true happiness to be achieved.

Advertisement

However, the Back To The Future video game series turned you from a doe-eyed Cupid into an emotional hitman as it tasks you with actively breaking up a relationship between Doc Brown and Edna, a young reporter he met back in the 1930s.

Now to be clear there is a very good reason for breaking up this relationship, as it turns out that Edna prevents Doc from exploring a career in science, and even uses his vast intellect to create a totalitarian society with her at the very top. HOWEVER, that still doesn't stop the act of getting Marty to sabotage their relationship in several different ways a very cruel act.

Thankfully his actions prevent the world from coming under Enda's heel, but at the same time, it leaves Doc heartbroken for many years, turning to science as a means of burying his emotional side.

8. Tranquility Lane - Fallout 3

This scenario sees the player trapped in a virtual reality simulation, as they try to free their father from the hold of the same false reality.

Advertisement

They soon find out that one of the members is able to kill and resurrect other people trapped inside Tranquility Lane and is doing just that to pass the time. Pretty horrible right? Well, it's about to get worse as this nutcase then asks us to help out with their "experiments".

What follows is a series of escalating examples of cruelty, beginning with you bullying a child, then moving to break up a marriage, and finally killing everyone in the town!

Now a lot of you will be pointing out that you can indeed activate a "fail-safe" that bypasses all of this horror by enacting a "mercy kill" on the inhabitants, murdering them once and for all, and freeing them from this cycle of torture. However if you actually look at what happens should you enact this kill switch, it's equally cruel and horrible!

You see by going down this route, the program loads in a group of Chinese Comandos to murder everyone in the community, and the last time I checked the definition of "mercy" it wasn't "being gunned down while you try to protect your family".

For Christ's sake, some of the civilians try and fight back! It's horrible to witness, and because you're trapped inside until you make a decision, it's a haunting scenario to be forced through.

7. Locking A Claustrophobic In A Closet - Grim Fandango

"No man should ever be locked up in such a small, dark place"

Advertisement

These are the exasperated words of Raoul the waiter, an NPC from the almighty puzzler Grim Fandango, or should he actually be called Raoul the waiter AND VICTIM OF YOUR ABUSE.

You see in order to progress in the game, Manny who is of course controlled by the player, is forced to lock Raoul inside a pantry while he's in there getting some wine for a client. Now, this is pretty nefarious, but on the grand scale of things not too bad right?

Well unfortunately Raoul suffers from claustrophobia, a very nasty fear of enclosed spaces, and as such his time inside the pantry might well be a prison sentence.

Luckily, and I use lucky rather loosely, his panicked hammering of the door causes an object to land on his head and knock him out, thus saving him from the panic attack he was clearly having. Manny clearly has no qualms about any of this, but the experience is so traumatizing that Raoul vows to quit because he can never look at that pantry again.

Brutal.

6. Persecuting An Innocent Woman - Ace Attorney: Justice For All

The Ace Attorney games have always been about putting the player in the shoes of Justice or to be more specific, a series of Lawyers looking to make sure that the truth comes out

Advertisement

In the fourth case of the brilliantly underrated Ace Attorney: Justice For All, you're presented with the murder of a TV show actor, and it's pretty obvious to everyone around that the fellow actor Matt Engarde is the guilty party.

Problem is that you're defending this man, and are doing so under duress because a mysterious assassin has kidnapped your friend and assistant Maya!

Therefore you have to try your damnedest to buy as much time as possible in order for the police to track down May's whereabouts.

What this translates to is actively persecuting an innocent and mentally unstable woman. It's a horrible and painfully drawn-out trial in which you attack with evidence that shakes the poor woman to the core, even though you know it's not her!

At certain points the jury even boos you, highlighting how awful this experience is. Yet you've no choice and even less chance to yell OBJECTION!

5. God Of War - Human Puzzle Sacrifice

The God of War series has never really shied away from a bit of the old ultra-violence, and basically uses the underlying current of pure rage and aggression to carry its narrative through from start to finish.

Advertisement

However most of these acts come from a somewhat justifiable place, after all, it's the Gods and their respective followers that have doomed portions of humanity and indeed cost Kratos all he held dear.

Yet sometimes the God Of War himself can just be a plain old dick for no reason whatsoever, and the player has no choice but to help him express this nasty side of his nature.

