12 Problems Nobody Wants To Admit About GTA
How is GTA melee combat the same today as it was in 2008?
If the Grand Theft Auto franchise is known for one thing, it’s that spirit of sheer, unbridled mayhem. With its gleeful violence, unsavoury characters and seedy missions, Rockstar’s series has it all.
Like South Park, this series always takes care to embrace every adult theme it possibly can. As a result, it’s been one of the most controversial franchises in gaming history, perhaps outright taking the top spot.
While this controversy has sometimes accomplished little more than making the series even more popular (as controversy inevitably does), some genuine points have been raised. There are times when the series goes too far, even by the standards it's set for itself.
In addition, Grand Theft Auto has some issues beyond morality. It may be among the most popular properties in the industry, but it has its problems like any other. Constructive criticism is always a positive thing, however hard it can be to dispense or receive.
Ultimately, legions of fans around the world want the eventual Grand Theft Auto VI to be as good as it can possibly be, and it's okay to acknowledge the things we don't want to see; the rough edges we'd like sanded down.
Here are some underlying issues with the series that fans may not want to admit.
12. Grand Theft Auto V Is Played Out
It’s tough to deny everything Rockstar achieved with Grand Theft Auto V. As one of the biggest franchises in the industry, the weight of expectation was colossal, but the team delivered in a big way.
There’s a reason the game’s still so successful after all this time, but as a direct result, a sequel is all but inevitable. It’s been a very long time coming, too - seven years, in fact.
With the new console generation landing soon, a new Grand Theft Auto game would be all the reason many gamers need to jump on board.
Instead, almost as a placeholder of sorts, Rockstar have confirmed that yet another enhanced version of Grand Theft Auto V is coming to PlayStation 5.
A lot of fans are surely completely on board with this decision and will be snapping up the game (again) whenever it releases for the system. This is all well and good, but the desperation for something (anything) about Grand Theft Auto 6 is almost palpable.
There’s really no way it won’t happen, but when will see what's next? There's only so long a team can rest on their laurels and ride on existing successes.
11. Weapon Variety And Combat Needs An Overhaul
One thing that the series has always been celebrated for is varied gameplay. It’s no racing game, but there’s a whole lot of driving involved. It’s not a shooter, but players certainly spend a lot of time brandishing weapons.
The series pioneered this mixture of action gameplay - a style that doesn’t come without its drawbacks. For one thing, it doesn’t specialize in any one area, meaning that the gunplay just doesn’t match up to a dedicated shooter.
The weapon selection, from pistols to machine guns, from grenades to sniper rifles, feels rather uninspired. This isn’t to say that the series hasn’t introduced many spins on this classic arsenal (it certainly has), but the chance to customize weapons with added effects or otherwise make them more interesting would be fantastic.
In terms of melee weapons and combat in particular, the mechanics are pretty simplistic. Whether you’re flailing fists at opponents or waving a golf club at them, it’s not the most sophisticated or enjoyable system.
A potential Grand Theft Auto VI that embraced these ideas could take us to a whole new plane of gleefully violent mayhem, without compromising anything that makes Grand Theft Auto combat what it is.
10. Other Open-Worlds Are Leaving It Behind
There’s no
denying that Grand Theft Auto has always brought players an extensive city
playground to cause havoc in. Since the very first game, simply driving from
objective to objective (or even ignoring objectives entirely) has been appealing.
Quite time consuming as well, with the size of the world.
Grand Theft Auto III ushered in a brave new world of new-fangled 3D, which has been expanded upon since 2001 as technology has allowed. All of this culminated in the latest title’s Los Santos, an enormous open world that was truly impressive in 2013.
Again, though, open-world adventures have truly been pushing the envelope lately. Assassin’s Creed Origins/Odyssey present worlds of truly stunning scale, as does Rockstar’s own Red Dead Redemption 2.
Though the current-gen edition of the game looks fantastic (it’ll be exciting to see the next-gen one in action too), it’s not the incredible technical feat it once was.
9. GTA Online Has Nowhere To Go
It’s odd to
think that Grand Theft Auto V first released way back in September 2013. It’s a
mark of the fandom’s love for the series that the game continues to be as
popular as it is.
By the same token, it’s a mark of Rockstar’s love for their flagship franchise that the game’s online component (which launched at the beginning of October that year) is still being treated to updates and expansions.
Even with all this being the case, though, there’s only so much that can be done. Some of these updates have been real gamechangers, introducing Heists, Organizations and the like, while others have largely revolved around cosmetics and a few new weapons/vehicles.
After almost seven years, it’s tough to know what’s left that can really shake things up. These factors have just made the need for a Grand Theft Auto VI announcement even plainer.
8. Does Anyone Play These Minigames More Than Once?
With the
franchise being largely set in huge, bustling cities, it would be fair to
expect a variety of different games, activities and such to engage in beyond
the main story.
Sure enough, Grand Theft Auto has always offered a selection of minigames.
From the touchscreen scratch cards of the Nintendo DS’s Grand Theft Auto: Chinatown Wars to yoga, golf, bowling, basketball, arm wrestling, tennis, Beefy Baron and many more besides, there’s no shortage of timewasters to enjoy when you need a break from the campaign.
While this is something that players always appreciate, many of these timewasters are exactly that: throwaway distractions added because minigames are 'expected'.
Some do offer rewards (boosts to your character’s stats, say), but others are very forgettable.
7. Female Characters STILL Relegated To Smaller Roles
The protagonists of Grand Theft Auto tend to be anti-heroes of the highest order. Bold, flawed human beings, who have made some terrible mistakes in life but owned them and vowed to make amends for them (well, sometimes).
Another important thing that fans will have noticed about the series’ main characters is that they’re all men. Not only the protagonists themselves, but the major players in the games in general.
