10 Video Games That Mocked You For Winning

You mad?

By Jack Pooley /

Bluepoint Games

Gaming can often be an exercise in masochism, with developers putting players through the wringer either by presenting an absurdly difficult challenge, or straight-up deciding to mess with the player's head.

Advertisement

Often this can result in gamers being punished for playing aggressively or getting ribbed for opting to play on the lowest possible difficulty setting, but sometimes games will go one step crueller and mock the player simply for making it to the end.

If it's the expectation that most entertainment products leave customers on an exhilarated high, these 10 games decided to ambitiously flip player expectations, ripping them a new one for expecting sunshine and rainbows, and making them likely feel like pure garbage in the process.

Advertisement

These games all rubbished and deconstructed the very idea of a typical video game ending, denying players the catharsis they anticipated when the end credits rolled, replaced instead with a knowing flip of the middle finger.

And no matter how ingenious these rug-pulls may have been, there's no denying that they left players feeling a little empty, having been brilliantly played after spending potentially dozens of hours slogging away to reach that ending...

Advertisement

10. Bioshock

2K Games

BioShock did something a little smarter than just cynically thumbing its nose at the player for doing some very bad things: it deconstructed the entire notion of "winning" in video games, by mocking the instruction-following dynamic by which most conventional games are defined.

Advertisement

Roughly 75% of the way through BioShock, the player's progress is rewarded with the reveal that Atlas, the seemingly benevolent character guiding protagonist Jack through the experience, has in fact been controlling his actions by way of psychological conditioning.

This culminates in the player having control of the game wrestled away from them, as they forcibly beat Atlas' business rival Andrew Ryan to death in a cut-scene, with no possibility of a diverging plot path.

Advertisement

Given that director Ken Levine's System Shock games were centered around player choice and freedom, Bioshock's late-day twist served as a defiant flip of the bird to players expecting more of the same here.

Instead, by severely limiting true player freedom and eventually denying them any input (literally) in the game's most pivotal moment, Levine at once passed commentary on the limitations of player agency while underlining the player's own conditioning to blindly carry out a list of objectives.

Advertisement

9. The Last Of Us

Naughty Dog

In the "feels bad, man" stakes, there aren't many games that can rival the haunting, morally contentious and much-debated ending of Naughty Dog's incredible The Last of Us.

Advertisement

The game of course casts players as Joel, a smuggler attempting to transport a teenage girl, Ellie, across a post-apocalyptic, parasite-infested United States.

As it turns out, Ellie is immune to the infection, and the Fireflies, the very people Joel is supposed to transport Ellie to, are planning to remove a portion of Ellie's brain in the hope of synthesising a cure.

Advertisement

But Joel, unable to face the prospect of losing a surrogate daughter figure after his own daughter's prior death, decides to rescue Ellie, shooting his way out of the hospital at the end of the game with Ellie in tow.

With any hope of a cure dashed, Joel lies to Ellie, insisting that the Fireflies have stopped trying to create a cure. Grim.

Advertisement

While this ending is entirely consistent with the game's tonal through-line, many players were left frustrated at the lack of dramatic choices afforded to them in this brutal final sequence.

The player's only option was to kill the Fireflies and save Ellie, yet given the agonising moral ambiguity of Joel's final choice, it would've been a perfect nexus point for players to make their own decision.

Advertisement

But it was an emphatic creative statement from Naughty Dog all the same, veering away from the expected bittersweet, happy(ish) ending for a deeply depressing one in which Joel effectively condemns humanity to further death.

By reaching the end you "won," but did it really feel like it? And that, ultimately, is the game's masterstroke.

Advertisement

8. Jurassic Park: The Lost World

DreamWorks Interactive

In slightly more overt terms, here's a game that straight-up insulted the player for their commitment.

Advertisement

1997's scarcely remembered adaptation of Steven Spielberg's The Lost World: Jurassic Park contains a special ending for those committed enough to hoover up all of the DNA bonuses scattered throughout the game.

