10 Video Games That Punished You For Being A Thief

Even in video games, your actions have consequences.

By Jack Pooley /

There's no denying that stealing in real life generally has dire consequences for those who are caught, but video games are a whole other kettle of fish.

Advertisement

In many games, you're free to run around the world opening up chests that don't belong to you and making off with the loot, with no sign of punishment whatsoever.

But some games aren't quite so charitable, and will ensure strict and strange penalties are imposed upon players who dare to run off with things that aren't theirs.

These 10 games, for instance, all treated thieving players with a unique degree of disdain, from loudly embarrassing them for their sneakiness, to making the game more difficult, or most aggressively throwing up an extra, ultra-tough boss fight for their trouble.

More often than not, these punishments served as solid deterrents, making the act of stealing far more hassle than it was actually worth in the first place, and ensuring players wished they'd never even bothered.

As much as video games usually offer some much-needed escapism from the dull realities of everyday life, crime still didn't pay in these video games...

10. Stealing Twice From Emil Will Unlock A Secret, INSANELY Difficult Boss Fight - Nier: Automata

In Nier: Automata, players can invoke the ire of Emil by stealing an item from his home, after which he will mention that he's beefed up security to keep thieves out.

Advertisement

However, if you go back and pinch another item, Emil will catch 9S and 2B in the act as they go to leave, triggering a hidden boss battle.

To call the ensuing fight difficult is a sure understatement: at level 99, Emil and his clones are the highest-level enemies in the base game, and will make short work of most players beneath level 70 with just a couple of hits.

Between his enormous amounts of health and the sheer bombardment of Emil heads he'll fire at you, the thievery simply won't be worth the hassle for most players.

It is nothing if not consistent with director Yoko Taro's status as one of the gaming industry's all-time great trolls, though. Talk about overkill.

9. The More You Steal, The More Cursed You Are - Enter The Gungeon

Stealing from shops in Enter the Gungeon isn't as simple as just shooting the place up and running off with your desired wares - firing a gun in a shop will cause shopkeeper Bello to issue a warning, then double his prices, then finally open fire on the player and subsequently close his shops to you.

Advertisement

Instead, you need to use an active item to distract Bello, such as a chaff grenade, a decoy, or a smoke bomb, giving you a few precious seconds to grab your goods.

But even if you do successfully half-inch something, it comes at a cost: the stolen item will raise your curse level, basically making the game tougher to progress through as enemies become more frequent and deal greater damage, and item drops also become more scarce.

As such, you'll need to bargain with yourself as to whether that item is really worth the curse it will inflict upon you - it's an agonising trade-off indeed.

8. Steal A Forsworn Briarheart's Heart & They'll Send Thugs From The Afterlife - Skyrim

Bethesda's RPGs generally hold a pretty strict stance on theft, and this is taken to an hilarious and not-quite-logical extreme in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim.

Advertisement

Players who successfully sneak up on a Forsworn Briarheart will find themselves able to pickpocket their briar heart, which was placed in their chest as part of the ritual which turned them into an undead Forsworn warrior (switching out their human heart in the process).

Unsurprisingly, stealing a Forsworn Briarheart's heart causes them to immediately keel over dead, but where's the punishment, you ask?

Well, despite being instantly dead, the Briarheart will somehow still find a way to send a gang of thugs after you from the nether.

Stranger still, if you manage to defeat the thugs, you might find a note among their possessions from the Briarheart, urging them to teach you a lesson for your thievery.

Quite how they managed to write and send a note with their heart ripped out is anyone's guess. Funny, but creepy too.

7. A Taxi Driver Will Murder You For Failing To Pay The Fare - Leisure Suit Larry

Though the Leisure Suit Larry games tout dubious morals at best, they draw a strangely hard line against theft, as anyone who attempts to catch a cab ride without paying their fare will quickly learn.

Advertisement

If you try to leave the cab without throwing down some cash, or are otherwise unable to pay, the cabbie will shout at you, kick you out of his cab, beat you on the pavement, and then run you over with his cab. Ludicrous.

Hilariously, the cabbie also shouts as he drives off, "You'll not ride with me again!" Not with him or anyone else, it seems, given that your remains are now pancake-flat on the pavement.

6. Keeping The Money From A Robbery Locks You Out Of Power-Ups & NPCs - Mega Man Legends

Mega Man Legends features a morality system which judges players based on the heroism (or not) of their conduct throughout the game, literalised by the player's bright blue armour turning increasingly dark the more nefarious their actions.

Advertisement

You can become darker simply by committing acts of day-to-day civil disobedience, or you can kick a dog, or you can just become a mustache-twirling bank robber instead.

