12 Dumbest Video Game Plot Reveals Since 2010

"Right, so to save the world and stop the solar flare, you'll need to kill yourself"

By Scott Tailford /

Irrational Games

Everyone loves a good video game story - something that hurtles along at breakneck speed, throws out twists and turns that force you re-evaluate who's really on your side, and all-round, gives you a damn good reason to see something through to the credits.

Advertisement

Then... there are those titles that attempt to do the above, attempt to be memorable, edgy or otherwise impactful, only to trip and face-plant the floor.

Sadly, whether you ended up loving them in retrospect or were sat with the letters 'W', 'T' and 'F' swirling around your head at the time, the following are the most straight-up dumb plot reveals since 2010.

Advertisement

I mean, I love them anyway - mostly - but... well, you'll see.

--

Advertisement

12. The Boss Is An A.I. - Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker

Konami

Metal Gear Solid is one dumb video game franchise. You just have to love it, but when you've got a series that combines water-walking vampires, octopus-armed Presidents and nanomachine-powered cyborg ninja-warriors well, we probably should've guessed Peace Walker's big twist, actually.

Alas, after revealing that despite being shot squarely in the head in MGS 3, The Boss appeared to be alive and talking at the beginning of the game, by Peace Walker's end it was revealed a simulation of her will and conscious had been recreated and 'transplanted' into an A.I. pod.

Advertisement

This took on another level of dumbf*ckery when near the close of the game, The Boss' actual spirit took over the A.I. pod and forced the nuclear-equipped mech it was controlling to drown itself, all in the name of world peace.

If I've got any part of that wrong, by all means please attempt to clarify it in the comments.

Advertisement
Konami

11. The Joker Isn't "Dead" - Batman: Arkham Knight

Rocksteady

How Have Your Cake and Eat It Too, by Rocksteady - or at least, that's what this felt like.

Advertisement

See, after months of being told Joker was dead, definitely dead, unanimously dead and opening the game on his corpse being incinerated, you were probably settling into the notion of having a Batman: Arkham game without the Clown Prince "Tee hee hee, hoo hoo hoo"'ing all the way through.

Well, NOPE, because no sooner can you say "I bet I know who the Arkham Knight is", Joker pops back up, aims a gun directly at Batman and says, "Miss me?"

Advertisement

No, actually, Mr. J, we didn't.

Then, as though Rocksteady were terrified of writing a Batman story without the Joker, he establishes himself as a figment of Batman's imagination, turning up in even more places than ever before. Mark Hamill returned yet again - because of course he did - and Arkham Knight went into full-on Joker overkill, including a mid-point song and final showdown before the credits rolled.

Advertisement

10. The Reason Master Chief Is Being Hunted? Insurbordination

343 Industries

What's that, 343? You've framed an entire advertising campaign around some mystery event in Master Chief's past? One that puts him in direct opposition against relative newcomer Spartan Locke? Oh, you've shot contrasting adverts showing the pair aiming guns at one another, and you've kickstarted a hashtag too?

Advertisement

"#HunttheTruth" is it? Well I'm sure the fans will snap up Halo 5 in hot pursuit of exactly what happe- ah, so the Chief disobeyed a simple order and Locke had nothing to do with it?

Yes, after only a few hours into Halo 5, it's revealed that the big 'mystery' behind why Master Chief was being hunted, was simply because he told the top brass at UNSC to shove it, as he wanted to track down Cortana instead of his primary objective. Locke was assigned to bring him in out of sheer duty - nothing personal whatsoever - the two have one short tussle for a couple of moments, before Chief explains his actions to Mr. Locke, and they become friends for the rest of the game.

Advertisement

So, that "Truth" we were hunting? Yeah... sort of just a big ol' lie, that.

9. Cole Phelps Randomly Dies For No Reason - L.A. Noire

Rockstar

The more years go by, the more L.A. Noire seems to really divide people. Either you really loved its facial tech, atmosphere and general setup enough to paper over the cracks that appeared in the conversation system... or that last point was enough to break the entire experience.

Advertisement

I'm with the latter, and as the story slowly unfolded that Phelps himself was less than a saint, cheating on his wife and expecting zero repercussions, the writers decided to give him a 'hero ending', where a random body of water is set to wipe him out, lest he climb out the way.

Naturally, he shoots the whole "Go on without me" look and gets consumed in an instant, only we didn't care, as it was more good riddance to bad rubbish than anything close to a beloved character.

Advertisement

8. Desmond Has To Kill Himself To Save The World - Assassin's Creed III

Ubisoft

And you thought Metal Gear Solid was all over the place.

Advertisement

By the time Assassin's Creed had a few sequels in the bank, Ubisoft's attempt to capitalise on that monumental finale to AC II only resulted in more "All-powerful-God-demands-great-sacrifice-from-lowly-humans" bullhockey.

First came Desmond having to kill Lucy as he was 'possessed' by mystical space energy (or something), and then in AC III, we got this ridiculous setup where some universe-saving 'pedestal' had to be touched, for everything to be okay. The counterpoint was a large meteor hurtling towards Earth, which interacting with the pedestal would somehow stop (as you do).

Advertisement

With barely any thought and only two Gods monologue'ing their intentions, Desmond grips the pedestal, dies, and enacts some sort of global blanket of electricity across the world, as the game cuts away to herald in the credits from its Civil War timeline.

Advertisement

Almost as though the writers couldn't think of a way to wrap this stuff up...

7. Shelby Is The Killer - Heavy Rain

Quantic Dream

Dammit, David Cage, you were so close.

Advertisement

First you had what's easily one of the finest opening levels in gaming history with the ludicrously engaging Fahrenheit/Indigo Prophecy, "What would you do to cover up a murder?" premise, then you go and nail almost the entirety of Heavy Rain; a film noir detective thriller with a killer twist.

