Long gone are the days when games used to be enjoyed purely for their mechanics and the simple pleasure of guiding a generic avatar from point A to point B. Sure, a thriving indie scene has ensured that those games continue to flourish today, but the medium itself has proven to be as adept as any at telling one hell of a story. In most cases, the best game stories don't simply try to mimic cinema, but use the unique tools at their disposal to engage the player through all sorts of unique interactions along the way. Cutscenes and well-written dialogue play their part, but it's often those little details in the environment or gameplay that help build a story for the player; the hacked computer terminals or secret diaries revealing a character's true intentions, or the difficult moral dilemmas you have to make snap-decisions in, for example. Yes, video games are capable of telling stories in truly unique ways, and over the years weve been treated to profound, powerful and memorable stories that stand tall among all storytelling forms (which absolutely does not mean that they should actually be made into films, by the way).
12. The Last Of Us
Advertisement
Since the turn of the millennium, both films and video games have been swarmed with zombie-apocalypse stories. The fact that The Last of Us stands out from the horde then, is a testament to what a special case it really is. Following the bereaved father/surrogate daughter pairing of Joel and Ellie, who must traverse a post-apocalyptic America to deliver a possible cure for a fungal virus that has ruined the nation, the intense survival bond between them means that the player - like Joel - is prepared to do anything to protect Ellie. You start to perceive everyone else as ultimately expendable; and that's a twisted outlook that builds up to one of the best endings of all time. As well as being well written and visually stunning, the pacing in The Last of Us is incredible, sometimes slowing down for extended periods to let the player explore, before rewarding that notion with some immensely touching stories that cleverly give more context on the tragic world the characters inhabit. Naughty Dog's latest is the benchmark for both cinematic and environmental storytelling in video games. Simply as. Buy The Last of Us
11. Bioshock Infinite
The mind-bending, time-travelling story of Bioshock Infinite took a sharp turn away from the themes of the legendary first game, sweeping players up in more ways than one into a majestic world of wormholes, multiverses and religious zealotry. As in the previous entry, the plot is driven by another father/surrogate daughter pairing of Booker and Elizabeth. While the player, as Booker, is determined to complete their seemingly straightforward goal of saving 'the girl', it soon becomes clear that things are way, way more complicated than they appear, and that there are forces far beyond your control that you end up being swept up along with, rather than in control of. By the end of the game, when things get seriously inter-dimensional, you're forced to sombrely accept that you are simply a crucial gear in the machine of destiny, unable to escape the demons of your past. You go from being a high-flying hero who 'saves the girl' to a passive being who's left with no choice but to accept whatever fate must occur, thanks to some massively consequential cogs you first set in motion. Buy BioShock Infinite
10. Final Fantasy VI
Yes, the final pixellated Fantasy game ever beats the more revered Final Fantasy VII to this list. While VII was one of the most impressive step-ups in a game series on a technical level, and combined that with a fantastic story, it owes a lot to the epic, sweeping plot of VI - which marked a tonal shift for the series. FFVI was the first time the series left behind the comforts of a generic medieval setting, taking us instead to a spectacular steampunk world of heavy industry and battleships. The story was gripping, and packed with some of the series' most memorable characters, such as Umaro, Terra, not to mention the terrifyingly sociopathic villain, Kefka. The main party characters felt like a true ensemble, rather than followers of one particular 'leader', and there's something poignant about this community-spirited approach. Unlike successive games in the series, the VI storyline didn't feel cluttered or convoluted (commonly known as 'Metal Gear Solid syndrome'). It's a pretty classic storyline, but set in such a world and written in such a way that it has the edge over its fellow games in the series.