During a side mission where you're able to retrieve some stolen money and return it to the police, you can also opt to just...keep the money for yourself.

Doing so will instantly turn Mega Man Volnutt a much darker shade, in turn preventing you from acquiring some of the game's power-ups and speaking to certain NPCs reserved for morally superior players.

Worse still, there's no way to undo your darkened armour, meaning you're stuck with this disadvantage for the rest of your playthrough. Considering you weren't stealing that much money, it surely wasn't worth the punishment.

5. Getting Caught Stealing Dents Your Reputation - Baldur's Gate

While the mere act of stealing itself won't cause players any major headaches in legendary RPG Baldur's Gate, getting caught stealing and turning the nearby NPCs hostile is a whole other matter.

Advertisement

Even if you can deal with the antsy NPCs - whether by fighting them, bribing them, or fleeing - your reputation will drop, which can affect how NPCs will deal with you and also the prices you'll pay for items in shops.

Given the game's already significant difficulty level, where every advantage you can get counts, that has the potential to be debilitating.

Let your reputation drop low enough and the authorities will attempt to engage and arrest you on sight at most every opportuniyt, which given the headache it creates is generally a pretty strong deterrent against players stealing.

4. Being An Unskilled Thief Allows You To Accidentally Commit Suicide - Quest For Glory

Nothing on this list - no, not even "stealing" someone's heart out of their chest and being haunted from beyond the grave - can top the insanity of cult classic RPG Quest for Glory: So You Want to Be a Hero.

Advertisement

The game has a special "punishment" in store for inquisitive thieves who decide to tinker around with their lockpick while their lockpicking skills are still underdeveloped.

Try and use the lockpick to pick your nose while at a sufficiently low level and you'll end up giving yourself a cerebral hemorrhage, inadvertently killing yourself in the process.

Hilariously, the message from the surgeon general informing the player of their misadventure also sarcastically adds, "Guess you should have been practising on less difficult locks."

In the event you are indeed a skilled enough lockpicker, you'll bizarrely be told that your nose is now "open," whatever that means.

3. Steal A Carton Of Milk & Get Shot At - Postal 2

From top to bottom, the Postal games and every character residing within them are absolutely mental, but early in the second game players learn just how trigger-happy the citizens of Paradise truly are.

Advertisement

In the first chapter, you're tasked with picking up a carton of goat milk from the Lucky Ganesh store, with players given the choice of either queuing up like everybody else, enduring the obnoxious customers, and paying their $5, or just attempting a five-finger discount.

$5 is a hell of a lot for a carton of milk, especially in 2003, after all.

Deciding to steal the milk will result in the store's shutter slamming down and the owner, Habib, coming after you with an automatic rifle.

He can make short work of you if you're not equipped for the situation, but of course, there are myriad grotesque ways to put Habib down for the count and make off with the white stuff for free.

Even with Postal being Postal, that's quite the excess reaction for nabbing some milk.

2. Your Name Is Changed To "THIEF" For The Rest Of The Game - The Legend Of Zelda: Link's Awakening

The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening decides to punish players for thievery in the most weirdly polite, hilariously Nintendo way possible.

Advertisement

If you're able to steal an item from the Town Tool Shop in Mabe Village - which involves circling around the shopkeeper until he loses sight of you - a message will pop up reminding you that you got the item for free before asking, "Are you proud of yourself?"

Better still, your character will be renamed to "THIEF" for the rest of the playthrough, ensuring every NPC refers to you by that moniker, serving as a continual reminder of your stealing. Beyond reverting to an earlier save - assuming you even have one - there's no way to avoid the public shaming.

Oh, and if that's not embarrassing enough, if you dare to re-enter the Mabe Village store, the shopkeeper will go full Emperor Palpatine on your ass and murder you with lightning, causing an immediate Game Over.

1. Using Money Cheats Massively Increases Chances Of A "Natural" Disaster - SimCity 2000

Is cheating stealing? In the case of SimCity 2000 it might as well be, given that you're able to enter cheat codes that magic money out of thin air, namely "cass" to receive $250 or "imacheat" to net a stonking $500,000.

Advertisement

But in acknowledgment of the fact that conjuring cash out of nothing is a one-way ticket to destabilising the local economy, developers Maxis included a universe-correcting solution: not-so-natural disasters.

Both cheat codes are accompanied by the high probability of a disaster, such as a UFO attack, earthquake, flood, hurricane, nuclear meltdown, volcano, or meteor.

Clearly, Maxis is trying to tell players that cheaters never prosper, and sooner or later their pilfering from the digital void is going to have dire consequences for their bustling, ill-gotten isometric metropolis.

Advertisement