15 Fan Demands For The Fable Reboot
And so our story begins.
There was a time when Fable was viewed as one of Microsoft's big name series alongside Forza and Halo. "Xbox's own Zelda" people called it, and without a trace of irony. Sadly, a fundamental misunderstanding of what fans saw in the game and an insistence on using the latest gimmicks led to mismanagement of the series and a general decline in the quality of the games. Fable, once a shining star in Microsoft's portfolio, was cancelled midway through production of Fable Legends, and Lionhead Studios was shut down.
Now, after years of whispered rumours, Fable is finally returning with Playground Games at the helm. Billed as a reboot of the series, nobody truly knows what to expect from the game. Will it be an expansive open world, ala The Witcher 3, or a more considered sandbox filled with minigames like the Yakuza series? Which features will it pull from the Blackadder style comedies of the original games and which will fall by the wayside?
Here are fifteen features, some new and some stolen from past games, that we think the new Fable needs to survive and thrive.
15. Childhood
One of the more original hallmarks of the Fable series is that the games begin with you playing a younger and more innocent version of your character. While Fable III showed us a prince who had no idea about the world, the first two games in the series had players cast in the role of children to begin with. Part tutorial to get players used to the controls before the stakes were real, these sections were also used to set the story up.
The childhood section would be a great way to create unique characters, with both a set mission that will lead to adulthood and a series of side activities that further define the Hero before they've even dreamed of that title. Those getting into a lot of fights may start with a long-standing scar. Those who join a gang may have criminal contacts in the future. Those who are good and go to school will be able to read books that are beyond other characters. Those who work an apprenticeship may start with higher skill levels in that job and perhaps a little more money saved up.
Give players a meaningful childhood where they can invest in their future.
14. Automatic Levelling
In the first two Fable games, characters levelled up by collecting experience orbs that they'd gain after combat. Those orbs would contain either melee, ranged, or magic experience which could be spent on abilities in those trees, alongside a large amount of general experience that could be spent on anything. So a guy could wade into enough enemies with a gigantic greatsword and then learn how to cast better spells.
Fable III introduced two new systems. Hidden behind the absolutely terrible Road To Rule, so well in fact that a majority of players don't even realise it's there, is a pretty neat auto-levelling system where the Hero would get better at magic by casting spells, better at melee attacks by hitting things, and better at shooting things by, well, shooting things. No more sucking down - ahem - balls or general experience making your development not match your activities.
This should be reintroduced in the new game, with a few more stats affected by different activities. Someone using a small weapon should get stronger in different ways to someone using a greatsword, after all.
13. More Realistic Morphing
As characters in Fable got stronger, the Hero's muscles would grow, and they'd become taller like the archers of legend as they became a better shot. But these character morphs weren't just tied to the character's stats.
Beating San Andreas to market by a month and a half, Fable was the first game that allowed a character to get fat if they ate fattening foods. Murdering innocents would make the character grow horns and get glowing red eyes to show how evil they were, while doing good deeds would eventually make a halo evident. It's best thought of as what those listening to this story around a campfire many years later are imagining of the person based on their actions.
Fable wouldn't be Fable without morphing, but I'm hoping that the new technology will allow them to be a bit more subtle with the alignment-based morphs. Let muscles grow when swinging weapons and skin go sallow from eating bad foods or being cruel, but nobody should be growing horns.
At least, not in the main gameplay. Taking an idea from the Fable box art, perhaps have reflections in water and mirrors show the more outlandish devilish and angelic morphs.
12. Interesting Magic
One of the strengths of the first Fable game and its semi-expansion, The Lost Chapters, was the list of spells available to the player. Among RPG staples like Fireball and Lightning, players found some much more interesting effects.
Berserk not only added to the power of melee attacks, but took the Hero beyond their maximum Physical morph, leaving them a grunting monstrous hulk-like being. Multi-arrow loaded a bow with several shots, all of which would be fired in different arcs but home in on the target. Assassin Rush would hurl the Hero at their opponent, teleporting them behind at the last moment for an opportune strike. Willpower abilities like these helped create some unique characters, and also made the world itself seem that little bit more magical.
Sadly, many of the non-damaging spells were lost by the time of the next game, and Fable III finished the job by removing anything that wasn't a direct damage dealer. Playground Games need to look at the original game and bring back some of those unique spells, letting Will players create interesting characters rather than the same attack based spell-slingers.
11. No More Will Potions
One of the reasons we lost so many interesting spells after the first game was the move from a more traditional MP (Will in Fable's vernacular) based system to a new system where spells were charged and released either as aimed or area effect versions.