9. Fallout 2
Yes, yes. We've all heard by now that Fallout 4 has a string of memorable endings, but that still doesn't bring it up to the level of what was told by Fallout 2, which marked a watershed moment in video game storytelling. Like other entries in the series, Fallout 2 is distinct thanks to its 1950s visualisation of what the future would've been like. It's all atomic power, broken down shark-finned cars and clunky, heavy-looking industrial equipment, and that gives it a charm unlike any other. The main questline sees you having to save the villagers of Arroyo from the Enclave, but it's all the little environmental and narrative stuff that really draw you into the world. The sharp dialogue (best in the series), the weird, engaging characters you meet, and the countless documents talking mournfully about the old world are all narrative elements that fill out the world beautifully. The significant level of choice given to players in making big decisions and shaping their own stories made Fallout 2 a narrative revolution in games, and most of the great RPGs of today owe a lot to this game as storytelling goes. Buy Fallout 2 at GOG
8. The Walking Dead: Season 1
The pinnacle of Telltale Games' narrative-driven interactive dramas, The Walking Dead is a raw, pure story of survival, quite unlike any other game. You don't have an arsenal of weapons to count on, nor replenishing health bars or some kind of energy levels, instead it's the power of speech and reason that'll keep order among your group of survivors. Yet as the game goes on, it becomes clear that not everyone is going to make it through this tale in one piece. Death is everywhere, and ultimately your priority becomes protecting the young girl, Clementine. Keeping her alive is one thing, but her innocence amidst the carnage means that you're also desperate to keep her sheltered from the horrors surrounding you. While things fizzle a bit in the second season, the first is masterful, tragic piece of storytelling that proves high-end graphics and action-packed gameplay aren't essential to a gripping experience. Buy The Walking Dead: Season 1 at GOG
7. Red Dead Redemption
Warning: Spoilers below The GTA stories are fine and everything; classic rags-to-riches tales that rigidly follow the American Dream story formula. But Red Dead Redemption wasn't afraid to break away from that, following the tale of a man who truly wanted to get away, but was sucked back into a world of crime in which he had nothing to gain but survival. John Marston never makes hundreds of thousands of dollars (what would he spend it on in the barren old west anyway?), nor is he a particularly sharp-witted fella who thrives on trash-talking. He's just a man who wanted to retire into the simple life, and as the story develops you feel like he's being torn further and further away from his goal, giving the plot the feel of an unfolding tragedy, rather than a typical 'rise to the top' tale. The shock ending to Marston's tale - in which he gets gunned down in a last stand outside his barn - left many gamers upset and fuming, and yet it was in many ways the most fitting ending possible. In many games, particularly Rockstar's, characters pretty much achieve success through mass murder. Yet Marston doesn't seek success, only the titular redemption, and the game wonderfully throws the idea that he could do it through violence back in our faces; maybe the only way he could get redemption was through death? It feels very fatalistic, and kind of beautiful because of it. Buy Red Dead Redemption
6. Planescape: Torment
Moving away from the typical high-fantasy RPGs that they became famous for, Interplay came out with this plane-traversing otherworldly RPG, which became one of the greatest stories told by a video game. You control a tortured, ostracised blue being called the Nameless One, who travels among countless surreal planes of existence in his quest to discover why he keeps being reborn with no memory of who he is when he dies. Haunted by the ghosts of the people who are sacrificed to fuel his resurrections, the Nameless One is an appropriately tormented character who wants to die in peace, and escape the twisted, purgatory-like universe that echoes his eternal plight. The game is relatively low on action, and relies mostly on its philosophically mature plot to keep you engaged. leaving you asking that game's overriding question, "What can change the nature of a man?" Buy Planescape: Torment at GOG
5. Mass Effect Trilogy
Being a BioWare trilogy, it's pretty hard to separate the plots of the three Mass Effect games from each other. More so than other series', the stories of each instalment blend seamlessly into one, with the decisions you make right from the first impacting on the story later on. Looking at the trilogy as a whole, Mass Effect is a pretty classic spacefaring adventure in which you control one Commander Shepard, whose job it is to assemble a crew of interstellar races aboard the Normandy spaceship, then spearhead the interstellar efforts to combat an ancient species hellbent on destroying the galaxy. As you traverse the cosmos with your ragtag crew, you build relationships with them, and will be forced to make difficult decisions that are likely to aggrieve one crew member, while pleasing another - even getting to the point where you can choose who lives and who dies. The genius of the story isn't just in the rich, lore-filled world or the epic business of saving the galaxy, but in the intimacy of life aboard the Normandy and its eclectic mix of characters. It ultimately feels like a tale of unlikely friendships set against the backdrop of unimaginably huge events, all dictated by your in-game decisions (aside from the very end, of course), making it an excellent piece of uniquely video game storytelling that's greater than the sum of its parts. Buy Mass Effect Trilogy
