12 Video Game Genres That Desperately Need A Comeback

From rocking out with a plastic guitar to classic point-and-click adventure games...

By Jack Pooley /

As gamers spend a lot of their time bemoaning the craven tactics of video game developers to cheekily part them with their cash, it's hard not to feel a little nostalgic, to wish for a return to a simpler time, or perhaps to just yearn to spend a night with the type of video game that just isn't really made anymore. Indeed, while MMORPGs release by the dozen and Call of Duty continues to show healthy sales, these 12 video game genres have gone down the tubes in recent years, and it's a damn shame. This list ranges from the most niche type of simulator imaginable to a game type that, on paper, should never seem to go out of date. Nevertheless, each has gone the way of the dodo, leaving loyal fans chomping at the bit for more, and save for returning to their pre-existing library, pretty much totally out of luck. Why is this? For the most part, it's trend-related, but it can also be due to technical reasons, or because the Internet has all but killed a certain pastime, and each is steamrolled out of existence due to circumstances beyond its control. However, developers aren't completely powerless to change this (especially in the golden age of the indie), by taking a gamble on one of these genres and, if they're successful, possibly ensuring a healthy new selection of titles in a similar vein. These game genres aren't going to be for everyone (evidently), though they're a niche that still demands to be filled, regardless of what the nay-sayers and bean counters might think. Here are 12 video game genres that desperately need a comeback...

Advertisement

12. Vehicular Combat

The Genre: The name of the game is destruction by any means necessary, but always with the aid of your vehicle of choice. Titles such as Twisted Metal, Vigilante 8, Destruction Derby, Road Rash and Carmageddon emphasised wrecking your opponents as brutally and hilariously as possible, with the result being tremendous joy every time. What Happened: Despite a gallant effort by 2012's Twisted Metal reboot, the genre began stagnating by the turn of the millennium and has never really recovered. In fairness, it has always been a niche genre of sorts, but the mid-90s in particular was absolutely flooded with titles catering to it. One possible explanation is simply that, as first-person shooters have become more sophisticated and popular, the idea of using a car as a weapon has just seemed a little too silly to some, even though that's typically the whole point. Why It Needs A Comeback: Because as gaming as a medium starts to be taken more seriously by the world as a whole, something needs to keep everyone close to the ground, to remind all that sometimes a dumb, silly action game just hits the spot. It doesn't need smart storytelling or innovative mechanics: just fit a Mustang V8 Fastback with dual Gatling guns and you've got a pretty kick-a** game. Plus, with today's online infrastructure, multiplayer mayhem can be more insane than ever before.

11. Rhythm Games

The Genre: Whether you're dancing on a DDR mat, strumming away on a plastic Guitar Hero guitar or simply using a controller or keyboard, the genre has proved intermittently popular over the years. It clearly reached its apex with the immense success of the Guitar Hero series from 2005-2010, becoming an overnight pop-culture phenomenon. What Happened: While the hardcore faithful of these franchises are still playing, mass-marketed rhythm games were a bubble that violently burst when casual gamers became fatigued with the lack of innovation in later entries. Guitar Hero and Rock Band died out, and the genre has pretty much been relegated to indie games like Kickbeat, along with flash titles. Why It Needs A Comeback: Millions of dollars worth of plastic guitars sit in storage unused, and it's pretty damn sad. Plus, five years without a new, fully-fledged Guitar Hero or Rock Band game has given a lot of people the itch again. Just this week, Harmonix confirmed that a new Rock Band game was in development for PS4 and Xbox One, so as long as gamers don't need to shell out for yet more peripherals, they could have a winner on their hands, which would no doubt also see the resurrection of Guitar Hero in due course.

10. Light-Gun Shooters

The Genre: If you were alive and gaming in the mid-90s, there's a good chance you played at least one light gun shoot 'em up. Ever tried to take down Wild Dog and rescue the president's daughter on Time Crisis or splatter endless hordes of zombies on House of the Dead? Whether you did it in an arcade or at home, it's pretty unlikely you did it with a controller. No, you did it with one of the many light-guns available, of course! What Happened: The real issue is that the light-guns themselves fell out of demand with the advent of the motion control peripherals for the Wii, PS3 and Xbox 360, all of which of course have their own iterations on the current-gen platforms also. As such, the very idea of the light-gun game pretty much disappeared, as it was simply something that could be achieved with any non-descript controller, rather than being a "special" experience with a specific gun controller. After all, who wants to buy a light gun simply because it looks like a gun when you already have a functional motion peripheral? Why It Needs A Comeback: Because the majority of motion sensing games are relatively forgettable, but in their hey-day, light-gun shooters were an addictive blast to play, because the characters, plots and scenarios were well thought-out (and intentionally corny). House of the Dead hasn't had a core entry since 2005 and Time Crisis hasn't had a core console release in over 7 years. This needs to change.