Or at least... it was being set up to be a killer twist, until you randomly made one of the main characters the murderer. By swapping out the intentions of the kindhearted Scott Shelby, Private Detective, and supplanting them with far more sinister ones, it made all his actions up until the finale make zero sense.

Advertisement

Why try and solve the murder if you are the killer? Even if you go down the route of "Well, killers like to get involved in their cases", why visit a random person (Manfred, the clockmaker) only to kill them and create more incriminating evidence?

It's almost as though you added this in at the last moment just for shock factor, David.

Advertisement

6. The Arkham Knight Is Jason Todd - Batman: Arkham Knight

Rocksteady

This might not have been quite so spectacularly naff if Rocksteady didn't make such a big song n' dance about Batman's new antagonist being "An entirely new character."

Advertisement

Time and again the devs insisted the ferocious Arkham Knight was someone original, only for the game to start drip-feedin- well, sledgehammering home the idea of Todd being behind the mask. Suddenly, Batman was having random flashbacks to that 'one time' he lost his former Robin to the Joker, being repeatedly reminded of it by other characters, despite such a weight on his mind not manifesting whatsoever in the past two games.

Then, wouldn't ya know it, the mask comes off and who do we have? It's Jason Todd, the most obvious assumption from day one, and the one character fans pleaded to the heavens it wouldn't be.

Advertisement

Hey, at least the boss battles against him were fu- oh.

5. Quiet Breathes Through Her Skin - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Konami

This entry could pretty much be "HAHAHA" repeated throughout, and it'd still do this point justice.

Advertisement

Just think about it: At some point, an entire team of writers had to sit down and actually get this pushed through. Not only was it pretty damn stupid that Quiet was half-naked anyway, but Kojima and co. decided to give her appearance a narrative, 'logical' reason.

Are you ready for what that is? Well, she breathes through her skin, you see. Her original skin was burned off in a horrific molotov cocktail incident, and since that day she's had extensive therapy with some rare parasites; ones that gave her a new biological makeup - replete with superpowers like super-speed and teleportation.

Advertisement

As you do.

Fun fact: Getting your kit off to breathe is the exact same reasoning given to why Jacob was always shirtless in Twilight. It's that level of thought.

Advertisement

Just let that sink in.

4. The Synthesis Ending - Mass Effect 3

Bioware

It wasn't that Mass Effect 3's ending was disappointing, or that its "Now here's an alien child to talk to" setup didn't feel all that fluid following the more believable interactions we'd had before. No, it was that one of the options just didn't feel like it made sense.

Advertisement

Like, we're told that by choosing the Synthesis ending - and as a quick recap, our hero Shepard is currently wielding a giant space-gun with infinite power at this point, or something - that this will force synthetics and organic lifeforms to merge as one.

Advertisement

Assumedly addressing the issue of 'life' and what it means to a synthetic lifeform by blending the two together, just what the hell was that going to look like? Would new lifeforms be born that were somehow a combination of the two? Would we all just black out and wake up with plastic limbs or synthetic fibres coursing through our veins? Would you suddenly zip across the room and meld with the toaster?

Tell us what you mean, Mass Effect.

Advertisement

Oh, you tried and failed miserably with the Extended Cut? Yeah... probably best to just look to the future then.

3. Booker Kills Comstock - Bioshock: Infinite

Irrational Games

Maybe it's just me, but considering a major narrative thrust of Bioshock: Infinite is tracking down the nefarious Comstock and assumedly, having a conversation about, well, the flying island he's on, I always thought it was a massive cop-out when Booker just kills him in a cutscene.

Advertisement

It's mostly in service of the final rug-pull being that the two characters are the same person, albeit from different universes - a fact you may have sussed out if you had time to say more than a couple of words to one another.

Advertisement

Either way, when this moment happened, I can't have been the only one who put their controller down and just sat there thinking, "Really?! That was the best you had?!"

Let me know in the comments what you made of this particular scene.

Advertisement

2. Ramsay Kills Ethan Forrester - Game Of Thrones

Telltale

Another 'huge amount of buildup leads to nothing at all' feeling, and it's clear Telltale wanted to kick off their Game of Thrones spin-off with a bang. Or rather, a blade to the neck.

Advertisement

Building off the notion that Ramsay Snow is one crazy son of a gun, come the close of the first episode, you'll square off against him as young Ethan Forrester, really getting a feeling for what it's like to tangle with one of the most hated characters in GoT history.

Then he randomly kills you, and that's that.

Advertisement

An entire episode's worth of narrative choices, "[Insert character] will remember that" pop-ups and general immersion washed away, all for the sake of establishing Ramsay as a catalyst for chaos - despite not being able to do anything interesting with him afterwards.

Advertisement

1. You Are Not Big Boss - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Konami

Dammit, Kojima, you had one job. One.

Advertisement

All you had to do was capitalise on the hype and deliver "the missing link" between Metal Gear Solid V and Metal Gear on the MSX. After years of advertising and allusions towards pivotal scenes that would show "the downfall of Big Boss", fans played The Phantom Pain just waiting for this mystery scene.

Was it when Boss had to save a bunch of slave children? How about when loads of his own men caught a viral infection and died by his own hand as an act of mercy?

Advertisement

Nope. In fact, none of that mattered, because you weren't even playing as Big Boss at all...

Advertisement

Whilst I can appreciate the notion of playing as a custom clone of BB as some sort of "YOU were Big Boss all along, you at home, no really!' finale, it kind of breaks the entire canon, as we now have no connective tissue as to why Boss descended into the villain he was in the very first game.

Still, at least the gameplay was phenomenal, so we'll always have that.

Advertisement

--

Which fantastically stupid plot reveals and moments just made you scratch your head? Let us know in the comments!

Advertisement