Take for example the absolutely abysmal scene in which Kratos must enter the Temple of Pandora, and finds the way to be blocked. Figuring that he needs a sacrifice in order to proceed, Kratos lowers a soldier who is trapped in a cage, and instead of freeing him, drags the cage in a painfully slow manner up a ramp towards a fire trap.

The man inside pleads for his life, asking that Kratos free him so they can both return to Athens, and desperately tries to free himself, yet for all his struggles is merely burned to death, having served as a glorified key to the temple doors. It's quite shocking how dragged out this section is, and in no way paints Kratos or the player in a positive light.

4. Killing A Baby Dinosaur - Conkers Bad Fur Day

If there's one thing that's pretty much at the top of the "holy hell that's pretty dark" list, it's killing a baby. Therefore it's pretty unsurprising that many games DON'T allow you to commit such a horrible act.

Advertisement

Yet, Conkers Bad Fur day is not your typical title, and doesn't just offer up a way to brutalize a babby, but also makes the event mandatory.

In the Chapter UGA BUGA, Conker has to make an "offering" to the dinosuar God that inhabits this lava filled level, yet before you start thumbing through the wallet to see if it will accept expired Subway vouchers, this is a debt that has to be paid in blood.

Enter the cutesy little Dino Baby, which hatchets and imprints on Conker and who is lead back through the level to a ritual site.

Well, I say ritual site, it's a platform with a massive stone slab hanging above it that with one well placed rock comes hurtling down and squishes our poor BABY DINOSAUR.

What makes all of this so horrible is the fact that not only is the dinosaur cute as heck, but even helps you out by eating enemies on the way back through the level! And what does Conker do? He just sits back and says "this is going to be interesting".

What a monster.

3. So Many Mario Maker Levels - Super Mario Maker Franchise

...Nintendo, what were you thinking?!

Advertisement

In giving the world the ability to make their own Mario levels, the Super Mario Maker Franchise unleashed a new wave of torture upon the world, so much so that some of these stages should be considered war crimes.

However, in amidst all of the brutally challenging platforming that would make even Tool Assisted Speedrunner software sweat, is an absolute horror show of cruelty.

As you can posit any of Mario's cute little helper friends, including the iconic Yoshi into any of the levels, some true sadists have used the poor creature as either a mechanism for making otherwise impossible jumps, or just to torment the player by inadvertently killing them with their actions.

These levels force you to walk through hell and cast down your allies into the firey pits, making Mario out to be one of the coldest bastards out there.

2. Winning A Crown - Fall Guys

It's been well documented by now, even despite its relatively short tenure in the gaming industry, that Fall Guys is a game made for bastard by bastards, who clearly want to drive a wedge between you and all your friends at every given opportunity.

Advertisement

This is because the game boils down to "survival of the shittest" aka who can outlast and indeed betray their way to victory and claim that elusive crown at the end of things. This means that even if you party up with three other friends in a group, time will come for you to turn your back on your friends and stab them in theirs.

Whether it's stealing another persons tail at the last second, forcing them off the ledges or into obstacles, or running along their hexes to deplete their movement options, you basically become a horrible person without even meaning to, as at the end of the day they're going to do the exact same to you.

So while Fall Guys looks like butter wouldn't melt on the outside, just below the surface is a raging inferno.

1. Literal Torture - Grand Theft Auto 5

The Grand Theft Auto series has often posited players into the morally questionable moccasins of some out and out aresholes across its time, and as such has meant that it's quite impossible to complete a mission with a clear conscience.

Advertisement

However there's mass murder and chaining explosions together for the fun of things, and then there's quite literal torture, which rears its ugly head in the mission "By The Book" in Grand Theft Auto 5.

Here the player is tasked with extracting information from a suspect, but thanks to the tools at your disposal can see you extracting teeth and part of your soul as well. This section rightly received backlash for its graphic depiction of waterboarding and other torture, but seeing as GTA lives off of controversy, this only invoked more people to play it!

It's a horrifying section for sure, and definitely challenged the player's perception of where the line of violence in video games as entertainment should be drawn, if at all, but the fact that it forced players to use such terrible means sure left a sour taste in many a mouth.

Advertisement