9. Stealth Games

The Genre: Metal Gear Solid, Thief, Hitman and Splinter Cell are just some of the franchises that helped popularise the stealth game, where the name of the game was sneaking rather than firing endless rounds of ammo. Stealth was rewarded with an easier path through the game, and the best entries in the genre wrung enormous suspense out of every movement you made. What Happened: In order to appeal to more casual audiences, the stealth genre has been progressively gimped over the years. The newer entries in each of the aforementioned series have all toned down stealth in order to allow less skilled players to beat the game with the Rambo approach. While the freedom to do either can be seen as commendable, it's also diluted the combination of fiendish difficulty and impeccable level design that made the earlier games in each franchise so great. Why It Needs A Comeback: Because games on the whole feel like they're getting progressively easier, what with hand-holding objectives and safety net save points. Sure, harder difficulties are there for a reason, but even so, most of these games have their infrastructure altered so much that it can't help but give you a helping hand regardless of difficulty.

8. Point & Click Adventure Games

The Genre: Graphical point-and-click adventure games have been around for decades, be it Policenauts, Day of the Tentacle or the undisputed king of the genre, 1993's Myst, which for a time was the highest-selling PC game in history. At their best, these games offer an insane level of immersion that in many ways helped herald gaming as an intellectual, novel-esque medium. What Happened: The upswing in graphical quality around the start of the millennium pretty much killed the genre dead, as the methodical nature of point-and-click gameplay was seen as outdated. The "meditative adventure game" has taken on new forms thanks to Telltale Games' various episodic adventures and also by way of contemplative indies such as Journey, but it's evolved to be a far cry from the elegant simplicity of Myst. Why It Needs A Comeback: Because as games get more complex and life-like, it's nice every so often for something to serve players up some nostalgia, something more wistful and slow-moving that isn't about scoring trophies and achievement points.

7. Local Multiplayer Games

The Genre: Alright, so it's not strictly a genre of games in of itself, but from the mid-90s to the mid-2000s, the majority of racing and shooting games boasted a multiplayer component which began with local, 4-player split-screen and maybe, just maybe, ventured online too. Who can forget the kings of the genre like Goldeneye 007, TimeSplitters and Mario Kart? What Happened: The Internet happened, and as developers began to realise that people loved playing online with their buddies, they progressively put less effort into couch play, to the point that it's pretty much a rarity these days. Mario Kart 8 allows 4-player local split-screen play, but Call of Duty has now deigned to just 2-player split-screen locally. Plus, even when it is in a game, developers seem to downplay its presence, perhaps in the hope of killing the trend outright. Why It Needs A Comeback: Because, despite what devs think, plenty of people still spend a Friday night at their buddy's place playing multiplayer games in a small group of 3 or 4, a pastime that's been severely diminished by this trend. Some games will keep carrying the torch, no doubt, but it's going to become less and less frequent as time passes.

6. Extreme Sports

The Genre: Because sometimes you want something other than basketball or football in your game console, and with the likes of Tony Hawk's Pro Skater, SSX, Skate, Amped and Cool Boarders, there was plenty to choose from from the mid-90s up until about 2010. What Happened: The Tony Hawk's franchise ran itself into the ground with two unsuccessful peripheral-based games, Ride and Shred, in quick succession. Perhaps this scared developers off from making anymore skating games, because the successful Skate franchise ended the very same year, and combined with the extreme sports surge leveling out, pretty much killed the whole genre. Why It Needs A Comeback: Because there's still an audience for these unconventional sports games. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD, a compendium of classic levels from the first two games, was released in 2012, and Hawk himself recently confirmed that another game was in the works, hopefully revitalising the franchise and convincing the makers of SSX, Skate and so on to get back to the...grind (sorry).

5. (Proper) Survival Horror

The Genre: Remember the first time you played the original Resident Evil and a dog dove through that mansion window? That is the exact moment at which survival horror was born in the hearts of millions, for while its origins came at least a decade before, it was after this game's release that the term "survival horror" was actually coined. What followed were numerous successful sequels in the same vein, and of course, the even more disturbing and creepy Silent Hill series. Other successful entries include the first Dino Crisis, the Fatal Frame/Project Zero franchise, and of course, Alone in the Dark. What Happened: Much like the stealth genre, the genre was compromised by a desire to cater to a wider user-base as gaming as a whole became more popular. After Resident Evil 4 reinvented the franchise with overhauled gameplay mechanics, the fifth and sixth games completely diluted the survival horror element, focusing more on action to disappointing effect. Similarly, Silent Hill lost its footing with its fourth game, toning down the psychological terror in favour of more combat, and has never really recovered (though the upcoming Silent Hills looks very promising indeed). Why It Needs A Comeback: Because fans of the genre miss having the living bajesus scared out of them. Though indie titles like Amnesia and Outlast are still carrying the torch, hopefully Silent Hills will be the big-budget survival horror game to bring the genre back for a second golden age. Call of Duty effortlessly manages an adrenaline rush with its breathless combat, but to drill true fear into a gamer is much more difficult, and when it happens, it's something else entirely...