The ending sees the player addressed by Dr. Ian Malcolm (a comatose Jeff Goldblum), who congratulates the player for their commitment before telling them, "turn the thing off, for Heaven's sakes, go outside, breathe the air, take a walk, call a member of the opposite sex."

Advertisement

Goldblum's velvet-voiced delivery makes it hard to take the insults too personally, but if you've invested enough time to gobble up all of a game's collectibles only for it to tell you to get a life, nobody could blame you for feeling a bit cheesed off.

7. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Konami

Hideo Kojima might be the gaming industry's greatest troll, given how thoroughly he has toyed with player expectations in practically every single modern Metal Gear Solid game.

Advertisement

This reached its nutty apex in Metal Gear Solid V, however, because after players defeated the "final" boss, Metal Gear Sahelanthropus, the game's true ending was held out of reach while they worked through a series of additional busy-work missions and tasks, with the unlock conditions proving frustratingly vague.

And even when you complete the game's truly final story mission, Kojima drops the mind-melting bombshell that you've actually spent the entire game playing as an imposter Big Boss, a reveal that left many fans positively fuming.

Advertisement

Worse still, several major plot threads were left hanging due to Konami rushing the game out the door, including an absent third act which would've seen Snake battle Eli (aka young Liquid Snake) on a remote island, and presumably made the piecemeal story feel a little more complete.

Players who forged ahead to achieve the game's true ending were therefore "rewarded" with an outrageously left-field twist that scarcely made sense and undermined the player's entire experience. If that isn't showing contempt for fans, what is?

Advertisement

6. Sonic The Hedgehog

Sega

Sonic the Hedgehog is a tough enough game as it is, so you can't really be blamed for focusing on simply making it to the end in one piece.

Advertisement

But if you rush through each level with a frantic urgency and manage to defeat Dr. Robotnik, the end credits will be followed by a patronising "try again" message, as Robotnik is seen juggling the six Chaos Emeralds you didn't bother to collect. Pfft.

To unlock the "good" ending, you have to collect 50 gold rings in order to enter each Zone's special stage, which will allow you to pick up a Chaos Emerald.

Advertisement

If you do this for each Zone and then defeat Robotnik, you'll get a slightly sunnier ending where the villain is seen jumping up and down angrily on top of the "end" message, having no Emeralds to play with.

But given that getting to the end of the game under any circumstances is an impressive feat, for the game to shame you for not bothering with an optional fetch quest is pretty damn rude.

Advertisement

5. Heavy Rain

Quantic Dream

The beauty of Quantic Dream's "interactive drama" video games is that, one way or another, anyone who plays through them will reach the end, of which there are countless permutations due to their multiple protagonists and branching narratives.

Advertisement

Heavy Rain, which revolves around the hunt for the murderer known as the Origami Killer, pulled an especially cheeky fast one on players, however, by having them unknowingly spend most of the game playing as the actual murderer himself, private investigator Scott Shelby.

In a top-notch troll, most of the investigating the player carries out as Shelby actually turns out to be him covering his own tracks.

Advertisement

And if that's not enough of a "f**k you" to the player, it's entirely possible to end the game with the three other players dead while Shelby gets away scot-free.

Beating a Quantic Dream game doesn't require a conventional "win" in a narrative sense, yet regardless of how your story wrapped up, you spent hours of the game blissfully unaware you were doing the bidding of a cold-blooded murderer. Gross.

Advertisement

4. Spec-Ops: The Line

2K Games

Spec-Ops: The Line is one of the most thought-provoking video games of the last decade, a riveting third-person shooter which asks deeply discomforting questions about both the nature of war and violence in gaming.

Advertisement

Though the first few hours suggest a standard issue war shooter, to the point that many dismissed it as soulless and generic, it eventually transpires that the game is a self-aware quasi-parody of flag-waving, jingoistic, fetishitic military shooters.

A harrowing, unforgettable early sequence tasks the player with deploying white phosphorus on a village, accidentally killing dozens of innocents in the process, the grisly results of which are sure to stick with players for a long, long time.