The developers behind the new magic system didn't like the idea that these wizards of incredible power were so reliant on quaffing Will potions to keep that power up. The term "wizardly viagra" was hilariously thrown around. While this system was widely maligned when it was first revealed, this was more to do with the loss of most of the signature Fable Will abilities than it was the system itself.
The idea behind this system is not only sound, but something that RPGs have been missing for a long time. While Fable II didn't quite manage to perfect it, there are only some minor tweaks needed to make this work well in the new game, both for dealing damage and the more interesting abilities from the last entry. Cooldowns and minimum charging times would make spellcasting a more tactical affair without having to stop the action and down a bottle of blue liquid.
10. Combat Skills
There are those who, quite rightly, deride Fable II for simplifying the popular formula from the original game rather than building on it. So much was taken away from that original promise, in fact, that it's sometimes hard to look at what the game brought to the series. While the majority of that focus will be on the dog, what's often overlooked is the addition of combat skills.
Both the Brutal Styles and Dextrous Styles skill chains started with basic defensive moves like blocking attacks and rolling out of the way. As Heroes progressed along those paths, they'd learn to flick their aim to different body parts while locked onto an enemy, perform powerful flourishes, and devastating ripostes that could allow even the least powerful Hero to kill an enemy in one hit.
These abilities absolutely must make a return for the reboot and be brought into modern gameplay stylings. Flourishes should be different for each weapon type and different again for legendary weapons no matter the type. Even something as simple as the dodge might be different depending on who uses it, with a fast warrior simply sidestepping a blow while a Will user teleports slightly away from the attack.
9. Story Based Defeat System
One of the first features that was spoken about for Fable, back in the Project Ego days, was a story based defeat system instead of a game over screen. Basically, whatever you did and however you failed would continue your personal story.
If you were journeying with a partner then you'd be taken down by beasts but they'd fight to get you back up again, leaving you with a lasting scar but ready to continue the mission. Should you get defeated alone in the woods, then a passing hunter or witch might find you and nurse you back to health, leaving you in debt to them and possibly opening up new missions. Should you be defeated by guards then you'd be arrested and spend time in jail, getting older and missing out on timed quests. Should you be beaten by bandits who are raiding a village, you'll not only be captured, but the village would be destroyed and anything the Hero could have done there in the future would have been lost for that playthrough.
So much better than heroically overcoming all enemies at the cost of a single scar, this system was a storytelling great that was never even given a chance.
8. A Modern Open World
Think back to the original Fable, in particular the city of Bowerstone. In the original tests for the game, Bowerstone was a proud city with all districts in a single region of the game. Just under a hundred NPCs roamed that city, from school children to drunks to merchants and nobles and even a few other adventurers. Of course, fans of the series know it didn't end up that way. The realities of the hardware meant that Bowerstone was soon split into four chunks with substantially fewer people wandering around, and this trend continued into the later games of the series.
While this allowed the games to look quite beautiful and carry that darker fairy tale feeling with them in some places, modern games are just as capable of offering the same sorts of beauty within a streaming world filled with things to do. If the Fable reboot wants to be relevant as a next-generation experience it can't just look beautiful. It must offer the same sort of world that gamers have gotten used to in their RPGs, just filled with the classic Fable charm.
7. More Reasons To Go Home
One of the hallmarks of the Fable games are the ability to buy a home, marry, and start a family. There's nothing quite like coming home after a time on the road, washing off the dust and blood, and spending time with loved ones. Sadly, having all communication relegated to the emotes system made these pretty unfulfilling experiences, even for the most dedicated roleplayers looking to destress their Heroes.
I would suggest introducing a system that rewards players for coming home with several levels of bonuses based on what they do when they're there. Spend some time having a few drinks in the pub with friends or playing gambling minigames, perhaps have some quality time with your partner (or paramour), maybe just take your kid to the local fairground and play some games, sit down with the family and have a meal, or just sleep in your own bed.
Once the Hero is refreshed and ready to go out adventuring again, they'll find themselves leveling up faster, having minor health regeneration, and a variety of other bonuses that make adventuring a bit easier and coming home a bit more worth it.
6. Local Twade Goods
While we're in our home town, why don't we deal with something that isn't just a weakness in Fable? In all RPGs, towns tend to be designed with the progression of the story in mind. Weapons on the other side of the world from the starting village always seem to be made out of some more damaging material than those the player has access to early on, which makes no sense in most RPG worlds.
As there needs to be some gameplay differentiation between what is available in these towns, we suggest making their items functionally different rather than simply more powerful. Towns in areas with faster enemies might have weapons that swing faster, while those facing things that can heal quickly may offer serrated blades and piercing clubs. Balverine-infested areas may offer silver weapons, those facing Trolls may have to rely on serrated blades to rend their armour, while those often facing faster enemies like Nymphs may find that faster-swinging weapons suit their style.