4. Flight Simulators

The Genre: Though the flight sim genre was held up through the 2000s by series such as IL-2 Sturmovik, the undisputed king was Microsoft Flight Simulator, which launched way back in 1982 and released its last edition in 2006. So authentic was the game by this point that it could actually be used to train pilots, and for those without the money or nerve to do it for real, it was a way to experience a fraction of the thrill of flying an aircraft. What Happened: It was a niche genre to begin with, but as the gaming audience became larger in the mid-2000s, it just didn't seem profitable to keep these games pumping out, and so short of action-based efforts like H.A.W.X., War Thunder and so on, the more delicate side of the genre died out. Why It Needs A Comeback: Because it's been almost a decade since the last MSF game came out (aside from last year's enhanced Steam edition), and enthusiasts are long overdue an upgrade of their old software. If there can be train simulators, garbage disposal simulators and even pigeon dating simulators in the modern age, there has to be room for a resurgence of authentic flight sims.

3. Insane Arena Shooters

The Genre: Anyone who owned a PC in the late 90s onwards has probably played one variation of Quake, Unreal Tournament or Doom, and each delivered gloriously insane arena-based deathmatches in spades, whether with bots or online. The focus was on a fast pace, futuristic weapons, deep-voiced announcers and a ton of hilariously over-the-top gore. What Happened: Call of Duty happened. While the CoD series itself boasted an increasingly fast pace and occasional flirtation with advanced weaponry, it's the stat-tracking and obsession with challenges and achievements that caused it to bury the arena shooter, which simply had no interest in introducing leveling mechanics and the such like. Quake Live continues to endure as an in-browser game, but for all intents and purposes, the genre is pretty much dead. Why It Needs A Comeback: Because not everything needs to be relentlessly stat-tracked, and CoD just can't deliver the same brilliant absurdity because it's still at its core a military shooter. While a free-to-play Unreal Tournament is on the way and Doom 4 is in development, few have much faith that either of these are going to be able to revitalise a genre that's been steamrolled by Activision's commercial juggernaut.

2. Hacking Simulators

The Genre: This is easily the most niche genre on this list, such that it's largely populated by online and flash games, with the only major commercial hacking sim being 2001's cult classic text-based game Uplink. The goal in these games is either to bring down a website or a corporation via a series of hacking operations which, of course, have been somewhat simplified for the game. Still, it made you feel like a total bada**. What Happened: Like the way that most 1990s movies dealt with computing, these video games fell out of vogue as your average consumer became more acquainted with how computers actually work, and so the superficial complexity of the hacking games became more transparent. Plus, there are only so many players a) interested in hacking and b) who want to play a game with minimal graphics driven by reading and text-based communications. Why It Needs A Comeback: Because Uplink was an awesome game, and if a new hacking sim used the Internet in a myriad of clever ways, it could completely revolutionise the scarcely-recognised genre.

1. 3D Platformers

The Genre: Platforming games are one of the pastime's mainstays, and it was in the mid-90s that it was completely revolutionised with 3D graphics, as the likes of Super Mario 64, the Crash Bandicoot series, Banjo Kazooie, Spyro the Dragon, Sonic Adventure, Jak & Daxter, Ratchet & Clank and so many more totally blew gamers away. What Happened: The genre moved on in a completely different way: the seeds were sewn early with Tomb Raider's platform-based complexity, and fed through to the likes of Prince of Persia and Assassin's Creed. The platforming genre still has Mario going strong, though on the whole steered back towards 2D platforming with indie games such as Fez, Rogue Legacy, Shovel Knight, Rayman Legends and so on. Why It Needs A Comeback: Because some of your fondest memories from the 90s were probably spent playing the ingenious (and often infuriatingly difficult) levels on Crash Bandicoot, and it's a crime that the series has just died a death (despite numerous teases of its return). There's still a place for this sort of game, even if Knack's critical failure might suggest otherwise, as long as they're imaginative and boast a mascot that's appealing to audiences young and old. Which ailing video game genres are you desperate to see make a triumphant comeback? Shout it out in the comments!