Advertisement

Suddenly, completing your checklist of objectives doesn't feel so rewarding - the dopamine rush you expect to receive from ticking off a task is replaced with soul-crushing dread as your own compliance with the game's objectives is paralleled with the reality of soldiers "just following orders."

This allegory is further cemented by the player's inability to affect the outcome, their only options being to act as instructed or turn the game off.

Advertisement

The story then culminates in a jaw-dropping finale where it's revealed that the Colonel Kurtz-like antagonist had actually died earlier in the game, and the PTSD-riddled protagonist was actually hallucinating his villainous presence in order to assuage his own guilt.

If you were lured into playing this game by its seemingly straight-forward action thrills, that ending sure did judge the hell out of you for viewing war as entertainment.

Advertisement

3. Braid

Number None

Jonathan Blow's terrifically charming platformer Braid casts the player as Tim, a man who spends the game attempting to rescue a princess from a grotesque monster. It's a classic, tried-and-tested video game formula, right?

Advertisement

Except, the devastating final level reveals that the princess has actually been fleeing from Tim the entire time, him being the monster she was attempting to escape, while what Tim thought was the monster was actually a gallant knight who ultimately rescues her.

Though Blow keeps the specifics of the narrative brilliantly ambiguous, to flip the script at the last minute and admonish the player for unknowingly being a huge creeper sure is something else.

Advertisement

It is the perfect artistic rendition of the saying, "every villain is a hero of his own story."

2. Shadow Of The Colossus

Bluepoint Games

Shadow of the Colossus is unquestionably one of the greatest video games of all time, an artful boss-rush in which player character Wander is tasked with felling sixteen gigantic, mythic creatures known as colossi in order to resurrect his love, Mono.

Advertisement

But after spending a solid 8-10 hours defeating all of the "monsters", the player's increasing suspicions are confirmed, that the colossi are in fact totally innocent creatures being led to the slaughter.

Furthermore, killing all of them has only helped free the soul of Dormin, a malevolent supernatural entity whose body was separated into sixteen segments in order to seal his power away.

Advertisement

There's no option for a pacifist run in the game, understandably, and while most players may start to suspect something fishy is going on by the time they battle the iconic thirteenth colossus, Phalanx - a winged creature who never attacks the player - the big reveal still comes as a major shock.

And as a dubious "reward" for killing the colossi, Mono is indeed resurrected, while Wander himself is seemingly reincarnated as a horned baby. Though Wander achieved his task, it was at a most unexpected cost to himself.

Advertisement

Needless to say, knowing the full context of Wander's crusade sure does make repeat playthroughs a decidedly more haunting and emotionally taxing experience.

1. Undertale

toby fox

Toby Fox's brilliantly post-modern Undertale is a deliciously clever deconstruction of the RPG genre, and players who take a traditional, combative approach to the game's short campaign will be left slack-jawed when it's revealed that passivity was very much the intended way to play.

Advertisement

The end of Undertale reveals that "EXP" actually stands for "Execution Points," while "LV" (initially believed to mean "LOVE") actually means "Level of Violence."

Progressing these attributes will lead to the game's "bad" ending, where the player is outed as the true antagonist of the story, and every "villain" you killed throughout the game was simply trying to stop your rampage.

Advertisement

Even if you decide to spare some of your "enemies," you'll be admonished for killing all the others, while being reminded that they all had friends and families who will miss them.

The only way to get the real, "good" ending is to play as a pacifist, yet even if you do achieve the happy ending, if you also attempt to try out any of the other two play styles on the same file, the game will literally beg you not to overwrite the happy conclusion.

Advertisement

If you decide to go ahead with it, in your new playthrough characters will be acutely aware of what you've done.

Worse still, if you get the worst ending first, even a subsequent pacifist run on the same file will lead to a warped "Soulless Pacifist" version of the happy ending, in effect creating an utter existential nightmare for completionists.

Advertisement

It's a brilliant game, no question, albeit one which trolls just about everybody who plays it.