With each town offering a new kind of armament that is better suited to their area, but also has generally useful properties, the player may find themselves spoilt for choice.
5. Advanced Real Estate
Speaking of businesses, why don't we take part in one of Fable's other main town-based activities? No, we're not talking about farting in the face of a passing villager, for once. We're talking about a signature feature of Fable that, like so much of the franchise, is so shallow it's begging to be built on for the reboot: real estate.
While the early real estate dabblings should be simple, affecting the economy of each town as they already do, the player should have more control if they want to immerse themselves in this aspect. This can be achieved through the use of a large office space in each town that enables the Hero to have more control over their business empire, such as changing any shop into any other sort. Want to change the bookshop into another pub? Expect more drunks staggering through the town. Want to add a criminal enterprise in the back room of the blacksmith? You'll see more thugs in the streets at night.
The office would also enable trade routes to be set up between businesses in different cities, and give the player a collector who grabs the rent in town and stores it in one location.
4. Replayable Missions
In Fable, one of the first enemies the Hero Of Oakvale comes across is the Wasp Queen. A boss creature that's terrorizing the picnic area, this creature tests his limits almost as soon as he's left the Guild. It's never seen again, and that seems like a waste. Now, imagine if the Hero is a little lax about killing wasps during his adventures, allowing them to get stronger until a new Wasp Queen is spawned. The mission suddenly becomes available at the Map Table in the Guild Of Heroes again, and that encounter is the result of the events in the world.
This isn't the only way to make some missions replayable though. Imagine if the Hero keeps a journal of their exploits that they can read through again and wonder "What if..?" about their past. Opening that journal would allow the player to select already completed story missions and replay them, perhaps striving to complete optional objectives that were missed the first time around.
These two systems are just a couple of ideas that can be used to bring a lot more optional content to the player, as well as simulate a living, breathing world.
3. Boasting
On the subject of replaying missions, one of the unique features of the original game was the ability to boast about your upcoming quests. You're going to defend this town against Balverines using only your fists, and you'll make sure not a single villager dies. You're going to fight off the Hobbes at this farm while naked apart from a tasteful pair of Union Jack briefs. A load of assassins? Why, you won't even take a single hit from them.
The more boasts you made about a quest, the more rewards you'd get from that quest. Simple and brilliant; the feature was popular with fans and regularly in the top ten requested additions, and the man who designed it always tried to have it brought back for the later games in the series, but it was never to be.
Boasting absolutely needs to be in the reboot with the podium, and maybe also built as a gateway to starting missions. Imagine your Hero gets drunk at a pub and the screen fades to black. You come to the next morning with a raging hangover and surrounded by people expecting you to fistfight a troll while wearing a flowery dress and singing La Bamba.
Make it happen, Playground.
2. Do You Have Any Potions Or Food?
The Guild Master of the Heroes Guild was a kindly man to his charges but not one who would take any sh*t from them. As he reminded us all when an errant blow would find its way onto him, he could break the Hero whenever he chose to (except that one time). Such a complex character needed a strong voice that was also kindly, and Lionhead turned to Hugo Myatt to fill the role in the first game.
His voice added a depth to the Guild Master that certainly wasn't there in the script and, despite prattling on about your health being low, players loved the kindly leader and certainly didn't ever murder him or carve anything into his forehead. Myatt was more than just the voice of the Guild Master to British players; he'd been guiding us through adventures for years as Treguard, the custodian of the Knightmare TV show.
While it's unlikely that Myatt will return to the role after all these years, Playground needs to get someone with similar vocal qualities to play Weaver this time around. Simon Callow, who narrated the trailer we saw at the Microsoft showcase, seems a perfect choice.
1. A New Beginning
The story of Fable is pretty simple, but fans know there is a deeper mythology there that has almost always been kept to the surrounding media rather than included in the games. Scythe, Jack Of Blades, and the Sword Of Aeons all have a fascinating shared history with the development of the world that you just don't even find hinted at in the games.
If Playground Games are truly looking to reboot the series starting with a modernised retelling of the Hero Of Oakvale's story, then they could do a lot worse than look at the extra lore that has been built since that game released and incorporate it into the new game from the beginning.
That could easily include some of the ideas cut from the series as they were thought too dark or complex for the 2004 original. At no point in that game does the boy at the beginning find his puppy nailed to the door by bandits, yet that was the original plan for the opening of the game. A later time-travel quest would even have seen the Hero opening the way for Jack's attack while retrieving important artifacts.
All of this could be fodder for the reboot.