4. Deus Ex
It's an incredible experience when you're first plunged into Deus Ex's near-future world of corporate conspiracies, nano-augmentation and moody nocturnal cityscapes (notice how it's never daytime in the game?). The plot is a veritable mish-mash of some of the world's most popular conspiracy theories, shamelessly throwing in groups like the Illuminati, Knights Templars, and the Bilderberg Group, while somehow taking itself entirely seriously and pulling it off. In the role of JC Denton, it's your job to uncover the source of a deadly plague-like disease called the 'Gray Death', inevitably dragging you into a world of corporate conspiracies, big business, and greed. Deus Ex is packed with lore, allowing you to break into computer terminals and generally be a filthy snoop to find out more about the game world- one which you could pessimistically say is among the most likely video game world to one day happen in real life. It's among the most mature futuristic visions ever conceived in video games, making it particularly resonate with those who play it. Like any great video game storyline, that of Deus Ex is bolstered by the mechanics, which encourage you to engage with different characters (even apparent villains), make difficult moral decisions that affect the world around you, and do your own digging around the world to get a clear picture on how you should interact with it. Buy Deus Ex at GOG
3. Dark Souls
Many video games make the mistake of battering the player over the head with an unsuccessfully cinematic storyline, but Dark Souls dares to do things differently, offering a story that the player can engage in as much or as little as they please. That's the ethos behind the the Souls series, and you could pick out any game in this series as a shining beacon of masterful video game storytelling. Dark Souls is set in a forlorn world that relies on the eternal balance between dark and 'fire'. When the flame of the world begins to fade, powerful beings in possession of 'Lords Souls' attempt to keep it alive, but in so doing plunge the world into chaos, which is where you, the player, come in. Where the story really thrives is in the player's encounters with other adventurers, all of whom are steadily deteriorating to become hollow. Should you choose to aid these characters, their unfolding stories are poetic in their tragedy and beauty (click here to read up on my favourite one). If you take the time to piece them together into the complex, wider Dark Souls story arc, you'll be treated to an awesome gestalt of video game storytelling. Buy Dark Souls
2. Silent Hill 2
Silent Hill 2 oozes creepiness, yet despite these traits appearing throughout the whole series, only the legendary second entry continues to haunt us in a truly timeless way. It's a testament to the power of the game's story, which eschews the clichés of other games in the series, instead focusing on exploring grief and guilt of its protagonist by way of horror. Nothing in Silent Hill is clear - from the misty streets to the intentions of the characters you meet - and everything is up for interpretation. The true nature of what is going remains elusive throughout, and the multiple possible endings depend on subtle, nuanced behaviours like how often you read letters and how much time you spend with certain characters, rather than big, crucial decisions you make. It's an enigmatic story akin to the puzzle-narratives of David Lynch, a dark psychological exploration that offers no easy explanation way out, making it truly unique to this day.
1. Bioshock
In many ways, Bioshock was the true coming-of-age for video game storytelling. Your time in the decrepit, ruined utopia of Rapture is not only a memorable trip, but an acerbic realisation of Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged, critiquing the book's championing of objectivism and individualism. The game is an interactive allegory, critiquing the concept of a society in which each person is completely free to pursue their greatest ambitions without considering the needs of others. Then there's the big twist, which towards the end of the game made us feel like for the past 15 hours we had pretty much no control over our actions, and were simply playing along by someone else's rules rather than our own. Of course, this is kind of the case in most games, but Bioshock made us powerfully, profoundly, aware of this fact. This is one of the purest examples of a distinctly 'video game' plot, in that there are no pre-rendered cutscenes, no dialogue coming from the player aside from the immediate intro, and very little face-to-face interaction with the game's few non-splicer characters. It's a story told through audiologs, the stunning, aspirational Deco environments of Rapture, and other fine background details of the game. Through its story, Bioshock proved that the gaming medium can be used to effectively critique philosophies, conceive its own ones, as well as make us reflect on the very nature of gaming itself. Brilliant. Buy BioShockNow, would you kindly leave a comment if you think I missed something from this list? And, if you'd like to try your hand at writing for WhatCulture, head over to whatculture.com/write!