Ignore what the masses would have you believe - it's perfectly acceptable to be left upset, distressed and in-tears while playing a video game... Well, unless the game in question is Hannah Montana: The Movie, then help is desperately needed at that point. Some games are designed to be sob-stories from start to finish; the exceptional Valiant Hearts (released last year) is a great example of this. As a game based around the First World War, sad moments and heart-breaking deaths come with the territory - when loading up something like this you're not exactly expecting a bright, happy tale. However, other games take a different approach to bringing players to tears. Shocking moments which dramatically change a game or depressing story moments hidden within otherwise straightforward titles can work especially well, simply because they're so unexpected. One incredibly well-made scene can turn a game into a real tear-jerker from out of nowhere. Likewise, a well crafted narrative with a tragic conclusion can also catch you by surprise. It's these moments from games where they're the weirdest fit that stick with you the longest. If you can think of any other titles which surprisingly went above and beyond to reduce gamers to tears, leave your thoughts in the comments below.
10. Dark Souls
Dark Souls is a game that could reduce a grown man to tears. No, not tears of frustration and agony (though those are common too), but tears for lost friends, bitterness and loneliness. The minimalist delivery of Dark Souls' story has won the game unbelievable levels of acclaim and rightfully so - here, rather than be told everything in walls of text, players are encouraged to explore, theorise and discover characters, lore and storylines. In particular, the supporting cast of Dark Souls are well worth discovering, though very few of their stories end well. Solaire of Astora pops up regularly throughout the game and his cheery, bright persona is very welcome in the bleak, dark world of Lordran. However, as Solaire journeys through the undead world, his quest becomes more and more futile. His search for his own sun leads him to despair and loneliness; without intervention from the player, Solaire will be driven insane and attack the hero when next seen. Dark Souls is full of these stories of personal tragedy and loss, adding a dark depth to the world of Lordran. All of them are moving, thought-provoking and, once their often tragic conclusions are laid out in front of the player, very distressing.
9. Halo: Reach
Surprisingly, the most emotionally engaging Halo game doesn't feature Master Chief or Cortana at all. Instead, Halo: Reach delves into the Halo universe's history to recreate the Fall of Reach - a monumental event in the Halo timeline. Playing as Noble Team seems a pointless endeavor, especially with Reach destined to fall, making Noble Team's mission irrelevant, right? Well yes, but Bungie managed to take that sense of futility and created some incredible moments with it. Each Spartan receives a heroic sendoff befitting their character but the best is saved for last - Noble Six's final stand against an overwhelming amount of Covenant forces. The finale of Reach sees the player controlling Noble Six during his last stand and it acts as a survival mission of sorts as the Spartan fights off wave after wave of Covenant attacks. As you take more damage his helmet cracks, obscuring the player's vision. Eventually, when you've taken enough punishment, he discards the helmet entirely, leaving the player to watch as he goes to his death, finally skewered by an Elite's Energy Sword. Despite the conclusion of the game being clear from the start, Bungie managed to tell a story which drew players in and left them feeling attached to Noble Team, making the emotional climax even more effective. Reach is regarded by many as the finest moment in the Halo series; Noble Six's gutting farewell a big contributor to its success.
8. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater
The genius mind of Hideo Kojima simply cannot be predicted; he always has a trick or two up his sleeve to stun, shock and awe fans. Snake Eater, the third instalment in the Metal Gear Solid series, is a great example of this. Rather than continue Solid Snake's story, Kojima instead dives back into the past and creates a James Bond inspired 60s spy thriller - crazy in concept but brilliant in execution. Naked Snake (also known as Big Boss) is an engaging protagonist but it's his relationship with The Boss which really drives the story forward. It builds to an incredible finale where Snake has to battle and defeat his mentor to complete his mission - the whole thing is remarkably emotional. However, the final tearjerker comes during the end scenes of the game where Snake learns that The Boss hadn't betrayed America at all; she was playing an undercover role but had to be killed at the end of the mission to ensure America didn't receive the blame for a nuclear missile strike. With this new information, Snake arrives at The Boss' grave and tearfully salutes her, leaving her signature Patriot weapon behind too. It's a memorable, moving farewell to an underrated character in the Metal Gear Solid universe and if it doesn't stir up the player's emotions, medical assistance is needed, stat.