From Tracey De Santa to Mercedes Cortez (Grand Theft Auto: Vice City), the series has featured some prominent female characters, but they frequently take a back seat to their male counterparts.
The outcry for a female protagonist continues, and hopefully a female warrior gets her due with Grand Theft Auto 6 (whenever Rockstar decide to grace us with the game’s presence).
6. Protagonists Have Blurred Into One
There’s a delicate balance that has to be struck with the main characters of the series. Owing to circumstances, they can’t be carefree scamps who skip through meadows, pick flowers and just wish that the Summer could last forever.
This isn’t Barney the Dinosaur: The Video Game. Protagonists in this series spend much of their time in the criminal underbelly of their respective cities, committing some distinctly shady deeds.
With all of this in mind, we’ve still got to root for them. Care for them. Want them to succeed. To achieve this, Rockstar usually gives the player rather extensive backgrounds to their protagonists, explaining how they came to be in the situation they’re in.
This is all well and good, but these very similar threads can make their stories feel a bit repetitive. Trevor was one example of a character who tried to break out of a rather predictable pattern, and Rockstar went way over the top in the process.
GIving the game a trio of main characters gave the impression that the team were trying a little too hard to highlight their differences. A single truly unique and creative character or arc would alleviate the need for this.
5. The World Can Seem Lifeless And Tiresome To Traverse
Driving has always been the cornerstone of the series. It’s all about buying the most ostentatious car you can with your ill-gotten gains, turning the in-game radio to your favourite channel and enjoying another fantastic soundtrack. Even the talkshows have hilarious dialog, and are just as entertaining a lot of the time.
What
with the busy highways and numerous pedestrians on the streets, the games definitely
give off the intended vibe of a bustling, living and breathing world, but it’s
a bit of an illusion.
While it would be unfair to expect to be able to interact with each and every NPC, for them all to be completely distinct, Los Santos is just a little lifeless when you get right down to it. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild suffered slightly from a huge, somewhat barren game world too, while GTA has the same problem in an urban sense.
These are the primary issues the team will need to tackle with a potential Grand Theft Auto VI, as well as the tricky subject of balancing fast travel (a bigger and bigger priority as game worlds become ever larger) with the driving experience that's so central to the series.
4. Microtransactions Have Become More Prominent
Of course, Rockstar are very, very far from being the only culprits here. Microtransactions and in-app purchases have become one of the greatest evils in the industry.
When it comes to pay-to-win shenanigans, there are examples from far and wide. Mobile games are particularly guilty, but free-to-play has become free-to-start lately, and that’s a huge issue.
Being a AAA title, Grand Theft Auto V certainly isn’t free-to-play, but it’s remarkable just how much money Grand Theft Auto Online continues to make. How? Because there’s always something new to buy; be it a weapon, vehicle, whole darn business or something else besides.
Those Cash Cards can be very tempting. They’re designed to be.
Seeing this, Rockstar may implement similar in-game purchase mechanics going forward, which would be a great shame if it began impacting gameplay.
3. Memes And Pop Culture References Will Become Tired & Dated
There’s one
big issue with humour that relies on pop culture references: it doesn’t tend to
age well. Players who have recently jumped into such games (with the
Borderlands series’ Nintendo Switch port for instance) may find these sorts of
things a little tough to swallow.
The Grand Theft Auto series, with its contemporary/very recent past settings, offers snapshots of life as it was then. Pop culture parodies, references, silly meme fodder… it’s part of what makes the series so appealing, but this could just as easily work against the series down the line.
As seen in Red Dead Redemption 2, Rockstar take their commitment to a game’s setting super seriously (right down to the clunky and authentic fast-travel options in that title).
This aspect certainly holds Grand Theft Auto back to an extent, just as it makes Red Dead a little less player-friendly.
2. It's A Little Too Dark At Times
On the subject of Rockstar going too far, this is really just a natural consequence of keeping Grand Theft Auto what it is: shocking, controversial, adult content and then some. The team have to move the goalposts just a little bit more, take things a stage further each time.
How far is too far? That’s the key question.
Many hardened fans who have been playing since the original launched in 1997 probably thought they’d seen it all. When things got dark in the latest game in the series, however, they got really, really dark.
The infamous torture scene in the mission By the Book is deeply uncomfortable to play through, seeing Trevor in his sadistic element as he pulls teeth (a delightful stick-twiddling minigame), swings a wrench and electrocutes his way to the information he needs from Ferdinand Kerimov.
What was truly disturbing about this scene was Trevor’s reaction to what he was doing: “Torture's for the torturer...or for the guy giving orders to the torturer. You torture for the good times - we should all admit that. It's useless as a means of getting information."
This mission was entirely bereft of the series’ usual black humour. Without that to ‘dilute’ what was happening, this was a grim new darkness for the series that resulted in fresh controversy.
1. Trevor Philips Was Just Too Much
It’s news to nobody that the Grand Theft Auto series’ protagonists are… well, ‘flawed’ would be one word for it. Even so, they always have redeeming qualities that make us care about them, keep us invested in their plight. Grand Theft Auto V’s Trevor Philips is a bit of a unique case.
There’s no denying that he’s a heck of a character to watch in action. He manages to steal the show in just about every single scene that features him. The trouble is, though, this tends to be for completely the wrong reasons.
Trevor is a terrifying, dangerous man. While he perfectly encapsulates the spirit of Grand Theft Auto in one sense, it’s tough to empathise with him; to root for him.
With Sweeney Todd, viewers almost see where he was going when we just wanted the judge dead, but when he moved on to baking innocent customers into meat pies, he kind of loses that sympathy.
Rockstar took several huge zero-gravity moon steps too far with Trevor.