7. Shadow Of The Colossus
Wander's journey through Shadow Of The Colossus is a lonely, isolated one with his only ally being his loyal horse Agro; there are no NPCs to interact with and the only enemies in the game are the hulking, great colossi which Wander must defeat to progress. Still, despite lacking these typical action-adventure elements, Shadow Of The Colossus is an incredibly moving game. It subverts common ideas about gaming and makes the player rethink the game with a brilliant twist right at the end - it's an unforgettable experience. Wander's quest sees him trying to resurrect a girl named Mono by defeating the sixteen Colossi for a disembodied spirit named Dormin, who promises to restore life to Mono upon completion of the task. In fact, by defeating the Colossi, Wander is releasing fragments of Dormin which enter Wander and slowly begin to corrupt him. As the game progresses, Wander's appearance begins to deteriorate as the dark spirit of Dormin consumes him. Seeing the hero of the story become corrupted before the player's eyes is genuinely upsetting, even if the player only really notices the changes late on. Shadow Of The Colossus begins as a fairly stereotypical quest to save a maiden; it grows and evolves to become something much darker, more unique and much more emotionally draining.
6. Lost Odyssey
Most RPGs are draining experiences, due to the huge volume of time players are forced to spend with their characters. Lost Odyssey goes above and beyond this simple bond though, creating a world full of history and story to craft something immersive and exciting. Kaim, the star of the show, is an immortal man who has little memory of his past but has lived for over a thousand years. Rather than simply use that as a unique character trait though, Lost Odyssey is built around Kaim's intriguing lifespan. In particular, exploring and discovering Kaim's memories is key to understanding the mysterious man. The game presents these vague, haunting memories as short stories, unlocked by interacting with people throughout the game world. The game's main emotional hook lies in these stories, entitled "A Thousand Years Of Dreams" - they make Lost Odyssey's world feel real and driven by real thoughts and emotions. Surprisingly, given Kaim's role as a soldier, these stories carry pacifist messages, showing the heartbreak and agony of war, rather than glorifying or reveling in it. Very few of Kaim's memories have happy endings and that adds to the tragedy of a man who has had to watch countless people die all around him. Yes, many RPGs deal with death and tragedy but few do it as well as Lost Odyssey. With these incredibly well written short stories, it evokes a ton of thoughts and feelings, sticking with players long after the game is finished.
5. Silent Hill: Shattered Memories
Silent Hill is known for being a terrifying series but one under-appreciated aspect of Konami's survival horror games is their ability to provoke deep thoughts and emotions - while exploring the foggy streets of Silent Hill, players are also inadvertently exploring the fragile psyche of the game's characters. Shattered Memories is a reboot of sorts for the series, reimagining the events of the first game in an alternate universe setting. The title refers to protagonist Harry Mason and his inability to correctly recall the events that led to his arrival in Silent Hill. Interestingly, the story is told via two different means - players explore Silent Hill on foot and also shift to the present day where Harry is in a therapy session. It's a unique way of fleshing out a character and creating an uneasy impression of them - Shattered Memories really nails this aspect. The sob story reveals itself very late on, as it turns out that Mason has actually been dead for eighteen years; the person in therapy is actually his now adult daughter Cheryl, who is receiving treatment as she is unable to let go of the memory of her father. It's a shocking turn of events and, like the best plot twists, paints question marks over every significant event in the game. Depending on the player's actions, more revelations are shown about Harry's life before the car crash too, adding to the emotional drama of the ending scenes. Players might have expected Silent Hill to scare them to tears, but to discover a genuinely sad story about a grieving daughter and the literal shattered memories of her father is truly awesome.
4. Brothers: A Tale Of Two Sons
Despite looking and feeling like a simple kid's game, the ingenious premise of indie puzzler Brothers: A Tale Of Two Sons is so brilliant, players will wonder how no other developer came up with it before. Each half of the controller is allocated to one of the titular brothers, allowing the player to move and control them simultaneously, the game building puzzles around this basic concept, and it works brilliantly. The story of Brothers is told in a minimalist fashion with little dialogue or text, yet the game manages to give each brother a distinctive personality through motions, expressions and gestures. The game does all of this to lead the player into one hell of a sucker punch. As the brothers approach their goal - The Tree of Life - they have to defeat a monstrous spider (who they had earlier aided when she was disguised as a girl). Doing so comes at a cost though as she mortally wounds the older brother, Naia. The two continue but the younger brother, Naiee, has to climb the Tree Of Life alone. When he returns, Naia has died. The player then has to drag Naia's lifeless body into a makeshift grave before venturing off alone for the first time - it's unbelievably moving and shocking. The final blow is surprisingly well done too. Throughout the game, Naiee has to climb onto Naia's back when they are required to swim across a pool of water; upon returning to the village, Naiee has to take it on a stretch of water alone, aided by the player using both triggers on the controller for the first time - never before has a single button press meant so much. Surprisingly, Brothers manages to form a deep connection with the player, while hiding dark secrets behind a colourful, cartoon-esque exterior; the final scenes of the game are masterfully done.
3. The Walking Dead
Death is a common feature in the Walking Dead series, be it the television series or the comic series - it is a story about survivors in a zombie apocalypse, after all. Despite the immense popularity of the comics, Telltale's series actually has very little to do with Robert Kirkman's characters and story, instead opting to create something original set within the universe. As it turns out, with a talented bunch of writers at the helm, this was a great decision. When Telltale gives the player control of a character, they pretty much give them a blank canvas to work with. The player dictates Lee's course through the events of the game, carefully selecting his reaction to events and making quick-fire decisions which affect the game's branching narrative. Yes, oftentimes, the game is merely offering the illusion of choice but really, that doesn't matter. What matters is how the game develops an attachment between the player and Lee, adding real weight to the monumental decisions forced upon them. As the game draws to a close (more precisely, at the end of Episode Four), Lee is bitten by a Walker, sealing his fate several hours before the end of the game. Still, in the finale, Lee presses forward on a mission to save Clementine, still offering a vague hope that his bite won't turn him. Of course, it doesn't happen. Having saved Clementine, Lee eventually succumbs to a variety of injuries and Clementine is left to fend for herself. The teary finale to Lee is expertly crafted, offering one final monumental decision - does Clementine leave Lee to turn or should she kill him to spare him that fate? What the player chooses is entirely down to personal preference but either way, it's a heart-breaking ending to a genuinely great character. The attachment between the player and Lee is something that only a video game could nurture - to see it broken in this manner is traumatic.
2. Final Fantasy VII
To be fair, Final Fantasy is full of emotional moments (the opera scene from Final Fantasy VI still chokes fans up to this day) but with the shift into 3D, the series opened itself up for newcomers who may have never heard of Square's masterpieces before. Still, new and old fans alike were still stunned by Final Fantasy VII's most dramatic, shocking moment. Cloud's feelings for Aerith are touched upon occasionally by the game but the woes of their relationship are brought to the forefront at the end of Disc 1. Aerith disappears, following the events that unfold in the Temple Of The Ancients, and the rest of the group journey to the Forgotten Capital to find her. Finally, the group find her praying in the center of the city, moments before Sephiroth descends from the ceiling and stabs her through the chest with his sword. The scene comes from out of nowhere and it's deeply shocking. Aerith had been a playable character for the past twenty or so hours; for her to suddenly be wiped out and gone in such a sudden fashion is a real stunner. Emotions really flare when Cloud cradles her lifeless body in his arms and delivers a great line on the tragedy of death - "Aerith will no longer talk, no longer laugh, cry or get angry." The reality of this scene suddenly sets in and it's hard not to get choked up. Often regarded as one of the finest moments in video game history, Aerith's death scene is incredibly well done and the emotional distress it caused in fans is something that many will never forget.
1. Red Dead Redemption
Rockstar's lust for violence and crime has nulled our senses and left gamers incapable of feeling emotions, or so the tabloids would have the public believe. Red Dead Redemption shows just how stupid those news stories are. Having killed Dutch van der Linde and been allowed to return to his ranch, one John Marston returns to his family life. The game reaches something of an anti-climax here, as gunfights and explosions are replaced by cattle herding and conversations with your wife. Of course, in true Rockstar fashion, there's one final kick in the gut waiting. These epilogue-styled missions lull the player into a false sense of security, offering the belief that Marston has found peace and no longer has to suffer because of his past crimes. Then, in the game's final mission, Edgar Ross and a bunch of men from the Bureau of Investigation arrive to put an end to Dutch's gang once and for all - by eliminating John Marston. Even the final moments of Marston's life keep the player believing he will survive. He bursts out of his barn, slow-mo Dead Eye systems activated, leaving the player to frantically mow down as many agents as possible before time is up. Of course, all of this is futile, as Marston will be overwhelmed and executed regardless of how many foes he takes with him. As Marston collapses to his knees, it's impossible not to feel the tears coming. His sacrifice allows his family to live the better life he always wanted to give them, but having seen Marston adjust and make amends for his past life over the course of the game, there's little justice in this ending. Red Dead Redemption was originally written off as "Grand Theft Auto on horses" but now it's generally regarded as Rockstar's finest hour. The game creates a protagonist players genuinely wanted to see succeed before snatching it all away in one final, brutally brilliant, tear-jerking moment. A completely unexpected masterpiece. Agree? Disagree? Are there any other games which surprisingly left you reaching for the tissues? Let us know in the comments below!